Evaluation of Various Tone Mapping Operators for Backward Compatible JPEG Image Coding

A fixed-point tone mapping operation (TMO) instead of a floating-point TMO is proposed in this paper. A TMO generates a low dynamic range (LDR) image from a high dynamic range (HDR) image. Since pixel values of an HDR image are generally expressed in a floating-point data format, e.g. RGBE and OpenEXR, a TMO is also implemented in floating-point arithmetic in conventional approaches. However, it requires a huge computational cost, even though a resulting LDR image is expressed in simple integers. The proposed TMO is implemented with only fixed-point arithmetic. As a result, the proposed method reduces a computational cost. Experimental results shows the PSNR of LDR images in the proposed method are comparable to those of the conventional methods.

Tone-mapping-operators (TMOs) provide a useful means for converting high dynamic range (HDR) images to low dynamic range (LDR) images so that they can be viewed on standard displays, but this may influence the visual quality of experience (QoE) of the end-user. There is a need to understand the impact of TMOs to inform the choice of TMO algorithms for different displays, especially for small-screen-devices (SSDs) such as those used in mobile phones. This is important, as mobile devices are becoming the primary means of consuming multimedia contents. However, few studies have been undertaken to assess the impact of TMOs and viewing devices (especially SSDs) on the visual QoE of the user when using. In this chapter, we evaluate subjectively and objectively, the commonly used TMOs in different displays and resolutions for colour and grey-scale HDR images. Our results show that viewing devices have an influence on the TMOs performance, suggesting the need for a careful choice of TMO to enhance the viewing-QoE of the end-user. As expected, the higher resolution, the better HDR-image quality. Surprisingly, there was no significant difference between the Mean of Opinion Score (MOS) scores for colour and grey-scale images in SSDs. The device and TMOs affect QoE for colour and grey HDR-image equally. We found Shannon entropy (SE) to be a good objective measure of quality for colour and grey HDR images, suggesting that entropy may find use in automated HDR quality control assessment schemes, while; HDR-VDP-2 is a good objective measure for colour HDR image only.

High dynamic range (HDR) image generation had been studied for years. Due to the expense and rareness of HDR cameras, many works try to generate HDR images using several low dynamic range (LDR) images with different exposure conditions. To ensure high-quality HDR image generation, details of the scene should be retained in different LDR images and the exposure parameters of LDR image should be chosen carefully. In this paper, we propose a technique to dynamically determine the suitable exposure parameter for LDR images according to the property of each scene to be captured. Experimental results reveal that better HDR images are always generated with the LDR images captured by the determined exposure, compared to those created by the method with fixed exposures.

This paper presents a novel High Dynamic Range (HDR) tone mapping (TM) system based on sub-band architecture. Standard wavelet filters of Daubechies, Symlets, Coiflets and Biorthogonal were used to estimate the proposed system performance in terms of Low Dynamic Range (LDR) image quality and reconstructed HDR image fidelity. During TM stage, the HDR image is firstly decomposed in sub-bands using symmetrical analysis-synthesis filter bank. The transform coefficients are then rescaled using a predefined gain map. The inverse Tone Mapping (iTM) stage is straightforward. Indeed, the LDR image passes through the same sub-band architecture. But, instead of reducing the dynamic range, the LDR content is boosted to an HDR representation. Moreover, in our TM sheme, we included an optimization module to select the gain map components that minimize the reconstruction error, and consequently resulting in high fidelity HDR content. Comparisons with recent state-of-the-art methods have shown that our method provides better results in terms of visual quality and HDR reconstruction fidelity using objective and subjective evaluations.

This paper introduces region of interest (ROI) as a functionality to local tone mappings of high dynamic range (HDR) radiance maps. In the proposed scheme, a new quadratic regularization method is provided to decompose the luminance of an HDR radiance map into a base layer with large gradients and a detail layer with small gradients. An ROI based global tone mapping is designed to compress the base layer. Since the dynamic range of a display device is limited, more dynamic ranges are assigned to the base layer in the ROI such that the visual quality of the ROI is preserved better. The detail layer can be amplified to enhance local contrasts such that the output LDR images look sharper. Both automatic and interactive modes are provided. With our automatic mode, the generated low dynamic range (LDR) images look natural and local details are also preserved very well. In addition, a user friendly interactive mode is provided which is also able to produce dynamic LDR images in real time.

