- Conference Article
7
- 10.1109/ntms.2015.7266476
Classification and comparative analysis of inter-cell interference coordination techniques in LTE networks
- May 24, 2015
- Mohamed A Aboulhassan + 6 more +6
International audience
Fractional Frequency Reuse (FFR) is a promising to improve the spectrum e ciency in the LongTerm Evolution (LTE) cellular network. In the literature, various research works have been conducted to evaluate the performance of FFR. However, the presented analytical approach only dealt with the special cases in which the users are divided into 2 groups and only two power levels are utilised. In this paper, we consider a general case of FFR in which the users are classified intogroups and each group is assigned a serving power level. The mathematical model of the general FFR is presented and analysed through a stochastic geometry approach. The derived analytical results in terms of average coverage probability can covered all the related well-known results in the literature.
 Keywords: 
 Fractional Frequency Reuse, LongTerm Evolution, coverage probability, stochastic geometry
 References
 [1] Cisco, Cisco visual networking index: Global mobile data traffic forecast update, 2015 - 2020, 2016.
 [2] A.S. Hamza, S.S. Khalifa, H.S. Hamza, K. Elsayed, A Survey on Inter-Cell Interference Coordination Techniques in OFDMA-Based Cellular Networks, IEEE Commun, Surveys & Tutorials 15(4) (2013) 1642-1670
 [3] 3GPP TR 36.819 V11.1.0, Coordinated multi-point operation for LTE physical layer aspects, 2011.
 [4] 3GPP Release 10 V0.2.1, LTE-Advanced (3GPP Release 10 and beyond), 2014.
 [5] 3GPP TS 36.211 V14.1.0, E-UTRA Physical Channels and Modulation, 2016.
 [6] R. Ghaffar, R. Knopp, Fractional frequency reuse and interference suppression for ofdma networks, in: 8th International Symposium on Modeling and Optimization in Mobile, Ad Hoc and Wireless Networks, 2010, pp. 273-277.
 [7] Y. Kwon, O. Lee, J. Lee, M. Chung, Power Control for Soft Fractional Frequency Reuse in OFDMA System, Vol. 6018 of Lecture Notes in Comput.Science, Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2010, book section 7 (2010) 63-71.
 [8] Enhancing LTE Cell-Edge Performance via PDCCH ICIC, in: FUJITSU NETWORK COMMUNICATIONS INC., 2011
 [9] A.S. Hamza, S.S. Khalifa, H.S. Hamza, K. Elsayed, A Survey on Inter-Cell Interference Coordination Techniques in OFDMA-Based Cellular Networks, IEEE Commun, Surveys & Tutorials 15(4) (2013) 1642-1670. https://doi.org/10.1109/SURV.2013.013013.00028.
 [10] A. Busson1, I. Lahsen-Cherif2, Impact of resource blocks allocation strategies on downlink interference and sir distributions in lte networks: A stochastic geometry approach, Wireless Communications and Mobile Computing.
 [11] H. ElSawy, E. Hossain, M. Haenggi, Stochastic Geometry for Modeling, Analysis and Design of Multi-Tier and Cognitive Cellular Wireless Networks: A Survey, IEEE Commun, Surveys Tutorials 15(3) (2013) 996-1019. https://doi.org/10.1109/SURV.2013.052213.00000.
 [12] W. Bao, B. Liang, Stochastic Analysis of Uplink Interference in Two-Tier Femtocell Networks: Open Versus Closed Access, IEEE Trans, Wireless Commun. 14(11) (2015) 6200-6215. https://doi.org/10.1109/TWC.2015.2450216 .
 [13] H. Tabassum, Z. Dawy, E. Hossain, M.S. Alouini, Interference Statistics and Capacity Analysis for Uplink Transmission in Two-Tier Small Cell Networks: A Geometric Probability Approach, IEEE Trans, Wireless Commun 13(7) (2014) 3837-3852.
 [14] J.G. Andrews, F. Baccelli, R.K. Ganti, A tractable approach to coverage and rate in cellular networks, IEEE Transactions on Communications 59(11) (2011) 3122-3134.
 [15] Y. Lin, W. Bao, W. Yu, B. Liang, Optimizing User Association and Spectrum Allocation in HetNets: A Utility Perspective, IEEE J. Sel. Areas Commun. 33(6) (2015) 1025-1039. https://doi.org/10.1109/JSAC.2015.2417011.
