- Research Article
- 10.1016/0022-460x(71)90666-3
Dynamic ground compliance in multistorey buildings
- Jun 01, 1971
- Journal of Sound and Vibration
- J.H Rainer
Dynamic ground compliance in multistorey buildings
A method is proposed for the probabilistic estimation of structural damage using measured statistical changes in natural frequencies and mode shapes. The variation of the structural integrity of the system (such as natural frequencies and mode shapes) can be interpreted as a variation in the structural parameters of the system (such as mass and stiffness). The relationship between the change in eigenvalues and a set of localized stiffness reduction factors yield a set of underdetermined simultaneous equations derived from a second-order perturbation (by keeping higherorder terms) of the healthy eigenvalue problem. Stochastic expressions for these factors are obtained from a least squares solution using healthy and damaged modal data. These stochastic expressions yield a set of localized probability damage quotients that indicate a confidence level on the existence of damage. The effectiveness of the proposed technique is illustrated using simulated experimental data on a three degree-of-freedom spring-mass system. Graduate Research Assistant, Department of Mechanical Engineering. T Associate Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Member AIAA. Copyright ©1996 by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc. All rights reserved. Introduction The Detection, Location, and Estimation (DLE) of structural damage has been the subject of much current research. Many structures, whether on the ground or in space, are often subjected to external hazards. Spacecraft and other large space structures have to endure the hazards of on-orbit existence, assuming they are undamaged during the launch process. Kashangaki provides a concise overview of the on-orbit damage detection and health monitoring process. The expense of maintenance, replacement, and time out of service may be costly. Therefore, it is advantageous to develop methods that can detect, locate, and estimate the extent of damage, if it exists at all. One approach adjusts a finite element model of the healthy structure to obtain the damaged mass and stiffness matrices based upon experimental natural frequencies and mode shapes. Others rely on changes in natural frequencies only (Vandiver, Cawley and Adams, and Hassiotis and Jeong), changes in mode shapes only (Wolff and Richardson^), or both frequency and mode shape changes (Pandey et al.) to indicate the presence of damage. In addition to these, the kinetic and strain energies for each mode may also add information, as considered by Chen and Garba and Kashangaki et al. respectively. Yet another alternative is a probabilistic approach, which examines the eigenvalue problem from a statistical standpoint by considering eigenvalue and eigenvector uncertainty (Collins and Thomson, Hart and Collins, Collins et al., and Hasselman and Hart). This paper is primarily concerned with the probabilistic approach and expands the work conducted by Hassiotis and Jeong. They performed a first-order perturbation (by neglecting higher-order terms) of the healthy eigenvalue problem, yielding the relationship between the variation in the global stiffness and the change in eigenvalues. If the higher order terms are not discarded, the resulting relationship is not that dissimilar to the one they derived. The change in global stiffness is then expressed as a linear sum of the healthy element stiffness submatrices and their corresponding stiffness reduction factors. These reduction factors, first introduced by White and Maytum, were originally intended as a stiffness matrix correction 2626 American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics method in the model updating problem. Lim improved the work of White and Maytum, and applied the results to the damage detection field^. These factors indicate the amount of stiffness reduction/increase for each structural element. Stochastic expressions for these coefficients are obtained from a least squares solution of a set of simultaneous linear equations that relate the changes in eigenvalues to those of the element stiffnesses. Stochastic damage stiffnesses are then calculated using these scaling factors, from which a probabilistic comparison is made to determine a probability of damage quotient (PDQ). This PDQ is a confidence indicator on the existence of damage, and can also be employed as a damage threshold indicator. In summary, the OLE problem poses three questions: is there damage?, where is the damage?, and what is the extent of the damage? The probability damage quotients and stiffness reduction factors answer these three questions. The effectiveness of the proposed technique is illustrated using a three degree-of-freedom spring-mass system. Theoretical Development The free vibration eigenvalue problem for an N order undamped dynamical system is given by ([K] -XJM]) { }. = {0} i = l,2,3,...,N (1) where [M] represents the (NxN) symmetric mass matrix, [K] is the (NxN) symmetric stiffness matrix, Xj is the i mode scalar eigenvalue, and {()>}. is the i mode eigenvector or mode shape of size (Nxl). It is tacitly assumed that the eigenvectors are mass normalized. Let us assume that Equation (1) represents the eigenvalue problem of the healthy, pre-damaged system. The eigenvalue problem of the damaged system can similarly be written as [AM] =
Dynamic ground compliance in multistorey buildings
Dynamic ground compliance in multistorey buildings
Structural Damage Identification: A Probabilistic Approach
A method is presented to improve the robustness of current damage detection methodologies. Measured statistical changes in natural frequencies and mode shapes along with a correlated analytical stochastic finite element model are used to assess the integrity of a structure. The approach accounts for variations in the modal properties of a structure (due to experimental errors in the test procedure). A perturbation of the healthy eigenvalue problem is performed to yield the relationship between the changes in eigenvalues and in the global stiffness matrix. This stiffness change is represented as a sum over every structural member by a product of a stiffness reduction factor and a stiffness submatrix. The determination of damaged stiffness statistics permits the comparison of probability density functions between the healthy and estimated damaged stiffnesses. A set of graphical and statistical probability damage quotients are then found that indicate a confidence level on the existence of damage. The effectiveness of the proposed technique is illustrated using simulated data on a three-degree-of-freedom spring-mass system and on an Euler-Bernoulli cantilever aluminum beam.
