Callan-Symanzik Equations andεExpansions

The field theoretic renormalization group technique together with the operator product expansion in the second order of the perturbation theory (in the two-loop approximation) is used for the investigation of the influence of the finite time correlations of the velocity field on the anomalous dimensions of the leading set of composite operators, which drive the anomalous scaling of correlation functions of a weak magnetic field in the framework of the kinematic Kazantsev–Kraichnan model in the presence of a large scale anisotropy. The system of possible scaling regimes of the model is found and two important special limits of the model are briefly discussed. The general two-loop expressions for the anomalous and critical dimensions of the leading composite operators are found as functions of the spatial dimension d and of the renormalization group fixed point value of the parameter u, which drives the presence of the finite time correlations of the velocity field in the model. The anisotropic hierarchies among various anomalous dimensions are investigated and it is shown that, regardless of the fixed point value of the parameter u as well as regardless of the spatial dimension of the system, the leading role in the anomalous scaling properties of the model is played by the anomalous dimensions of the composite operators near the isotropic shell, in accordance with the Kolmogorov’s local isotropy restoration hypothesis. The properties of the anomalous dimensions of the leading composite operators in the Kazantsev–Kraichnan model with finite time correlations of the velocity field are compared to the properties of the corresponding anomalous dimensions of the composite operators relevant in the framework of the Kraichnan model of passively advected scalar field with finite time correlations. It is shown that, regardless of the fixed point value of the parameter u, the two-loop corrections to the anomalous dimensions are much more important in the framework of the Kazantsev–Kraichnan vector model than in the Kraichnan model of a passive scalar advection. At the same time, again regardless of the strength of time correlations, the two-loop values of the leading anomalous dimensions in the Kazantsev–Kraichnan model of the passive magnetic field are significantly more negative than the corresponding two-loop values of the relevant anomalous dimensions in the framework of the Kraichnan model. It means that the anomalous scaling of the correlation functions of the passive magnetic field, deep inside the inertial interval of the turbulent environment with finite time correlations of the velocity field, must be much more pronounced than in the case of the correlation functions of the passively advected scalar field.

We compute the anomalous dimensions of a set of composite operators which involve derivatives at four loops in \(\bar{\rm MS}\) in \(\phi^4\) theory as a function of the operator moment \(n\). These operators are similar to the twist-2 operators which arise in QCD in the operator product expansion in deep inelastic scattering. By regarding their inverse Mellin transform as being equivalent to the DGLAP splitting functions we explore to what extent taking a restricted set of operator moments can give a good approximation to the exact four loop result.

Monopole operators are studied in a large family of quantum critical points between Dirac and topological quantum spin liquids (QSLs): chiral and Z$_{2}$ QSLs. These quantum phase transitions are described by conformal field theories (CFTs): quantum electrodynamics in 2+1 dimensions with 2N flavors of two-component massless Dirac fermions and a four-fermion interaction. For the transition to a chiral spin liquid, it is the Gross-Neveu interaction (QED$_{3}$-GN), while for the transitions to Z$_{2}$ QSLs it is a superconducting pairing term with general spin/valley structure (generalized QED$_{3}$-Z$_{2}$GN). Using the state-operator correspondence, we obtain monopole scaling dimensions to sub-leading order in 1/N. For monopoles with a minimal topological charge q=1/2, the scaling dimension is 2N*0.26510 at leading-order, with the quantum correction being 0.118911(7) for the chiral spin liquid, and 0.102846(9) for the simplest Z$_{2}$ case (the expression is also given for a general pairing term). Although these two anomalous dimensions are nearly equal, the underlying quantum fluctuations possess distinct origins. The analogous result in QED$_{3}$ is also obtained and we find a sub-leading contribution of -0.038138(5), which differs slightly from the value first obtained in the literature. The scaling dimension of a QED$_{3}$-GN monopole with minimal charge is very close to the scaling dimensions of other operators predicted to be equal by a conjectured duality between QED$_{3}$-GN with 2N=2 flavors and the CP$^{1}$ model. Additionally, non-minimally charged monopoles on both sides of the duality have similar scaling dimensions. By studying the large-q asymptotics of the scaling dimensions in QED$_{3}$, QED$_{3}$-GN, and QED$_{3}$-Z$_{2}$GN we verify that the constant O(q$^{0}$) coefficient precisely matches the universal non-perturbative prediction for CFTs with a global U(1) symmetry.

