The study explores the effects of extensive reading (ER) on EFL college students of elementary or pre-intermediate level in learning attitudes, reading habits, and reading performances by undertaking a classroom action research in conjunction with both quantitative and qualitative methods. The ER practices were integrated in existing intensive reading (IR) curriculum, to investigate the influence on the students' learning attitudes and reading habits with the use of graded readers (GR) and books for native English speaking children (BNESC). The students' reading proficiency and reading fluency were also explored after the treatment. The study was divided into three stages—Pilot Study One, Pilot Study Two, and the Main Study. Pilot study one aimed to recognize the college students' reading habits, learning attitudes, and reading proficiency, which helped the teachers tailor appropriate instructional approaches and class materials. Pilot study two aimed to design and select eligible test instruments in order to objectively assess the participants’ reading proficiency. A total of 113 non-English major sophomores from four intact classes participated in the main study which lasted for a semester. There were two ER classes (1 Level A class, and 1 Level B class) and two IR classes (1 Level A class, and 1 Level B class). The ER groups were exposed to GR and BNESC during sustained silent reading (SSR) session in the last hour of the weekly three-hour course following the two-hour skills-based or IR instruction, adopting a school-designated textbook. The comparison groups were taught with the school-designated textbook in the first two-hour, and were directed to review the reading texts in the textbook and complete a workbook exercise in the last hour of the weekly three-hour course session. Both quantitative and qualitative data were collected, including the class term grades of the first semester in Fall 2012 (i.e., mean scores combining the unified online midterm and final exam grades) before treatment, Vocabulary Size Test, several English reading comprehension tests, a speed reading test, pre- and post-treatment surveys, teacher’s logs, and students’ written reports. The study adopted a two-way ANOVA with repeated measure analysis to examine the effects of ER on reading proficiency, reading habits, and attitudes toward the ERP and toward English learning in general. The overall results of the study displayed that, after the treatment, (1) the ERP had a positive influence on the college students of elementary or pre-intermediate level in reading comprehension based on a norm-referenced test result (i.e., CSEPT). In particular, the Level A ER group (or E1) made a significant gain in comparison with the other three groups. (2) Both of the ER groups outperformed the IR groups on the teacher-designed post-reading test while no significant difference was detected between the groups of different levels. (3) The Level B ER group (or E2) made a significant gain on the publisher’s custom-made reading test compared with their counterpart group (or C2) while no significant difference was found between the ER groups. (4) The reason for the non-significant difference between the ER groups on the teacher-designed post-reading test and publisher’s custom-made reading test could be attributed to the fact that E2 read much more GR than E1. (5) Neither ER nor IR groups demonstrated any significant differences in terms of their reading speed after receiving the instructions. However, groups of different levels showed significant difference. (6) There was significant improvement on both ER groups in reading habits, attitudes toward the ERP and English learning in general. (7) Students expressed that teacher-selected class readers were harder than and not as interesting as those selected by themselves. (8) Reading paper-back GR or BNESC was more suitable and viable than reading free online books for the students in the study. Pedagogical implications were proposed for teachers at technological universities or technical colleges in similar educational contexts alongside the research findings.
Read more