- Research Article
2- 10.1258/jrsm.2009.09k016
The fallacy of competing interest statements: no shortcut to rigour in research
- Apr 01, 2009
- Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine
- Kara G Hanson + 3 more +3
We are concerned that it could be taken to imply that we failed to declare appropriately 'competing interests' that might have influenced our views in a recent PLOS Medicine debate on the role of the private sector. 2 We refute this suggestion and believe that it is essential to distinguish competing interests from the broad range of factors that influence and shape judgements about evidence -such as personal values and beliefs, professional and disciplinary training, et cetera.We do not claim to be lacking in self-interestthat would run counter to most bodies of economic thought -but it is incorrect to suggest that our views were influenced by competing interests as usually defined: '. anything that interferes with, or could reasonably be perceived as interfering with, the full and objective presentation, review, or publication of research findings .'. 3 The authors of the editorial do not argue that we received any direct financial benefits from our contribution.However, they imply that a range of potential institutional linkages may have affected our position on the appropriate role for the private sector -our employer (the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine), the World Health Organization and the other 'governments, foundations, NGOs and UN agencies' with which we have all collaborated or received funding from in the past.There are two issues here.The first is that none of these organizations could be said to have a single and unitary view on the private sector -they are all institutions within which a range of positions and perspectives thrive.Second, it is difficult to see how we would stand to benefit, jointly or individually, from presenting any particular perspective.Neither our reputation, nor our incomes, nor those of our employer, depend on taking a particular side in this debate.Indeed, given the current wave of interest in the private sector we might argue the opposite -that taking a more positive line on the private sector might attract greater income for our activities!The suggestion
Read more