Access control and the Resource Description Framework: A survey

Chapter 23 - Policies, Access Control, and Formal Methods

Access control (AC) is a computer security requirement used to control, in a computing environment, what the user can access, when and how. Policy administration is an essential feature of an AC system. As the number of computers are in hundreds of millions, and due to the different organization requirements, applications and needs, various AC models are presented in literature, such as: Discretionary Access Control (DAC), Mandatory Access Control (MAC), Role Based Access Control (RBAC), etc. These models are used to implement organizational policies that prevent the unauthorized disclosure of sensitive data, protecting the data integrity, and enabling secure access and sharing of information. Each AC model has its own methods for making AC decisions and policy enforcement. However, due to the diversity of AC models and the various concerns and restrictions, its essential to find AC metamodels with higher level of abstraction. Access control metamodels serve as a unifying framework for specifying any AC policy and should ease the migration from an AC model to another. This study reviews existing works on metamodels descriptions and representations. But, are the presented metamodels sufficient to handle the needed target of controlling access especially in the presence of the current information technologies? Do they encompass all features of other AC models? In this paper we are presenting a survey on AC metamodels.

Access control is an important part of security in software, such as business applications, since it determines the access of users to objects and operations and the constraints of this access. Business and access control models are expressed using different representations. In addition, access control rules are not generally defined explicitly from access control models. Even though the business model and access control model are two separate modeling abstractions, they are inter-connected as access control is part of any business model. Therefore, the first goal is to add access control models to business models using the same fundamental building blocks. The second goal is to use these models and define general access control rules explicitly from these models so that the connection between models and their realizations are also present. This paper describes a new common representation for business models and classes of access control models based on the Resource---Event---Agent (REA) modeling approach to business models. In addition, the connection between models and their represented rules is clearly defined. We present a uniform approach to business and access control models. First, access control primitives are mapped onto REA-based access control patterns. Then, REA-based access control patterns are combined to define access control models. Based on these models, general access control rules are expressed in Extended Backus---Naur Form.

With the increasingly strict requirement for computer system security, access control models have become more complex. Existing models, such as discretionary access control (DAC) model, mandatory access control (MAC) model, role based access control (RBAC) model, and attribute based access control (ABAC) model, all have advantages and disadvantages regarding practicability and security. In addition, there is an inherent security risk in these access control models. The models merely control the access permission, but ignore the verification for the identity credibility of the entities involved in the access. With the proposal of trusted computing and the application of trusted platform, it is possible to implement, on stand-alone computers, the verification of identity credibility for the entities involved in the access. In this paper, we analyze the authorization and access decision policy of the RBAC model and the ABAC model. The characteristics of the trusted computing, which can ensure the identity credibility of the entities involved in the access, is also considered. Based on the above analysis, we establish a trusted computing based enhanced access control (TCBEAC) model, which can be deployed on stand-alone computers for common users.

The Pi-calculus has been developed to reason about behavioural equivalence. Different notions of equivalence are defined in terms of process interactions, as well as the context of processes. There are various extensions of the Pi-calculus, such as the SPI calculus, which has primitives to facilitate security protocol design.<br /> <br />Another area of computer security is access control research, which includes problems of access control models, policies and access control mechanism. The design of a unified framework for access control requires that all policies are supported and different access control models are instantiated correctly.<br /> <br />In this paper we will utilise the Pi calculus to reason about access control policies and mechanism. An equivalence of different policy implementations, as well as access control mechanism will be shown. Finally some experiences regarding the use of Pi-calculus are presented.

Traditional access control mechanisms prevent illegal access by controlling access right before executing an action; they belong to a class of a priori security solutions and, from this point of view, they have some limitations, like inflexibility in unanticipated circumstances. By contrast, a posteriori mechanisms enforce policies not by preventing unauthorized access, but rather by deterring it. Such access control needs evidence to prove violations. Evidence is derived from one or several log records, which trace each user's actions. Efficiency of violation detection mostly depends on the compliance of log records with the access control policy. In order to develop an efficient method for finding these violations, we propose restructuring log records according to a security policy model. We illustrate our methodology by applying it to the healthcare domain, taking care of the IHE (Integrating the healthcare enterprise) framework, particularly its basic security profile, ATNA (Audit Trail and Node Authentication). This profile defines log records established on the analysis of common health practice scenarios. We analyze and establish how ATNA log records can be refined in order to be integrated into an a posteriori access and usage control process, based on an expressive and contextual security policy like the OrBAC policy.

Cloud computing is considered one of the most dominant paradigms in the Information Technology (IT) industry these days. It offers new cost-effective services on-demand such as Software as a Service (SaaS), Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS) and Platform as a Service (PaaS). However, with all of these services promising facilities and benefits, there are still a number of challenges associated with utilizing cloud computing such as data security, abuse of cloud services, malicious insider and cyber-attacks. Among all security requirements of cloud computing, access control is one of the fundamental requirements in order to avoid unauthorized access to systems and protect organizations assets. Although, various access control models and policies have been developed such as Attribute based Access Control (ABAC) and Role Based Access Control (RBAC) for different environments, these models may not fulfil cloud’s access control requirements. In this paper, an enhanced attribute-based access control based on strategy mechanism is proposed by introducing a strategy for providing access control to the users in the cloud environment.

