Comparative transcriptome analysis reveals vertebrate phylotypic period during organogenesis

The question of vertebrate head segmentation has become one of the central issues in Evolutionary Developmental Biology. Beginning as a theory based in comparative anatomy, a segmental theory of the head has been adopted and further developed by comparative embryologists. With the use of molecular and cellular biology, and in particular analyses of the Hox gene complex, the question has been addressed at new levels, but it remains unresolved. In this review, vertebrate head segmentation is reevaluated, by introducing findings from experimental embryology and evolutionary biology. Developmental biology has shown that pattern is generated through hierarchically organized and causally linked series of events. The question of head segmentation can be viewed as a question of generative constraint, that is whether segmentation in the head is imposed by underlying segmental patterns, as it is in the trunk. In this respect, amphioxus appears to be segmented along the entire anteroposterior axis, with myotomes and peripheral nerves repeating with the same rhythm (somitomerism). Similarly, in the vertebrate trunk, the segmental patterns shared by myotomes, peripheral nerves and vertebrae are derived from the somites. However, in the head of vertebrates there is no such mesodermal pattern, although neuromerism and branchiomerism do indicate the presence of constraints derived from rhombomeres and pharyngeal pouches, respectively. These data fit better the concept of dual metamerism of the vertebrate body proposed by Romer (1972), than the traditional head cavity-based segmental model by Goodrich (1930).

Gray mold caused by Botrytis cinerea, which is considered to be the second most destructive necrotrophic fungus, leads to major economic losses in strawberry (Fragaria × ananassa) production. B. cinerea preferentially infects strawberry flowers and fruits, leading to flower blight and fruit rot. Compared with those of the fruit, the mechanisms of flower defense against B. cinerea remain largely unexplored. Therefore, in this study, we aimed to unveil the resistance mechanisms of strawberry flower through dynamic and comparative transcriptome analysis with resistant and susceptible strawberry cultivars. Our experimental data suggest that resistance to B. cinerea in the strawberry flower is probably regulated at the transcriptome level during the early stages of infection and strawberry flower has highly complex and dynamic regulatory networks controlling a multi-layered defense response to B. cinerea. First of all, the higher expression of disease-resistance genes but lower expression of cell wall degrading enzymes and peroxidases leads to higher resistance to B. cinerea in the resistant cultivar. Interestingly, CPKs, RBOHDs, CNGCs, and CMLs comprised a calcium signaling pathway especially play a crucial role in enhancing resistance by increasing their expression. Besides, six types of phytohormones forming a complex regulatory network mediated flower resistance, especially JA and auxin. Finally, the genes involved in the phenylpropanoid and amino acids biosynthesis pathways were gene sets specially expressed or different expression genes, both of them contribute to the flower resistance to B. cinerea. These data provide the foundation for a better understanding of strawberry gray mold, along with detailed genetic information and resistant materials to enable genetic improvement of strawberry plant resistance to gray mold.

The mechanisms associated with the regulation of iron (Fe) homeostasis have been extensively examined, however, epigenetic regulation of these processes remains largely unknown. Here, we report that a naturally occurring epigenetic mutant, Colorless non-ripening (Cnr), displayed increased Fe-deficiency responses compared to its wild-type Ailsa Craig (AC). RNA-sequencing revealed that a total of 947 and 1,432 genes were up-regulated by Fe deficiency in AC and Cnr roots, respectively, while 923 and 1,432 genes were, respectively, down-regulated. Gene ontology analysis of differentially expressed genes showed that genes encoding enzymes, transporters, and transcription factors were preferentially affected by Fe deficiency. Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes pathway enrichment analysis revealed differential metabolic responses to Fe deficiency between AC and Cnr. Based on comparative transcriptomic analyses, 24 genes were identified as potential targets of Cnr epimutation, and many of them were found to be implicated in Fe homeostasis. By developing CRISPR/Cas9 genome editing SlSPL-CNR knockout (KO) lines, we found that some Cnr-mediated Fe-deficiency responsive genes showed similar expression patterns between SlSPL-CNR KO plants and the Cnr epimutant. Moreover, both two KO lines displayed Fe-deficiency-induced chlorosis more severe than AC plants. Additionally, the Cnr mutant displayed hypermethylation in the 286-bp epi-mutated region on the SlSPL-CNR promoter, which contributes to repressed expression of SlSPL-CNR when compared with AC plants. However, Fe-deficiency induced no change in DNA methylation both at the 286-bp epi-allele region and the entire region of SlSPL-CNR gene. Taken together, using RNA-sequencing and genetic approaches, we identified Fe-deficiency responsive genes in tomato roots, and demonstrated that SlSPL-CNR is a novel regulator of Fe-deficiency responses in tomato, thereby, paving the way for further functional characterization and regulatory network dissection.

