- Research Article
- 10.63745/joger.2025.12.30.002
Evaluating the Impact of Ground Control Network Type on UAV Photogrammetric Accuracy: NTRIP, Radio RTK, and GCP-Free P4-RTK
- Dec 30, 2025
- Journal of Geomatics and Environmental Research
Accurate Digital Terrain Models (DTMs) are essential for precise mapping, hydrological analysis, and engineering design. This study evaluates the influence of three ground control network configurations—CORS-based NTRIP, Radio RTK, and GCP-free P4-RTK on UAV photogrammetric accuracy over a gully-prone terrain at the University of Benin, Nigeria. A DJI Phantom 4 RTK UAV was deployed to acquire identical flight data under each configuration, ensuring consistent flight altitude, overlap, and lighting conditions. Ground elevations were measured using a Tersus Oscar Ultimate GNSS receiver operating in both NTRIP and Radio modes to provide reference data for validation.The comparative analysis focused on Mean Error (ME), Root Mean Square Error (RMSE), Bias, Correlation, and one-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) to quantify differences in elevation accuracy across the three DTMs. Results show that both GNSS GCP-assisted DTMs, Radio RTK, and NTRIP achieved sub-5 cm vertical accuracy, with RMSE values of 0.043 m and 0.048 m, respectively, while the GCP-free P4-RTK DTM exhibited a consistent positive bias of +0.162 m and a weaker correlation (r = 0.962) with ground truth. The ANOVA test confirmed statistically significant differences (p < 0.05) between the GCP-free and CORS-based configurations, whereas no significant variation was observed between the Radio and NTRIP results. This study presents one of the first statistically validated comparisons of GNSS CORS-integration and GCPfree RTK UAV workflows in Nigeria. The findings demonstrate that GNSS-based differential corrections, whether transmitted via NTRIP or Radio link, ensure higher positional fidelity and stability in DTM generation. The results have practical implications for advancing the operational standards of UAV–CORS integration and supporting the national geospatial infrastructure through the SOGPOS CORS network.
Read more