Access control is one of the most common and versatile mechanisms used for information systems security enforcement. An access control model formally describes how to decide whether an access request should be granted or denied. Since the role-based access control initiative has been proposed in the 90s, several access control models have been studied in the literature. An access control policy is an instance of a model. It defines the set of basic facts used in the decision process. Policies must satisfy a set of constraints defined in the model, which reflect some high level organization requirements. First-order logic has been advocated for some time as a suitable framework for access control models. Many frameworks have been proposed, focusing mainly on expressing complex access control models. However, though formally expressed, constraints are not defined in a unified language that could lead to some well-founded and generic enforcement procedures. Therefore, we make a clear distinction by proposing a logical framework focusing primarily on constraints, while keeping as much as possible a unified way of expressing constraints, policies, models, and reference monitors. This framework is closely tied to relational database integrity models. We then show how to use well-founded procedures in order to enforce and check constraints. Without requiring any rewriting previous to the inference process, these procedures provide clean and intuitive debugging traces for administrators. This approach is a step toward bridging the gap between general but hard to maintain formalisms and effective but insufficiently general ones.

We propose formal analysis of access control policies associated with business processes. Formal analysis of such policies enables us to investigate certain properties of interest and determine whether they hold. Discovering whether these policies create the intended effects, especially when the number of policies is increased and often composed, can become complex. In addition, we believe that access control policies must be specified in such a way that their integration into business processes is straightforward. Prior research has focused on formal verification of either access control policies or business processes but not viewed the two as an integrated whole. We show an approach in which access control policies and business processes are described using the same foundational building blocks, consequently, integration of access control policies and business processes is significantly less complex. Furthermore, access control policies can now be described by business patterns, and this description may result in discovery of access control patterns that can be used in the future. Finally, our approach through the use of business patterns is capable of modeling access control policies in the same way an access control model does. In addition, these policies can be specified and extended using rules, and in this respect, are akin to a policy language.

Access control system is an important component to protect patients’ information from abuse in a health care system. It is a major concern in the management, design, and development of healthcare systems. Designing access control policies for healthcare systems is complicated due to the dynamic and inherent complexity of the tasks performed by the healthcare personnel. Permissions in access control systems are usually granted on the basis of static policies. However, static policies are not enough to cope with various situations such as emergencies. Most often, the Break-the-glass mechanism is used to bypass static policies to handle emergency situations. Since healthcare systems are critical systems, where errors can be very costly in terms of lives, quality of life, and/or dollars, it is crucial to identify discrepancies between policy specifications and their intended function to implement correctly a flexible access control system. Formal verifications are necessary for exhaustive verification and validation of policy specifications to ensure that the policy specifications truly encapsulate the desires of the policy authors. We present a verifiable framework to enact a dynamic access control model by integrating the ANSI/INCTIS RBAC Reference Model in a workflow and an approach for property verifications of the access control model. Access control policies are expressed by the formal semantics of a model checker and properties are verified by the DiVinE model checker.

Access control is an important security issue. It has been addressed since the late 1960s in the early time-sharing computer systems. Many access control models have been proposed since than but of particular interest is Ferraiolo and Khun's role-based access control model (RBAC). It is a simple and yet general model which has been deeply studied and applied both in industry and in academia. A variety of industrial standards have been proposed based on this model. Generating code for an access control policy is an interesting challenge. Understanding access control as a non-functional concern that cross-cuts the functional part of a system raises difficulties quite suitable for a solution based on aspect-oriented programming. In this paper, we address the problems of specification and validation of code generation for access control policies targeting an aspect-based infra-structure. We propose an MDA approach. The code generator is a transformation from SecureUML, an RBAC-based modeling language, to the language Aspects for Access Control (AAC), an aspect-oriented modeling language proposed in this paper. Metamodels are used to represent the languages and to specify the transformation. A metamodel is used to represent the abstract syntax of a language and the constraints that a given instance model of the metamodel must fulfill. We also use a metamodel to specify the code generator. This transformation metamodel, together with all the constraints, that is, from both languages and those constraints regarding the merge of the two languages, we call a transformation contract. It merges and conservatively extends the source and target metamodels of the model transformation it represents. In the context of code-generation for access control policies, the transformation contract specifies the relationships between the abstract syntaxes of SecureUML and AAC and constrains the two languages. The validation of the code generator also uses the transformation contract. For a given access control policy and aspect, represented as instances of the appropriate metamodels, with aspects produced by the code generator, the constraints of the transformation contract must hold. We have prototyped a transformer from SecureUML to aspects on top of ITP/OCL, an OCL interpreter that automatically validates the generated aspect code by applying the constraints of the transformation contract.

