Exact methods for two vehicle routing problems with lockers in last-mile delivery

The last-mile delivery problem is one of the most complex and resource-intensive aspects of modern logistics, especially within the growing e-commerce sector. As online shopping continues to expand, companies are under immense pressure to deliver goods more quickly, efficiently, and at lower costs, all while meeting the demands of increasingly time-sensitive customers. This has created a need for innovative solutions that can tackle challenges related to dynamic traffic patterns, fluctuating customer preferences, and operational constraints such as vehicle capacities and delivery windows. In response to these challenges, this paper explores the application of predictive analytics as a tool for optimizing last-mile delivery routes in real-time.The study begins by identifying the core challenges inherent in last-mile logistics, particularly in the U.S. e-commerce landscape, where the cost of last-mile delivery can represent up to 53% of total shipping costs. With traffic congestion, unpredictable customer availability, and delivery time constraints posing significant hurdles, conventional static route planning models often fall short. In this paper, predictive analytics is proposed as a solution to these challenges, utilizing real-time data to inform more efficient routing decisions. By processing vast amounts of real-time traffic data, customer preferences, and delivery constraints, predictive models can offer a more flexible and responsive approach to last-mile delivery.The research then presents a comprehensive literature review of existing route optimization methods, such as the traditional Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) and its extensions, including VRP with Time Windows (VRPTW), Dynamic VRP (DVRP), and Capacitated VRP (CVRP). While these models have proven useful, their limitations are exposed when faced with real-time operational complexities in the e-commerce sector. Therefore, this study introduces an advanced dynamic routing model that integrates machine learning algorithms—such as decision trees and neural networks—with traditional VRP frameworks. These machine learning models, trained on historical data, are capable of predicting future traffic patterns, customer behavior, and delivery time windows.A case study is conducted using data from U.S.-based e-commerce companies to demonstrate the practical application of predictive analytics in optimizing last-mile delivery. The case study outlines how predictive models are used to dynamically adjust delivery routes based on real-time conditions, leading to significant improvements in efficiency, cost savings, and customer satisfaction. Key performance indicators such as delivery times, fuel consumption, and vehicle utilization are examined before and after the implementation of the predictive models, with the results showing a reduction in delivery time by 20% and fuel costs by 15%, alongside improved on-time delivery rates.The paper concludes by presenting the proposed dynamic route optimization model as a solution that combines the flexibility and responsiveness of predictive analytics with the robust framework of traditional VRP models. Through the integration of machine learning, real-time data processing, and dynamic routing, the model is shown to significantly improve last-mile delivery efficiency. This study's findings highlight the potential for predictive analytics to revolutionize the logistics industry, particularly in the high-demand e-commerce sector, where quick and reliable delivery is paramount. The research suggests that as e-commerce continues to grow, predictive analytics will play an increasingly critical role in ensuring that last-mile delivery is both cost-effective and responsive to the evolving needs of consumers.

Last-mile delivery service providers and drivers often choose routes deviating from the shortest distance, influenced by personal preferences and various business-level factors. This study introduces an innovative data-driven optimization approach for learning preferences of decision-makers (DMs) in multi-objective vehicle routing problems. Utilizing real-world historical data from a last-mile delivery logistics platform, we develop a machine-learning framework to learn DMs’ preferences in designing delivery routes. To design our approach we focus on a multi-objective capacitated vehicle routing problem with time windows and develop an integrated framework that combines supervised learning models, sampling techniques, and optimization methods to determine preference weights for objective functions based on selected features. We conduct extensive numerical experiments to test the proposed data-driven optimization approach. Our findings suggest that analyzing historical planned and actual routes reveals DMs’ preferences, such as prioritizing workload balance and minimizing fleet usage over travel distance alone. Furthermore, this study offers insights into key factors shaping last-mile delivery logistics, including workload distribution and deviations from pre-planned routes, enabling more informed and human-centered decision-making in logistics optimization. • Learning decision-makers’ preferences in multi-objective vehicle routing optimization. • Combines machine learning with ALNS for scalable, efficient routing solutions. • Validated using 800+ real-world scenarios from a commercial logistics platform. • Demonstrates improved workload balance and fleet utilization.

