- Research Article
- 10.1002/spe.2205
Pattern languages: addressing the challenges
- Jun 05, 2013
- Software: Practice and Experience
- Mohamed E Fayad + 1 more +1
Pattern languages: addressing the challenges
Software engineers are creators of habits. During software development, they follow again and again the same patterns when architecting, designing and implementing programs. Alexander introduced such patterns in architecture in 1974 and, 20 years later, they made their way in software development thanks to the work of Gamma et al. Software design patterns were promoted to make the design of programs more flexible, modular, reusable, and understandable. However, ten years later, these patterns, their roles, and their impact on software quality were not fully understood. We then set out to study the impact of design patterns on different quality attributes and published a paper entitled Do Design Patterns Impact Software Quality Positively? in the proceedings of the 12th European Conference on Software Maintenance and Reengineering (CSMR) in 2008. Ten years later, this paper received the Most Influential Paper award at the 25th International Conference on Software Analysis, Evolution, and Reengineering (SANER) in 2018. In this retrospective paper for the award, we report and reflect on our and others' studies on the impact of design patterns, discussing some key findings reported about design patterns. We also take a step back from these studies and re-examine the role that design patterns should play in software development. Finally, we outline some avenues for future research work on design patterns, e.g., the identification of the patterns really used by developers, the theories explaining the impact of patterns, or their use to raise the abstraction level of programming languages.
Pattern languages: addressing the challenges
Pattern languages: addressing the challenges
Software Design Patterns and Architecture Patterns –A Study Explored
Software Patterns are intellectual patterns that assist the development of more effective solutions to common problems in general. Software Patterns are examples of tried-and-true solutions and practice guidelines that can assist in transforming software engineering into a profession. As a result, it is frequently used to create restricted solutions to specific software development challenges during various phases of the software development process (analysis, design, and architecture). At any point in time, patterns may be examined and incorporated to improve the design of a system. Additionally, it is straightforward to look for and sort. Any good pattern should provide aesthetic appeal to the application. The challenge, on the other hand, is identifying the optimal pattern that is extremely relevant to the issue area. As a result, this work examines the numerous software patterns especially design and architecture that are frequently employed in applications, along with their characteristics. Applying appropriate software patterns to a particular problem is a manual procedure that is prone to failure. As a result, a pattern’s relevance should be judged by its ability to address a common issue. Empirical research on engineers’ use of Software Patterns can assist in determining the pattern’s utility in issue resolution. It would be difficult to establish a structural, organized schema system, even while the patterns attempt to evaluate, generate, and construct architecture across the software development life cycle. The goal of this article is to chart the evolution of software design and architecture patterns, with a particular emphasis on system design that adheres to a consistent organizational and structural schema.
Read moreSoftware-security patterns
Since Gamma et al. published their design patterns, patterns are very popular in the area of software engineering. They provide best practice to handle recurring problems during the software development phase. Three years later, security patterns appeared and provided solutions for security problems. Besides the name analogy, design and security patterns should be very similar except for the security factor. In research and industry software engineering with design patterns is widespread. However, some researchers suspect that security-pattern engineering is made difficult by some issues such as terminology or description form. Detecting adoption problems can help to improve security patterns in future. Thus, they can promote the awareness of security especially in the software maintenance phase where many programmers first give attention to security problems. Therefore, we will compare design and security patterns to find indicators for negative impact on security pattern engineering in software development. We address this issue on inspecting the aspects classification, description form, provided code examples, and usage in the software life-cycle. We determine the degree of maturity of software-security patterns by comparing them to the well-explored design patterns. To achieve the objective, we inspect the pattern terminology and conducted a study on the used description forms including provided UML diagrams and code examples. Moreover, a literature review is conducted to compare their state of research w.r.t. the software life-cycle. The maturity degree of security patterns compared to common design patterns differs and we depict further research opportunities on security patterns.
