- Book Chapter
- 10.1093/9780198989219.003.0004
Coda
- Mar 26, 2026
- Michelle Pfeffer
Abstract This short coda discusses scholarship on the history of the immortal soul in early Christianity. The early modern period saw an increased awareness of the importance of Greek philosophy to understanding the New Testament and the early church fathers. In confessional warfare, many suggested a chief cause of historical heresies was the mixing of theology and pagan philosophy begun by the fathers. Utilising emerging contextualist approaches to the history of Christianity, in which the scriptures and the writings of the church fathers were treated as artefacts of past cultures, scholars suggested that early Christians, to facilitate their attempts to convert, used pagan philosophical vocabulary liberally, even going so far as to incorporate into their theologies what were originally pagan ideas. The pre-existence of the soul was one of these plagiarised ideas. It was thus not a great step for critics of the immortality of the soul to suggest that this doctrine might be blemished by the same unsavoury history.
Read more