Comprehensive Hydraulic Fracture Diagnostics in the Permian Bone Spring: Integrating Pressure-Based Analyses for Fracture Geometry Characterization and Well Spacing Optimization
Abstract Objectives/Scope A comprehensive data collection and analysis plan was applied to a Permian Basin Devon Energy Bone Spring pad (the Devon Project) comprising 3 new wells and 2 recently drilled parent wells as shown in Figure 1. The goal of this ‘science pad’ was to characterize and quantify fracture growth between wells having stratigraphic and structural variation to further optimize well spacing, landing depths, and completion design. Methods, Procedures, Process To understand hydraulic fracture propagation and drainage behavior a suite of diagnostic tests were applied: Toe-stage conventional Diagnostic Fracture Injection Tests (DFITs) and repeat DFIT Flow-back (DFIT-FB) tests on the same toe ports,Post-frac stage fall-off analysis including a Pressure-Transient-Analysis (PTA) technique to estimate treating well perforation cluster efficiency,Fracture Driven Interaction (FDI) statistics and modeling including Sealed Wellbore Pressure Monitoring (SWPM),Post completion sequential flow-back interference testing,Parent well production diagnostics. Results, Observations, Conclusions Repeat testing of the toe-port with conventional DFITs and DFIT-FB presented a unique opportunity to compare results using different testing and analysis techniques in exactly the same location. DFIT execution was again shown to be critical to achieve the best results. DFIT-FB interpretation was challenging in this setting with low net pressure, Pnet, and net stress, Ps (defined in the nomenclature section). PTA diagnostics and modeling workflows were applied to select frac stages having sufficient post-frac stage fall-off data. This analysis provides greater clarity and quantification of well friction, perforation friction, near-well tortuosity, and Far-field Fracture Extension Pressure (FFEP). Results from the suite of diagnostic tests applied on this pad presented an important example of ‘the whole is greater than the sum of the parts’. Individual tests results, taken alone, may have been interpreted as misruns, inconclusive, or contradictory. However, taken in concert, results provided a clear picture of ‘unconventional’ fracture growth and likely depletion gaps that will be used by Devon for further testing of well spacing and fracture designs to optimize development. Novel/Additive Information Pressure data acquisition is known to be inexpensive and non-disruptive in most completion operations. However, this project demonstrated the value of more data and repeat testing to help define the range of outcomes and to distinguish when data may be indicating representative vs outlier behavior. Pre-planning and investment in higher resolution pressure gauges located on all wells-of-interest to capture uninterrupted pressure measurements is recommended.
Read more