Comparative study with practical validation of photovoltaic monocrystalline module for single and double diode models

This paper presents a critical analysis of the meta-heuristic techniques used in various researches on the optimisation of photovoltaic (PV) parameters, which involves the use of different algorithms in order to extract and improve these parameters from the single diode model (SDM), double diode model (DDM) and three diode model (TDM) respectively. The modelling parameters such as the photon current, saturation current, the series and parallel resistances are investigated to understand the optimum value. It will also equate the results of datasheet values from PV manufactures with experiment values obtained from PV module measurements. The meta-heuristics techniques to be considered include genetic algorithm (GA), particle swarm optimisation (PSO), harmony search (HS), flower pollination algorithm (FPA), simulated annealing (SA), teaching learning based optimisation (TLBO), and other different hybrid solutions to optimize the convergence speed. Root mean square error (RMSE) is used as a performance indicator of each meta-heuristic technique. These optimisation techniques are utilised in extracting the parameters of a 5 W polycrystalline panel at standard testing conditions. The results presented in this paper compared the performances of the mentioned meta-heuristics on the single, double and triple diode models respectively.

This paper compares two methods for extraction of photovoltaic (PV) module parameters. The numerical method called Gauss-Seidel, used on the single diode model, and the analytical method applied on the double diode model. Both methods are based on the manufacturer’s datasheets to extract the five parameters. These methods are validated using monocrystalline PV module. The modified mathematical modeling equations are classified into models 1 to 5. Only model 2 and model 4 are used for the analytical method. Each model is based on the different combinations of the ideality factor, the series resistance, photocurrent and saturation current plotted under varying temperature and irradiance. The accuracy of PV module based on both methods is evaluated by Absolute Error (AE). In order to evaluate the effectiveness and accuracy of the proposed methods, the equations were implemented in the MATLAB/Simulink environment and the results obtained are compared with extracted experimental data.

In this paper the modelling of the photovoltaic module has been applied through the experimental flash test data of industrial photovoltaic module. The theoretical background of the single diode model and the double diode model of the photovoltaic module have been described and similar procedures for the extraction and estimation of the unknown parameters have been proposed. The Levenberg-Marquardt optimization algorithm has been used to minimize objective function as a set of five nonlinear equations that were written for five equilibrium points on the current-voltage curve of the photovoltaic module. The single diode model and double diode model have then been simulated with the estimated unknown parameters and a very good matching between flash test data and a simulation data.

Perovskite solar cells (PSCs) are third-generation photovoltaic technology that has gained a lot of attention due to its technological and economic advantages. The PSCs are characterized with low cost, high absorption, long carrier diffusion length, and low fabrication temperature. To model the performance of PSCs, a new dynamic model is proposed to track the cells hysteresis by adding a variable voltage capacitor to the single, double, and triple diode models. The aim with adding the variable capacitor is to emulate the effect of charge accumulation at the interfaces of the device. Three modified models are presented based on one or more variable capacitors at single, double, and triple diode models. Where, the triple diode model with third order variable voltage capacitor model is the best among all models by 74.9% enhancement in comparison with single diode model. Also, the Equilibrium optimization algorithm (EOA) is proposed to determine the parameters of the proposed dynamic model based on the triple diode model. In comparison with the experimental data, for both forward and reverse scans, the findings showed that the suggested model accurately reflects cell performance. Added to that, the EOA finds well the optimal model parameters considering the root mean square as primary objective function. Based on the simulation results, it was proved that the proposed model gives very close results to reality.

