• Home
  • Search
  • Confounding fuels misinterpretation in human genetics
  • https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2025.1615Copy DOI Icon

Confounding fuels misinterpretation in human genetics

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

The scientific literature has seen a resurgence of interest in genetic influences on human behaviour and socioeconomic outcomes. Such studies face the central difficulty of distinguishing possible causal influences, in particular genetic and non-genetic ones. When confounding between possible influences is not rigorously addressed, it invites over- and misinterpretation of data. We illustrate the breadth of this problem through a discussion of the literature and a reanalysis of two examples. The first paper we discuss suggested that patterns of similarity in social status between relatives indicate that social status is largely determined by one’s DNA. Our reanalysis shows that the paper’s conclusions are based on the conflation of genetic and non-genetic transmission (for example, of wealth) within families. The second paper we discuss posited that genetic variants underlying bisexual behaviour are maintained in the population because they also affect risk-taking behaviour and thereby confer an evolutionary fitness advantage through increased sexual promiscuity. In this case, too, our reanalysis shows that, though possible explanations cannot be distinguished, only one is chosen and presented as a conclusion. We discuss how issues of confounding apply more broadly to studies that claim to establish genetic underpinnings to human behaviour and societal outcomes.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations212

Childhood Stress and Family Environment

  • Dec 01, 1995
  • Current Anthropology
  • Mark V Flinn +1
  • PDF
  • Book Chapter

The Relationship between Gender and Socioeconomic Outcomes: Evidence from the Maltese Islands

  • Nov 28, 2024
  • Sustainable development
  • Shania Duca +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations5

A Blueprint for Genetic Determinism

  • Dec 01, 2022
  • The American Journal of Psychology
  • Jay Joseph
  • Research Article
  • Citations300

Heritability of anxiety sensitivity: a twin study.

  • Feb 01, 1999
  • American Journal of Psychiatry
  • Murray B Stein +2
  • Research Article

Sociale status en antropobiologische kenmerken: een sociaal-biologisch onderzoek op Vlaamsen mannen van 19- en 20-jarige leeftijd

  • Jan 01, 1963
  • Tijdschrift voor sociale wetenschappen
  • Robert Cliquet
  • Research Article
  • Citations120

Sport Education and social goals in physical education: relationships with enjoyment, relatedness, and leisure-time physical activity

  • Sep 01, 2013
  • Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy
  • Tristan L Wallhead +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations7

Improving the social status of peer-rejected youth with disabilities: Extending the research on positive peer reporting.

  • Jan 01, 2008
  • International Journal of Behavioral Consultation and Therapy
  • Frank E Bowers +4
  • Supplementary Content

Empirical Studies on the Role of Input Control on Digital Platforms

  • Jan 01, 2021
  • TUbilio (Technical University of Darmstadt)
  • Evgheni Croitor
  • Research Article
  • Citations132

Human parental behavior: Evidence for genetic influence and potential implication for gene-culture transmission

  • Jul 01, 1994
  • Behavior Genetics
  • Daniel P�Russe +3
  • PDF
  • Supplementary Content
  • Citations9

Perspectives to Performance of Environment and Health Assessments and Models—From Outputs to Outcomes?

  • Jun 26, 2013
  • International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
  • Mikko V Pohjola +3
  • Book Chapter
  • Citations1

Understanding and Rewiring Cities

  • Jan 01, 2022
  • Bruno Lepri +2
  • Supplementary Content
  • Citations1

Abass Alavi: A giant in Nuclear Medicine turns 80 and is still going strong!

  • Mar 20, 2018
  • Hellenic journal of nuclear medicine
  • Poul Fl Høilund-Carlsen
  • Research Article
  • Citations69

Genetic Influences on Patient-Oriented Outcomes in Traumatic Brain Injury: A Living Systematic Review of Non-Apolipoprotein E Single-Nucleotide Polymorphisms

  • Apr 05, 2021
  • Journal of Neurotrauma
  • Frederick A Zeiler +12
  • Discussion

In Reply

  • Mar 01, 2012
  • Journal of Hand Surgery
  • L Andrew Koman
  • Research Article
  • Citations51

Determinants and Outcomes of Suicidal Behavior Among Patients With Major Depressive Disorder

  • Aug 16, 2023
  • JAMA Psychiatry
  • Johan Lundberg +8
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.