An Improved Subspace Clustering Algorithm Based on Sparse Representation

Subspace clustering methods with sparsity prior, such as Sparse Subspace Clustering (SSC) [1], are effective in partitioning the data that lie in a union of subspaces. Most of those methods require certain assumptions, e.g. independence or disjointness, on the subspaces. These assumptions are not guaranteed to hold in practice and they limit the application of existing sparse subspace clustering methods. In this paper, we propose \(\ell ^{0}\)-induced sparse subspace clustering (\(\ell ^{0}\)-SSC). In contrast to the required assumptions, such as independence or disjointness, on subspaces for most existing sparse subspace clustering methods, we prove that subspace-sparse representation, a key element in subspace clustering, can be obtained by \(\ell ^{0}\)-SSC for arbitrary distinct underlying subspaces almost surely under the mild i.i.d. assumption on the data generation. We also present the “no free lunch” theorem that obtaining the subspace representation under our general assumptions can not be much computationally cheaper than solving the corresponding \(\ell ^{0}\) problem of \(\ell ^{0}\)-SSC. We develop a novel approximate algorithm named Approximate \(\ell ^{0}\)-SSC (\(\hbox {A}\ell ^{0}\)-SSC) that employs proximal gradient descent to obtain a sub-optimal solution to the optimization problem of \(\ell ^{0}\)-SSC with theoretical guarantee, and the sub-optimal solution is used to build a sparse similarity matrix for clustering. Extensive experimental results on various data sets demonstrate the superiority of \(\hbox {A}\ell ^{0}\)-SSC compared to other competing clustering methods.

Video co-segmentation refers to the task of jointly segmenting common objects appearing in a given group of videos. In practice, high-dimensional data such as videos can be conceptually thought as being drawn from a union of subspaces corresponding to categories rather than from a smooth manifold. Therefore, segmenting data into respective subspaces --- subspace clustering --- finds widespread applications in computer vision, including co-segmentation. State-of-the-art methods via subspace clustering seek to solve the problem in two steps: First, an affinity matrix is built from data, with appearance features or motion patterns. Second, the data are segmented by applying spectral clustering to the affinity matrix. However, this process is insufficient to obtain an optimal solution since it does not take into account the {\em interdependence} of the affinity matrix with the segmentation. In this work, we present a novel unified video co-segmentation framework inspired by the recent Structured Sparse Subspace Clustering ($\mathrm{S^{3}C}$) based on the {\em self-expressiveness} model. Our method yields more consistent segmentation results. In order to improve the detectability of motion features with missing trajectories due to occlusion or tracked points moving out of frames, we add an extra-dimensional signature to the motion trajectories. Moreover, we reformulate the $\mathrm{S^{3}C}$ algorithm by adding the affine subspace constraint in order to make it more suitable to segment rigid motions lying in affine subspaces of dimension at most $3$. Our experiments on MOViCS dataset show that our framework achieves the highest overall performance among baseline algorithms and demonstrate its robustness to heavy noise.

Data clustering is an important research topic in data mining and signal processing communications. In all the data clustering methods, the subspace spectral clustering methods based on self expression model, e.g., the Sparse Subspace Clustering (SSC) and the Low Rank Representation (LRR) methods, have attracted a lot of attention and shown good performance. The key step of SSC and LRR is to construct a proper affinity or similarity matrix of data for spectral clustering. Recently, Laplacian graph constraint was introduced into the basic SSC and LRR and obtained considerable improvement. However, the current graph construction methods do not well exploit and reveal the non-linear properties of the clustering data, which is common for high dimensional data. In this paper, we introduce the classic manifold learning method, the Local Linear Embedding (LLE), to learn the non-linear structure underlying the data and use the learned local geometry of manifold as a regularization for SSC and LRR, which results the proposed LLE-SSC and LLE-LRR clustering methods. Additionally, to solve the complex optimization problem involved in the proposed models, an efficient algorithm is also proposed. We test the proposed data clustering methods on several types of public databases. The experimental results show that our methods outperform typical subspace clustering methods with Laplacian graph constraint.

This paper studies the subspace segmentation problem. Given a set of data points drawn from a union of subspaces, the goal is to partition them into their underlying subspaces they were drawn from. The spectral clustering method is used as the framework. It requires to find an affinity matrix which is close to block diagonal, with nonzero entries corresponding to the data point pairs from the same subspace. In this work, we argue that both sparsity and the grouping effect are important for subspace segmentation. A sparse affinity matrix tends to be block diagonal, with less connections between data points from different subspaces. The grouping effect ensures that the highly corrected data which are usually from the same subspace can be grouped together. Sparse Subspace Clustering (SSC), by using $\ell^1$-minimization, encourages sparsity for data selection, but it lacks of the grouping effect. On the contrary, Low-Rank Representation (LRR), by rank minimization, and Least Squares Regression (LSR), by $\ell^2$-regularization, exhibit strong grouping effect, but they are short in subset selection. Thus the obtained affinity matrix is usually very sparse by SSC, yet very dense by LRR and LSR. In this work, we propose the Correlation Adaptive Subspace Segmentation (CASS) method by using trace Lasso. CASS is a data correlation dependent method which simultaneously performs automatic data selection and groups correlated data together. It can be regarded as a method which adaptively balances SSC and LSR. Both theoretical and experimental results show the effectiveness of CASS.