Read moreSoftware Design Patterns
Software Design Patterns are reusable solutions to software development difficulties. However, a Software Design Pattern is not code; rather, it is a guide or paradigm that helps software engineers to construct products that follow best practices. A Design Pattern is more of a template to tackle the topic at hand than a library or framework, which can be added and utilized right away. Object-oriented programming (OOP) is supported by Design Patterns, which are based on the ideas of objects (instances of a class; data with unique attributes) and classes (user-defined types of data). Design Patterns are blueprints for resolving typical software engineering issues. They provide reproducible solutions to some of the most prevalent difficulties you’ll encounter. That said, Design Patterns aren’t a complete solution, nor are they code, classes, or libraries that you may use in your project. They are a type of problem-solving solution. Each job will be approached in a slightly different way. Why Should You Learn Software Design Patterns? As a programmer, you can use Software Design Patterns to help you build more reliable structures. Design Patterns give you the skills to create smart and interactive applications or software with simple and easy problem-solving methods; they also allow you to create the greatest user-friendly apps and change them easily to meet the latest requirements. Design Patterns are interesting to deal with since such knowledge enables flexible coding patterns and structural techniques, reusable codes, loosely written codes, classes, patterns, and so on. This Book Contains: • A step-by-step approach to problem solving and skill development • A quick run-through of the basic concepts, in the form of a "Crash Course" • Advanced, hands-on core concepts, with a focus on real-world problems • Industry level coding paradigm with practice-oriented explanations • Special emphasis on writing clean and optimized code, with additional chapters focused on coding methodology
Read moreA Consolidated Approach for Design Pattern Recommendation
Software design patterns are standard solutions to common problems found in software development and design. Among many other benefits, they enable the creation of reusable, extensible and easy-to-maintain software systems. However, the complexity of comprehending design patterns hinders software designer's ability to adapt software design patterns in software design and development. For novice developers, choosing the most appropriate pattern for a given design context and situation becomes a challenging task. For this reason, a design pattern recommendation system can be of great help, especially for novice designers and developers, to instantiate the right pattern in their design problems. This paper proposes a consolidated approach and presents a tool which combines text-based, case-based and question-based recommendations to suggest an adequate pattern to a design problem. The effectiveness of the tool has been tested on several scenarios used in a design pattern course. Our preliminary evaluation shows that in majority of the cases, the correct design pattern is placed in the top three.
Read moreMapping design patterns to cloud patterns to support application portability
The use of Design Patterns in software engineering is well documented and supported, with new patterns descriptions being proposed and applied to software development even today. Cloud Patterns can be seen as an evolution of classic Design Patterns, since they provide optimal solutions for software development specialized for Cloud environments. By mapping Design and Cloud Patterns elements, we think it would be possible to develop an approach to support the porting of legacy applications to the Cloud, thus easing the modernization process and laying the basis for an interoperability and portability friendly software development. Here we analyse the actual feasibility of the mapping between Design and Cloud Patterns, by proposing a simple score-based methodology which analyses characteristics of both pattern categories to propose a solution to the matching problem. In order to compare different categories of patterns we leverage a semantic based representation, defined in previous works, which describes a set of common relevant characteristics related to patterns' scope and objectives.
Read moreApplying Agile Programming and Design Patterns in IT Domain
Agile software development methods have recently become popular in software engineering. Agile methods emphasize simplicity and the elimination of work that is not absolutely necessary. These techniques give preference for working software which satisfies all stake holders, and leads to a successful completion in shorter time frames, giving much importance to real-time communication. Design Patterns have been widely used by many software developers. Recent statistics reveals that patterns can have a beneficial impact on software quality. In brief, what is needed for today’s software development scenario is a combination of Agile Methodologies for faster development and usage of Design Patterns for maximizing design reusability. The combined approach applied to the software development leads to robust, secure and almost risks free software which has adaptability to accommodate rapid requirements changes. Section 1 of this paper explains the Agile Development Methodologies. Section 2 outlines the Design Patterns, while 3rd and 4th sections elaborate case studies for the combined approach.