 [16] M. Haenggi, Stochastic Geometry for Wireless Networks, Cambridge Univ, Press, November 2012.
 [17] H. ElSawy, E. Hossain, M. Haenggi, Stochastic Geometry for Modeling, Analysis and Design of Multi-Tier and Cognitive Cellular Wireless Networks: A Survey, IEEE Commun, Surveys Tutorials 15(3) (2013) 996-1019.
 [18] Huawei, R1-050507: Soft Frequency Reuse Scheme for UTRAN LTE, in: 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #41, 2005.
 [19] M.A. Stegun, I.A., Handbook of Mathematical Functions with Formulas, Graphs and Mathematical Tables, 9th Edition, Dover Publications, 1972.
Classification and comparative analysis of inter-cell interference coordination techniques in LTE networks
International audience
References
References
Stochastic Geometry for Modeling, Analysis, and Design of Multi-Tier and Cognitive Cellular Wireless Networks: A Survey
For more than three decades, stochastic geometry has been used to model large-scale ad hoc wireless networks, and it has succeeded to develop tractable models to characterize and better understand the performance of these networks. Recently, stochastic geometry models have been shown to provide tractable yet accurate performance bounds for multi-tier and cognitive cellular wireless networks. Given the need for interference characterization in multi-tier cellular networks, stochastic geometry models provide high potential to simplify their modeling and provide insights into their design. Hence, a new research area dealing with the modeling and analysis of multi-tier and cognitive cellular wireless networks is increasingly attracting the attention of the research community. In this article, we present a comprehensive survey on the literature related to stochastic geometry models for single-tier as well as multi-tier and cognitive cellular wireless networks. A taxonomy based on the target network model, the point process used, and the performance evaluation technique is also presented. To conclude, we discuss the open research challenges and future research directions.
Read moreStochastic Geometry Based Dynamic Fractional Frequency Reuse for OFDMA Systems
Fractional Frequency Reuse (FFR) has been acknowledged as an efficient Interference Management (IM) technique, which offers significant capacity enhancement and improves cell edge coverage with low complexity of implementation. The performance of cellular system greatly depends on the spatial configuration of base stations (BSs). In literature, FFR has been analyzed mostly with cellular networks described by Hexagon Grid Model (HGM). HGM is neither tractable nor scalable to the dense deployment of next generation wireless networks. Moreover, the perfect geometry based HGM tends to overestimate the system's performance and not able to reflect the reality. In this paper, we use the stochastic geometry approach; FFR is analyzed with cellular network modeled by homogeneous Poisson Point Process (PPP). PPP model provides complete randomness in terms of BS deployment, which captures the real network scenario. A dynamic FFR scheme is proposed in this article, which take into account the randomness of the cell coverage area described by Voronoi tessellation. It is shown that the proposed scheme outperforms the traditional fixed frequency allocation schemes in terms of capacity and capacity density.
Read moreVoronoi cell geometry based dynamic Fractional Frequency Reuse for OFDMA cellular networks
Interference Management (IM) is one of the major challenges of next generation wireless communication. Fractional Frequency Reuse (FFR) has been acknowledged as an efficient IM technique, which offers significant capacity enhancement and improve cell edge coverage with low complexity. In literature, FFR has been analyzed mostly with cellular networks described by Hexagon Grid Model, which is neither tractable nor scalable to the dense deployment of next generation wireless networks. Moreover, the perfect geometry based grid model tends to overestimate the system performance and not able to reflect the reality. In this paper, we use the stochastic geometry approach, FFR is analyzed with cellular network modeled by homogeneous Poisson Point Process (PPP). A dynamic frequency allocation scheme is proposed which take into account the randomness of the cell coverage area describe by Voronoi tessellation. It is shown that the proposed scheme outperforms the traditional fixed frequency allocation schemes in terms of per user capacity and capacity density.
