• Home
  • Search
  • AI-Assisted Sentencing Modeling Under Explainability Constraints: Framework Design and Judicial Applicability Analysis
  • https://doi.org/10.3390/info17030234Copy DOI Icon

AI-Assisted Sentencing Modeling Under Explainability Constraints: Framework Design and Judicial Applicability Analysis

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

The integration of artificial intelligence into criminal sentencing decisions represents one of the most consequential applications of algorithmic systems in contemporary governance. While AI-assisted risk assessment tools promise enhanced consistency and predictive accuracy, their deployment in judicial contexts raises profound concerns regarding transparency, due process, and fundamental rights. This paper proposes a comprehensive framework for AI-assisted sentencing modeling that embeds explainability as a foundational constraint rather than an afterthought. Drawing upon the landmark State v. Loomis decision, empirical analyses of the COMPAS algorithm, and emerging regulatory frameworks including the European Union Artificial Intelligence Act, we examine the tension between predictive performance and interpretive transparency. Our framework integrates a three-layer explanation architecture: inherent interpretability through generalized additive models (GA2Ms) providing transparent global structure, exact local feature attribution derived directly from the additive model decomposition without approximation, and counterfactual reasoning that identifies minimal input changes altering risk classifications. We demonstrate through rigorous experimental validation on the ProPublica COMPAS dataset (n = 6172) that explainability-constrained models achieve comparable predictive validity to opaque alternatives (AUC 0.71 versus 0.70–0.72 for black-box methods) while satisfying constitutional due process requirements and emerging regulatory mandates under the EU Artificial Intelligence Act. The impossibility theorems governing algorithmic fairness are examined in light of their implications for sentencing equity, and we propose that transparent model architectures enable targeted interventions unavailable when decision logic remains concealed. The paper concludes with policy guidance for jurisdictions seeking to implement AI-assisted sentencing systems that balance public safety objectives with procedural fairness and individual rights.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article

Role of AI in Enhancing Critical Thinking in Science Education: Challenges and Opportunities for Science Instructor

  • Aug 23, 2025
  • International Journal of Multidisciplinary: Applied Business and Education Research
  • Charlie T Anselmo +5
  • Research Article

The Influence of Artificial Intelligence on Teacher Professional Identity and Job Satisfaction

  • Dec 13, 2025
  • The Critical Review of Social Sciences Studies
  • Zarina Naz +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations15

Machine Learning And Artificial Intelligence in Diabetes Prediction And Management: A Comprehensive Review of Models

  • Dec 17, 2024
  • Innovatech Engineering Journal
  • Md Ashraful Alam +3
  • Research Article

Conceptual Framework for Training Specialists for the Maritime Transport Industry

  • Mar 04, 2026
  • Siberian Pedagogical Journal
  • Evgeny M Dorofeev
  • Research Article

Ethical considerations in the integration of artificial intelligence into education: a novel deep neural network framework for predicting transparency scores.

  • Apr 13, 2026
  • Scientific reports
  • Reemiah Muneer Alotaibi +4
  • Research Article

Integration of the Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education: a Case Study from the University of Tirana (Quality Education SDG)

  • Jun 13, 2025
  • Journal of Lifestyle and SDGs Review
  • Elda Xhumari +5
  • Abstract

SAT-469 Update on the Use of Robotic Surgery and Artificial Intelligence for Adrenal Tumors

  • Oct 22, 2025
  • Journal of the Endocrine Society
  • Hassan M Heshmati +1
  • Research Article

Trends of recent data, AI/ML approaches for geospatial AI in Earth observation towards sustainable development goals

  • Mar 11, 2025
  • ITU Journal on Future and Evolving Technologies
  • Shivangi Somvanshi +2
  • Research Article

The integration of artificial intelligence into foreign language teaching of maritime students: preparation for professional interviewing

  • Apr 30, 2025
  • Russian Journal of Education and Psychology
  • Vladlena V Lysenko +2
  • Supplementary Content
  • Citations26

Semantic analysis of blockchain intelligence with proposed agenda for future issues

  • Jan 01, 2023
  • International Journal of System Assurance Engineering and Management
  • Rashi Saxena +2
  • Research Article

Integration of Ground-Penetrating Radar and Artificial Intelligence for Soil Piping- A Review

  • Apr 02, 2024
  • Journal of Applied Science, Engineering, Technology and Management
  • Anju R Nair +1
  • Research Article

ЦИФРОВА ТРАНСФОРМАЦІЯ В МЕНЕДЖМЕНТІ: ВПЛИВ ШТУЧНОГО ІНТЕЛЕКТУ ТА АНАЛІТИКИ ВЕЛИКИХ ДАНИХ НА ПРИЙНЯТТЯ СТРАТЕГІЧНИХ РІШЕНЬ

  • Jan 01, 2025
  • Business Navigator
  • Stanislav Horbachenko +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations6

The Role of Digitalization in the Development of Public Finance

  • Dec 31, 2024
  • Theory and Practice of Public Administration
  • Mykola Kovalenko +1
  • Research Article

A Survey on Recent Advances in the Integration of Discrete Event Systems and Artificial Intelligence

  • Mar 20, 2026
  • Applied Sciences
  • Jie Ren +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Exploring Students’ Attitudes Toward the Integration of Artificial Intelligence in Education

  • Jan 12, 2026
  • Societies
  • Remus Runcan +3
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.