Read morePatterns in the Field of Software Engineering
In the mid 1960’s, the architect Christopher Alexander (1964) came up with the idea of Patterns, as “a solution to a problem within a defined context” and developed this concept. He explains, in a very original way, his ideas of urban planning and building architecture, using patterns to explain the “what”, “when”, and “how” of a design. Alexander invented a Pattern Language that is the fundamental to good building and city designs, and describes it in a collection of repetitive schemas called patterns. In Computer Science, software is susceptible to conceptual patterns. Consequently, Ward Cunningham and Kent Beck, used Alexander’s idea to develop a programming pattern language composed of five patterns as an initiation guide for Smalltalk programming. This work was presented at the Object-Oriented Programming, Systems, Languages & Applications Conference (OOPSLA) in 1987. In the early 1990’s, Erich Gamma and Richard Helm did a joint research that resulted in the first specific design patterns catalog. They identified four patterns: Composite, Decider, Observer, and Constrainer patterns. According to many authors, OOPSLA ’91 highlighted the evolutionary process of design patterns. The synergy between Erich Gamma, Richard Helm, Rala Johnson, and John Vlissides (better known as the “Gang of Four” or GoF) and other reputable researchers (Ward Cunningham, Kant Beck or Doug Lea) definitively launched the study of and research into Object Oriented Design Patterns. At the same time, James Coplien, another software engineer, was compiling and shaping a programming patterns catalogue in C++, which was a significant advance in the implementation phase in software development. Coplien’s catalog was published in 1991 under the title “Advanced C++ Programming Styles and Idioms”. Between 1991 and 1994 the concept of pattern design was discussed at international congresses and conferences. All of these encounters culminated in OOPSLA ’94. The GoF took advantage of this event to present their compilation (Gamma, Helm, Johnson & Vlissides, 1995). This publication, considered at that time as the best book on Object Orientation, compiled a 23-pattern catalog, founding the basis of patterns design. The number of pattern-related works, studies and publications in general, but especially in design, has exponentially grown since. However, the different research groups being born must be cataloged into three fundamental paradigms: • Theoretical approximations to the software pattern design concept and pattern languages. Coplien’s work (Coplien, 1996; 2004; Coplien & Douglas, 1995) stands out in this field. • Analysis and compilation of software applications design patterns. Rising’s efforts (Rising, 1998; 2000) and Buschmman (Buschmann, Meunier, Rohnert, Sommerlad & Stal, 1996; Buschmann, Rohnert, Stal & Schmidt, 2000) are included in this classification. • The study of special purpose patterns, like antipatterns (Brown, 1998).
Read moreThe Evolution of Software Design Patterns: An In-Depth Review
Design patterns are repeatable fixes for common issues in software design. Even if it's helpful for software analysis, finding design patterns may be difficult, particularly in big and intricate software systems. A number of tools have been put out in this area to automate this procedure. Review the many studies on software design patterns in the literature in this topic. This review highlights the varied impact of design patterns on software quality and maintainability. While some studies suggest that design patterns enhance software quality, others argue they can be detrimental, with results varying based on factors like failure rates, performance, and maintainability. Design patterns such as Data Management UI Page and Dependent Dropdown Filters improve consistency, code reuse, and development efficiency. Among 42 design pattern detection (DPD) tools, only ten are available online, with low detection accuracy and weak agreement among tools. GEML, a novel approach using evolutionary machine learning, improves detection accuracy but may generate false positives due to limited training data.
Read moreSpecial issue on software reuse
Special issue on software reuse
Assessing the Impact of Enterprise Software Design Patterns on Maintainability: A Case Study
Software design patterns are used to improve the software quality. There are distinct kinds of software, as well as design patterns. One of them is patterns for enterprise application architecture. Although enterprise design patterns are said to be able to improve the software quality, there is a lack of literature that discusses the evidence of the impact. This preliminary study proposes a method to assess the impact of enterprise software design pattern on maintainability. We use the Academic Information System (AIS) of Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember (ITS) as a case study. It is enterprise software which is frequently maintained and need to be evolved. The software maintainability is measured by using C&K metrics. Then we calculate the relative change and evaluate it based on viewpoints of the metrics. Transaction Script pattern is selected to verify the method. As a result, it decreases the maintainability instead of improving it. The result of this preliminary study shows that design patterns did not improve the software maintainability. Based on the previous researches, it depends on several factors which may be studied in the future work. Thus, we need to propose a method to select the appropriate patterns or whether we use design patterns or not.