Read moreNon-Cooperative Inter-Cell Interference Coordination Technique for Increasing Throughput Fairness in LTE Networks
International audience
Handover management in dense cellular networks: A stochastic geometry approach
Cellular operators are continuously densifying their networks to cope with the ever-increasing capacity demand. Furthermore, an extreme densification phase for cellular networks is foreseen to fulfill the ambitious fifth generation (5G) performance requirements. Network densification improves spectrum utilization and network capacity by shrinking base stations' (BSs) footprints and reusing the same spectrum more frequently over the spatial domain. However, network densification also increases the handover (HO) rate, which may diminish the capacity gains for mobile users due to HO delays. In highly dense 5G cellular networks, HO delays may neutralize or even negate the gains offered by network densification. In this paper, we present an analytical paradigm, based on stochastic geometry, to quantify the effect of HO delay on the average user rate in cellular networks. To this end, we propose a flexible handover scheme to reduce HO delay in case of highly dense cellular networks. This scheme allows skipping the HO procedure with some BSs along users' trajectories. The performance evaluation and testing of this scheme for only single HO skipping shows considerable gains in many practical scenarios.
Read moreSelf-Regulating Spectrum Management: A Case of Fractional Frequency Reuse Patterns in LTE Networks
In recent years, Self-management (Self-X) technologies that fully automate the tasks of managing (i.e. configuring, monitoring, and optimizing) a cellular network are emerging as an important tool in reducing service provider OPEX and CAPEX and will be a distinguishing feature of LTE (Long Term Evolution) networks. In this work, we focus on one such Self-X technology, namely, self-configuration of fractional frequency reuse (FFR) patterns for LTE/WiMAX. % We contend that any solution to this problem must meet the following often-conflicting objectives: (1) Computational efficiency: The self-assignment procedure should be efficient and use only local neighborhood information for computation. (2) Controlled cascading and stability: in the event of cell addition or deletion, the impact of recomputing the FFR should be restricted to a well-defined local neighborhood of the base station and should not cascade over the entire network. (3) Optimality of solution: The spectrum utilization resulting from FFR computed should be closest to optimal as possible. % We report design, analysis and simulation of distributed algorithms that provide the network designer a flexible tool to tune the above objectives. For each possible choice made by the system designer, our tool delivers a near-optimal spectrum utilization with specific guarantees on the rest of the properties. We report example results using realistic network topologies and our efforts to integrate the algorithms in the ALU LTE Simulator.
Read moreOn the downlink SINR and outage probability of stochastic geometry based LTE cellular networks with multi-class services
Due to the increasing number of irregularly spaced base stations (BSs) as well as the intrinsic random channel environment, modeling and analysis of cellular networks using classical hexagonal cell shapes is becoming ever more impractical. Therefore, stochastic geometry models having the ability to picture near realistic situations is gaining a wide acceptability for evaluating cellular network performance. In light of this, this paper presents a simulation-based investigation on the downlink signal-to-interference-noise-ratio (SINR) and the outage probability of orthogonal frequency division multiple access (OFDMA)-based long term evolution (LTE) cellular systems using stochastic geometry with multi-class services. Locations of BSs are modeled using both Poisson point process (PPP) as well as hard-core Poisson process (HCPP). Moreover, a computationally efficient method is proposed for capturing the effect of inter-cell interference in such stochastic geometry based cellular networks. Network performance including the outage probability of various multi-class services under varying shadow fading scenario and BS density is evaluated using Monte Carlo simulations, and compared with that of the traditional hexagonal models. Simulation results clearly demonstrates the over optimistic network performance of hexagonal model, while the most realistic HCPP model provides a compromise between the hexagonal and the PPP models.
Read moreAnalysis and comparison of Fractional Frequency Reuse schemes based on worst case Signal to Interference power Ratio in OFDMA uplink
Fractional Frequency Reuse (FFR) is an efficient interference mitigation technique for modern cellular networks due to its low complexity, low coordination requirements and resource allocation flexibility. This work considers the use of FFR in the cellular uplink (UL). We analyze the uplink worst case Signal to Interference power Ratio (SIR) for sectored FFR and compare its results with those of strict FFR and Soft FFR. A closed form expression is derived analytically for worst SIR and best inner radius. This analytical technique is utilized to configure a FFR solution for the TIL of Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access (OFDMA) cellular systems. The analysis is performed using two-tiers cellular network with uniform user density and for three different cases of FFR, sectored FFR, Soft Frequency Reuse (SFR), and strict FFR with Frequency Reuse Factor (FRF)= 3 and FRF= 4. Also the effect of power control exponent on those FFR schemes is studied. The inner radius configuration depends on equalizing the worst SIR for both inner and outer edges of the cell. Numerical results show that sectored FFR without power control yields the highest SIR followed by strict FFR with FRF= 4. Power control exponent does not affect FFR with reuse three but strongly affects SFR and FRF= 4 as its increase reduces its SIR and inner radius. Sectored FFR without power control have the highest SE, hence sectored FFR highly balances the needs of interference reduction and resource efficiency but at the expense of increased system complexity.