Read moreCharacterization Of Ambient Vibration Data By Response Shape Vectors
Ambient vibration monitoring methods are based on the calculation and interpretation of auto- and cross-spectral densities of accelerations recorded simultaneously at several selected locations on a structure. In principle, these data are used to identify natural frequencies and mode shapes that, presumably, will remain stable with time unless significant structural damage occurs. In practice, although the identification of peaks in the spectral density functions is straightforward, interpretation of natural frequencies and mode shapes is a tedious and difficult task because of the quantity and complex nature of the data. This paper describes a least-squares method for calculating a response shape vector at each discrete frequency of the matrix of auto- and cross-spectral density functions. The resulting shape vectors provide (1) a single function of frequency, the squared norm, for displaying peaks in the spectral density function, (2) a quantitative measure of the "mode shape" associated with the peaks, and (3) a measure of goodness of fit of the vector to the data. These results provide a quantitative and greatly simplified basis for interpretation. The paper includes (1) a derivation of' the method, (2) a description of its implementation including a listing of a Fortran computer code, (3) an example using measured data, and (4) suggestions for further development. The examples illustrate the ability of the method to quantify mode shapes, difficulties associated with distinguishing between closely spaced modes, and the degree to which resulting response shapes are stable in time. INTRODUCTION The detection of structural damage by ambient vibration monitoring relies on the identification of significant changes in natural frequencies and mode shapes of the structure by interpretation of auto- and cross-spectral density functions of acceleration measurements. The concept, identification of significant changes, implies that:a positive identification is made of a number of natural frequencies and mode shapes in the measured data;a quantified' measure of stability is established for modal frequency and shape for the undamaged structure, anda basis is available for determining that a particular damage level will cause changes in the detectable modes that are measurably greater than established stable ranges. ignificant improvements to the ambient vibration monitoring are achieved when:the number of identifiable modes that exhibit significant changes with member damage is increased, andthe measure of stability for frequency or shape is improved. This paper describes results of an attempt to develop a method for computing response shapes from measured cross-spectra; the computed response shape vector is envisioned as a means to provide a quantifiable measure of mode shape and an additional basis for identifying natural modes of the structure. The method employs a least-squares fit to the auto- and cross-spectral densities of measured data to determine a "best" shape vector at each frequency. A theoretical basis for the method is presented, and the equations for the method are derived. Results from measurements on an oil producing platform in the Gulf of Mexico are presented to illustrate the method and to provide a basis for its evaluation.