Evolutionary developmental biology (evo–devo) is that part of biology concerned with how changes in embryonic development during single generations relate to the evolutionary changes that occur between generations. Charles Darwin argued for the importance of development (embryology) in understanding evolution. After the discovery in 1900 of Mendel’s research on genetics, however, any relationship between development and evolution was either regarded as unimportant for understanding the process(es) of evolution or as a black box into which it was hard to see. Research over the past two decades has opened that black box, revealing how studies in evo–devo highlight the mechanisms that link genes (the genotype) with structures (the phenotype). This is vitally important because genes do not make structures. Developmental processes make structures using road maps provided by genes, but using many other signals as well—physical forces such as mechanical stimulation, temperature of the environment, and interaction with chemical products produced by other species—often species in entirely different kingdoms as in interactions between bacteria and squid or between leaves and larvae (Greene Science 243:643–666, 1989). Not only do genes not make structures (the phenotype), but new properties and mechanisms emerge during embryonic development: genes are regulated differentially in different cells and places; aggregations of similar cells provide the cellular resources (modules) from which tissues and organs arise; modules and populations of differently differentiated cells interact to set development along particular tracks; and organisms interact with their environment and create their niche in that environment. Such interactions are often termed “epigenetic,” meaning that they direct gene activity using mechanisms that are not encoded in the DNA of the genes. This paper reviews the origins of evo–devo, how the field has changed over the past 30 years, evaluates the recognition of the importance for development and evolution of mechanisms that are not encoded in DNA, and evaluates what the future might bring for evo–devo. Although impossible to know, history tells us that we might expect more of the same; expansion of evo–devo into other areas of biology (ecology, physiology, behavior); absorption of evo–devo by evolution or a unification of biology in which evo–devo plays a major role.

Michael Akam has been awarded the 2007 Kowalevsky medal for his many research accomplishments in the area of evolutionary developmental biology. We highlight three tributaries of Michael’s contribution to evolutionary developmental biology. First, he has made major contributions to our understanding of development of the fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster. Second, he has maintained a consistent focus on several key problems in evolutionary developmental biology, including the evolving role of Hox genes in arthropods and, more recently, the evolution of segmentation mechanisms. Third, Michael has written a series of influential reviews that have integrated progress in developmental biology into an evolutionary perspective. Michael has also made a large impact on the field through his effective mentorship style, his selfless promotion of younger colleagues, and his leadership of the University Museum of Zoology at Cambridge and the European community of evolutionary developmental biologist.

Many scientists and philosophers of science are troubled by the relative isolation of developmental from evolutionary biology. Reconciling the science of development with the science of heredity preoccupied a minority of biologists for much of the twentieth century, but these efforts were not corporately successful. Mainly in the past fifteen years, however, these previously dispersed integrating programmes have been themselves synthesized and so reinvigorated. Two of these more recent synthesizing endeavours are evolutionary developmental biology (EDB, or "evo-devo") and developmental systems theory (DST). While the former is a bourgeoning and scientifically well-respected biological discipline, the same cannot be said of DST, which is virtually unknown among biologists. In this review, we provide overviews of DST and EDB, summarize their key tenets, examine how they relate to one another and to the study of epigenetics, and survey the impact that DST and EDB have had (and in future should have) on biological theory and practice.

BackgroundCurrently, mechanical maize kernel harvesting has not been fully utilized in developing countries including China, partly due to the absence of suitable cultivars capable of rapid desiccation during seed maturation. The initiation of rapid desiccation during seed maturation is regulated by abscisic acid (ABA). For further characterization of ABA-regulated key genes and cellular events, it is necessary to perform transcriptome analysis of maize developing embryos. The ABA synthesis-deficient mutant (vp5) and normal maize (Vp5) seeds are suitable materials for such purpose.ResultsIn the present work, developing vp5 and Vp5 embryos were compared by ABA content and transcriptome analyses. Quantitative analysis revealed the significant difference in ABA synthesis between both genotypes. From 29 days after pollination (DAP), ABA content increased rapidly in Vp5 embryos, but decreased gradually in vp5 embryos. At 36 DAP, ABA level in vp5 decreased to 1/4 that of Vp5, suggesting that the differential ABA levels would affect seed maturation. Comparative transcriptomic analysis has found 1019 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between both genotypes, with the most DEGs (818) at 36 DAP. Further, weighted correlation network analysis (WGCNA) revealed eight DEGs co-expression modules. Particularly, a module was negatively correlated with ABA content in vp5 embryos. The module was mainly involved in metabolic and cellular processes, and its hub genes encoded thiamine, NPF proteins, calmodulin, metallothionein etc. Moreover, the expression of a set of key genes regulated by ABA was further verified by RT-qPCR. The results of the present work suggested that because of ABA deficiency, the vp5 seeds maintained strong metabolic activities and lacked dormancy initiation during seed maturation.ConclusionTranscriptome and WGCNA analyses revealed significant ABA-related changes in metabolic pathways and DEGs between vp5 and Vp5 during seed maturation. The results would provide insights for elucidating the molecular mechanism of ABA signaling and developing high dehydration tolerance maize suitable for mechanical harvesting.

