- Research Article
1
- 10.2139/ssrn.2776932
Efficient Calibration for CVA Using Multi-Level Monte Carlo
- May 09, 2016
- SSRN Electronic Journal
- Markus Hofer + 1 more +1
Efficient Calibration for CVA Using Multi-Level Monte Carlo
We propose a Credit Value Adjustment (CVA) model capturing the Wrong Way Risk (WWR) that is not product-specific and is suitable for large-scale computations. The model is based on a doubly stochastic default process with the default intensities proxied by credit spreads. For different exposure structures, we show how credit–market correlation affects the CVA level, its sensitivities to credit and market factors, its volatility and the quality of hedging. The WWR is most significant for exposures highly sensitive to the market volatility in a situation when credit spreads are at moderate levels but both the market factors and credit spreads are volatile. In such conditions, ignoring credit–market correlations results in important CVA mispricing. While the benefits from hedging are always magnified in the situation of the WWR, the right way exposure case is more delicate: only a well-designed mix of credit and market hedges can bring volatility down. Our results raise doubts on the Basel III policy of recognizing credit but not market hedges for computing the CVA volatility capital charge.
Efficient Calibration for CVA Using Multi-Level Monte Carlo
Efficient Calibration for CVA Using Multi-Level Monte Carlo
EFFICIENT WRONG-WAY RISK MODELING FOR FUNDING VALUATION ADJUSTMENTS
Wrong-Way Risk (WWR) is an important component in Funding Valuation Adjustment (FVA) modeling. Yet, the standard assumption is independence between market risks and the counterparty defaults and funding costs. This typical industrial setting is our point of departure, where we aim to assess the impact of WWR without running a full Monte Carlo simulation with all credit and funding processes. We propose to split the exposure profile into two parts: an independent and a WWR-driven part. For the former, exposures can be re-used from the standard xVA calculation. We express the second part of the exposure profile in terms of the stochastic drivers and approximate these by a common Gaussian stochastic factor. Within the affine setting, the proposed approximation is generic, is an add-on to the existing xVA calculations and provides an efficient and robust way to include WWR in FVA modeling. Case studies for an interest rate swap and a representative multi-currency portfolio of swaps illustrate that the approximation method is applicable in a practical setting. We analyze the approximation error and use the approximation to compute WWR sensitivities, which are needed for risk management. The approach is equally applicable to other metrics such as Credit Valuation Adjustment.
Read moreDANGEROUS KNOWLEDGE: CREDIT VALUE ADJUSTMENT WITH CREDIT TRIGGERS
We generalize the arbitrage-free valuation framework for counterparty credit risk (CCR) adjustments when credit triggers are allowed in the contract. The settlement of the deal for the investor could be either obliged or optional to execute when the counterparty hits the credit trigger before any default events from the two parties. General formulas for credit value adjustment (CVA) are given for all four cases: obliged unilateral, obliged bilateral, optional unilateral and optional bilateral. The unilateral CVA with an optional credit trigger is found to be the same as the unilateral CVA with an analogous obliged credit trigger. We show that adding credit triggers will decrease the unilateral CVA for both obliged and optional cases, which are in line with the motivation of investors to reduce CCR. However, adding credit triggers may not necessarily reduce bilateral CVA. Counter-intuitively, we show that the bilateral CVA may actually increase by adding credit triggers. Moreover, the increased amount of bilateral CVA due to credit triggers for one party is exactly the same amount of bilateral CVA reduced for the other party. The CVA calculation is subjected to large uncertainty of model risks, mostly due to the lack of data for calibrating jump-to-default probabilities. Some explicit models for obliged unilateral CVA are discussed with special caveats on the model assumptions. Numerical examples are also given to illustrate the model risk of CVA calculation due to the uncertainty of jump sizes, even though pure jump models are assumed.
