- Research Article
37
- 10.1016/j.acra.2007.05.025
A Validation Framework for Brain Tumor Segmentation
- Sep 20, 2007
- Academic Radiology
- Neculai Archip + 2 more +2
A Validation Framework for Brain Tumor Segmentation
Automated segmentation of brain tumour from multimodal MR images is pivotal for the analysis and monitoring of disease progression. As gliomas are malignant and heterogeneous, efficient and accurate segmentation techniques are used for the successful delineation of tumours into intra-tumoural classes. Deep learning algorithms outperform on tasks of semantic segmentation as opposed to the more conventional, context-based computer vision approaches. Extensively used for biomedical image segmentation, Convolutional Neural Networks have significantly improved the state-of-the-art accuracy on the task of brain tumour segmentation. In this paper, we propose an ensemble of two segmentation networks: a 3D CNN and a U-Net, in a significant yet straightforward combinative technique that results in better and accurate predictions. Both models were trained separately on the BraTS-19 challenge dataset and evaluated to yield segmentation maps which considerably differed from each other in terms of segmented tumour sub-regions and were ensembled variably to achieve the final prediction. The suggested ensemble achieved dice scores of 0.750, 0.906 and 0.846 for enhancing tumour, whole tumour, and tumour core, respectively, on the validation set, performing favourably in comparison to the state-of-the-art architectures currently available.
Loading PDF
A Validation Framework for Brain Tumor Segmentation
A Validation Framework for Brain Tumor Segmentation
An Integrated Deep Convolutional Neural Networks Framework for The Automatic Segmentation and Grading of Glioma Tumors Using Multimodal MRI Scans
Gliomas are the most prevalent and aggressive primary brain tumors characterized by rapid progressions and infiltration. Timely and precise diagnosis is crucial for effective oncology treatment. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) facilitates noninvasive assessment of brain lesions. Manual brain tumor evaluation from MRI scans is labor-intensive, relies heavily on clinician experience, and is prone to errors. Consequently, automated diagnosis of brain tumors is essential for optimal clinical management and glioma surgical interventions. This study introduces an Integrated Deep Convolutional Neural Network (IDCNN)-based framework for segmenting and grading glioma tumors from multimodal MRI scans. The framework integrates two state-of-the-art CNN architectures. Based on 3D U-Net architecture, the first CNN performs tumor segmentation from multimodal MRI volumes. The segmentation network utilizes the encoder for feature extraction and dimensionality reduction, while the decoder reconstructs the output to the original input size. A thorough performance evaluation of CNN architectures based on pre-trained (ResNet50, EfficientNetB0, DensNet121, EfficientNetB2, and ResNet152V2) was conducted on a three-class dataset of glioma, meningioma, and pituitary tumors to determine the best model for tumor grading. EfficientNetB2 surpassed other models across all evaluation metrics, achieving 99.19% test accuracy, 99.17% precision, 98.94% sensitivity, 99.57% specificity, and 99.06% F1-score. The optimal EfficientNetB2 model was subsequently utilized to grade tumors identified by the segmentation network. The proposed framework exhibited exceptional performance in both segmentation and grading tasks, attaining dice coefficient scores (DSC) of 86.13, 86.75, and 92.41 in enhancing tumor, tumor core, and whole tumor, respectively, alongside 98.49% classification accuracy for high- and low-grade glioma. Experimental findings validate the superior capabilities of the proposed framework compared to the existing methods. These results highlight the potential of the proposed model to aid radiologists in achieving accurate and reliable diagnoses, improving patient outcomes, and supporting clinical decision-making.
