Monument Lab: Creative Speculations for Philadelphia is a collection of documentations, reflections, and illustrations of the collectively authored urban art research project known as Monument Lab. Like the project itself, the book resists easy disciplinary categorization and serves as an illustrated catalog of an important public art exhibition, a scholarly resource on the role of public art in political and social discourses, and as a manual that prefigures future creative research projects engendered by its precedent. Throughout, the diverse texts are written with a general audience in mind.According to the primary organizers/curators Paul M. Farber and Ken Lum, Monument Lab is a “public art and history studio based in Philadelphia that comprises a team of curators, artists, scholars, and students [that] ask open research questions about the ways publicly sited art, memorials, and monuments operate.” A central question, “What is an appropriate monument for the current city of Philadelphia?,” served as a foundation for a variety of activities that reached over a quarter of a million participants in culminating events held between September 16 and November 19, 2017 (x). These included an exhibition of twenty artists who created their own prototype monuments that were sited in different neighborhoods, institutions, and historic locations across the City of Philadelphia; the operation of staffed outdoor research labs housed in shipping containers that encouraged citizens to contribute their own ideas for appropriate monuments through sketches and answers to simple questions on forms; and the compilation of 4,500 of these proposals as data into a Report to the City, much of which can now be accessed online at proposals.monumentlab.com.The book, which documents all of these activities, is organized into the following four sections: “Essays,” three introductory essays by organizers and collaborators Paul M. Farber, Ken Lum, and Jane Golden; “Artists Reflections,” basic descriptions of each artist's project followed by a longer literary or scholarly reflection on it written by others, followed by high quality color photographs of the artwork; “Research,” a reflective essay on the research findings by librarian and Monument Lab research director Laurie Allen; and “Monumental Exchanges,” transcriptions of three public conversations held by various interlocutors in September and November 2017. Throughout, and interspersing these four sections are approximately seventy-five quarter-page reproductions of samples of the 4,500 citizen-submitted monument proposals. The accompanying essays throughout the book are generally short but rich resources of academic contextualization, personal and poetic responses to different artworks or the city itself (such as Ursula Rucker's love letter to Philadelphia, Epic Poem), and artists' interviews.As a collection, the book chronicles through practice-based creative research, the timely and urgent resurrection of a foreboding sense of a crisis of identity for many Americans; one that has only come more clearly into focus over the last two years as the fractious internal politics of the United States continue to ideologically divide citizens also ravaged by climate, health, and economic disaster. Despite these ongoing challenges and the searing loss of human life from COVID-19, the radical spirit of the Constitution retains its potency in the urban centers of the United States. The American Dream of prosperity can be found embedded in the vibrant communities of African Americans, Native Americans, and generations of immigrants who live in cities like Philadelphia. The latter will forever be marked by the geographic and discursive legacies of its special history as the home of American independence, which makes the city arguably the best place in the country to embark on a long-term research project about what monuments erected to honor local and national histories actually represent and for whom. The book seems to ask: What is at stake for the future in one's honoring of the past?Indeed, the many documents that comprise Monument Lab testify to the complex narrative threads that depict the work-in-progress of American democracy. Sculptor Karyn Olivier's The Battle Is Joined consisted of a twenty-foot high mirrored shell enclosing the 1903 Battle of Germantown Memorial (also known as the Soldier's Monument) in Vernon Park. Olivier hid architect Frank Miles Day's commemoration of a 1777 battle between American and British soldiers behind the mirrored reflections of trees and local residents, the latter often delighted to see themselves reflected in its surface.On the banks of the Delaware River, on the site of an ancient Lenape village called Shackamaxon, and near where William Penn and Lenape Chief Tamanend met to negotiate a peace treaty in the 1680s, Omaskeko Ininiwak artist Duane Linklater mounted a red neon sign in the form of his daughter's handwriting that said “as long as the rivers flow, and the sun, moon, and stars endure” (127). According to oral tradition this is a phrase taken from Tamanend's response to Penn in the famous “Treaty of Friendship”: “We will live in love with William Penn and his children as long as the creeks and rivers flow, and the sun, moon, and stars endure” (127). The poetic words of friendship, now understood as a broken promise to the Lenape people, illuminated the landscape with an eerie red glow.In Center City, another testimonial to historic erasures could be found in Rittenhouse Square. Sharon Hayes placed a number of figureless cast concrete monument pedestals in a group (If They Should Ask, 2017). Inscribed text on the pedestals offered up the many names of women who have been almost entirely excluded from representation in monumental form in Philadelphia. These platforms holding up the absence of female accomplishments also acted as sites for impromptu activation by passersby who climbed up on them to give voice to current issues.What is clear from this research lab and its book-form is that our public monuments are so far woefully inadequate to the task of representing the diversity of American life in the twenty-first century and are instead predictably weighted toward Colonial Euro-American master narratives of power and conquest. Many of the public's proposals submitted to the Monument Lab reflect these omissions, such as an anonymous proposal to erect a “plaque & tour of the rich cultural history of Washington Square as it was shaped and influenced by the African American community in Philadelphia” (125), as well as proposals to honor the lives or work of Billie Holiday, Sun Ra, Rufus Harley, Joel Embiid, and Joe Frazier, among many others.Monument Lab: Creative Speculations for Philadelphia might be compared to Creative Time's multifaceted national traveling exhibition and series of events in 2008 collectively titled Democracy in America, which resulted in the publication A Guide to Democracy in America. Organized parallel to the 2008 presidential campaign that resulted in Barack Obama's election, the Democracy in America events focused on artwork that questioned “the nature of war, freedom, justice and how we define democracy.”1 While the latter included an overview of more than 100 artist and activist projects across nine cities and numerous states, Monument Lab is distinguished by its emphasis on the particularity of Philadelphia's monuments as markers and producers of collective meaning, and through its ongoing and inclusive research methods. As such, this book will be of significance to anyone interested in the history of the city of Philadelphia, American public art, and the ongoing national debate about the relevance and management of historic monuments in the twenty-first century.
Read more