This paper proposes an efficient algorithm, with a reduced number of parameters, for solving the two‐dimensional loading‐capacitated vehicle routing problem (2L‐CVRP). This problem combines two of the most important issues in logistics, that is, vehicle routing and packing problems. Our approach contemplates unrestricted loading including the possibility of applying 90° rotations to each rectangular‐shaped item while loading it into the vehicle, which is a realistic assumption seldom considered in the existing literature. The algorithm uses a multistart approach that is designed to avoid local minima and also to make the algorithm an easily parallelizable one. At each restart, a biased randomization of a savings‐based routing algorithm is combined with an enhanced version of a classical packing heuristic to produce feasible good solutions for the 2L‐CVRP. The proposed algorithm has been compared with the classical benchmarks for two different 2L‐CVRP variants, that is, with and without item rotations. Experimental results show that our approach outperforms several best‐known solutions from previous work, both in terms of quality and the computational time needed to obtain them.

Traditional vehicle routing problems implicitly assume that only one crew operates a vehicle for the entirety of its journey. However, this assumption is violated in many applications arising in humanitarian and military logistics. This paper considers a joint vehicle and crew routing and scheduling problem in which crews are able to interchange vehicles, resulting in space and time interdependencies between vehicle routes and crew routes. The problem is formulated as a mixed integer programming (MIP) model and a constraint programming (CP) model that overlay crew routing constraints over a standard vehicle routing problem. The constraint program uses a novel optimization constraint to detect infeasibility and to bound crew objectives. This paper also explores methods using large neighborhood search over the MIP and CP models. Experimental results indicate that modeling the vehicle and crew routing problems jointly and supporting vehicle interchanges for crews may bring significant benefits in cost reduction compared with a method that sequentializes these decisions.

This paper presents an overview of recent advances in the field of the vehicle routing problem (VRP), based on papers published in high-quality journals during the period from January 2015 to July 2017. A distinctive feature of the presented survey is its focus on new versions of the VRP, which have recently emerged or gained momentum, and the corresponding new solution methods, with particular emphasis on computational intelligence (CI) approaches. The list of newly proposed or currently popular VRP formulations include last mile and same day delivery, crowdshipping, bike sharing systems, post-disaster response plans, local routing in large production or cargo plants, customer-centric VRP, autonomous delivery, unnamed aerial vehicle delivery, green VRP, waste collection VRP, rich VRP, or VRP with backhauls. Simultaneously, an adequate increase of interest in the application of traditional CI methods (e.g., genetic, memetic, ant colony or particle swarm optimization, simulated annealing, or their various hybrid versions) can be observed in the VRP domain. At the same time, approaches proven efficient in other optimization areas (e.g., hyperheuristics, methods based on Monte Carlo simulations, algorithms rooted in game theory and bi-level optimization-Stackelberg games, or cognitively motivated methods) have lately entered the VRP field and become a viable alternative to more traditional techniques. Since VRP is one of the fastest growing fields in the operations research area, we believe that an analysis of the recently published VRP papers from the perspective of their novelty in problem formulation and/or applied solution method can provide a true value for the CI community, especially young researchers entering the field and seeking challenges in this interesting and fast developing research area.

New forms of transport, such as autonomous delivery robots (ADRs), have attracted considerable attention in recent years for their potential use as green last-mile delivery alternatives because of their flexibility in some areas unreachable by van. However, their low efficiency, delivering a limited number of orders each trip, limits their application in the last mile. Also, the cost and emission impact of new forms of transport on the last-mile delivery network is still not clear. To address these issues, we developed a new two-echelon delivery system that combines traditional vans and ADRs, making use of their individual advantages to overcome their drawbacks and enhance efficiency in the deliveries. The objective of this study was to develop a new approach based on a metaheuristics methodology to minimize transport and emission costs through modeling and to solve the extension of two-echelon load-dependent vehicle routing problems with mixed vehicles (2E-LDVRP-MV). The complicated 2E-LDVRP-MV problem was formulated as a mixed-integer programming (MIP) model and solved efficiently with a cluster-based artificial immune algorithm (C-AIA) in which clustering was employed to allocate customers. We performed a set of numerical experiments with a solver and the proposed C-AIA heuristics. C-AIS highlights the operational implications of four parameters: ratios between load and the empty vehicle weight; vehicle types; emission levels; and customer densities. Our results provide a unique perspective on tactical planning for a sustainable urban logistics system, and this new two-echelon system could be applied in e-grocery last-mile delivery networks where vans and ADRs are combined.

The Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) is a well-known NP-hard combinatorial optimization problem, which has wide spread applications in real world, such as logistics, bus route planning, and urban path planning. To solve VRP, traditional optimization methods usually start the search from scratch and ignore the VRPs solved in the past, which could lead to repeated explorations of the search space of related problems, and thus results in slow optimization process involving unnecessary computational cost. Keeping this in mind, to speed up the optimization for vehicle routing, this article presents a new study towards faster vehicle routing by transferring knowledge from customer representations which are learned from past solved VRPs. In particular, we propose to capture the useful traits buried in previous optimized routing solutions by learning a new customer representation, which can be transferred across VRPs, serving as the prior knowledge, to bias the optimization in the target VRP. In contrast to existing approaches, the proposed knowledge transfer is consist of a learning of new customer representation based on the optimized routing solution, which is general to VRPs possessing different structural properties, and a weighted <inline-formula xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"> <tex-math notation="LaTeX">$l_{1}$ </tex-math></inline-formula> norm-regularized formulation for building sparse mapping across VRPs, that is easy to solve. Further, the proposed knowledge transfer across VRPs occurs along the whole optimization search process, and is thus able to guide the routing optimization process consistently. To verify the efficacy of the proposed method, by using population-based optimization method as the VRP solver, comprehensive empirical studies on both commonly used VRP benchmarks and real world vehicle routing application are presented.

Vehicle routing problems (VRPs) are a fundamental class of combinatorial optimization problems (COPs) in computer science and operations research, with diverse real-world applications in logistics, transportation, and manufacturing. The intrinsic NP-hard nature makes VRPs exponentially expensive to be solved by exact solvers. As an alternative, heuristic solvers deliver suboptimal solutions within reasonable time but require extensive hand-crafted rules and domain expertise tailored to each specific problem. Recently, neural combinatorial optimization (NCO), which leverages machine learning to learn heuristics in a data-driven manner, has gained significant attention. These neural solvers demonstrate strong performance while reducing computational overhead and reliance on domain expertise compared to traditional solvers. However, they face significant generalization challenges. For example, their performance may degrade substantially when applied to instances with different data distributions, problem scales, or constraints than those encountered during training. This generalization issue severely limits their practical applicability. This thesis aims to systematically address these challenges and advance the development of generalizable neural solvers for VRPs. The thesis begins by enhancing the cross-distribution generalization of neural VRP solvers through an adversarial training approach. We introduce an ensemble-based Collaborative Neural Framework (CNF) that adversarially trains multiple models in a collaborative manner, promoting robustness against adversarial attacks while also boosting performance on clean instances. In this framework, an attacker generates hard instances by perturbing the data distribution, challenging the models to adapt and thereby strengthening cross-distribution generalization. Additionally, a neural router is designed to efficiently distribute training instances among the models, thereby improving load balancing and collaborative efficacy. Extensive experiments on two classic routing problems -- the travelling salesman problem (TSP) and the capacitated vehicle routing problem (CVRP) -- demonstrate the effectiveness and versatility of CNF in enhancing the cross-distribution generalization. Next, the thesis further expands neural solvers to simultaneously address both cross-size and cross-distribution generalization challenges. We propose Omni-VRP, a generic meta-learning framework that enables effective training of an initial model with the capacity for rapid adaptation to new tasks during inference, where each task corresponds to a set of instances with the same problem scale and data distribution. Additionally, we introduce a simple yet efficient approximation method to reduce the training overhead associated with second-order derivative calculations. Extensive experiments on both synthetic and benchmark instances of TSP and CVRP validate the effectiveness of our approach. Finally, the thesis pioneers the study of cross-problem generalization, pushing the boundaries of neural VRP solvers in learning generalizable representations across diverse constraints. We propose MVMoE, a unified neural solver capable of solving 16 VRP variants simultaneously in a zero-shot manner through attribute composition. To efficiently enhance model capacity, we employ a mixture-of-experts architecture with a hierarchical gating mechanism, striking a balance between empirical performance and computational complexity. Experimentally, our method significantly promotes zero-shot generalization on 10 unseen VRP variants, and showcases decent results on the few-shot setting and real-world benchmark instances. Overall, this thesis represents a pioneering exploration and substantial advancement in developing generalizable neural solvers for VRPs. It investigates innovative designs across various components, including model architectures, training algorithms, and problem settings, to enhance the generalization of neural solvers across diverse contexts such as varying data distributions, problem scales, and constraints. These contributions encourage neural solvers to learn more robust and generalizable representations, paving the way for the first generation of foundation models capable of addressing a wide range of COPs. Ultimately, the insights gained here not only propel the field of NCO forward but also enrich the broader landscape of learning-based optimization methods.

The Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) is a well-known combinatorial optimization problem where a number of customers must be served with a fleet of vehicles. The classical variation of the VRP is the Capacicated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP) with the additional constraint that each vehicle must have uniform capacity. Many Decision Support Systems (DSS) have been implemented to solve real life problems of the VRP and its’ variants, but they do not allow multiple decision makers to explore several scenarios of a given problem simultaneously and collaborate with each other in order to find the best possible solution. In this paper, we extend our previous work [35] and incorporate in our spatial DSS four variants of the CVRP: (i) Distance Constrained Vehicle Routing Problem (DVRP), (ii) Vehicle Routing Problem with Time Windows (VRPTW), (iii) Vehicle Routing Problem with Backhauls (VRPB), and (iv) Vehicle Routing Problem With Pickup and Delivery (VRPPD). This extension allows decision makers to solve specific routing problems according to their needs. The proposed collaborative spatial DSS allows two decision makers to collaborate with each other in order to find the best possible solution through a tangible interface. The locations are added through interactive Google Maps and other parameters through user-friendly forms that can be manipulated via tangible interfaces. The proposed DSS has been implemented using Java, TUIO protocol, jsprit, and Google Maps.

Nowadays genetic algorithms stand as a trend to solve NP-complete and NP-hard problems. In this paper, we present a new hybrid metaheuristic which combines Genetic Algorithms and Scatter Search coupled with a decomposition-into-petals procedure for solving a class of Vehicle Routing and Scheduling Problems. Its performance is evaluated for a heterogeneous fleet model, which is considered a problem much harder to solve than the homogeneous vehicle routing problem.

SYNOPTIC ABSTRACTBranch exchange techniques, such as the well-known 2-opt and 3-opt procedures, are among the most powerful heuristics available for the solution of the classic vehicle routing problem. The imposition of time window constraints on customer delivery time within the vehicle routing problem, however, introduces several complexities that can reduce the power of these techniques. In this paper, two test data sets for the vehicle routing and scheduling problem with time window constraints are studied. Initial solutions are obtained using a variety of heuristics. These solutions are then improved using branch exchange procedures modified to incorporate the time window constraints.

In this paper, we study a two-dimensional vehicle loading and routing problem in which customer orders with deadlines become available for dispatch as per their release dates. The objective is to minimize the sum of transportation, inventory, and tardiness costs while respecting various loading and routing constraints. This scenario allows us to study various tradeoffs that tend to arise due to temporal order aggregation across release dates. We thereby propose an integrated mathematical formulation to simultaneously model both the routing and loading requirements of the problem at hand. Specifically, as the problem is NP-hard, we propose a scatter search-based heuristic approach to solve large-size instances. Further, its performance is enhanced using problem-specific procedures and strategic oscillation approaches. Additionally, the numerical experiments illustrate the influence of cost structures on both the optimal loading configurations along with the optimal routes. Importantly, our experiments also suggest that the proposed scatter search method can produce good-quality solutions in less time.

Metaheuristics with variable diversity control and neighborhood search for the Heterogeneous Site-Dependent Multi-depot Multi-trip Periodic Vehicle Routing Problem

The vehicle routing problem (VRP), as a classic combinatorial optimization problem, has always been a hot research topic in operations research. In order to gain a deeper understanding of the VRP problem, this work uses the knowledge graph to comprehensively analyze and summarize the literature related to VRP from 1959 to 2022 in the Web of Science (WoS) database. Firstly, according to the basic statistical information of the literature, the annual publications, the authors, their institutions and countries, the keyword co-occurrence, and the literature co-citation network are analyzed to comprehensively summarize and generalize the research on VRP and predict its future development trend. The results show that, in the past 60 years, there have been abundant changes in the research on VRP. The United States and China have made the most important contributions in the field of VRP. According to the WoS literature retrieval results and classification methods, the VRP models and their solutions are comprehensively classified, and the model solving algorithms are divided into exact algorithms, heuristic algorithms, metaheuristic algorithms, hyper-heuristic algorithms, machine learning, etc. The results show that the development of information computing technology plays an important role in research on the VRP problem, and dynamic VRP, hyper-heuristic algorithms, deep reinforcement learning, etc. are the future development directions of the VRP model and its optimization. The results of this research can provide help and guidance for beginners and scholars outside the industry to comprehensively understand the development and research hotspots of VRP.

Routing and charging of electric vehicles: Literature review