Read moreAn integrated deep convolutional neural networks framework for the automatic segmentation and grading of glioma tumors using multimodal MRI scans
Gliomas are the most prevalent and aggressive primary brain tumors characterized by rapid progressions and infiltration. Timely and precise diagnosis is crucial for effective oncology treatment. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) facilitates noninvasive assessment of brain lesions. Manual brain tumor evaluation from MRI scans is labor-intensive, relies heavily on clinician experience, and is prone to errors. Consequently, automated diagnosis of brain tumors is essential for optimal clinical management and glioma surgical interventions. This study introduces an Integrated Deep Convolutional Neural Network (IDCNN)-based framework for segmenting and grading glioma tumors from multimodal MRI scans. The framework integrates two state-of-the-art CNN architectures. Based on 3D U-Net architecture, the first CNN performs tumor segmentation from multimodal MRI volumes. The segmentation network utilizes the encoder for feature extraction and dimensionality reduction, while the decoder reconstructs the output to the original input size. A thorough performance evaluation of CNN architectures based on pre-trained (ResNet50, EfficientNetB0, DensNet121, EfficientNetB2, and ResNet152V2) was conducted on a three-class dataset of glioma, meningioma, and pituitary tumors to determine the best model for tumor grading. EfficientNetB2 surpassed other models across all evaluation metrics, achieving 99.19% test accuracy, 99.17% precision, 98.94% sensitivity, 99.57% specificity, and 99.06% F1-score. The optimal EfficientNetB2 model was subsequently utilized to grade tumors identified by the segmentation network. The proposed framework exhibited exceptional performance in both segmentation and grading tasks, attaining dice coefficient scores (DSC) of 86.13, 86.75, and 92.41 in enhancing tumor, tumor core, and whole tumor, respectively, alongside 98.49% classification accuracy for high- and low-grade glioma. Experimental findings validate the superior capabilities of the proposed framework compared to the existing methods. These results highlight the potential of the proposed model to aid radiologists in achieving accurate and reliable diagnoses, improving patient outcomes, and supporting clinical decision-making.
Read moreK-NET+SEGAN-BASED SEGMENTATION WITH GANNET AQUILA OPTIMIZATION ALGORITHM-ENABLED DEEP MAXOUT NETWORK FOR BRAIN TUMOR CLASSIFICATION USING MRI
Segmentation and classification of brain tumor are time-consuming and challenging chore in clinical image processing. Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) offers more information related to human soft tissues that assists in diagnosing brain tumor. Precise segmentation of the MRI images is vital to diagnose brain tumor by means of computer-aided medical tools. Afterwards suitable segmentation of MRI brain tumor images, tumor classification is performed that is a hard chore owing to complications. Therefore, Gannet Aquila Optimization Algorithm_deep maxout network (GAOA_DMN) and GAOA_K-Net+speech enhancement generative adversarial network (GAOA_K-Net+Segan) is presented for classification and segmentation of brain tumor utilizing MRI images. Here, pre-processing phase performs noise removal from input image utilizing the Laplacian filter and also the region of interest (ROI) extraction is also carried out. Then, segmentation of brain tumor is conducted by K-Net+Segan, which is combined by Motyka similarity. However, K-Net+Segan for segmentation is trained by GAOA that is an amalgamation of Gannet Optimization Algorithm (GOA) and Aquila Optimizer (AO). From segmented image, features are extracted for performing classification phase. At last, brain tumor classification is conducted by DMN, which is tuned by GAOA and thus, output is obtained. Furthermore, GAOA_K-Net+Segan obtained better outcomes in terms of segmentation accuracy whereas devised GAOA_DMN achieved maximum accuracy, true negative rate (TNR) and true positive rate (TPR) of 92.7%, 94.5% and 91.5%.
Read more3D Brain Tumor Image Segmentation Integrating Cascaded Anisotropic Fully Convolutional Neural Network and Hybrid Level Set Method
The accuracy of three-dimensional (3D) brain tumor image segmentation is of great significance to brain tumor diagnosis. To enhance the accuracy of segmentation, this study proposes an algorithm integrating a cascaded anisotropic fully convolutional neural network (FCNN) and the hybrid level set method. The algorithm first performs bias field correction and gray value normalization on T1, T1C, T2, and fluid-attenuated inversion recovery magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) images for preprocessing. It then uses a cascading mechanism to perform preliminary segmentation of whole tumors, tumor cores, and enhancing tumors by an anisotropic FCNN based on the relationships among the locations of the three types of tumor structures. This simplifies multiclass brain tumor image segmentation problems into three binary classification problems. At the same time, the anisotropic FCNN adopts dense connections and multiscale feature merging to further enhance performance. Model training is respectively conducted on the axial, coronal, and sagittal planes, and the segmentation results from the three different orthogonal views are combined. Finally, the hybrid level set method is adopted to refine the brain tumor boundaries in the preliminary segmentation results, thereby completing fine segmentation. The results indicate that the proposed algorithm can achieve 3D MRI brain tumor image segmentation of high accuracy and stability. Comparison of the whole-tumor, tumor-core, and enhancing-tumor segmentation results with the gold standards produced Dice similarity coefficients (Dice) of 0.9113, 0.8581, and 0.7976, respectively.
