- Research Article
- 10.4085/1062-6050-1005.22
ACL Research Retreat IX March 17–19, 2022 High Point, NC
- Sep 01, 2022
- Journal of Athletic Training
- Sandra J Shultz + 23 more +23
Objective: To critically assess the literature focused on sex-specific trajectories in physical characteristics associated with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury risk by age and maturational stage.Data Sources: PubMed, CINHAL, Scopus, and SPORTDiscus databases were searched through December 2021.Study Selection: Longitudinal and cross-sectional studies of healthy 8- to 18-year-olds, stratified by sex and age or maturation on 1 measure of body composition, lower extremity strength, ACL size, joint laxity, knee-joint geometry, lower extremity alignment, balance, or lower extremity biomechanics were included.Data Extraction: Extracted data included study design, participant characteristics, maturational metrics, and outcome measures. We used random-effects meta-analyses to examine sex differences in trajectory over time. For each variable, standardized differences in means between sexes were calculated.Data Synthesis: The search yielded 216 primary and 22 secondary articles. Less fat-free mass, leg strength, and power and greater general joint laxity were evident in girls by 8 to 10 years of age and Tanner stage I. Sex differences in body composition, strength, power, general joint laxity, and balance were more evident by 11 to 13 years of age and when transitioning from the prepubertal to pubertal stages. Sex differences in ACL size (smaller in girls), anterior knee laxity and tibiofemoral angle (greater in girls), and higher-risk biomechanics (in girls) were observed at later ages and when transitioning from the pubertal to postpubertal stages. Inconsistent study designs and data reporting limited the number of included studies.Conclusions: Critical gaps remain in our knowledge and highlight the need to improve our understanding of the relative timing and tempo of ACL risk factor development.Context: The risk of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury in female athletes increases throughout the stages of maturation. Previous evidence has indicated a lack of dynamic knee control during double-limb jump landings throughout maturation, yet the extent of biomechanical changes that occur throughout maturation during single-limb landings are not well understood. A maturational analysis of high-risk biomechanics during single-limb landings may elucidate and inform injury risk reduction efforts.Objective: To determine differences in single-limb landing biomechanics between pre-pubertal, pubertal, and post-pubertal female soccer players.Design: Cross-sectional (pre-testing component of a randomized controlled trial)Setting: Research biomechanics laboratoryPatients or Other Participants: 151 competitive female soccer playersIntervention(s): Participants were categorized based on percent of adult stature into pre-pubertal (PRE: <84% of adult stature, n=23), pubertal (PUB: 87%-94% of adult stature, n=36), and post-pubertal (POST: >94% of adult stature, n=92) maturational groups.Main Outcome Measure(s): All participants were instrumented for standard three-dimensional motion analysis and completed three trials of an ipsilateral single-limb hop and land over a 4-inch hurdle. Variables of interest included peak landing kinematics (hip flexion, hip adduction, hip internal rotation, knee flexion, knee abduction, ankle dorsiflexion) and peak landing external moments and ground reaction forces normalized to body mass (hip flexion, knee flexion, knee abduction, vertical ground reaction force). Multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) was used to compare the biomechanical variables of the dominant limb (preferred kicking limb) between maturational groups (α=0.05). Pearson's correlational analyses identified the relationship between the estimated percent of adult stature and lower extremity biomechanical variables.Results: There were significant differences in lower extremity kinematics (λ=0.79, p<0.001) and kinetics (λ=0.78, p<0.001) between maturational groups. POST landed in less hip internal rotation (POST: -0.3±5.4°) than PRE (3.8±7.0°, d= 0.67, p=0.008) and PUB (3.4±6.0°, d= 0.65, p=0.004), and greater knee abduction (POST: 5.1±4.8°) than PUB (2.4±3.4°, d= 0.66, p=0.009). POST also landed with vertical ground reaction forces 14% lower (POST: 3.20±0.76 xBW) than PRE (3.69±0.78 xBW, d= 0.62, p=0.01) and 13% lower than PUB (3.65±0.47 xBW, d= 0.73, p=0.005). Weak relationships were identified between the estimated percent of adult stature and peak hip internal rotation angle (r=-0.26) and vertical ground reaction force (r=-0.31).Conclusions: Post-pubertal female soccer players performed single-limb landings with lesser hip internal rotation, greater knee abduction, and lower vertical ground reaction forces. These findings are inconsistent with previous evidence that indicates higher risk movement strategies in post-pubertal athletes. The