Comparative transcriptome analysis of fiber tissues between Gossypium barbadense and Gossypium hirsutum could reveal the molecular mechanisms underlying high-quality fiber formation and identify candidate genes for fiber quality improvement. In this study, 759 genes were found to be strongly upregulated at the elongation stage in G. barbadense, which showed four distinct expression patterns (I–IV). Among them, the 346 genes of group IV stood out in terms of the potential to promote fiber elongation, in which we finally identified 42 elongation-related candidate genes by comparative transcriptome analysis between G. barbadense and G. hirsutum. Subsequently, we overexpressed GbAAR3 and GbTWS1, two of the 42 candidate genes, in Arabidopsis plants and validated their roles in promoting cell elongation. At the secondary cell wall (SCW) biosynthesis stage, 2275 genes were upregulated and exhibited five different expression profiles (I–V) in G. barbadense. We highlighted the critical roles of the 647 genes of group IV in SCW biosynthesis and further picked out 48 SCW biosynthesis-related candidate genes by comparative transcriptome analysis. SNP molecular markers were then successfully developed to distinguish the SCW biosynthesis-related candidate genes from their G. hirsutum orthologs, and the genotyping and phenotyping of a BC3F5 population proved their potential in improving fiber strength and micronaire. Our results contribute to the better understanding of the fiber quality differences between G. barbadense and G. hirsutum and provide novel alternative genes for fiber quality improvement.

Design of biomaterials and cellular scaffolds for tissue-engineering applications and regenerative medicine requires a precise understanding of the principles underlying multicellular patterning. Adhesion, migration, division, differentiation, and apoptosis are characteristic cellular behaviors, the engineering of which has the potential to allow creation of custom, multicellular structures. These cellular events occur naturally during embryonic and postembryonic development of multicellular organisms. Development thus offers the opportunity to learn about the design principles and molecular mechanisms that guide cellular patterning. A key finding in developmental biology is that a limited set of conserved molecular signaling pathways act at multiple times and locations throughout the embryo to introduce cell-fate asymmetries in homogenous populations of cells. In turn, these asymmetries serve as starting points for the patterning of new organs. These signaling pathways interact quantitatively at multiple levels, including signaling cues, post-translational regulation, and gene-regulatory networks, to guide multicellular patterning. How does the quantitative performance of these signaling networks ensure the intended phenotype pattern? How do changes in the quantitative performance of these networks, possibly over the course of evolution, give rise to new phenotypes? These are the central questions pursued in this thesis. In order to answer such questions, we used vulva formation in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans as a model system of cellular patterning. We formulated a mathematical model of the molecular network underlying cellular-fate specification in this system. Computational analysis of this molecular network reveals that cell–cell coupling through lateral LIN-12/Notch signaling amplifies the perception of the gradient in the epidermal-growth-factor-like soluble cue, LIN-3. Thus, the gradient in LIN-3 concentration produces an even steeper difference in LIN-3-mediated intracellular signals between adjoining cells. Such gradient amplification may be particularly important in converting a shallow, graded-specification signal into a spatial pattern of distinct fate choices. Through quantitative perturbations of interaction strengths between components of the vulval patterning network, we further show that our modeling approach can correctly predict phenotype patterns observed in C. elegans mutation studies. This study generated a framework for quantitative analysis of molecular networks that links quantitative molecular perturbations to patterning outcomes. This framework will prove useful in the analysis of other systems involving cellular fate decisions and in tissue engineering applications where the generation of precise cell patterns is needed. We demonstrate the generality of our approach through an application to evolutionary developmental biology. Since molecular connectivity of the vulva patterning network of several closely related Caenorhabditis species is preserved, we correctly predict the quantitative diversification that must have occurred in this network during species evolution.