In this work, we proposed a novel depth adaptive tone mapping scheme for stereo HDR imaging and 3D display. We are interested in the case where different exposures are taken from different viewpoints. The scheme employed a new depth-adaptive cross-trilateral filter (DA-CTF) for recovering High Dynamic Range (HDR) images from multiple Low Dynamic Range (LDR) images captured at different exposure levels. Explicitly leveraging additional depth information in the tone mapping operation correctly identify global contrast change and detail visibility change by preserving the edges and reducing halo artifacts in the synthesized 3D views by depth-image-based rendering (DIBR) procedure. The experiments show that the proposed DA-CTF and DIBR scheme outperforms state-of-the-art operators in the enhanced depiction of tone mapped HDR stereo images on LDR displays.

This paper proposes a High Dynamic Range (HDR) image Tone Mapping (TM) approach converting HDR images into Low Dynamic Range (LDR) images so as the tone mapped HDR images ensure good visual quality on LDR display devices in accordance with the observers’ assessment. The proposed algorithm adjusts the logarithm luminance distribution of the HDR image according to a perceptual quantizer with respect to the Human Visual System (HVS) using a piecewise linear function. The parameters’s approximation are induced by L M -norms (l 1 , l 2 , l ∞ ) and the performance of the proposed algorithm is discussed. Simulation results provide good results, both in terms of visual quality and TMQI metric, compared to existing competitive TM approaches.

High dynamic range (HDR) images are becoming pervasive due to capturing or rendering of a wider range of luminance, but their special display equipment is difficult to be popularized because of high cost and technological problem. Thus, HDR images must be adapted to the conventional display devices by applying tone mapping (TM) operation, which puts forward higher requirements for intellectual property protection of HDR images. As the robustness presents regional diversity in the low dynamic range (LDR) watermarked image after TM, which is different from the traditional watermarking technologies, a concept of watermarking activity is defined and used to distinguish the essential distinction of watermarking between LDR image and HDR image in this paper. Then, a novel robust HDR image watermarking algorithm is proposed against TM operations. Firstly, based on the hybrid processing of redundant discrete wavelet transform and singular value decomposition, the watermark is embedded by modifying the structure information of the HDR image. Distinguished from LDR image watermarking, the high embedding strength can cause more obvious distortion in the high brightness regions of HDR image than the low brightness regions. Thus, a perceptual brightness mask with low complexity is designed to improve the imperceptibility further. Experimental results show that the proposed algorithm is robust to the existing TM operations, with taking into account the imperceptibility and embedded capacity, which is superior to the current state-of-art HDR image watermarking algorithms.

High dynamic range (HDR) images are highly desirable and widely applied in our daily life. However, most conventional digital cameras are only able to capture low dynamic range (LDR) images. To produce HDR images, a popular and effective method is to merge multiple LDR images with different exposure settings. To achieve high quality HDR images, determining the exposure settings when capturing the multiple LDR images is of great importance. Though many researchers have paid attention to the exposure determination issue for HDR imaging, most of them have focused on DSLR cameras and surveillance video cameras. Meanwhile, mobile devices nowadays have increasing use but few studies in literature focus on them. Since cameras of mobile devices have some features different from DSLR cameras and surveillance video cameras, many existing exposure determination methods may not be directly applied on them. To fill this research gap, this paper proposes a dynamic exposure determination method for HDR photography on mobile devices, in particular on iOS mobile devices. In the proposed method, three LDR images are captured on iOS devices, which are then merged to generate an HDR result image that can cover more details of the target scene. Considering the time and memory limits of mobile devices, the proposed method analyzes the histogram of the target scene thumbnail to determine the three exposure settings with suitable exposure gaps. Based on our proposed method, we have developed an iOS HDR Camera App. The experimental results demonstrate that the HDR result images of this App are capable to contain more details in both bright area and dark area than those of Apple's default HDR Camera App on iPhone 5s for real-world target scenes.