Read moreAn improved approach of high graded glioma segmentation using sparse autoencoder and fuzzy c-means clustering from multi-modal MR images
Accurate and automated brain tumor segmentation using multi modal MR images is essential for the evaluation of the disease progression in order to improve disease diagnosis and treatment planning. We present a new fully automated method for high graded brain tumor segmentation combining sparse autoencoder and multimodal Fuzzy C-means clustering. The approach utilizes multimodal MRI contrast: T1, T2, FLAIR and T1c (contrast-enhanced) for 15 high graded glioma (HGG) subjects. The objective of the proposed study is to segment tumor tissues from HGG including edema and tumor core within edema. The segmentation was performed on the training data of the multimodal brain tumor image segmentation benchmark 2015. Sparse autoencoder, which is an unsupervised learning algorithm, was used to automatically learn features from unlabeled dataset of tumor in order to segment edema. Followed by edema segmentation, tumor core was segmented from edema using multimodal FCM clustering. Evaluating the performance of the segmentation results with the ground truth yields high dice score (DS) of 0.9866±0.01 and 0.9843±0.01 for edema and tumor core respectively and high Jaccard similarity (JS) of 0.9738±0.02 and 0.9692±0.02 for edema and tumor core respectively; showed high accuracy in segmenting the complex tumor structures from multi-contrast MR scans of HGG patients. We also compared our methodology in terms of segmentation efficiency with some recent techniques reported in proceedings of MICCAI-BRATS challenge 2015.
Read moreA Novel Encoder Decoder Architecture with Vision Transformer for Medical Image Segmentation
Brain tumor image segmentation is one of the most critical tasks in medical imaging for diagnosis, treatment planning, and prognosis. Traditional methods for brain tumor image segmentation are mostly based on Convolution Neural Network (CNN), which have been proved very powerful but still have limitations to effectively capture long-range dependencies and complex spatial hierarchies in MRI images. Variability in the shape, size, and location of tumors may affect the performance and may get stuck into suboptimal outcomes. In these regards, new encoder-decoder architecture with the VisionTranscoder(ViT) is proposed, to enhance brain tumor detection and classification. The proposed VisionTranscoder exploits a transformer's ability in modeling global context through self-attention mechanisms, providing more inclusive interpretation of the intricate patterns in medical images and classification by capturing both local and global features. The proposed VisionTranscoder maintains the Vision Transformer in its encoder for processing images as sequences of patches to capture global dependencies often outside the view of traditional CNNs. Then the segmentation map is rebuilt at a high level of fidelity with the decoder through upsampling and skips connections to maintain detailed spatial information. The risk of overfitting is hugely reduced by design and advanced regularization techniques with extensive data augmentation. The dataset contains 7,023 human brain MRI images, all of which are in four different classes: glioma, meningioma, no tumor, and pituitary. Images from the 'no tumor' class, indicating an MRI scan without any detectable tumor, were taken from the Br35H dataset . The results show the efficiency of VisionTranscoder over a wide set of brain MRI scans, producing an accuracy of 98.5% with a loss of 0.05. This performance underlines the ability of it to accurately segment and classify a brain tumor without overfitting.
Read moreThree-dimensional multipath DenseNet for improving automatic segmentation of glioblastoma on pre-operative multimodal MR images.
Convolutional neural networks have achieved excellent results in automatic medical image segmentation. In this study, we proposed a novel three-dimensional (3D) multipath DenseNet for generating the accurate glioblastoma (GBM) tumor contour from four multimodal pre-operative MR images. We hypothesized that the multipath architecture could achieve more accurate segmentation than a singlepath architecture. Two hundred and fifty-eight GBM patients were included in this study. Each patient had four MR images (T1-weighted, contrast-enhanced T1-weighted, T2-weighted, and FLAIR) and the manually segmented tumor contour. We built a 3D multipath DenseNet that could be trained to achieve an end-to-end mapping from four MR images to the corresponding GBM tumor contour. A 3D singlepath DenseNet was also built for comparison. Both DenseNets were based on the encoder-decoder architecture. All four images were concatenated and fed into a single encoder path in the singlepath DenseNet, while each input image had its own encoder path in the multipath DenseNet. The patient cohort was randomly split into a training set of 180 patients, a validation set of 39 patients, and a testing set of 39 patients. Model performance was evaluated using the Dice similarity coefficient (DSC), average surface distance (ASD), and 95% Hausdorff distance (HD95% ). Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were conducted to assess statistical significances. The singlepath DenseNet achieved the DSC of 0.911±0.060, ASD of 1.3±0.7mm, and HD95% of 5.2±7.1mm, while the multipath DenseNet achieved the DSC of 0.922±0.041, ASD of 1.1±0.5mm, and HD95% of 3.9±3.3mm. The P-values of all Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were less than 0.05. Both DenseNets generated GBM tumor contours in good agreement with the manually segmented contours from multimodal MR images. The multipath DenseNet achieved more accurate tumor segmentation than the singlepath DenseNet. Here presented the 3D multipath DenseNet that demonstrated an improved accuracy over comparable algorithms in the clinical task of GBM tumor segmentation.