single-limb landing over a standardized hurdle height may not provide a comprehensive biomechanical picture for which to assign injury risk profiles.Context: Researchers have identified modifiable biomechanical anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury risk factors in laboratory settings with change of direction tasks. To preserve athlete-environment relationship, it has been advocated to assess movement strategies on the field rather than only in the laboratory. However, the kinematic differences between laboratory and on-field settings have never been investigated.Objective: To investigate the knee kinematics of female soccer players during agility movements performed both in laboratory and in soccer field environments.Design: Observational.Setting: Research laboratory and field.Patients or Other Participants: Twenty healthy female soccer players (14.9 ± 0.9 years, height 167.9 ± 4.8 cm, mass 56.4 ± 7.3 kg) participated.Intervention(s): Unanticipated sidestep cutting tasks with the dominant leg (towards the non-dominant leg) were collected both in the laboratory and on the field. In the laboratory, the players used a 5m approach run followed by a 1-foot landing and a 40°-50° change of direction followed by running through a gate 5m away. On-field tasks were recorded during a game performed as part of their regular training session. Kinematics were collected through wearable inertial sensors (Xsens Technologies, Enschede, The Netherlands). One-way ANOVA was used to compare knee joint kinematics between the conditions, with level of significance set at p<.05. Waveform consistency was investigated through Pearson's correlation coefficient and standardized z-score vector.Main Outcome Measure(s): For both conditions, 3D joint angles were defined using the Euler sequence ZXY and exported from the Xsens software (Xsens MVN Analyze 2020.0.1) to a customized Matlab (The MathWorks 2019a, Natick, Massachusetts, US) script. The ultimate foot contact before the change of direction was used and data were processed in a time-normalized interval from 50ms prior to the initial contact (0%) to 25ms after (100%). For the field, 40°-50° changes of direction were extracted for comparison with the laboratory condition.Results: On-field agility yielded vastly different knee kinematics compared to lab agility. At initial contact, the average knee flexion angle on-field was 31.96° - 36.92° versus 19.47° - 21.15° in the laboratory (p=.004). For the frontal plane at initial contact, we found -1.08° - -2.31° knee abduction in the field and 0.29° - 0.67° knee adduction in the laboratory (p=.007). The peak knee angles in frontal and sagittal planes were comparable among the two conditions. Waveform correlation was poor-to-excellent between laboratory and field (r: 0.20-1.00).Conclusions: Movement strategies used for changes of direction tasks in the laboratory were different from the on-field movement strategies in young female soccer players. This could be attributed to the differences in the environment and support the need for on-field injury risk screening.Context: Increased knee extensor moments relative to hip extensor moments during landing have been proposed as a risk factor for ACL injury in females. Diminished strength of the hip extensors relative to the knee extensors has been shown to predict an increased knee-hip extensor moment ratio during the deceleration phase of landing.Objective: To determine if decreased strength of the hip extensors relative to the knee extensors predicts re-injury in females who have returned to sport following ACL reconstruction (ACLR). Design: Retrospective, case-controlSetting: Patient clinicIntervention(s): Maximum isometric strength of the hip and knee extensors was measured using a motor-driven dynamometer (BTE Primus; BTE) as part of return to sport testing following ACLR. Patients were contacted to participate in an online survey concerning their return to sport and ACL injury status at least 12 months following testing.Patients or Other Participants: 345 females post ACLR who had previously undergone baseline strength testing were surveyed. The survey response rate was 54%. Respondents who sustained an ipsilateral ACL re-injury (non-contact) within 36 months of returning to sport were considered as cases.Main Outcome Measure(s): Twelve cases (14-22 years) were identified and matched with 2-4 non-injured controls (n = 41) based on sport level, athletic exposures, age, and graft type. Peak isometric strength for the hip and knee extensors was identified for each case and control from patient records. The hip-knee extensor strength ratio was calculated by dividing the peak strength of the hip extensors by the knee extensors (expressed as percentage). Logistic regression was performed to determine if the hip-knee extensor strength ratio predicted ACL re-injury, adjusted for known confounders (athletic exposures, age, graft type, months ACLR to return to sport). Receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was