Read moreSelection of optimal SINR threshold in fractional frequency reuse by comparing Otsu's and entropy method
Selection of optimal SINR threshold in fractional frequency reuse by comparing Otsu's and entropy method
Fractional frequency reuse in LTE networks
3GPP Long Term Evolution (LTE) is a standard for wireless communications to achieve high spectral efficiency, high peak data rates, as well as flexibility in frequency and bandwidth. By using frequency reuse of one in LTE networks, high spectral efficiency is achieved. However, the Inter-Cell Interference (ICI) resulted from the frequency reuse of one is a main limitation in these networks. Fractional Frequency Reuse (FFR) has been proposed as an Inter-Cell Interference Coordination (ICIC) technique in Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access (OFDMA) based LTE networks. FFR divides the cell into an inner and an outer region, and then different frequency reuse factors are applied in each region in such a way the interference is reduced. This paper focuses on evaluating two FFR deployment schemes, namely, Strict FFR and Soft Frequency Reuse (SFR) and compares them with the conventional frequency reuse scheme. A broad comparison among all these frequency reuse schemes is performed by using a proposed mechanism which depends on Monte Carlo simulations considering performance metrics such as Signal to Interference plus Noise Ratio (SINR), capacity and throughput. Simulation results show that, the higher SINR achieved by Strict FFR is not reflected in terms of throughput due to the small bandwidth utilization, and Soft Frequency Reuse (SFR) can provide higher cell-edge throughput by increasing the power control factor but this comes at the cost of decreased inner region throughput.
Read moreA Novel Frequency Planning for Femtocells in OFDMA-Based Cellular Networks Using Fractional Frequency Reuse
Femtocells are expected to be one of the emerging technologies for next generation communication systems. For successful deployment of femtocells in the pre-existing macrocell networks, there are some challenges such as the cell planning for interference management, handoff, and power control. In this paper, we focus on frequency planning which can provide interference avoidance for the co-existence of macrocells and femtocells. We propose a novel frequency planning for femtocells in cellular networks using fractional frequency reuse (FFR). We consider downlink performance of cellular systems based on Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing Access (OFDMA), e.g., WiMAX and 3GPP Long Term Evaluation (LTE). Simulation results show that our scheme indeed reduces the effect of additional co-channel interference (CCI) between a given macrocell and deployed femtocells as well as neighboring macrocells.
Read moreAdmission control design for integrated WLAN and OFDMA-based cellular networks
We propose a QoS-aware admission control scheme (ACS) considering slow and fast calls for the integrated WLAN and OFDMA-based cellular network where only slow calls are allowed to connect with WLAN to maintain low handover overhead. The proposed ACS allows efficient traffic offloading from the macrocell to WLAN and considers QoS requirements for users in terms of minimum rates in all regions. The fractional frequency reuse (FFR) technique is assumed to be employed for interference mitigation in the cellular network. We also propose a novel bandwidth (BW) borrow-return strategy in the proposed ACS to improve the system performance. We then develop an analytical model to derive the blocking probabilities for calls in different areas. Numerical results demonstrate the performance enhancement of the ACS with the BW borrow-return strategy and the usefulness of the proposed analytical model in determining the size of WLAN offloading region.
Read moreCoverage in Two-Tier Cellular Networks with Fractional Frequency Reuse
Fractional frequency reuse (FFR) is an interference management technique well-suited to OFDMA-based cellular networks wherein the cells are partitioned into spatial regions with different frequency reuse factors. These techniques are of further relevance when considered in the context of heterogeneous networks whose performance is often limited by intercell and inter-tier interference. To date, FFR techniques have typically been evaluated through system-level simulations using a hexagonal grid for the base station locations. This paper instead focuses on analytically evaluating the two main types of FFR deployments - Strict FFR and Soft Frequency Reuse (SFR) - using a Poisson point process to model the access point locations. Under reasonable assumptions for modern cellular networks, our results reduce to tractable expressions which provide insight into system design guidelines and the relative merits of Strict FFR and SFR, compared to universal reuse for a two-tier network with open access between tiers.
Read more