Read moreEnhanced Modelling of Valuation Adjustments for Comprehensive Financial Risk Management
The 2007-2008 global financial crisis provided a wake-up call for the financial industry that some assumptions underlying the classical risk-neutral valuation framework for financial derivatives are violated. Especially the assumption related to the absence of Counterparty Credit Risk, i.e., the risk that a counterparty goes in default. This gave rise to various Valuation Adjustments (xVAs) to account for aspects of trading financial derivatives which are not part of the risk-neutral framework. Appropriate assumptions and modelling choices must be made when developing an xVA model, such that the computed values are fit for purpose while keeping the computations practically feasible. This thesis proposes refined xVA modelling techniques that enhance risk prediction accuracy for financial derivatives, addressing gaps in traditional Valuation Adjustment methodologies. We challenge assumptions related to Wrong-Way Risk (WWR) and the volatility smile, while guaranteeing the efficient computation of exposures, metrics and associated risks. Chapter 2 explores dynamic Credit Valuation Adjustment (CVA) hedging, starting in a Black-Scholes setting, followed by a Merton jump-diffusion model to incorporate volatility smile. Chapters 3 and 4 focus on the relevance and efficient computation of WWR in Funding Valuation Adjustment (FVA) on linear interest rate and foreign exchange derivatives. We propose a method to split exposures into independent and WWR components and approximate the latter. Chapter 5 introduces a novel model for smile-aware xVA for linear and early-exercise IR derivatives. These enhancements of the xVA modelling landscape give rise to interesting mathematical research at the cross-section of practically motivated work and academically relevant research.
Read moreCredit contingent interest rate swap pricing
Credit value adjustment (CVA) is an adjustment to an existing trading price based on the counterparty-risk premium. Currently, CVA is computed with an implicit assumption that the replacement contract is default-free after the original counterparty defaults, with the assumption that those trades will not re-assigned. In the actual counterparty default settlement, it is the norm that trades will be re-assigned, especially on the buy side. Since the counterparty of the replacement contract could also default within the lifetime of an existing contract, ignoring the possibility of counterparty defaults of replacement contracts will either under or over estimate the cost of the risk. An important practical question is, therefore, how to estimate under/over pricing of CVA under current practice.In this paper, we considered the pricing of credit contingent interest rate swap (CCIRS) or credit contingent default swap (CCDS), which is considered the CVA hedge for interest rate swaps (IRS). We derived partial differential Eqs. (PDEs) satisfied by the approximated CVA with the assumption that the replacement contracts do not default. For comparison purposes, we also derived the PDEs for the cost of CVA by relaxing the assumption of default-free replacement contracts with a finite number of counterparty defaults. It shows that the no-default and two default cases can be derived within the same analytical solution framework, similar to the Funding Valuation Adjustment (FVA) problem where continuous funding is a reasonable assumption. The finite number of default case is non-trivial. The PDE for the two default case is derived in this paper.We calibrate our model based on market data and carry out extensive computations for the purpose of comparing these three CVAs. Our basic finding is that the values of the two CVAs are close for top rated counterparties. On the other hand, for counterparties with lower credit ratings, the difference among the two CVAs can be significant.
Read moreStochastic Intensity Models of Wrong Way Risk:Wrong Way CVA Need Not Exceed Independent CVA
Buyers of OTC derivatives need to be concerned about both market risk from the contract’s underlying asset and credit risk of the derivatives counterparty. Taking counterparty risk into valuation leads to Credit Value Adjustment (CVA), which is now recognized as a necessary factor in the calculation of regulatory capital. Wrong way risk occurs when the counterparty’s credit quality is correlated with the value of the derivative contract, so that the counterparty’s default risk increases just when its liability under the contract goes up. Under Basel III, required capital is increased for wrong way risk. In this article, Ghamami and Goldberg question whether that treatment is appropriate. The authors show that CVA may actually be lower than independent CVA in theory, and they provide a numerical example showing that the parameter values for this to occur in practice are not unreasonable.
Read moreCOUNTERPARTY RISK FOR CREDIT DEFAULT SWAPS: IMPACT OF SPREAD VOLATILITY AND DEFAULT CORRELATION
We consider counterparty risk for Credit Default Swaps (CDS) in presence of correlation between default of the counterparty and default of the CDS reference credit. Our approach is innovative in that, besides default correlation, which was taken into account in earlier approaches, we also model credit spread volatility. Stochastic intensity models are adopted for the default events, and defaults are connected through a copula function. We find that both default correlation and credit spread volatility have a relevant impact on the positive counterparty-risk credit valuation adjustment to be subtracted from the counterparty-risk free price. We analyze the pattern of such impacts as correlation and volatility change through some fundamental numerical examples, analyzing wrong-way risk in particular. Given the theoretical equivalence of the credit valuation adjustment with a contingent CDS, we are also proposing a methodology for valuation of contingent CDS on CDS.
Read moreAn Initial Approach to Risk Management of Funding Costs
An Initial Approach to Risk Management of Funding Costs
Discounting and General Value Adjustment Techniques
The collapse of Lehman has acted as a sharp reminder that financial modeling is about modeling PnL treasury shift. Indeed, holding financial products with Lehman as a counterparty can create a loss if our exposure is positive to Lehman at the time of default. This situation has created the need to follow the CVA (credit value adjustment — a measure of counterparty risk). How much should I adjust my price to reflect the possibility of my counterparty defaulting? There is also a symmetrical notion that is the DVA (debit value adjustment) which constitutes the answer to the damage my own default can create for my counterparties.