Read moreA Review on Convolutional Neural Networks for Brain Tumor Segmentation: Methods, Datasets, Libraries, and Future Directions
A Review on Convolutional Neural Networks for Brain Tumor Segmentation: Methods, Datasets, Libraries, and Future Directions
Read moreA Fully Automated Deep Learning Network for Brain Tumor Segmentation.
We developed a fully automated method for brain tumor segmentation using deep learning; 285 brain tumor cases with multiparametric magnetic resonance images from the BraTS2018 data set were used. We designed 3 separate 3D-Dense-UNets to simplify the complex multiclass segmentation problem into individual binary-segmentation problems for each subcomponent. We implemented a 3-fold cross-validation to generalize the network's performance. The mean cross-validation Dice-scores for whole tumor (WT), tumor core (TC), and enhancing tumor (ET) segmentations were 0.92, 0.84, and 0.80, respectively. We then retrained the individual binary-segmentation networks using 265 of the 285 cases, with 20 cases held-out for testing. We also tested the network on 46 cases from the BraTS2017 validation data set, 66 cases from the BraTS2018 validation data set, and 52 cases from an independent clinical data set. The average Dice-scores for WT, TC, and ET were 0.90, 0.84, and 0.80, respectively, on the 20 held-out testing cases. The average Dice-scores for WT, TC, and ET on the BraTS2017 validation data set, the BraTS2018 validation data set, and the clinical data set were as follows: 0.90, 0.80, and 0.78; 0.90, 0.82, and 0.80; and 0.85, 0.80, and 0.77, respectively. A fully automated deep learning method was developed to segment brain tumors into their subcomponents, which achieved high prediction accuracy on the BraTS data set and on the independent clinical data set. This method is promising for implementation into a clinical workflow.
Read moreScSE-NL V-Net: A Brain Tumor Automatic Segmentation Method Based on Spatial and Channel "Squeeze-and-Excitation" Network With Non-local Block.
Intracranial tumors are commonly known as brain tumors, which can be life-threatening in severe cases. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is widely used in diagnosing brain tumors because of its harmless to the human body and high image resolution. Due to the heterogeneity of brain tumor height, MRI imaging is exceptionally irregular. How to accurately and quickly segment brain tumor MRI images is still one of the hottest topics in the medical image analysis community. However, according to the brain tumor segmentation algorithms, we could find now, most segmentation algorithms still stay in two-dimensional (2D) image segmentation, which could not obtain the spatial dependence between features effectively. In this study, we propose a brain tumor automatic segmentation method called scSE-NL V-Net. We try to use three-dimensional (3D) data as the model input and process the data by 3D convolution to get some relevance between dimensions. Meanwhile, we adopt non-local block as the self-attention block, which can reduce inherent image noise interference and make up for the lack of spatial dependence due to convolution. To improve the accuracy of convolutional neural network (CNN) image recognition, we add the “Spatial and Channel Squeeze-and-Excitation” Network (scSE-Net) to V-Net. The dataset used in this paper is from the brain tumor segmentation challenge 2020 database. In the test of the official BraTS2020 verification set, the Dice similarity coefficient is 0.65, 0.82, and 0.76 for the enhanced tumor (ET), whole tumor (WT), and tumor core (TC), respectively. Thereby, our model can make an auxiliary effect on the diagnosis of brain tumors established.
Read moreBrain Tumor Segmentation in MRI Scans Using Deeply-Supervised Neural Networks
Gliomas are the most frequent primary brain tumors in adults. Improved quantification of the various aspects of a glioma requires accurate segmentation of the tumor in magnetic resonance images (MRI). Since the manual segmentation is time-consuming and subject to human error and irreproducibility, automatic segmentation has received a lot of attention in recent years. This paper presents a fully automated segmentation method which is capable of automatic segmentation of brain tumor from multi-modal MRI scans. The proposed method is comprised of a deeply-supervised neural network based on Holistically-Nested Edge Detection (HED) network. The HED method, which is originally developed for the binary classification task of image edge detection, is extended for multiple-class segmentation. The classes of interest include the whole tumor, tumor core, and enhancing tumor. The dataset provided by 2017 Multimodal Brain Tumor Image Segmentation Benchmark (BraTS) challenge is used in this work for training the neural network and performance evaluations. Experiments on BraTS 2017 challenge datasets demonstrate that the method performs well compared to the existing works. The assessments revealed the Dice scores of 0.86, 0.60, and 0.69 for whole tumor, tumor core, and enhancing tumor classes, respectively.