High-dimensional data is usually drawn from the union of multiple low-dimensional subspaces. The task of subspace clustering is to cluster high-dimensional data into their corresponding subspace. Subspace clustering algorithm based on spectral clustering is one of the important methods of subspace clustering. This method is proposed by the spectral clustering framework. This type of method is usually divided into two steps, namely learning the affinity matrix and obtaining the segmentation matrix by spectral clustering. However, the results obtained this way are often sub-optimal. Meanwhile many state-of-the-art algorithms do not consider consistency of correlation data, resulting in the affinity matrix either too dense to make the algorithm contain a lot of erroneous information, or too sparse to make the algorithm lose correlation information. In this paper, we propose Correlation Structured Low-Rank Subspace Clustering (CSLRSC). The CSLRSC is based on the model of low rank representation by adding new $l_{1}$ norm to solve the problem that the affinity matrix established by the previous method is too dense. Adding the structured norm to the model can integrate affinity matrix learning and spectral clustering into one step to obtain an approximate optimal solution of the algorithm. The experimental results that we obtain on Extended Yale B face dataset, MINIST hand-write dataset, and ORL dataset show that our algorithm is superior to others.

Subspace clustering refers to the problem of clustering high-dimensional data into a union of low-dimensional subspaces. Current subspace clustering approaches are usually based on a two-stage framework. In the first stage, an affinity matrix is generated from data. In the second one, spectral clustering is applied on the affinity matrix. However, the affinity matrix produced by two-stage methods cannot fully reveal the similarity between data points from the same subspace, resulting in inaccurate clustering. Besides, most approaches fail to solve large-scale clustering problems due to poor efficiency. In this paper, we first propose a new scalable sparse method called Iterative Maximum Correlation (IMC) to learn the affinity matrix from data. Then we develop Piecewise Correlation Estimation (PCE) to densify the intra-subspace similarity produced by IMC. Finally we extend our work into a Sparse-Dense Subspace Clustering (SDSC) framework with a dense stage to optimize the affinity matrix for two-stage methods. We show that IMC is efficient for large-scale tasks, and PCE ensures better performance for IMC. We show the universality of our SDSC framework for current two-stage methods as well. Experiments on benchmark data sets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approaches.

We propose Ordered Subspace Clustering (OSC) to segment data drawn from a sequentially ordered union of subspaces. Current subspace clustering techniques learn the relationships within a set of data and then use a separate clustering algorithm such as NCut for final segmentation. In contrast our technique, under certain conditions, is capable of segmenting clusters intrinsically without providing the number of clusters as a parameter. Similar to Sparse Subspace Clustering (SSC) we formulate the problem as one of finding a sparse representation but include a new penalty term to take care of sequential data. We test our method on data drawn from infrared hyper spectral data, video sequences and face images. Our experiments show that our method, OSC, outperforms the state of the art methods: Spatial Subspace Clustering (SpatSC), Low-Rank Representation (LRR) and SSC.

Attention reweighted sparse subspace clustering

Multi-view data clustering often aims to utilize various representations or views of original data to improve the clustering performance compared to the single-view clustering approach. Most multi-view subspace clustering methods are proposed to construct the affinity matrix of each view individually and then implement with spectral clustering for multi-view data clustering. The multi-view low-rank sparse subspace clustering (MLRSSC) is an effective and popular clustering algorithm among multi-view subspace clustering. This method can explore the joint subspace representation through creating an affinity matrix integrated of all views of input data. In addition, the low-rank and sparsity constraints are introduced into this method to enhance the clustering results. However, the original MLRSSC uses the mean square error as the fidelity term while not consider the complex noise pollution in real situations. Therefore, we introduce a complex noise modeling approach, i.e., independent and piecewise identically distributed (IPID) noise model, for MLRSSC to improve its performance. The related experimental results confirm that this proposed algorithm surpasses many state-of-the-art subspace clustering methods on several real-world datasets.

Multi-view subspace clustering has been an important and powerful tool for partitioning multi-view data, especially multi-view high-dimensional data. Despite great success, most of the existing multi-view subspace clustering methods still suffer from three limitations. First, they often recover the subspace structure in the original space, which can not guarantee the robustness when handling multi-view data with nonlinear structure. Second, these methods mostly regard subspace clustering and affinity matrix learning as two independent steps, which may not well discover the latent relationships among data samples. Third, many of them ignore the different importance of multiple views, whose performance may be badly affected by the low-quality views in multi-view data. To overcome these three limitations, this paper develops a novel subspace clustering method for multi-view data, termed Kernelized Multi-view Subspace Clustering via Auto-weighted Graph Learning (KMSC-AGL). Specifically, the proposed method implicitly maps the multi-view data from linear space into nonlinear space via kernel-induced functions, so as to exploit the nonlinear structure hidden in data. Furthermore, our method aims to enhance the clustering performance by learning a set of view-specific representations and their affinity matrix in a general framework. By integrating the view weighting strategy into this framework, our method can automatically assign the weights to different views, while learning an optimal affinity matrix that is well-adapted to the subsequent spectral clustering. Extensive experiments are conducted on a variety of multi-view data sets, which have demonstrated the superiority of the proposed method.

