Efficient Insertion Heuristics for Vehicle Routing and Scheduling Problems

This paper investigates the application of a new class of neighborhood search algorithms—cyclic transfers—to multivehicle routing and scheduling problems. These algorithms exploit the two-faceted decision structure inherent to this problem class: First, assigning demands to vehicles and, second, routing each vehicle through its assigned demand stops. We describe the application of cyclic transfers to vehicle routing and scheduling problems. Then we determine the worst-case performance of these algorithms for several classes of vehicle routing and scheduling problems. Next, we develop computationally efficient methods for finding negative cost cyclic transfers. Finally, we present computational results for three diverse vehicle routing and scheduling problems, which collectively incorporate a variety of constraint and objective function structures. Our results show that cyclic transfer methods are either comparable to or better than the best published heuristic algorithms for several complex and important vehicle routing and scheduling problems. Most importantly, they represent a novel approach to solution improvement which holds promise in many vehicle routing and scheduling problem domains.

SYNOPTIC ABSTRACTBranch exchange techniques, such as the well-known 2-opt and 3-opt procedures, are among the most powerful heuristics available for the solution of the classic vehicle routing problem. The imposition of time window constraints on customer delivery time within the vehicle routing problem, however, introduces several complexities that can reduce the power of these techniques. In this paper, two test data sets for the vehicle routing and scheduling problem with time window constraints are studied. Initial solutions are obtained using a variety of heuristics. These solutions are then improved using branch exchange procedures modified to incorporate the time window constraints.

The model and algorithm for Vehicle Routing and Scheduling Problem (VRSP) in picking up and delivering customers to airport service were presented in this paper. VRSP is an extension of the class Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) with more resource constraints. Mathematical models are described for the VRSP with minimizing the cost based on low carbon emissions. The Bi-directional Optimization Heuristic Algorithm (BOHA) is developed for this model. The results verified the effectiveness of the model and Algorithm. The proposed model and algorithm can provide quantitative support and help the air ticket company decision-maker develop economical, punctual shuttle service with high satisfaction.

A bi-criteria heuristic for the vehicle routing problem with time windows

Nowadays genetic algorithms stand as a trend to solve NP-complete and NP-hard problems. In this paper, we present a new hybrid metaheuristic which combines Genetic Algorithms and Scatter Search coupled with a decomposition-into-petals procedure for solving a class of Vehicle Routing and Scheduling Problems. Its performance is evaluated for a heterogeneous fleet model, which is considered a problem much harder to solve than the homogeneous vehicle routing problem.

The ant system (AS) is a metaheuristic approach originally developed for solving the traveling salesman problem. AS has been successfully applied to various hard combinatorial optimization problems and different variants have been proposed in the literature. In this paper, we introduce a time-based pheromone approach for AS (TbAS). Due to this nature TbAS is applicable to routing problems involving time-windows. The novelty in TbAS is the multi-layer pheromone network structure which implicitly utilizes the service time information associated with the customers as a heuristic information. To investigate the performance of TbAS, we use the well-known vehicle routing problem with time-windows as our testbed and we conduct an extensive computational study using the Solomon (Algorithms for the vehicle routing and scheduling problems with time window constraints 35:254–265, 1987) instances. Our results reveal that the proposed time-based pheromone approach is effective in obtaining good quality solutions.

We modify the classical chain decomposition model for vehicle routing in order to formulate a very general class of vehicle routing and scheduling problems with time windows, in which vehicles may pick up loads while on the way to deliver others. We use the model as a framework for a tabu search heuristic that exploits the constraint structure these problems have in common while accommodating complex side constraints and objective functions. We test the heuristic computationally on several random problems and a problem supplied by the U.S. Military Airlift Command.

After you have studied this chapter, you should: Know the classification system for vehicle routing problems and algorithms. Know the following for each of the classes of vehicle routing and scheduling problems: The characteristics of the base problem and its variants. The mathematical formulation. Simple solution algorithms. How to solve problems of modest size with a computer program.

Contributors

The chapter by Teodor Crainic in this book discusses the long haul truck routing problem. Some of the key differences between the long haul truck routing problem and the vehicle routing problems considered in this chapter are as follows: 1. In the long haul truck routing problem, the routes can extend over several days whereas, in the vehicle routing problem described herein, the routes are of one-day duration. 2. In the long haul truck routing problem, the locations can be scattered over a wide region, even the entire United States, whereas in the vehicle routing problems considered herein, the locations requiring service are packed in a small region.

