Effect of eHealth intervention (ADHERE) on adherence to partograph and WHO safe childbirth checklist in intrapartum care: implementation research in Ethiopia.
The partograph and WHO safe childbirth checklist (SCC), which include on-admission, before-birth, after-birth and discharge components, are quality improvement (QI) tools in intrapartum care that have long been recommended for use. However, poor-quality intrapartum care remains a significant barrier to improving maternal and newborn health outcomes in countries like Ethiopia, largely due to total non-use or poor adherence to these QI tools. eHealth-based interventions present promising strategies to enhance healthcare quality. Therefore, we conducted implementation research to examine the effect of ADHERE (Antenatal care, chilDbirtH carE and postnatal ca.RE), an innovative eHealth system with a clinical decision support element, on adherence to QI tools during intrapartum care in health facilities in Ethiopia. A quasi-experimental study was conducted in 3 hospitals and 6 health centers (5 intervention and 4 control) in Ethiopia, guided by the Implementation Research Logic Model. Data were collected from labor and delivery charts by trained data collectors. A total of 2,190 charts (1,076 baseline [538 per arm] and 1,114 end-line [554 control and 560 intervention arms] charts) were included in the analysis. Difference-in-difference (DiD) analysis was used to estimate the effect of the intervention. The partograph adherence score and SCC completion rates were compared between the two arms. Statistically significant differences were determined using a p-value < 0.05 cutoff. Baseline mean partograph scores in the control and intervention arms were 4.11 and 4.23, respectively. Baseline SCC adherence rates at admission, before-birth, after-birth, and discharge were 25.8%, 24.9%, 24.9%, and 24.3% in the control arm, respectively, and 49.6%, 47.8%, 45.9%, and 45.5% in the intervention arm, respectively. The ADHERE intervention increased partograph adherence score by 4.27 units (DiD = 4.27, 95%CI [1.80, 5.09]). The ADHERE intervention increased SCC adherence by 9.3%-points (DiD = 0.093, 95%CI [0.036, 0.151]) at admission, 22.3%-points (DiD = 0.223, 95%CI [0.121, 0.325]) before-birth, and 15.2%-points (DiD = 0.152, 95%CI [0.072, 0.231]) after-birth. Conversely, the ADHERE intervention did not significantly change SCC adherence at discharge (DiD = -0.025, 95%CI [-0.071, 0.021]). The lack of significant improvement may be due to providers less attention to discharge evaluation because of work overload. The ADHERE intervention significantly improved adherence to partograph and SCC at admission, before-birth, and immediately after-birth during intrapartum care. However, it did not significantly improve adherence to the discharge checklist. Therefore, ADHERE-assisted implementation of QI tools can potentially prevent adverse birth outcomes related to low-quality intrapartum care and could be considered for scale up across health facilities in Ethiopia. Poor-quality childbirth care remains a significant barrier to improving health outcomes in countries like Ethiopia. eHealth interventions present promising strategies to enhance healthcare quality. We conducted implementation research to see the effect of a clinical decision support intervention on childbirth care in health facilities in Ethiopia. The study was conducted in three hospitals and six health centers: five received the new intervention and four continued with the usual care. We followed a step-by-step guide during project implementation. The data were gathered from 2,190 patient charts. We compared how childbirth care practices changed between the two groups over the two time periods (before- and after-intervention). We followed scientific procedure to declare that the differences were real. The intervention increased the correct use of partograph by 4.27 units as compared to without intervention. The intervention increased essential childbirth practices at admission by 9.3% points, practices during labor by 22.3% points, and practices immediately after birth by 15.2% points. Conversely, the intervention did not change essential childbirth practices at discharge from the facility. The intervention clearly helped health workers use the partograph correctly and follow key childbirth care steps when the woman arrived, during labor, and right after birth. Therefore, eHealth-assisted provision of key childbirth care can potentially prevent bad birth outcomes related to low-quality childbirth care and could be considered for scale-up across health facilities in Ethiopia.
Read more