Compressive spectral imaging (CSI) acquires compressed observations of a spectral scene by applying different coding patterns at each spatial location and then performing a spectral-wise integration. Relying on compressive sensing, spectral image reconstruction is achieved by using nonlinear and relatively expensive optimization-based algorithms. In the CSI literature, several works have focused on improving reconstructions quality by properly designing the set of coding patterns. However, signal recovery is not actually necessary in many signal processing applications. For instance, assuming that compressed measurements with similar characteristics lie on the same subspace, unsupervised methods such as subspace clustering can be used to separate them into the same cluster. Since the structure of compressed measurements is defined by the applied codification, it is possible to improve clustering performance. This paper proposes to design a set of coding patterns such that inter-class and intra-class data structure is preserved after the CSI acquisition in order to improve clustering results directly on the compressed domain. To validate the coding pattern design, an algorithm based on sparse subspace clustering (SSC) is proposed to perform clustering on the compressed measurements. The proposed algorithm adds a three-dimensional (3-D) spatial regularizer to the SSC problem exploiting the spatial correlation of spectral images. In general, an overall accuracy up to 83.81% is obtained, when noisy measurements are assumed. In addition, a difference of at most 4% in terms of overall accuracy was observed when comparing the clustering results obtained by the full 3-D data with those achieved using CSI measurements acquired with the proposed coding pattern design.

Subspace clustering is the problem of partitioning unlabeled data points into a number of clusters so that data points within one cluster lie approximately on a low-dimensional linear subspace. In many practical scenarios, the dimensionality of data points to be clustered is compressed due to the constraints of measurement, computation, or privacy. In this paper, we study the theoretical properties of a popular subspace clustering algorithm named sparse subspace clustering (SSC) and establish formal success conditions of SSC on dimensionality-reduced data. Our analysis applies to the most general fully deterministic model, where both underlying subspaces and data points within each subspace are deterministically positioned, and also a wide range of dimensionality reduction techniques (e.g., Gaussian random projection, uniform subsampling, and sketching) that fall into a subspace embedding framework. Finally, we apply our analysis to a differentially private SSC algorithm and established both privacy and utility guarantees of the proposed method.

Gene expression data is a kind of high dimension and small sample size data. The clustering accuracy of conventional clustering techniques is lower on gene expression data due to its high dimension. Because some subspace segmentation approaches can be better applied in the high-dimensional space, three new subspace clustering models for gene expression data sets are proposed in this work. The proposed projection subspace clustering models have projection sparse subspace clustering, projection low-rank representation subspace clustering and projection least-squares regression subspace clustering which combine projection technique with sparse subspace clustering, low-rank representation and least-square regression, respectively. In order to compute the inner product in the high-dimensional space, the kernel function is used to the projection subspace clustering models. The experimental results on six gene expression data sets show these models are effective.

Sparse subspace clustering (SSC) has achieved state‐of‐the‐art clustering quality by performing spectral clustering over an ℓ1‐norm based similarity graph. However, SSC is a transductive method, i.e. it cannot handle out‐of‐sample data that is not used to construct the graph. For each new datum, SSC requires solving n optimisation problems in O(n) variables, where n is the number of data points. Therefore, it is inefficient to apply SSC in fast online clustering and scalable grouping. An inductive spectral clustering algorithm called inductive SSC (iSSC) is proposed, which makes SSC feasible to cluster out‐of‐sample data. iSSC adopts the assumption that high‐dimensional data actually lie on the low‐dimensional manifold such that out‐of‐sample data could be grouped in the embedding space learned from in‐sample data. Experimental results show that iSSC is promising in clustering out‐of‐sample data.

The main contribution of the paper is a new approach to subspace clustering that is significantly more computationally efficient and scalable than existing state-of-the-art methods. The central idea is to modify the regression technique in sparse subspace clustering (SSC) by replacing the $\ell_{1}$ minimization with a generalization called Ordered Weighted $\ell_{1}$ (OWL) minimization which performs simultaneous regression and clustering of correlated variables. Using random geometric graph theory, we prove that OWL regression selects more points within each subspace than $\ell_{1}$, resulting in better clustering results. This allows for accurate subspace clustering based on regression solutions for only a small subset of the total dataset, significantly reducing the computational complexity compared to SSC. In experiments, we find that our OWL approach can achieve a speedup of $ 20\times$ to $30\times$ for synthetic problems and $4\times$ to $8\times$ on real data problems.