Operator products in 2-dimensional critical theories

Logarithmic operators and hidden continuous symmetry in critical disordered models

Operator-product expansion with spontaneously broken symmetry

We study integrability of fishnet-type Feynman graphs arising in planar four-dimensional bi-scalar chiral theory recently proposed in arXiv:1512.06704 as a special double scaling limit of gamma-deformed mathcal{N} = 4 SYM theory. We show that the transfer matrix “building” the fishnet graphs emerges from the R−matrix of non-compact conformal SU(2, 2) Heisenberg spin chain with spins belonging to principal series representations of the four-dimensional conformal group. We demonstrate explicitly a relationship between this integrable spin chain and the Quantum Spectral Curve (QSC) of mathcal{N} = 4 SYM. Using QSC and spin chain methods, we construct Baxter equation for Q−functions of the conformal spin chain needed for computation of the anomalous dimensions of operators of the type tr(ϕ1J) where ϕ1 is one of the two scalars of the theory. For J = 3 we derive from QSC a quantization condition that fixes the relevant solution of Baxter equation. The scaling dimensions of the operators only receive contributions from wheel-like graphs. We develop integrability techniques to compute the divergent part of these graphs and use it to present the weak coupling expansion of dimensions to very high orders. Then we apply our exact equations to calculate the anomalous dimensions with J = 3 to practically unlimited precision at any coupling. These equations also describe an infinite tower of local conformal operators all carrying the same charge J = 3. The method should be applicable for any J and, in principle, to any local operators of bi-scalar theory. We show that at strong coupling the scaling dimensions can be derived from semiclassical quantization of finite gap solutions describing an integrable system of noncompact SU(2, 2) spins. This bears similarities with the classical strings arising in the strongly coupled limit of mathcal{N} = 4 SYM.

Composite operators from the operator product expansion: what can go wrong?

We develop the idea of an effective conformal theory describing the low-lying spectrum of the dilatation operator in a CFT. Such an effective theory is useful when the spectrum contains a hierarchy in the dimension of operators, and a small parameter whose role is similar to that of 1/N in a large N gauge theory. These criteria insure that there is a regime where the dilatation operator is modified perturbatively. Global AdS is the natural framework for perturbations of the dilatation operator respecting conformal invariance, much as Minkowski space naturally describes Lorentz invariant perturbations of the Hamiltonian. Assuming that the lowest-dimension single-trace operator is a scalar, O, we consider the anomalous dimensions, gamma(n,l), of the double-trace operators of the form O (del^2)^n (del)^l O. Purely from the CFT we find that perturbative unitarity places a bound on these dimensions of |gamma(n,l)|<4. Non-renormalizable AdS interactions lead to violations of the bound at large values of n. We also consider the case that these interactions are generated by integrating out a heavy scalar field in AdS. We show that the presence of the heavy field "unitarizes" the growth in the anomalous dimensions, and leads to a resonance-like behavior in gamma(n,l) when n is close to the dimension of the CFT operator dual to the heavy field. Finally, we demonstrate that bulk flat-space S-matrix elements can be extracted from the large n behavior of the anomalous dimensions. This leads to a direct connection between the spectrum of anomalous dimensions in d-dimensional CFTs and flat-space S-matrix elements in d+1 dimensions. We comment on the emergence of flat-space locality from the CFT perspective.