Read moreSoftware design patterns classification and selection using text categorization approach
Software design patterns classification and selection using text categorization approach
Landscape of Architecture and Design Patterns for IoT Systems
Due to the widespread proliferation of today’s Internet of Things (IoT), a system designer needs the IoT system and software design patterns to assist in designing scalable and replicable solutions. Patterns are encapsulations of reusable common problems and solutions under specific contexts. Many IoT patterns have been published, such as IoT design patterns and IoT architecture patterns to document the successes (and failures) in IoT systems and software development. However, because these patterns are not well classified, their adoption does not live up to their potential. To understand the reasons, we conducted a systematic literature review. From the 32 identified papers, 143 IoT architecture and design patterns were extracted. We analyzed these patterns according to several characteristics and outlined directions for improvements when publishing and adopting IoT patterns. Of the extracted patterns, 57% are non-IoT patterns, suggesting that IoT systems and software are often designed via conventional architecture and design patterns that are not specific to IoT design. Although most IoT design patterns are applicable to any domain, IoT architecture patterns tend to be domain specific, implying that the unique nature of IoT adoption in specific domains appears at the architecture level. As more domains adopt IoT, the number of domain-specific IoT design patterns should increase. In terms of quality attributes, many IoT patterns address compatibility, security, and maintainability.
Read moreThe Analysis and Application Research of the System Structure Model for Software Engineering
With the development of human society and scientific technology, people's material production and social activities, cultural activities, and increasing the scale of scientific research, social contact is increasingly close, between departments of human's epistemological and methodological level is increasing day by day, gradually from the height of the overall and the system to recognize and solve the problem, to form the concept of system theory and related theoretical system. This article is around the software engineering of the defects in the system structure model conversion technology. On the basis of the focus on design pattern oriented model transformation method, the model of knitting and the metadata mapping were studied, based on the model driven architecture (MDA) is designed for Web application development platform, verify the validity of the above technologies and methods. Introduction With the rapid development of information technology, especially the prosperity of the Internet has greatly changed the lifestyle of human society. A lot on the Internet as the carrier of the software system appear constantly, such as electronic commerce, electronic government affairs, battle command systems and network game network software is applied to the economy, society, military, entertainment and other fields, to the progress of human society played an immeasurable role. These systems instead of a single technology, relatively closed, compared the static structure of the software system, presents the heterogeneity, the characteristics of the open and dynamic [1]. The thought of software engineering, is in the early 1980s by Dr. Winston W. Royce put forward for the first time. He believes that the lack of system engineering method of the project, is likely to lead to software cannot be run on the selected hardware, software can't with other software and hardware system integration, software is not suitable for use for a long time [2]. In product development, oversight system, long-term not solve the software crisis will intensify. This article from the Angle of the engineering system theory to the software engineering investigation and analysis, the structure model of the elements and the mutual relationship are analyzed. Use of the established software engineering system structure model, this paper discusses the general steps in the process of software engineering, the key of object-oriented design pattern model transformation method, the model of knitting and the metadata mapping were studied, based on the model driven architecture (MDA) design for Web application development platform, verify the validity of the above technologies and methods. Overview of the software engineering related technology Related with the development of science and technology, computer technology has also obtained fast development, accordingly software quantity more and more, the scale of software is more and more big, the individual characteristics of many programs makes software more and more difficult to maintain, and produces the software crisis. In order to solve software crisis, from two aspects of technical measures and necessary organization management measures research how to better development and maintenance of computer software, and then the software engineering this emerging subject. The concept of software engineering system is to examine some of the thoughts of system theory, application engineering and research on software engineering science system, International Conference on Education Technology, Management and Humanities Science (ETMHS 2015) © 2015. The authors Published by Atlantis Press 1253
Read moreExploring the Software Design Patterns Course Based on the Outcome-Based Education (OBE) Philosophy
To address practical challenges in teaching "Software Design Patterns" courses-including complex content, disconnect between theory and practice, and implementation difficulties-this study explores an OBE (Outcome-Based Education) approach. Through discovery-based exploration with classroom implementation as the ultimate goal, we developed implementation-oriented projects that integrate software design patterns with commercial software development. These projects enable students to learn the advantages of modular programming through software development, cultivating design pattern thinking. By adopting OBE principles in teaching "Software Design Patterns," students gain precise understanding of design patterns' value in commercial software development, enhancing learning engagement and improving course effectiveness.
Read more