Towards Optimising Neurodevelopment in very preterm infants: the effects of infant massage by the mother
Background:Preterm infants are at increased risk of poorer neurodevelopmental outcomes, because of early exposure of the vulnerable developing nervous system to the extrauterine environment. The neonatal brain possesses the capacity for neuroplasticity, which may be modulated by early intervention to improve long term outcomes. Infant massage of VPT infants, as an early intervention, has demonstrated positive effects on cognitive and language function, EEG power, maturity of visual function, and positive effects on maternal mood and mother-infant attachment. Overall, the evidence remains limited by heterogeneity in studies, small sample size and weaknesses in methodology. Aims:This study aims to investigate the effects of infant massage, performed by the mother on VPT (very preterm) infants, and measure its effects at the electrophysiological, neuroradiological and clinical level at term equivalent age (TEA) and 24 months corrected age (CA). In addition, the impact of infant massage on maternal mood, anxiety, maternal responsiveness, maternal competence, and infant attachment will be also be assessed. The hypothesis that infant massage can promote favourable processes in brain development, mitigating the adverse effects of early exposure to the extrauterine environment, and improve mother mood, anxiety, maternal responsiveness, competence and mother-infant attachment, will be tested.Methods: Sixty VPT infants, born between 28 and 32+6 weeks gestational age, were randomly assigned to receive daily infant massage (Massage group, n = 30) from 33 to 34 weeks postmenstrual age (PMA) until TEA (39 to 42 weeks PMA), or standard care (SC group, n = 30). At recruitment, before the intervention, all VPT infants were assessed with a Dubowitz assessment (DA). At TEA, after the intervention, all VPT infants were assessed by dense array EEG (dEEG), diffusion MRI (dMRI), Dubowitz Assessment and Neonatal Vision Scale (NVS). As reference, 10 healthy term control infants (TC group) were also evaluated with the same assessments at TEA. At 24 months CA, all VPT infants were assessed with the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development, Third Edition (Bayley-III). At recruitment, before the intervention, all mothers were assessed with the Mother Infant Bonding Scale (MIBS), Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) and Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale (DASS). At TEA, after the intervention, all mothers were again assessed with MIBS, EPDS and DASS. At 12 months CA, mothers were assessed with the Maternal Infant Responsiveness Instrument (MIRI) and the Maternal Postnatal Attachment Scale (MPAS), and at 24 months CA, mothers were assessed with the Maternal Efficacy Questionnaire (MEQ) and the DASS. Analysis of the data was by intention to treat, with further exploration of the data for deviations from the planned intervention. Results:Baseline demographics included 48 singleton VPT infants and 6 sets of VPT twins, equally randomised to each VPT group. There were smaller, more premature and more female VPT infants, randomised to the Massage group. A large variation in massage therapy dose (0 to 61 episodes) was administered by mothers in the Massage group. For infant measures, at TEA, 28 (93%) Massage group versus 23 (77%) SC group VPT infants were assessed with dEEG, dMRI, DA and NVS assessments. For EEG power, only 25 (83%) Massage group versus (67%) SC group EEGs were available for comparative analysis. No differences were detected between Massage and SC group infants in global relative power (GRP) or global absolute power (GAP) across beta (13-30 Hz), alpha (6-13 Hz), theta (2-6 Hz) and delta (0.5-2 Hz) band frequencies. There was a significantly higher central alpha relative power measured in Massage group infants compared to SC group infants (MD=1.424, 95% CI: 0.116 to 2.733; p=0.034, R2=0.101). EEG power trends indicated Massage group infants demonstrated greater brain maturation than SC group infants, with results confounded by differences in BW, GA at birth and chronological days of age at EEG. Massage dose effects showed an extremely small, but favourable increase in brain maturation across all bands with massage dose, after controlling for confounders (effect on beta GRP, 95%CI: 0.002 to 0.026, p=0.027; effect on alpha GRP, 95%CI: 0.009 to 0.062, p=0.011; effect on theta GRP, 95%CI: 0.026 to 0.212, p=0.013; effect on delta GRP, 95%CI: -0.302 to -0.039; p=0.013). Only 24 (80%) Massage group versus 17 (57%) SC group dMRIs were available for comparative analysis. No significant differences were detected between intervention groups in Fractional Anisotropy (FA)(p=0.97) or Mean Diffusivity (MD)(p=0.47). DA (p=0.132) and NVS (p=0.36) assessments showed no significant differences between intervention groups at TEA. Dense array EEG, dMRI measures and DA scores for TC group, were significantly higher than combined VPT infant groups (Massage and SC groups). At 24 months, only 23 (77%) Massage group versus 15 (50%) SC group Bayley-III scores were available for comparative analysis. No significant differences were detected between intervention groups on Bayley-III subscores (Cognitive p=0.42, Language p=0.56, Motor p=0.76, Social Emotional p=0.18 and General Adaptive p=0.41). For maternal measures, no significant differences were found between Massage group and SC group, at baseline or at TEA, in MIBS, EPDS and DASS scores. At 12 months CA, 22 (81%) Massage group versus 14 (52%) SC group mothers’ MIRI and MPAS scores returned for analysis. There were significantly higher MIRI scores in the Massage group compared to SC group (MD=-7.0, 95% CI: -13.6 to -0.4; p=0.038, R2=0.109). Maternal attachment scores were higher in Massage group mothers than SC group mothers, but did not reach significance (MPAS p=0.18). At 24 months, 18 (67%) Massage group versus 7 (26%) SC group mothers’ MEQ and DASS scores returned for analysis. There was significantly higher MEQ scores in the SC group compared to Massage group (p=0.036). DASS scores showed significantly lower stress in the Massage group than SC group mothers, over 24 months (p=0.031). Significant attrition bias cautions interpretation of this finding.Conclusions:This study demonstrated that infant massage, as an early intervention, generates favourable measurable differences, that can be detected using EEG. Positive impacts on maternal mental health and mother-infant outcomes support previous findings. Limitations of the study including confounders, variability in massage dose administered and small sample size, warrant further research to confirm validity of the positive EEG findings. Infant massage holds promise as an intervention, to optimize neurodevelopmental outcomes in very preterm infants.
Read more