• Open Access IconOpen Access
  • https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-2022-535-rc1Copy DOI Icon

Comment on egusphere-2022-535

  • Aug 10, 2022
  • Guillaume Blanchy +3 more
Show More
  • Abstract
  • PDF
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

Climate change will most likely lead to an increase of extreme weather events, including heavy rainfall with soil surface runoff and erosion. Adapting agricultural management practices that lead to increased infiltration capacities of soil has potential to mitigate these risks. However, effects of agricultural management practices (tillage, cover crops, amendment, …) on soil variables (hydraulic conductivity, aggregate stability, …) often depend on the pedo-climatic context. Hence, the only possibility to gather information needed to advise stakeholders on suitable management practices is to quantify such dependencies using meta-analyses of studies investigating this topic. As a first step, structured information from scientific publications needs to be extracted to build a meta-database, which then can be analyzed and recommendations can be given in dependence to the pedo-climatic context. Manually building such a database by going through all publications is very time-consuming. Given the increasing amount of literature, this task is likely to require more and more effort in the future. Natural language processing (NLP) facilitates this task, but it is not clear yet to which extent the extraction process is reliable or complete. In this work, two corpora of documents were used, which we refer to as the OTIM and the Meta corpus in the following. The OTIM corpus contains the source publications of the entries of the OTIM database of near-saturated hydraulic conductivity from tension-disk infiltrometer measurements (https://github.com/climasoma/otim-db). The Meta corpus is constituted of all primary studies from 36 selected meta-analyses on the impact of agricultural practices on sustainable water management in Europe. We focused on three NLP techniques: topic modeling, tailored regular expressions and dictionaries and the shortest dependency path. We used topic modeling to sort the individual source-publications of the Meta corpus into 6 topics (e.g. related to cover crops, biochar, …) with a coherence metric Cv ranging from 0.7 to 0.9; Then, we used tailored regular expressions and dictionaries to extract coordinates, soil texture, soil type, rainfall, disk diameter and tensions on the OTIM corpus. We found that the respective information could be retrieved with 56 % up to 100 % of all relevant information (recall) and with a precision between 83 % and 100 %. Finally, we extracted relationships between a set of practices keywords (e.g. ‘biochar’, ‘zero tillage’, …) and soil variables (e.g. ‘soil aggregate’, ‘hydraulic conductivity’, ‘crop yield’,…) from the source-publications’ abstracts of the Meta corpus using the shortest dependency path between them. These relationships were further classified according to positive, negative or absent correlations between the driver and soil property. This quickly provided an overview of the different driver-variable relationships and their abundance for an entire body of literature. Overall, we found that all three tested NLP techniques were able to support evidence synthesis tasks such as selecting relevant publications on a topic, extracting specific information to build databases for meta-analysis and providing an overview of relationships found in the corpus. While human supervision remains essential, NLP methods have the potential to support fully automated evidence synthesis that can be continuously updated as new publications become available.

Loading PDF

Similar Papers
  • PDF
  • Peer Review Report

Comment on egusphere-2022-535

  • Nov 28, 2022
  • Blanchy, Guillaume +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations13

Responses of soil water supply during the wheat growing season to agricultural management practice in Northern China: A meta-analysis

  • Nov 30, 2024
  • Field Crops Research
  • Lina Jiang +6
  • Research Article
  • Citations5

Impacts of agricultural management practices on water cycle, soil erosion and crop yields in a Mediterranean agroecosystem.

  • Sep 01, 2025
  • The Science of the total environment
  • Giuseppe Pulighe +3
  • Research Article

Discovering the Significance of Sports Footwear Brands through Text Analysis

  • Dec 28, 2023
  • GATR Journal of Management and Marketing Review
  • Sara Slamić Tarade +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations6

The Use of Natural Language Processing Methods in Reddit to Investigate Opioid Use: Scoping Review.

  • Sep 13, 2024
  • JMIR infodemiology
  • Alexandra Almeida +5
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Balancing bats and agriculture: Investigating the effects of agricultural management practices on bat species diversity in mountain ecosystems

  • Aug 01, 2025
  • Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment
  • Chiara Paniccia +9
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations183

Augmenting Qualitative Text Analysis with Natural Language Processing: Methodological Study

  • Jun 29, 2018
  • Journal of Medical Internet Research
  • Timothy C Guetterman +5
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations522

Machine Learning and Natural Language Processing in Mental Health: Systematic Review.

  • May 04, 2021
  • Journal of medical Internet research
  • Aziliz Le Glaz +10
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations130

User Stories and Natural Language Processing: A Systematic Literature Review

  • Jan 01, 2021
  • IEEE Access
  • Indra Kharisma Raharjana +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations16

From Natural Language Text to Visual Models: A survey of Issues and Approaches

  • Dec 30, 2016
  • Informatica Economica
  • Cristina-Claudia OSMAN +1
  • Preprint Article
  • Citations1

Policy scenarios for agriculture that enhance soil ecosystem services in Europe and China

  • Mar 23, 2020
  • Araceli Martín-Candilejo +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations4

Guest Editors Introduction: Machine Learning in Speech and Language Technologies

  • Sep 01, 2005
  • Machine Learning
  • Pascale Fung +1
  • Conference Article
  • Citations1

Una comparación de técnicas de NLP semánticas para analizar casos de uso

  • Jun 01, 2014
  • Alejandro Rago +2
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations9

Optimal Soil, Climate, and Management Factors for Maximizing Crop Yield and Soil Nutrients in a Rice–Oilseed Rotation System with Straw Return

  • Mar 04, 2024
  • Agriculture
  • Jianling Song +5
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations3

Automated Identification of Aspirin-Exacerbated Respiratory Disease Using Natural Language Processing and Machine Learning: Algorithm Development and Evaluation Study.

  • Jun 12, 2023
  • JMIR AI
  • Thanai Pongdee +5
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.