In this work we propose improved holographic hard wall (HW) models by the inclusion of anomalous dimensions in the dual operators that describe glueballs inspired by the AdS/CFT correspondence. The anomalous dimensions come from well known semiclassical gauge/string duality analysis showing a dependence with the logarithm of spin S of the boundary states. We show that these logarithm anomalous dimensions of the high spin operators combined with the usual HW model allow us to match the pomeron trajectory and give glueball masses that are better than that of the original HW and soft wall models in comparison with lattice data. We also build up other anomalous HW models considering that the logarithm anomalous dimensions can be approximated by a truncated series of odd powers of the difference S−1/S. These models also fit the pomeron trajectory and produce good glueball masses. Then, we consider an anomalous dimension that is proportional to S, providing reasonable results. Finally, we propose an asymptotic linear anomalous HW model that effective dimensions for high spins operators are of the form Δ=aS+b, where a and b are constants to be fixed by comparison with the soft pomeron trajectory. In this last model, the Regge trajectory is asymptotically linear even for very high spins (J∼100) matching the soft pomeron trajectory accurately and generates glueball masses with deviations with respect to the lattice data better than the original HW and soft wall models. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Planar parts of conformal dimensions of primary operators in Uk(N) × U−k(N) ABJM theory are controlled by integrability. Strong coupling asymptotics of planar dimensions of operators with large spins can be found from the energy of semiclassical strings in AdS4 × CP3 but computing non-planar corrections requires understanding higher genus string corrections. As was pointed out in arXiv:2408.10070, there is an alternative way to find the non-planar corrections by quantizing M2 branes in AdS4 × S7/ℤk which are wrapped around the 11d circle of radius 1/k = λ/N and generalize spinning strings in AdS4 × CP3. Computing the 1-loop correction to the energy of M2 brane that corresponds to the long folded string with large spin S in AdS4 allowed to obtain a prediction for the large λ limit of non-planar corrections to the cusp anomalous dimension. Similar predictions were found for non-planar dimensions of operators dual to M2 branes that generalize the “short” and “long” circular strings with two equal spins J1 = J2 in CP3. Here we consider two more non-trivial examples of 1-loop M2 brane computations that correspond to: (i) long folded string with large spin S in AdS4 and orbital momentum J in CP3 whose energy determines the generalized cusp anomalous dimension, and (ii) circular string with spin S in AdS4 and spin J in CP3. We find the leading terms of the expansion of the corresponding 1-loop M2 brane energies in 1/k. We also discuss similar semiclassical 1-loop M2 brane computation in flat 11d background and comment on possible relation to higher genus corrections to energies in 10d string theory.

We use renormalization group methods to study composite operators existing at a boundary of an interacting conformal field theory. In particular we relate the data on boundary operators to short-distance (near-boundary) divergences of bulk two-point functions. We further argue that in the presence of running couplings at the boundary the anomalous dimensions of certain composite operators can be computed from the relevant beta functions and remark on the implications for the boundary (pseudo) stress-energy tensor. We apply the formalism to a scalar field theory in d = 3−\U0001d716 dimensions with a quartic coupling at the boundary whose beta function we determine to the first non-trivial order. We study the operators in this theory and compute their conformal data using \U0001d716 −expansion at the Wilson-Fisher fixed point of the boundary renormalization group flow. We find that the model possesses a non-zero boundary stress-energy tensor and displacement operator both with vanishing anomalous dimensions. The boundary stress tensor decouples at the fixed point in accordance with Cardy’s condition for conformal invariance. We end the main part of the paper by discussing the possible physical significance of this fixed point for various values of \U0001d716.

We elucidate aspects of the one-loop anomalous dimension of so(6)-singlet multi-trace operators in N=4SU(Nc) SYM at finite Nc. First, we study how 1/Nc corrections lift the large Nc degeneracy of the spectrum, which we call the operator submixing problem. We observe that all large Nc zero modes acquire anomalous dimensions starting at order 1/Nc2 with a non-positive coefficient and they mix only among the operators with the same number of traces at leading order. Second, we study the lowest one-loop dimension of operators of length equal to 2Nc. The dimension of such operators becomes more negative as Nc increases, which will eventually diverge in the double scaling limit. Third, we examine the structure of level-crossing at finite Nc in view of unitarity. Finally we find out a correspondence between the large Nc zero modes and completely symmetric polynomials of Mandelstam variables.

On-shell amplitude methods allow to derive one-loop renormalization effects from just tree-level amplitudes, with no need of loop calculations. We derive a simple formula to obtain the anomalous dimensions of higher-dimensional operators from a product of tree-level amplitudes. We show how this works for dimension-6 operators of the Standard Model, providing explicit examples of the simplicity, elegance and efficiency of the method. Many anomalous dimensions can be calculated from the same Standard Model tree-level amplitude, displaying the attractive recycling aspect of the on-shell method. With this method, it is possible to relate anomalous dimensions that in the Feynman approach arise from very different diagrams, and obtain non-trivial checks of their relative coefficients. We compare our results to those in the literature, where ordinary methods have been applied.

We present the first calculations of next-to-next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order (N4LO) contributions to anomalous dimensions of spin-N twist-2 operators in perturbative QCD. Specifically, we have obtained the respective non-singlet quark–quark anomalous dimensions at N=2 and N=3 to the fifth order in the strong coupling αs. These results set the scale for the N4LO contributions to the evolution of the non-singlet quark distributions of hadrons outside the small-x region, and facilitate a first approximate determination of the five-loop cusp anomalous dimension. While the N4LO coefficients are larger than expected from the lower-order results, their inclusion stabilizes the perturbative expansions for three or more light flavours at a sub-percent accuracy for αs<0.3.