Cloud computing paradigm is still an evolving paradigm but has recently gained tremendous momentum due to its potential for significant cost reduction and increased operating efficiencies in computing. However, its unique aspects exacerbate security and privacy challenges that pose as the key roadblock to its fast adoption. Cloud computing has already become very popular, and practitioners need to provide security mechanisms to ensure its secure adoption. In this chapter, the authors discuss access control systems and policy management in cloud computing environments. The cloud computing environments may not allow use of a single access control system, single policy language, or single management tool for the various cloud services that it offers. Currently, users must use diverse access control solutions available for each cloud service provider to secure data. Access control policies may be composed in incompatible ways because of diverse policy languages that are maintained separately at every cloud provider. Heterogeneity and distribution of these policies pose problems in managing access policy rules for a cloud environment. In this chapter, the authors discuss challenges of policy management and introduce a cloud based policy management framework that is designed to give users a unified control point for managing access policies to control access to their resources no matter where they are stored.

A Virtual Organization (VO) consists of some real organizations with common interests, which aims to provide inter organizational associations to reach some common goals by sharing their resources with each other. Providing security mechanisms, and especially a suitable access control mechanism, which enforces the defined security policy is a necessary requirement in VOs. Since VO is a complex environment with the huge number of users and resources, traditional access control models cannot satisfy VOs security requirements. Most of the current proposals are basically based on the attributes of users and resources. In this paper, we suggest using a combination of the semantic based access control (SBAC) model, and the attribute based access control (ABAC) model with the shared ontology of subjects' attributes in VOs. In this model, each participating organization makes its access control decisions according to an enhanced model of the ABAC model. However, access decision in the VO is made in more abstract level through an enhanced model of theSBACmodel. Using the ontology of users and resources in this model facilitates access control in large scale VOs with numerous organizations. By the combination ofSBACand ABAC, we attain their benefits and eliminate their shortcomings. In order to show the applicability of the proposed model, an access control system, based on the proposed model, has been implemented in Java using available APIs, including Sun's XACML API, Jena, Pellet, and Protege.

The area of smart homes is one of the most popular for deploying smart connected devices. One of the most vulnerable aspects of smart homes is access control. Recent advances in IoT have led to several access control models being developed or adapted to IoT from other domains, with few specifically designed to meet the challenges of smart homes. Most of these models use role-based access control (RBAC) or attribute-based access control (ABAC) models. As of now, it is not clear what the advantages and disadvantages of ABAC over RBAC are in general, and in the context of smart-home IoT in particular. In this paper, we introduce HABACα, an attribute-based access control model for smart-home IoT. We formally define HABACα and demonstrate its features through two use-case scenarios and a proof-of-concept implementation. Furthermore, we present an analysis of HABACα as compared to the previously published EGRBAC (extended generalized role-based access control) model for smart-home IoT by first describing approaches for constructing HABACα specification from EGRBAC and vice versa in order to compare the theoretical expressiveness power of these models, and second, analyzing HABACα and EGRBAC models against standard criteria for access control models. Our findings suggest that a hybrid model that combines both HABACα and EGRBAC capabilities may be the most suitable for smart-home IoT, and probably more generally.

Cloud computing offers cost effective services on-demand which encourage critical infrastructure providers to consider migrating to the cloud. Critical infrastructures are considered as a backbone of modern societies such as power plants and water. Information in cloud computing is likely to be shared among different entities, which could have various degrees of sensitivity. This requires robust isolation and access control mechanisms. Although various access control models and policies have been developed, they cannot fulfil requirements for a cloud based access control system. The reason is that cloud computing has a diverse sets of security requirements and unique security challenges such as multi-tenant and heterogeneity of security policies, rules and domains. This thesis provides a detailed study of cloud computing security challenges and threats, which were used to identify security requirements for various critical infrastructure providers. We found that an access control system is a crucial security requirement for the surveyed critical infrastructure providers. Furthermore, the requirement analysis was used to propose a new criteria to evaluate access control systems for cloud computing. Moreover, this work presents a new cloud based access control model to meet the identified cloud access control requirements. The model does not only ensure the secure sharing of resources among potential untrusted tenants, but also has the capacity to support different access permissions for the same cloud user. Our focused in the proposed model is the lack of data isolation in lower levels (CPU caches), which could lead to bypass access control models to gain some sensitive information by using cache side-channel attacks. Therefore, the thesis investigates various real attack scenarios and the gaps in existing mitigation approaches. It presents a new Prime and Probe cache side-channel attack, which can give detailed information about addresses accessed by a virtual machine with no need for any information about cache sets accessed by the virtual machine. The design, implementation and evaluation of a proposed solution preventing cache side-channel attacks are also presented in the thesis. It is a new lightweight solution, which introduces very low overhead (less than 15,000 CPU cycles). It can be applied in any operating system and prevents cache side-channel attacks in cloud computing. The thesis also presents a new detecting cache side-channel attacks solution. It focuses on the infrastructure used to host cloud computing tenants by counting cache misses caused by a virtual machine. The detection solutions has 0% false negative and 15% false positive.