It is important to investigate the long-term performances of an accurate modeling of photovoltaic (PV) systems, especially in the prediction of output power, with single and double diode models as the configurations mainly applied for this purpose. However, the use of one configuration to model PV panel limits the accuracy of its predicted performances. This paper proposes a new hybrid approach based on classification algorithms in the machine learning framework that combines both single and double models in accordance with the climatic condition in order to predict the output PV power with higher accuracy. Classification trees, k-nearest neighbor, discriminant analysis, Naïve Bayes, support vector machines (SVMs), and classification ensembles algorithms are investigated to estimate the PV power under different conditions of the Mediterranean climate. The examined classification algorithms demonstrate that the double diode model seems more relevant for low and medium levels of solar irradiance and temperature. Accuracy between 86% and 87.5% demonstrates the high potential of the classification techniques in the PV power predicting. The normalized mean absolute error up to 1.5% ensures errors less than those obtained from both single-diode and double-diode equivalent-circuit models with a reduction up to 0.15%. The proposed hybrid approach using machine learning (ML) algorithms could be a key solution for photovoltaic and industrial software to predict more accurate performances.

Among all renewable energy sources, solar cells are considered the most popular solution for a clean source of energy and have a wide range of applications from few watts to Megawatt industrial and domestic loads. Building a precise mathematical model based on nonlinear equations for solar cells as well as photovoltaic (PV) modules is an essential issue for reasonable performance assessment, control and optimal operation of PV energy systems. In the current study, a novel optimization algorithm, Tree Growth Algorithm (TGA), is applied for accurate and efficient extraction of the unknown solar cell and PV module parameters. TGA is applied for estimating the unidentified parameters of PV models. Single diode model (SDM), double diode model (DDM) and three diode model (TDM) are investigated in the mathematical models of both solar cells and PV modules. The obtained results from the application of TGA to achieve this objective are compared with different algorithms reported in the literature. Moreover, the results demonstrated that the proposed algorithm of TGA superior to other reported methods. The good matching of the I-V characteristic curve of the computed parameters with those of the measured data from the manufacturer’s PV modules/cells datasheet proved that the proposed TGA may function as a competitor to the methods provided in literature for parameters’ identification of PV of solar cells.

Parameters identification of photovoltaic models by using an enhanced adaptive butterfly optimization algorithm

This research paper systematically reviewed and investigated single diode model and double diode model of a solar photovoltaic systems in terms of accuracy, differences under major unknown PV parameters, different optimization and fabrication. This research paper reviewed the differences and the similarities between the single diode model and double diode model. From the review, it was clear that single diode model has less computation time and number of unknown parameters compared to double diode model. The double diode model on its own superiority is more accurate under solar shading condition effect than single diode model but single diode model performs better under high insolation levels. None of the two models is superior than the other but the solar photovoltaic modelers/installers should bear the solar irradiance of the environment before installation

Extracting accurate values for involved unknown parameters of solar photovoltaic (PV) models is very important for modeling PV systems. In recent years, the use of metaheuristic algorithms for this problem tends to be more popular and vibrant due to their efficacy in solving highly nonlinear multimodal optimization problems. The whale optimization algorithm (WOA) is a relatively new and competitive metaheuristic algorithm. In this paper, an improved variant of WOA referred to as MCSWOA, is proposed to the parameter extraction of PV models. In MCSWOA, three improved components are integrated together: (i) Two modified search strategies named WOA/rand/1 and WOA/current-to-best/1 inspired by differential evolution are designed to balance the exploration and exploitation; (ii) a crossover operator based on the above modified search strategies is introduced to meet the search-oriented requirements of different dimensions; and (iii) a selection operator instead of the “generate-and-go” operator used in the original WOA is employed to prevent the population quality getting worse and thus to guarantee the consistency of evolutionary direction. The proposed MCSWOA is applied to five PV types. Both single diode and double diode models are used to model these five PV types. The good performance of MCSWOA is verified by various algorithms.