conducted to determine the cutoff for the hip-knee extensor strength ratio that distinguished between high-risk and low-risk outcomes.Results: Cases had a lower hip-knee extensor strength ratio compared to controls (0.83 ± 0.16 vs. 0.98 ± 0.17, p = 0.007). The hip-knee extensor strength ratio significantly predicted ACL re-injury (p = 0.036, adjusted OR = 0.944, 95% CI: 0.894, 0.996). For every 1% increase in the hip-knee extensor strength ratio, there was 5.6% lower odds of re-injury. ROC curve analysis revealed an area under the curve of 74.8% [95% CI: 58.7%, 90.9%] (p=0.010), indicating fair prediction accuracy. The cutoff for the hip-knee extensor strength ratio to define high risk was <= 97.1% (sensitivity: 91.7%, specificity: 51.2%).Conclusions: Female athletes with a lower hip-knee extensor strength ratio following ACLR are at greater risk of ACL re-injury (ipsilateral limb). These results suggest that return to sport testing to assess risk for ACL re-injury should consider the inclusion of hip and knee extensor strength.Context: Upwards of 30% of youth athletes sustain a repeat anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury after ACL reconstruction. While specific risk factors for re-injury and predictive models exist, these models are: 1) Limited in scope, failing to consider the large number of variables related to re-injury, 2) Overly simplistic, overlooking the interaction amongst variables, 3) Too broad, identifying risk factors within a group context and 4) non-actionable, utilizing risk factors that cannot be altered in recovery.Objective: The goal of this study was to develop an ACL re-injury prediction model capable of evaluating each patient's individual risk, identifying modifiable risk factors and ranking these factors on the order of importance and ability to be modified.Design: Retrospective database study of 432 patients (mean age 15.0, Female 50.7%) who underwent ACL reconstruction. This dataset represented a targeted extraction from a larger dataset and had a reinjury rate of 30%.Setting: The dataset included variables across the following categories: Demographics, injury information, family history of ACL injury, surgical variables, rehabilitation & performance testing and re-injury information.Intervention(s): Machine learning (ML) techniques leveraging clinician domain knowledge were utilized to develop a model capable of determining a patient's risk for repeat ACL injury. Two highly experienced surgeons and a physical therapist independently assessed risk factors and ranked their contribution to injury and ability to be modified during recovery. These classifications were integrated into the modeling, allowing clinician expertise to improve upon standard ML methodologies. After patient risk classification, the model ranks the most significant risk factors according to impact and ease of modification.Main Outcome Measure(s): Multiple weighting methods and hyperparameter schemes were evaluated to obtain the highest accuracy classifying patients into high, medium or low risk categories, and weighting of modifiable risk factors. Model accuracy was determined using a 5-fold cross validation process over a 20% holdout dataset. An a-priori goal of classifying double the rate of re-injury across the entire dataset into high-risk patients (54%) and half this rate (13.5%) into low-risk.Results: The final model included 23 modifiable variables represented mostly by performance factors (e.g. normalized quad peak torque, quad/hamstring strength ratio, hop testing performance or time to return to sports). The model adjusts risk factor weight on a case-by-case basis. Performance goals were achieved with ACL re-tear rates of 58% in high-risk and 7% in low-risk categories, with sensitivity of 89% and specificity of 66% and verified within the cross-validation process.Conclusions: This ACL-Reinjury Risk Prediction Model can improve clinical care through accurate risk stratification and identification of patient specific modifiable risk factors, that can inform ongoing reinjury reduction or rehabilitation programs. Continued improvements in model accuracy will incorporate additional features, developing more intelligent labeling functions and adding confidence metrics.Context: The high incidence of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries in young female soccer players compared to their male counterparts has led to a large body of work aimed at reducing injury.Objective: To determine the effects of neuromuscular training using biomechanical biofeedback in order to reduce the risk of ACL injuries in adolescent female athletes.Design: Randomized controlled clinical trial; Level of evidence, 1.Setting: Research laboratoryPatients or Other Participants: 150 (age:13.3±2.2yrs; height: 156.1±10.6cm; mass:50.2±11.3kg) female soccer players.Intervention(s): A prospective, randomized, active comparator, open blinded, end-point trial was conducted. Participants were randomized into one of three study arms