• Home
  • Search
  • An Analytical and Empirical Comparison of End-User Logical Database Design Methods
  • Cite Icon2
  • https://doi.org/10.4018/jdm.1990100101Copy DOI Icon

An Analytical and Empirical Comparison of End-User Logical Database Design Methods

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

The current trend toward increasing database applications and end-user computing brings about the need for effective training and support tools that enable end users to perform logical database designs. This paper presents a unique comparison of a network-based data model (the extended entity relationship (EER)) and a hierarchical-based data model (the structured object model (SOM)) and their associated logical database design methods, LRDM (EER-based) and the SOM method, in end-user logical database design. The SOM method, based on an object-oriented knowledge representation scheme, is a new structured method designed to be less susceptible to designer errors and yet capable of maintaining ease of understanding and use. The Logical Relational Design Methodology (LRDM), based on the EER model, shares some common characteristics with the SOM method. In the analytic comparison the basic components and constructs of EER and SOM, as well as their use in the logical design process, are compared to derive a qualitative assessment of the two methods. Two experiments using novice database designers were conducted to examine the effectiveness of each method in leading to accurate logical designs, the time needed for task completion and the improvement in performance over a short training period. To confirm the findings from other studies on logical database design using non-graphic methods versus using graphic methods, the normalization method was included in one of the experiments. The results showed that end users performed better with graphic methods and also preferred them to the non-graphic (normalization) method. Furthermore, users learned and improved in a short period using LRDM (EER-based). However, users of the SOM method generated more accurate designs, were able to identify more complex relationships, and had more significant improvements during the training period than did users of LRDM (EER-based).

Similar Papers
  • Book Chapter
  • Citations4

LDDM — A structured logical database design methodology

  • Jan 01, 1982
  • Beverly K Kahn
  • Book Chapter

Physical Database Design

  • Jan 01, 2009
  • Iggy Fernandez
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Perancangan Database Relasional Data Lansia Panti Jompo Graha Kasih Bapa Kabupaten Kubu Raya

  • Aug 01, 2018
  • Gusti Syarifudin Atanasia
  • Research Article
  • Citations6

Mapping XML Schema to Entity Relationship and Extended Entity Relationship Models

  • Jan 01, 2007
  • International Journal of Intelligent Information and Database Systems
  • Sikha Bagui
  • Research Article
  • Citations4

Comment on “Segment Synthesis in Logical Data Base Design” [Letter to the Editor

  • May 01, 1976
  • IBM Journal of Research and Development
  • G Wiederhold
  • Conference Article
  • Citations11

A descriptive model of physical database design problems and solutions

  • Apr 01, 1984
  • John V Carlis +1
  • Conference Article
  • Citations4

Logical database design with ontologically clear entity relationship models

  • Sep 01, 2012
  • Dhammika Pieris +1
  • Research Article

ANALYSIS OF THE DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT OF A WEB-BASED CLOTHING SALES APPLICATION FOR LILYS GALLERY

  • Jan 29, 2025
  • Jurnal Ilmu Komputer dan Sistem Informasi
  • Ken Grinaldy Longdong +1
  • Conference Article
  • Citations1

Design and implementation of a database design aid using VP-Expert

  • Sep 30, 1991
  • I.-Y Song +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations7

Design and implementation of a CIM information system

  • Mar 01, 1994
  • Engineering with Computers
  • Bipin Chadha +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Database Design of Pop Music Website Development

  • Nov 01, 2014
  • Applied Mechanics and Materials
  • Ying Yue
  • Conference Article
  • Citations3

The Development and Usage of a Relational Database Design Tool for Educational Purposes

  • Jan 01, 2008
  • Milos Bogdanovic +3
  • Book Chapter
  • Citations6

Tools for the automation of database design

  • Jan 01, 1982
  • Rob Gerritsen
  • Research Article

Database Design on Warehouse Information System of College Music Equipment

  • Mar 01, 2014
  • Applied Mechanics and Materials
  • Xin Xin Lv
  • Research Article
  • Citations10

Extending classical functional dependencies for physical database design

  • Jan 01, 1996
  • Information and Software Technology
  • Tok Wang Ling +2
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.