Read moreDetermining Natural Frequencies Using Embedded and Placed Sensors under Ambient and Shaker Excitation
Dynamic monitoring of structures is a method of detecting changes and damage to the structure. Vibration based monitoring has been used to detect damage in rotating machinery and is gaining popularity in the field of Structural Health Monitoring (SHM). Monitoring involves detecting changes in natural frequencies and changes in mode shapes. These changes reflect changes to properties of the bridge which can indicate damage. The Nibley Bridge is a single span bridge comprised of ten deck bulb girders. The bridge spans 25.91m (85 ft.) and includes two lanes, sidewalks on both sides, and a small median. The Nibley Bridge was constructed with monitoring in mind. A dynamic monitoring system was planned to detect frequencies for long term monitoring. Initial monitoring of the embedded accelerometers was ineffective, so additional testing was required. An impact test was done with additional sensors to calibrate the embedded sensors. To further define the natural frequencies and mode shapes of the bridge, two shaker tests were also performed. The embedded sensors were noted as having a large noise range. Also, they required a specific data logger to detect meaningful data. Recommendations for the use of the embedded accelerometers were determined and defined. The additional tests were able to assist in calibrating the accelerometers, as well as defining the natural frequencies and mode shapes of the structure. Natural frequencies were defined for each test and the changing condition of the bridge between those tests. The addition of asphalt occurred between two tests and a change of approximately 20° C between the other two tests. Though there is not much information to form a correlation, the detected changes define the dynamic aspects of the bridge. Lastly, mode shapes were determined and a Modal Assurance Criterion (MAC)analysis was done to correlate the measured and analytical mode shapes. This model helped to indicate which parameters effect the mode shapes of the structure. Comparison between these parameters and changes between them help to indicate the predicted behavior of the structure under different circumstances. Though these tests do not define all of the dynamic properties of the bridge, they do provide a general baseline of values that can be expected for future tests of the structure.
Read moreStructural Health Monitoring of FRP-Reinforced Concrete Bridges Using Vibration Responses
This paper evaluates the feasibility of using vibration-based structural damage detection methods to identify potential damage in FRP-reinforced concrete (FRP-RC) bridges. A series of dynamic load tests were conducted immediately after construction on a continuous three-span FRP-RC bridge deck to capture its dynamic responses under intact conditions. A detailed finite element (FE) model was developed and validated against the experimental results. This model allows for the simulation and study of the bridge dynamic behavior after cracking develops at different locations along the deck. The effects of cracking severity and location on the bridge were investigated using natural frequency and mode shapes changes. The numerical results showed that natural frequency and mode shape changes are sufficiently sensitive for detecting cracks in the FRP-RC bridge deck. Additional dynamic load tests are scheduled for this bridge so that experimental data, possibly obtained from a cracked deck, can be used to calibrate the FE model after some damage. While recognizing that corrosion is a non-issue for FRP-RC structures, the ultimate question that this research attempts to answer is how the deck flexural stiffness changes over time as the result of traffic loads and possibly predict a service life expectation based on stiffness degradation.KeywordsFRP barsFRP-reinforced concreteBridgesStructural health monitoringDamage detectionFinite element analysisVibration method
Read moreInfluence of Thermal Loading on the Dynamic Response of Thin-Walled Structure under Thermo-Acoustic Loading
Future flight vehicle structures will encounter severe loading conditions, a combination of aerodynamic, thermal, acoustic and mechanical loads. Although the analysis methods for responses of structures under acoustic loads have been developed to some extent, but with thermal loads considered, the responses show fundamental differences, which complicate the analysis immensely. It was reported that hypersonic flight may give rise to surface temperature as high as and intense noise whose overall sound pressure level (OSPL) may reach 180dB. Thin-walled structures subjected to such loadings will exhibit nonlinear responses. Large temperature increments may cause thermal buckling, large thermal deflections and large thermal stresses superimposed on dynamic stresses, coupled with changes in material properties. Both the geometry change by thermal buckling and stiffness change by thermal stress account for the changes of natural frequencies and mode shapes. When the acoustic loading increases to a high enough level, the post-buckled structures will exhibit snap-through motion, a large amplitude nonlinear vibration between different equilibrium positions, which will introduce extra large mean stress. As a result, thermo-acoustic fatigue may be caused, which will reduce the structure's fatigue life dramatically. Therefore it is an urgent need to estimate the influences of thermal loads on the nonlinear response of structures. A numerical investigation of the influences of thermal loads on the dynamic response of thin-walled structure under thermo-acoustic loadings is implemented. With clamped-clamped thin flat plate selected, the response characteristics related to temperature are investigated by changing thermal loads. The thermal load is considered as constant both on the surface and across the thickness. The acoustic load is simulated using stationary Gaussian white noise. Firstly, a thermal buckling analysis is proceeded to obtain critical buckling temperatures, followed by modal analysis under different thermal loads. The pre-buckled and post-buckled mode frequencies and shapes are obtained. Then three types of snap-though motions are predicted: i) vibration around one post-buckled equilibrium position, ii) intermittent snap-through, and iii) persistent snap-through. The relations between thermal loads and the occurrence of snap-though is obtained together with results about the statistics characteristic of dynamic response and their relations with thermal loads, which include critical thermal buckling loads, natural frequencies and mode shapes, RMS response and snap-through frequency. Good agreements have been achieved with previous analytical solutions, which demonstrate the effectiveness and reliability of the method employed.
