• Open Access IconOpen Access
  • Cite Icon2
  • https://doi.org/10.1108/lm-09-2016-0070Copy DOI Icon

Catch-22

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

PurposeServices to researchers are a key strategic focus point for academic libraries. In many cases these services are linked to performance management systems. However, this kind of system for measuring scholarly research has unintended side effects and may demotivate researchers on a number of levels. This presents somewhat of a catch-22 for research libraries. The purpose of this paper is to describe the Bibliometric Research Indicator (BRI) in Denmark, show why the researchers may feel demotivated, outline the dilemmas and the effects on libraries, and present a possible course of action.Design/methodology/approachAt least 14 countries have implemented performance management systems for researchers. The impact has been the topic of several – primarily quantitative – studies, e.g., in Denmark. The analysis is made by means of a qualitative study (interviews with 43 Danish researchers), using motivation crowding as well as self-determination theory to further explore their motives and experiences, to determine whether these factors have any influence on their experience of the BRI.FindingsThe analysis confirms earlier studies which showed that researchers as a whole do not see the BRI as supportive and that this kind of system may have unintended side effects. Unintended side effects include pressure, limitation of freedom, a drop in the perceived standard of research, the slicing of articles, negative collegial behavior as well as borderline academic theft. In connection researchers do not see the incentives or rewards given by the system as supportive.Research limitations/implicationsThis BRI study is made within only one country and as these systems tend to vary not only from country to country but also with incomparability within faculties and institutes, further studies might expose different patterns. However, as the results fit a more general trend within the research area, the takeaways could potentially prove useful for research libraries in general. Furthermore it could be beneficial to research libraries in general to get a clearer understanding of the role they play, which in part could be done by surveying them on this subject.Practical implicationsThe finding presents potential dilemmas for research libraries, as they might get caught in the crossfire between expectations or demands from the university management and the hope and dreams from individual scholars with the risk of unintentionally alienating a key target group. Thus, a possible course of action is outlined including focus points and target areas for libraries.Originality/valueThis paper presents original research with some key findings with a focus on the dilemmas for research libraries with regard to BRI-like systems, strategic management and performance measurement.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations101

ACCF/AHA New Insights Into the Methodology of Performance Measurement

  • Nov 08, 2010
  • Circulation
  • John A Spertus +11
  • Research Article
  • Citations222

Unintended consequences of peacekeeping operations

  • Dec 01, 2007
  • Choice Reviews Online
  • Chiyuki Aoi +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations36

Successful performance management? Apply the strategic performance management development cycle!

  • Jun 05, 2007
  • Measuring Business Excellence
  • André A De Waal
  • Research Article
  • Citations45

Evolutionary paths of performance measurement and management system: the longitudinal case study of a leading SME

  • Jun 27, 2020
  • Measuring Business Excellence
  • Alberto Sardi +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

THE PARADIGM OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT OF TELECOMMUNICATIONS ENTERPRISES IN THE DIGITAL ECONOMY

  • Jan 01, 2023
  • Economy. Management. Business
  • S V Sazonova
  • Research Article
  • Citations3

EPS inhibitor treatment of Salmonella impacts evolution without selecting for resistance to biofilm inhibition

  • May 06, 2025
  • npj Biofilms and Microbiomes
  • Mathieu Joos +10
  • Research Article
  • Citations45

Barium (Ba) leaching from soils and certified reference materials

  • May 02, 2017
  • Applied Geochemistry
  • Valérie Cappuyns
  • Research Article
  • Citations7

Option Pricing Theory and its Unintended Consequences

  • Feb 28, 1998
  • The Journal of Investing
  • Bruce I Jacobs
  • Research Article
  • Citations34

Ecological Vulnerability Through Insurance? Potential Unintended Consequences of Livestock Drought Insurance

  • Dec 17, 2018
  • Ecological Economics
  • Felix John +4
  • Research Article
  • Citations22

Lessons learned? Intended and unintended effects of India's second-generation maternal cash transfer scheme.

  • Jul 18, 2021
  • Health Economics
  • Paula Von Haaren +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations145

Strategic Performance Management: Development of a Performance Measurement System at the Mayo Clinic

  • Jan 01, 2000
  • Journal of Healthcare Management
  • Jonathan W Curtright +2
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations9

The Balanced Scorecard (BSC) as a Multidimensional Performance Measurement System Tool: Case the Company of Algeria Post

  • Jan 01, 2021
  • Financial Markets, Institutions and Risks
  • Sabah Fadel +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations6

Implementation of performance management in an environment of conflicting management cultures

  • Feb 24, 2020
  • International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management
  • Joe Christopher
  • Research Article
  • Citations8

Strategic Management and Performance Measurement – A Connected or Disconnected Duo? Evidences from Croatian Public Administration

  • Jun 01, 2017
  • Central European Public Administration Review
  • Romea Manojlović
  • Research Article
  • Citations25

SPATIAL HETEROGENEITY, NOT VISITATION BIAS, DOMINATES VARIATION IN HERBIVORY

  • Aug 01, 2003
  • Ecology
  • Kate L Bradley +8
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.