In this paper, the ant colony algorithms is studied, and improve the shortcomings of the algorithm, And the improved algorithm is introduced into the field of logistics transportation.Aiming at the complexity and uncertainty of logistics transportation vehicle scheduling problem, a new algorithm is designed.The experimental results show that the improved algorithm can choose the transport route, speed up the transportation speed, improve the service quality, reduce the transportation cost and increase economic benefits.

Traditional vehicle routing problems implicitly assume that only one crew operates a vehicle for the entirety of its journey. However, this assumption is violated in many applications arising in humanitarian and military logistics. This paper considers a joint vehicle and crew routing and scheduling problem in which crews are able to interchange vehicles, resulting in space and time interdependencies between vehicle routes and crew routes. The problem is formulated as a mixed integer programming (MIP) model and a constraint programming (CP) model that overlay crew routing constraints over a standard vehicle routing problem. The constraint program uses a novel optimization constraint to detect infeasibility and to bound crew objectives. This paper also explores methods using large neighborhood search over the MIP and CP models. Experimental results indicate that modeling the vehicle and crew routing problems jointly and supporting vehicle interchanges for crews may bring significant benefits in cost reduction compared with a method that sequentializes these decisions.

In many countries, truck drivers are obliged by law to take a break or a rest regularly. In the European Union, for example, this is governed by Regulation (EC) No. 561/2006. It states that, after 4.5 hours of driving a truck, it is prohibited to continue driving until a 45-minute break is taken. After accumulating a driving time of 9 hours, a rest of 11 hours is mandatory. These are only two rules of a considerably longer list of break rules set out in this regulation, and it is only one of many regulations there are worldwide. Such breaks and rests have to be planned into the work schedules of the drivers. In general, the task of a dispatcher is to find routes and schedules for the truck drivers such that every customer is served in time. With the regulations on drivers’ working hours, both the routing and the scheduling parts of the task become more challenging. In this thesis, we study several optimization problems that arise in the context of drivers’ working hours. One is known as the truck driver scheduling problem. Here, a sequence of customers is given, and the task is to find a schedule for a driver such that every customer is visited within one of the customer’s time windows and the applicable break rules are complied with. Depending on the regarded break rules, we get different variants of the truck driver scheduling problem. Little is known about the complexity of the individual problem variants. One of the two focal points of this thesis is to present polynomial-time algorithms for different variants of the problem, for which polynomial-time algorithms are not yet known. With this, we can falsify the NP-hardness conjecture of Xu et al. (2003) for an important special case of their considered problem variant. But this thesis is not only about scheduling, it is also about routing. This constitutes the second focal point of this thesis. We present an integrated approach for the vehicle routing and truck driver scheduling problem. Here, a route refers to the order in which the customers are visited. However, the meaning of route is twofold. In another studied problem, the truck driver scheduling and routing problem, it means the sequence of road segments that the driver takes to drive from one customer to the other. In this problem, we take into account that, before taking a break, truck drivers need to head for a rest area or at least a spot where their vehicle can be parked. We even consider the time-dependent scenario in which driving times on road segments vary over the day due to rush hours. Both an exact approach and a heuristic for this problem are presented, and both are evaluated on a recent road network instance of Germany. It turns out that the heuristic is at least two orders of magnitude faster but still hardly worse than the exact approach. Our main motivation is the application in practice. It is our aim – and this is especially true for the second focal point – to provide helpful algorithms that may find their way into software products for dispatchers, like the described approach for the vehicle routing and truck driver scheduling problem is already integrated into the vehicle route planning tools of a commercial provider of logistics optimization software.

The home health care routing and scheduling problem (HHCRSP) is an extension of the vehicle routing problem (VRP) that are scheduled and routed to perform a wide range of health care services. Nurses, doctors and/or caregivers provide these services at patients’ home. In this study, a mathematical model for HHCRSP is presented. The model is extended to take into account additional characteristics and/or constraints based on specific services, patient needs. In the home health care (HHC) problems, services that must be performed simultaneously or within a convinced time are undoubtedly very important. Thus, we consider several numbers of services, skill requirements for the care workers and time windows. Generally, the main aim of the HHC problems is minimizing the travelling distance as well as maximizing the patients’ satisfaction. Thus, the model in this study contains both of these objectives taking into account several measurements.

A classification scheme for vehicle routing and scheduling problems