Read moreStructural Damage Detection with Different Objective Functions in Noisy Conditions Using an Evolutionary Algorithm
Dynamic properties such as natural frequencies and mode shapes are directly affected by damage in structures. In this paper, changes in natural frequencies and mode shapes were used as the input to various objective functions for damage detection. Objective functions related to natural frequencies, mode shapes, modal flexibility and modal strain energy have been used, and their performances have been analyzed in varying noise conditions. Three beams were analyzed: two of which were simulated beams with single and multiple damage scenarios and one was an experimental beam. In order to do this, SAP 2000 (v14, Computers and Structures Inc., Berkeley, CA, United States, 2009) is linked with MATLAB (r2015, The MathWorks, Inc., Natick, MA, United States, 2015). The genetic algorithm (GA), an evolutionary algorithm (EA), was used to update the damaged structure for damage detection. Due to the degradation of the performance of objective functions in varying noisy conditions, a modified objective function based on the concept of regularization has been proposed, which can be effectively used in combination with EA. All three beams were used to validate the proposed procedure. It has been found that the modified objective function gives better results even in noisy and actual experimental conditions.
Read moreNumerical simulation of dynamic characteristics of hydrofoil structure under cavitation conditions
Numerical simulation of dynamic characteristics of hydrofoil structure under cavitation conditions
The Application of Probability Theory to Model Updating
A method is proposed for probabilistically model updating an initial deterministic finite element model using measured statistical changes in natural frequencies and mode shapes (i.e., modal parameters). The approach accounts for variations in the modal properties of a structure (due to experimental errors in the test procedure). A perturbation of the eigenvalue problem is performed to yield the relationship between the changes in eigenvalues and in the global stiffness matrix. This stiffness change is represented as a sum over every structural member by a product of a stiffness reduction factor and a stiffness submatrix. Monte Carlo simulations, in conjunction with the variations of the structural modal parameters, are used to determine the variations of the stiffness reduction factors. These values will subsequently be used to estimate statistics for the corrected stiffness parameters. The effectiveness of the proposed technique is illustrated using simulated data on an aluminum cantilever Euler-Bernoulli beam.
Read moreSpatial wavelet vibration method for laminar defect detection in composite beams
This thesis aims to propose a possible method for locating and characterising laminar defects in composite beams. Currently, some structural health monitoring techniques do exist, using flexural vibration methods by detecting a change in natural frequencies or mode shapes. However, they do not easily give information about its location and extent. Chang & Chen (2003) illustrated that it was theoretically possible to locate the damage in a cracked beam by using a spatial wavelet transform on the mode shape data. The wavelet transform is a signal processing tool which has undergone a large amount research during the last twenty years. Using a wavelet transform on spatial data such as mode shapes, has the property of plotting a singularity where there is a discontinuity in the mode shape data. The test beam was modelled as a three segment Timoshenko beam where the middle element represented a change in properties to simulate the damage. The theory used to develop this model was described and using the mode shapes that were plotted from the simulation model wavelet analysis was done. To perform the spatial wavelet analysis the biorthogonal splines wavelet was chosen as the mother wavelet. Using wavelet factors of (3,3) to (3,7) for the mother wavelet the analysis showed that it was possible to locate the defect theoretically as clear singularities were noticed in the decomposition that correlated to the location of the defect. For the experiment carbon fibre reinforced laminate beam specimens with unidirectional fibres were used. A free- free boundary condition was set up for the beam by placing foam padded supports at the nodes of the vibrating beam and the vibration was excited by using a piezoelectric transducer attached to the end of the beam. The mode shapes were recorded using a laser vibrometer to measure the response along the beam. Three cases of damage were investigated on the vibrating beam. Two of the damage cases consisted of attaching brass masses to the beam causes a simulated inertial damage on the beam. The wavelet transform of the mode shapes from these damage cases did not indicate the location of the damage at all. The third damage case was a low velocity impact damage that had been initiated into the beam using an impact hammer. The first and second mode shapes didn’t indicate the location of the damage, however the third mode shape seemed to indicate the location of the damage when analysed by the wavelet transform. It was recommended that for future experiments, use must be made of a smoothing function to try and reduce the sensitivity of the method to noise. Also further experimentation must be done on beams containing real damage.