Parameters identification of photovoltaic models using niche-based particle swarm optimization in parallel computing architecture

As countries attach importance to environmental protection, clean energy has become a hot topic. Among them, solar energy, as one of the efficient and easily accessible clean energy sources, has received widespread attention. An essential component in converting solar energy into electricity are solar cells. However, a major optimization difficulty remains in precisely and effectively calculating the parameters of photovoltaic (PV) models. In this regard, this study introduces an improved rime optimization algorithm (RIME), namely ERINMRIME, which integrates the Nelder-Mead simplex (NMs) with the environment random interaction (ERI) strategy. In the later phases of ERINMRIME, the ERI strategy serves as a complementary mechanism for augmenting the solution space exploration ability of the agent. By facilitating external interactions, this method improves the algorithm’s efficacy in conducting a global search by keeping it from becoming stuck in local optima. Moreover, by incorporating NMs, ERINMRIME enhances its ability to do local searches, leading to improved space exploration. To evaluate ERINMRIME's optimization performance on PV models, this study conducted experiments on four different models: the single diode model (SDM), the double diode model (DDM), the three-diode model (TDM), and the photovoltaic (PV) module model. The experimental results show that ERINMRIME reduces root mean square error for SDM, DDM, TDM, and PV module models by 46.23%, 59.32%, 61.49%, and 23.95%, respectively, compared with the original RIME. Furthermore, this study compared ERINMRIME with nine improved classical algorithms. The results show that ERINMRIME is a remarkable competitor. Ultimately, this study evaluated the performance of ERINMRIME across three distinct commercial PV models, while considering varying irradiation and temperature conditions. The performance of ERINMRIME is superior to existing similar algorithms in different irradiation and temperature conditions. Therefore, ERINMRIME is an algorithm with great potential in identifying and recognizing unknown parameters of PV models.

Photovoltaic parameter estimation using honey badger algorithm and African vulture optimization algorithm

Lately, there has been a notable interest among researchers in constructing a precise mathematical representation using experimentally gathered data from solar cells and photovoltaic (PV) modules. This representation serves as a means to simulate and assess the performance of PV systems. In this study, the Walrus Optimization Algorithm (WaOA) and Cheetah optimizer (CO) were employed to deduce the unknown parameters inherent in various modes of solar cells and PV modules, specifically the single-diode model (SDM) and double-diode model (DDM). Furthermore, the evaluation criterion for this work involved measuring the route mean square error (RMSE) between the simulated outcomes generated using identified parameters for each mathematical model and the actual voltage derived from measurements of solar cells and PV modules. Notably, a comprehensive statistical analysis was carried out to validate the efficacy and stability of the WaOA and CO algorithms. These algorithms were compared against other optimization techniques for their effectiveness in solving the optimization challenge of accurately estimating the design parameters of PV systems. The outcomes of simulations and the extensive statistical assessment substantiate the superior performance and reliability of the Walrus Optimization Algorithm in effectively extracting parameter values from diverse PV modules under various operational scenarios.

The operation of Photovoltaic (PV) system mainly rely on appropriate modeling of solar cells and optimum approximation of parameters associated with them. Recently, various hybrid, numerical and analytical techniques were proposed to extract optimal parameters of PV cell. This paper presents an efficient approach, A Simulated Annealing Inertia Weight Particle Swarm Optimization (SAIW-PSO) for optimal estimation of PV parameters for double and single diode models. In addition, fitness indicator is guided using the Newton Raphson Method (NRM) that supports SAIW -PSO to explore the optimal solution. The premature convergence problem of typical PSO is resolved by the proposed framework. The strength of proposed approach is validated under standard test conditions (STC) on RTC France Silicon Solar cell. The SAIW-PSO is capable to explore optimum solution in smaller number of iterations and less computation time. The obtained results clearly depict that the proposed framework is fast, efficient and much accurate for PV cells parameters approximation.

the important issue in the extraction of the unknown parameters in the photovoltaic model is the mathematical models.Therefore, a five equivalent circuit is analyzed in this work.The unknown parameters are five for single diode model, seven for double-diode model, eight for modified double-diode, and nine for three-diode model and ten for modified three-diode parameters.The performance of the modified three-diode model and three-diode model after estimate all parameters without assumption for any variable are compared with the performance of the both single diode model, double-diode model and also the modified double-diode of the same solar cell.Cuckoo search optimization algorithm (CSOA) is proposed for the estimation of the unknown parameters for the five solar cell equivalent models.The root mean square error, the absolute error for current and power, and the maximum power point absolute error are analyzed to the performance of the five solar cell models.