where each received neuromuscular training plus 1) sham biofeedback as an active control (NMT), 2) knee-focused biofeedback (NMT+K), and 3) hip-focused biofeedback (NMT+H).Main Outcome Measure(s): Each participant completed a pre-intervention baseline session and a post-intervention session to determine knee abduction moment (KAM) during a double leg drop vertical jump (DVJ) and an unplanned single leg cutting task at discrete time points and at specific time points during the stance phase. Athletic exposures and ACL injuries were tracked weekly for six months following the post-test session.Results: 140 participants (93.3%) completed the 6-week intervention and post-test. No ACL injuries were reported among any of the intervention groups six months following post-testing. Peak KAM was significantly improved in all three intervention groups from baseline to the post-test during the drop vertical jump (NMT: baseline -21.4Nm [95% CI: -25.4, -17.4], post -16.6Nm [95% CI: -19.7, -13.5], p=0.001, d=-0.48; NMT+K baseline -19.5Nm [95% CI: -23.2, -15.8], post -14.6Nm [95% CI: -17.6, -11.7], p=0.003, d=-0.42; NMT+H baseline -22.2Nm [95% CI: -26.9, -17.8]; post -17.6Nm [95% CI: -21.1, -14.1], p=0.002, d=-0.45). The primary outcome in this RCT, peak KAM, had mean improvement of 22.7% from baseline to post-testing which did not differ between groups during the DVJ (p>0.05). However, statistically significant differences in peak KAM during the unanticipated cutting task were only found in the NMT+H intervention group (NMT: baseline -25.0Nm [95% CI: -30.4, -19.6], post -25.0Nm [95% CI: -29.6, -20.5], p=0.49, d=004; NMT+K baseline -23.6m [95% CI: -28.9, -18.3], post -22.8Nm [95% CI: -28.0, -17.6], p=0.377, d=-0.05; NMT+H baseline -29.5Nm [95% CI: -35.3, -23.8]; post -22.9Nm [95% CI: -27.8, -18.0], p=0.003, d=-0.44).Conclusions: While female soccer players involved in neuromuscular training programs regardless of intervention group exhibit significant improvements in KAM during a double leg landing, those that engage in hip-focused biofeedback compared to knee-focused or sham biofeedback exhibit decreased KAM during an unanticipated cutting maneuver. Neuromuscular training programs that aim to modify the high-risk biomechanics associated with ACL injury may benefit from targeting the underlying components of injury, such as underutilization of hip musculature during dynamic sport related movements.Context: Neuromuscular training (NMT) programs have been shown to modify high-risk biomechanics and ACL injury risk. However, it is unknown which neuromuscular factors are modified following the completion of NMT programs. Hip strength has been suggested to be an important factor in ACL injury risk and is commonly emphasized in NMT programs. Understanding the immediate effects and retention of hip strength following a NMT program will provide insight into the effectiveness of NMT programs in reducing ACL injury risk.Objective: To examine the increase and retention of isokinetic hip strength in female adolescent soccer players following a neuromuscular training (NMT) program.Design: Prospective cohort study.Setting: Research laboratory.Patients or Other Participants: 126 adolescent female soccer players (age=13.2±2.1yrs, height=156.4±10.2cm, mass=49.9±11.0kg) were included in this subgroup analysis that completed all isokinetic hip strength assessments.Intervention(s): Participants volunteered to complete 6 consecutive weeks of a neuromuscular training (NMT) program with a frequency of 3 times a week. The NMT program included progressive exercises that included components of lower extremity strengthening, plyometrics, and core strengthening. Using an isokinetic dynamometer, 5 repetitions of isokinetic concentric (CON) and eccentric (ECC) hip extension (HEXT) torque were measured at 60 deg•s−1 bilaterally prior to (PRE) and following (POST) the NMT program. Retention (RET) of hip strength was assessed 6-months following the completion of the NMT program.Main Outcome Measure(s): The average peak torque (Nm) of the middle 3 repetitions for CON and ECC HEXT strength measures of the right and left limb during each testing session were used for analyses. Separate repeated measures ANOVAs were used to compare differences in HEXT strength between PRE, POST, and RET. Post-hoc pairwise comparisons with Bonferroni correction were performed when appropriate.Results: HEXT strength (CON, ECC) were significantly different between testing sessions. Specifically, POST right (146.9±48.3 Nm, 150.0±57.9 Nm) and left (147.4±47.7 Nm, 144.2±52.7 Nm) were greater than PRE right (138.8±44.0 Nm, P=0.007; 139.6±56.5 Nm, P= 0.026) and left (138.4±45.0 Nm, P=0.009; 139.4±56.2 Nm, P=0.035). RET right (130.2±48.8 Nm, 133.5±50.2 Nm) and left (131.9±46.2 Nm. 133.2±50.2 Nm) were less than POST (Prange= <0.001-0.007). However, neither right or left HEXT strength were different between PRE and RET (Prange=0.094-0.203).Conclusions: In female adolescent soccer players, increases in isokinetic HEXT strength