Read moreUnilateral counterparty risk valuation of CDS using a regime-switching intensity model
Unilateral counterparty risk valuation of CDS using a regime-switching intensity model
Derivative pricing under asymmetric and imperfect collateralization and CVA
The importance of collateralization through a change of funding cost is now well recognized among practitioners. In this article, the authors have extended previous studies of collateralized derivative pricing to more generic situations, i.e. asymmetric and imperfect collateralization with the associated counterparty credit risk. By introducing the collateral coverage ratio, their framework can handle these issues in a unified manner. Although the resultant pricing formula becomes a nonlinear forward–backward stochastic differential equation and cannot be solved exactly, its first-order approximation is provided using the Gateaux derivative. The authors have shown that it allows one to decompose the price of a generic contract into three parts: a market benchmark, a bilateral credit value adjustment (CVA), and a collateral cost adjustment (CCA) independent of the credit risk. Each term is studied closely, and the significant impact is demonstrated of asymmetric collateralization through CCA using numerical examples.
Read morePricing Counterparty Risk at the Trade Level and CVA Allocations
We address the problem of allocating the counterparty-level credit valuation adjustment (CVA) to the individual trades composing the portfolio. We show that this problem can be reduced to calculating contributions of the trades to the counterparty-level expected exposure (EE) conditional on the counterparty's default. We propose a methodology for calculating conditional EE contributions for both collateralized and non-collateralized counterparties. Calculation of EE contributions can be easily incorporated into exposure simulation processes that already exist in a financial institution. We also derive closed-form expressions for EE contributions under the assumption that trade values are normally distributed. Analytical results are obtained for the case when the trade values and the counterparty's credit quality are independent as well as when there is a dependence between them (wrong-way risk).
Read moreVulnerable options, risky corporate bond, and credit spread
In the current literature, the focus of credit-risk analysis has been either on the valuation of risky corporate bond and credit spread or on the valuation of vulnerable options, but never both in the same context. There are two main concerns with existing studies. First, corporate bonds and credit spreads are generally analyzed in a context where corporate debt is the only liability of the firm and a firm’s value follows a continuous stochastic process. This setup implies a zero short-term spread, which is strongly rejected by empirical observations. The failure of generating non-zero short-term credit spreads may be attributed to the simplified assumption on corporate liabilities. Because a corporation generally has more than one type of liability, modeling multiple liabilities may help to incorporate discontinuity in a firm’s value and thereby lead to realistic credit term structures. Second, vulnerable options are generally valued under the assumption that a firm can fully pay off the option if the firm’s value is above the default barrier at the option’s maturity. Such an assumption is not realistic because a corporation can find itself in a solvent position at option’s maturity but with assets insufficient to pay off the option. The main contribution of this study is to address these concerns. The proposed framework extends the existing equity-bond capital structure to an equity-bond-derivative setting and encompasses many existing models as special cases. The firm under study has two types of liabilities: a corporate bond and a short position in a call option. The risky corporate bond, credit spreads, and vulnerable options are analyzed and compared with their counterparts from previous models. Numerical results show that adding a derivative type of liability can lead to positive short-term credit spreads and various shapes of credit-spread term structures that were not possible in previous models. In addition, we found that vulnerable options need not always be worth less than their default-free counterparts. © 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Jrl Fut Mark 21:301–327, 2001
Read moreCounterparty risk and the impact of collateralization in CDS contracts
We analyze the counterparty risk embedded in CDS contracts, in presence of a bilateral margin agreement. First, we investigate the pricing of collateralized counterparty risk and we derive the bilateral Credit Valuation Adjustment (CVA), unilateral Credit Valuation Adjustment (UCVA) and Debt Valuation Adjustment (DVA). We propose a model for the collateral by incorporating all related factors such as the thresholds, haircuts and margin period of risk. We derive the dynamics of the bilateral CVA in a general form with related jump martingales. We also introduce the Spread Value Adjustment (SVA) indicating the counterparty risk adjusted spread. Counterparty risky and the counterparty risk-free spread dynamics are derived and the dynamics of the SVA is found as a consequence. We finally employ a Markovian copula model for default intensities and illustrate our findings with numerical results.
Read moreAmerican Monte Carlo by Stochastic Separation of the Expected Value
American Monte Carlo by Stochastic Separation of the Expected Value