Read moreStudy on MRI Brain Tumor Recognition and Segmentation Based on an Improved U-Net Network Model
Current malignant tumor is one of the main causes of death in Chinese residents, and the incidence of brain tumor in the population is higher. With the continuous development of modern imaging technology, especially MRI imaging technology, it provides a favorable help for doctors to assess brain tumors and choose treatment options. The accuracy of brain tumor segmentation is the key for doctors to diagnose patients’ medical condition information. Brain tumor’s structure is complex, shape is changeable and grayscale isn’t uniform, showing considerable differences in different patients. Artificial segmentation of MRI brain tumor images is time-consuming, and it is often affected by subjective differences. For the above reasons, researchers are working to develop an MRI brain tumor recognition segmentation method. This paper presents a recognition and segmentation method for MRI brain tumors, based on an improved U-Net network model. The proposed method avoids too large or too small learning rate leading to too fast or too slow convergence, and adds the BatchNormalization module to normalize the input of the input activation function of the network, thus realizing the training length, robustness, and accurately and completely dividing the brain tumor image. This paper performs detection experiments on the Kaggle+LGG Datasets, with the average classification accuracy of 99.8309%, the average IoU is 0.9935, and the average Dice coefficient is 0.9956.
Read moreNested Dilation Networks for Brain Tumor Segmentation Based on Magnetic Resonance Imaging.
Aim: Brain tumors are among the most fatal cancers worldwide. Diagnosing and manually segmenting tumors are time-consuming clinical tasks, and success strongly depends on the doctor's experience. Automatic quantitative analysis and accurate segmentation of brain tumors are greatly needed for cancer diagnosis.Methods:This paper presents an advanced three-dimensional multimodal segmentation algorithm called nested dilation networks (NDNs). It is inspired by the U-Net architecture, a convolutional neural network (CNN) developed for biomedical image segmentation and is modified to achieve better performance for brain tumor segmentation. Thus, we propose residual blocks nested with dilations (RnD) in the encoding part to enrich the low-level features and use squeeze-and-excitation (SE) blocks in both the encoding and decoding parts to boost significant features. To prove the reliability of the network structure, we compare our results with those of the standard U-Net and its transmutation networks. Different loss functions are considered to cope with class imbalance problems to maximize the brain tumor segmentation results. A cascade training strategy is employed to run NDNs for coarse-to-fine tumor segmentation. This strategy decomposes the multiclass segmentation problem into three binary segmentation problems and trains each task sequentially. Various augmentation techniques are utilized to increase the diversity of the data to avoid overfitting.Results: This approach achieves Dice similarity scores of 0.6652, 0.5880, and 0.6682 for edema, non-enhancing tumors, and enhancing tumors, respectively, in which the Dice loss is used for single-pass training. After cascade training, the Dice similarity scores rise to 0.7043, 0.5889, and 0.7206, respectively.Conclusion: Experiments show that the proposed deep learning algorithm outperforms other U-Net transmutation networks for brain tumor segmentation. Moreover, applying cascade training to NDNs facilitates better performance than other methods. The findings of this study provide considerable insight into the automatic and accurate segmentation of brain tumors.
Read moreAutomated Segmentation of Brain Tumor MRI Images Using Deep Learning
Segmenting brain tumors automatically using MR data is crucial for disease investigation and monitoring. Due to the aggressive nature and diversity of gliomas, well-organized and exact segmentation methods are used to classify tumors intra-tumorally. The proposed technique uses a Gray Level Co-occurrence matrix extraction of features approach to strip out unwanted details from the images. In comparison with the current state of the art, the accuracy of brain tumor segmentation was significantly improved using Convolutional Neural Networks, which are frequently used in the field of biomedical image segmentation. By merging the results of two separate segmentation networks, the proposed method demonstrates a major but simple combinatorial strategy that, as a direct consequence, yields much more precise and complete estimates. A U-Net and a Three-Dimensional Convolutional Neural Network. These networks are used to break up images into their component parts. Following that, the prediction was constructed using two distinct models that were combined in a number of ways. In comparison to existing state-of-the-art designs, the proposed method achieves the mean accuracy (%) of 99.40, 98.46, 98.29, precision (%) of 99.41, 98.51, 98.35, F-Score (%) of 99.4, 98.29, 98.46 and sensitivity (%) of 99.39, 98.41, 98.25 for the whole tumor, enhanced tumor, tumor core on the validation set, respectively.
Read more