Read moreInfluence of Pressure Inside a Hydraulic Line on Its Natural Frequencies and Mode Shapes
Vibrational behaviour of hydraulic power system elements is crucial in aspects of noise problems. Hydraulic lines used in engineering systems to transfer hydraulic energy are also a structural and fluid coupling between vibrating elements of the entire system. Excitation generated in different places of the hydraulic systems due to external loads, control elements or flow pulsation are all transferred through hydraulic lines on which resonances may occur. Experimental investigations were undertaken in order to identify the influence of hydraulic pressure on the natural frequencies and mode shapes of a basic hydraulic line model. Modal analysis was conducted on a hydraulic line at several pressure increments to identify the change in natural frequencies and mode shapes.
Read moreFault detection of composite beam by using the modal parameters and RBFNN technique
The detection of transverse cracks in terms of their location and intensity by using the radial basis function neural network (RBFNN) technique is analyzed in the current research and validated with experimental investigation. The glass fiber-reinforced epoxy composite is used in this research because of its valuable features, such as high stiffness and strength-to-weight ratios, good fatigue and wear resistance, and damage tolerance capability compared with isotropic material. The theoretical and numerical investigations are performed to obtain a relationship between the change in natural frequencies and mode shapes for the cracked and noncracked composite beam. Numerical analysis is performed by using the finite element software ANSYS on cracked and noncracked composite beams to measure the modal parameters, such as natural frequencies and mode shapes. These parameters are used to design an artificial intelligent controller based on the RBFNN-type neural network for predicting crack severity and its intensity. The relative natural frequencies and mode shapes (First, second, and third modes) of vibration are used as input data to the RBFNN controller, and the relative crack locations and crack depths are the output of RBFNN. Results from theoretical and numerical analysis are compared with the experimental results, and a good agreement is observed between them.
Read moreFault Diagnosis of Cracked Cantilever Composite Beam by Vibration Measurement and RBFNN
In the current investigation numerical and radial basis function neural network (RBFNN) are adopted for diagnosis of fault in a cantilever composite beam structure present in form of transverse cracks. The presence of cracks a severe threat to the performance of structures and it affects the vibration signatures (Natural frequencies and mode shapes). The material used in this analysis is graphite fiber reinforced polyimide composite. The Numerical analysis is carried out by using commercially available software package ANSYS to find the relation between the change in natural frequencies and mode shapes for the cracked and un-cracked composite beam. Which subsequently used to the design of smart system based on RBFNN for forecast of crack depths and locations following inverse technique. The RBFNN controller is developed with relative natural frequencies and relative mode shapes difference as input parameters to calculate the deviation in the vibration parameters for the cracked dynamic structure. The output from the RBFNN controller is relative crack depth and relative crack location. Results from numerical analysis are comparing with experimental results having good agreement to the results predicted by the RBFNN controller.
Read moreDamage Identification in Composite Beam by Vibration Measurement and Fuzzy Inference System
A significant efforts have been done by scientists and researchers in the last few years to develop many non-destructive techniques for damage recognition in a beam like dynamic structures. In this paper, theoretical, numerical, fuzzy logic methods employed for diagnosis of damage in the form of cracks of the cantilever composite beam with an aim to detect, quantify, and determine its intensity and locations. The Glass fiber reinforced epoxy composite engaged in the analysis due to high strength and stiffness-to-weight ratios. The theoretical analysis is performed to get the relationship between change in natural frequencies and mode shapes for the cracked and non-cracked composite beam. The Numerical analysis is performed on the cracked composite beam to get the vibration parameters such as natural frequency and mode shape, which is used to design fuzzy logic, based smart artificial intelligent technique for predicting crack severity and its intensity. Online fuzzy based smart technique has been developed, first three natural frequencies and mode shapes used as input parameters, Gaussian membership functions is considered to detect cracks location and depth. The results of theoretical and numerical analysis are compared with experimental results having good agreement with the results predicted by the fuzzy inference system.
Read moreVibration Analysis of a Simply Supported Beam with Multiple Breathing Cracks
Vibration Analysis of a Simply Supported Beam with Multiple Breathing Cracks