International audience

High dynamic range image tone mapping based on asymmetric model of retinal adaptation

In this paper, we propose a bit-depth scalable lossless coding method for high dynamic range (HDR) images based on a reversible logarithmic mapping. HDR images are generally expressed as floating-point data, such as in the OpenEXR or RGBE formats. Our bit-depth scalable coding approach outputs base layer data and enhancement layer data. It can reconstruct the low dynamic range (LDR) image from the base layer data and reconstructs the HDR image by adding the enhancement layer data. Most previous two-layer methods have focused on the lossy coding of HDR images. Unfortunately, the extension of previous lossy methods to lossless coding does not significantly compress the enhancement layer data. This is because the bit depth becomes very large, especially for HDR images in floating-point data format. To tackle this problem, we apply a reversible logarithmic mapping to the input HDR data. Moreover, we introduce a format conversion to avoid any degradation in the quality of the reconstructed LDR image. The proposed method is effective for both OpenEXR and RGBE formats. Through a series of experiments, we confirm that the proposed method decreases the volume of compressed data while maintaining the visual quality of the reconstructed LDR images.

Due to the growing popularity of High Dynamic Range (HDR) images and HDR displays, a large amount of existing Low Dynamic Range (LDR) images are required to be converted to HDR format to benefit HDR advantages, which give rise to some LDR to HDR algorithms. Most of these algorithms especially tackle overexposed areas during expanding, which is the potential to make the image quality worse than that before processing and introduces artifacts. To dispel these problems, we . present a new,LDR to HDR approach, unlike the existing techniques, it focuses on avoiding sophisticated treatment to overexposed areas in dynamic range expansion step. Based on a separating principle, firstly, according to the familiar types of overexposure, the overexposed areas are classified into two categories which are removed and corrected respectively by two kinds of techniques. Secondly, for maintaining color consistency, color recovery is carried out to the preprocessed images. Finally, the LDR image is expanded to HDR. Experiments show that the proposed approach performs well and produced images become more favorable and suitable for applications. The image quality metric also illustrates that we can reveal more details without causing artifacts introduced by other algorithms.

High dynamic range (HDR) images can only be backward-compatible with existing low dynamic range (LDR) imaging systems after being processed by tone-mapping operators. Hence, the quality assessment (QA) of tone-mapped HDR images has become an important and challenging issue in HDR imaging research. In this paper, we propose a naturalness index for a tone-mapped image to predict its quality. First, we extract the statistical features of the tone-mapped image's luminance value and use it to evaluate the brightness naturalness with no reference information. Meanwhile, we use perceptive color, image contrast, and detail information to represent the image content and predict their naturalness qualities, respectively. Then, the four components of the naturalness qualities are combined to yield the overall naturalness quality of the tone-mapped image. Experimental results on a publicly available database demonstrated that, in comparison with a traditional LDR image QA method and a leading tone-mapped image QA method, the proposed method has better performance in evaluating a tone-mapped image's quality.

Feature Point (FP) detection is a fundamental step in computer vision tasks. Although FP detectors are mostly designed to support Low Dynamic Range (LDR) images as input, interest in High Dynamic Range (HDR) images has increased recently due to their higher precision to register overexposed and underexposed areas in an image. As the detection of FPs is strongly dependent on the illumination of the scene, HDR images have the potential to be more robust than LDR images during FP detection. Known FP detectors, however, do not use the full potential of HDR images. In addition, few works have evaluated the performance of HDR images in this context. In this paper, we propose a modification of FP detectors aiming to improve FP detection on HDR images. To this end, we design a local mask based on the Coefficient of Variation (CV) of sets of pixels, creating thus a new step in FP detection. We compare our approach with popular FP detection methods using a standard evaluation metric, Repeatability Rate (RR) of FPs, and also Uniformity as a proposed new criterion. A dataset of images from scenes affected by camera transformations and substantial illumination changes was used as input. Experimental results show that our proposed algorithms give better Uniformity and RR in most HDR images from the dataset when compared to standard FP detectors. Moreover, they indicate that HDR images present a great potential to be explored in applications that rely on FP detection.