were observed immediately following a 6-week NMT program. However, the increases in hip strength were not retained 6-months following the completion of the NMT program. While the immediate increases in hip strength may contribute to the effectiveness of NMT programs in reducing ACL injury risk, these positive changes appear to decrease over time. This suggests that adolescent athletes may need to continuously engage in NMT programs to maintain the immediate observed increases in hip strength.Context: Despite decades of research and innovation, primary and secondary ACL injury rates remain high. Traditional injury prevention programs focus on biomechanical-related outcomes, neglecting to maximize more cognitively-driven processes that capitalize on motor learning principles. The advent of virtual reality technology allows for seamless integration of targeted motor learning strategies into injury prevention regimens, which may lead to improved acquisition and retention of safe movement patterns.Objective: Determine the efficacy of a brief virtual-reality intervention to deliver specific motor learning of support or for retention of safe frontal plane We that and in greater improvements compared to a control repeated motion analysis laboratoryPatients or Other Participants: included participants cm, cm, kg) who frontal plane inclusion history of lower extremity or lower extremity injury for six months to data the final was Participants were to one of three groups or such that the ratio was across groups. All participants virtual reality that an plane Participants were to the 5 of 8 on the left The group their prior to each The group received positive biofeedback in the of when kinematics within Outcome Measure(s): Participants were for three-dimensional motion and completed repetitions of left leg Peak frontal plane and angles were measured before and immediately following the changes were assessed with A for time indicated that all groups increased hip adduction control by time revealed that the control group greater increases in knee abduction compared to and and that greater in ipsilateral compared to and control Hip adduction in all Despite and groups baseline knee the control group was through in ipsilateral of motor learning to the effects of increased and to athletes during increases and the motor learning on the timing of to movement The effects of on the of sidestep cutting a task that is highly related with ACL injury risk, are To investigate the of on was that the group more after the training than the Randomized controlled Research laboratory.Patients or Other Participants: healthy sport athletes years, cm, kg) were from on participants were to the or 1 and participants performed trials as and retention of three randomized an task and two in which participants had to and or and a to the All participants received and were to the movement of the to the of their The group was to for after every trial during of 1) the Movement 2) and sagittal of the trial and 3) an external focus on to improve their The goal was to lower the The counterparts received after the trial on which their in the group had Outcome Measure(s): between groups and were with repeated measures with level of significance set at between groups were of at were higher compared to training and retention to the group improved during training which was in the and retention The group higher in and retention compared to training The group their improved during the retention the group to their baseline may benefit and could be considered as a to in ACL injury prevention the years, have injury prevention programs capable of reducing the rate of ACL injury. However, youth sport have been to these programs and injury rates to Previous studies have focused on the efficacy of during controlled conditions. research that factors impact the effectiveness of in Understanding and on and may be important for the and effectiveness of in youth To and the and of youth sport Sources: An database search was conducted in using and A of search prevention and were were limited to in studies were following a search for those Selection: with data were and studies were that did not injury prevention in sport were as were and and the studies and those which did not did not focus on the and only included of youth sport Extraction: studies from sport female not were to knowledge and were reported in the included of studies was not Synthesis: to lack of knowledge and lack of to to increase knowledge to positive that youth athletes are at high risk of injury and that reduce injury The identified this literature support the need for and to knowledge and support of youth sport for of the evidence in the 13 of the studies from the the focused on soccer and when sex of was the were The of such as the for Research and the will be in identifying that and developing to the of individual program increases risk of lower extremity injury, to the anterior cruciate ligament in neuromuscular control following
Read more