- Peer Review Report
- 10.5194/gchron-2024-36-rc1
Comment on gchron-2024-36
- Jan 20, 2025
- Sontag-Gonzã¡Lez, Mariana + 4 more +4
<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> Infrared radiofluorescence (IR-RF) is an alternative dating technique for potassium feldspar grains, offering a higher signal stability and based on a simpler underlying mechanism than more common luminescence dating approaches. However, its accuracy when tested on known-age samples has so far shown inconsistent results. In this study, we present a refined accuracy assessment using samples that have previously produced unreliable IR-RF ages. Our approach incorporates two major methodological advancements developed over the past decade: elevated temperature measurements using the IR-RF<sub>70</sub> protocol and sensitivity change correction by vertical sliding. To expand the dose range comparison, we included two additional samples: one expected to be in saturation and another of modern age. Additionally, we evaluated the effect of using a narrower bandpass filter to exclude any signal contributions from potentially contaminating shorter wavelength emissions. Our results following the IR-RF<sub>70</sub> protocol with sensitivity corrections show an improvement over the original room temperature results. For four out of the seven tested known-age samples spanning 20–130 ka, we obtained results in keeping with the expected doses. Two additional modern samples, however, yielded slight age underestimations. Introduction of a multiple-aliquot regenerative dose (MAR) protocol improved the accuracy of two out of three samples with large sensitivity changes. Finally, we also compared the new IR-RF equivalent doses (D<sub>e</sub>) to those obtained with the newer trap-specific dating method infrared-photoluminescence (IRPL) for the same samples, including previously published values and new measurements. We observe that with the new improvements the success rate of IR-RF is comparable to that of IRPL.
Read more