Ovarian transcriptomic analysis of black Muscovy duck at the early, peak and late egg-laying stages.

A more comprehensive version of evolutionary theory that focuses as much on the origin of biological form as on its diversification. The field of evolutionary biology arose from the desire to understand the origin and diversity of biological forms. In recent years, however, evolutionary genetics, with its focus on the modification and inheritance of presumed genetic programs, has all but overwhelmed other aspects of evolutionary biology. This has led to the neglect of the study of the generative origins of biological form. Drawing on work from developmental biology, paleontology, developmental and population genetics, cancer research, physics, and theoretical biology, this book explores the multiple factors responsible for the origination of biological form. It examines the essential problems of morphological evolution—why, for example, the basic body plans of nearly all metazoans arose within a relatively short time span, why similar morphological design motifs appear in phylogenetically independent lineages, and how new structural elements are added to the body plan of a given phylogenetic lineage. It also examines discordances between genetic and phenotypic change, the physical determinants of morphogenesis, and the role of epigenetic processes in evolution. The book discusses these and other topics within the framework of evolutionary developmental biology, a new research agenda that concerns the interaction of development and evolution in the generation of biological form. By placing epigenetic processes, rather than gene sequence and gene expression changes, at the center of morphological origination, this book points the way to a more comprehensive theory of evolution. Bradford Books imprint

Comparative transcriptome analysis between the short-term stress and long-term adaptation of the Ruditapes philippinarum in response to benzo[a]pyrene

Portuguese oyster (Magallana angulata) is one of the most important shellfish species worldwide. Although significant improvements in growth have been achieved through artificial selection breeding, the genetic basis underlying these traits remains unclear. Thus, this study aimed to (i) estimate variation and heritability for growth-related traits and (ii) identify SNPs and candidate genes associated with growth traits in Portuguese oyster. Five growth-related traits, including shell height (SH), shell length (SL), shell width (SW), whole weight (WW), and soft tissue weight (STW), were measured and analyzed in 114 one-year-old individuals from a cultivated population in Fujian Province, China. Through whole-genome sequencing and genotyping, we obtained 8,183,713 high-quality SNPs. Based on the genomic relationship matrix, heritability for the five traits was estimated, ranging from 0.071 to 0.695. Through genome-wide association analysis (GWAS), a total of nine SNPs were identified as significantly or suggestively associated with one of the growth-related traits, each explaining phenotypic variation ranging from 14.13% to 18.56%. Differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between individuals with extreme phenotypes were identified using comparative transcriptome analysis, ranging from 868 to 2274 for each trait. By combining GWAS and comparative transcriptome analysis, a total of seven candidate genes were identified, with biological functions related to growth inhibition, stress response, cell cycle regulation, and immune defense. The associations between the candidate genes and the growth-related traits were validated by using single-marker association analysis in other populations. Based on SNPs in these candidate genes, 16 haplotypes associated with growth-related traits were obtained. This study contributes to a deeper understanding of the genetic mechanisms of growth traits, and provides a theoretical basis and genetic markers for the breeding of fast-growing strains of the Portuguese oyster.

Lysobacter enzymogenes is well known for producing extracellular enzymes and bioactive molecules that suppress a wide range of plant pathogens, including fungi such as Rhizoctonia and Fusarium spp. and oomycetes such as Phytophthora infestans. It also exhibits antagonistic effects against Gram-negative bacteria through the type IV secretion system. Interestingly, L. enzymogenes JCK1421, isolated from the rhizosphere of pine forests, showed neither antifungal nor antibacterial activity, in contrast to other L. enzymogenes strains. However, foliar application of JCK1421 significantly reduced disease symptoms in tomato seedlings challenged with Ralstonia solanacearum. To elucidate the underlying defense mechanisms, comparative transcriptome analysis integrated with network and pathway enrichment approaches was performed. Comparative transcriptome and network analyses identified signaling modules activated by JCK1421 in pathogen-free plants and further enhanced upon R. solanacearum challenge. In challenged plants, JCK1421 treatment strongly induced resistance-related genes, including those encoding Ca2+-dependent proteins and ion channels, hormone biosynthesis components, and mitogen-activated protein kinase cascades—hallmarks of plant immune responses. These findings demonstrate that JCK1421 provides an effective model for investigating microbe-associated defense activation in plants, highlighting its potential as an eco-friendly agent for sustainable crop protection.

The Evolution of Gene Regulation Underlies a Morphological Difference between Two Drosophila Sister Species