• Home
  • Search
  • From fairytale to clinical practice: A response to commentaries
  • https://doi.org/10.1111/add.70206Copy DOI Icon

From fairytale to clinical practice: A response to commentaries

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

Evidence gaps in synthetic opioid overdose management require urgent research through observational studies, experimental investigations and clinical trials. Three priorities emerge: comprehensive naloxone training that emphasizes basic first aid, improved products ensuring accurate dose titration and simple teachable principles for lay responders to implement graded naloxone administration safely. We thank our colleagues for their responses to our article [1] in which we proposed a more nuanced approach to the emergency management of opioid overdose. We are pleased that it has generated thoughtful discussion and debate. Wong et al. [2] raise the valid concern that evidence on responding to potent synthetic opioids is lacking, concluding that ‘the risk of inadequate reversal […] often outweighs the potential harms of over-antagonism.’ We agree that there is a pressing need for improved evidence on responses to synthetic opioid overdose to inform real-world, evidence-based practice. There is an urgent need for clinical trials, observational studies and emergency medical services data analysis involving these drugs. Coffin [3] supports our core argument for integrating tailored dosing strategies into overdose management protocols. We agree that over-reliance on naloxone risks delaying other critical interventions, such as respiratory and cardiovascular support. Coffin also highlights the importance of timing, noting that fentanyl-related mortality may reflect not only its potency, but also the rapid onset of its effects compared with heroin. Similarly, Morgan and Walley [4] emphasize the importance of timely intervention and how dose selection is secondary to a more fundamental issue—whether a bystander is present and able to respond, particularly given that witnesses may not be present. On this basis, not consuming drugs alone should be a core in harm reduction strategies. Our research group is one of a number around the world developing real-time overdose detection interventions to enable the earliest possible response [5]. We believe that there are three practical aspects that deserve emphasis. First, naloxone training in the community must include recognizing symptoms, basic first aid including airway and rescue breathing and alerting medical services before naloxone administration. Second, we need improved naloxone products that allow dose titration in community settings. Products designed to ensure individual incremental dosing could help bridge the gap between clinical and community environments. Recent pharmacokinetic studies have demonstrated significant inter-individual variability in naloxone absorption, supporting the need for flexible dosing approaches [6, 7]. The development of naloxone formulations that permit stepwise administration could address both efficacy and safety concerns in community settings. Third, we should develop simple, teachable principles of dose titration for lay responders. Rather than complex protocols, basic training could focus on the initial assessment and then starting conservatively if the patient is not in extremis/still breathing, monitoring respiratory response, and understanding when additional doses are warranted. Evidence from emergency medical services suggests that trained responders can successfully implement graded naloxone administration, and similar principles could be adapted for community use [8, 9]. The evidence gaps identified by all commentators underscore the need for research that addresses real-world application challenges. The design and conduct of randomized controlled trials during active overdose events is ethically challenging although several research groups have successfully conducted such trials [10-15], and valuable conclusions can also be reached from observational studies, emergency medical services data analysis and carefully designed simulation studies to build the evidence base for optimal dosing strategies. Human laboratory studies of controlled opioid intoxication and reversal will also be important [16]. Recent analyses of naloxone distribution programmes have provided valuable insights into usage patterns and outcomes that can inform future product development [17]. The diversity of perspectives in these commentaries reflects the genuine complexity of optimizing overdose response in the synthetic opioid era. We believe this complexity justifies continued exploration of a range evidence-based approaches that can be practically implemented across the range of settings where overdose response occurs. The shared goal remains clear: saving lives through effective, compassionate intervention that minimizes both fatal outcomes and iatrogenic harm. None.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article

The Role of Emergency Medical Services in Addressing Opioid Use Disorder – A Position Statement and Resource Document of NAEMSP

  • May 07, 2026
  • Prehospital Emergency Care
  • Melody J Glenn +10
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Compression-Only CPR

  • Oct 06, 2010
  • JAMA
  • David C Cone
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Board 339 - Research Abstract Patient Simulation for Assessment and Reinforcement of Layperson Management of Opioid Overdose with Intranasal Naloxone in a Recently Released Prison Inmate Cohort (Submission #66)

  • Dec 01, 2013
  • Simulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare
  • Traci Green +5
  • Research Article
  • Citations83

The impact of take-home naloxone distribution and training on opiate overdose knowledge and response: An evaluation of the THN Project in Wales

  • Apr 30, 2012
  • Drugs: Education, Prevention and Policy
  • Trevor Bennett +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations324

Part 6: Electrical Therapies

  • Oct 17, 2010
  • Circulation
  • Mark S Link +9
  • Research Article

Efficacy of intranasal naloxone compared to other administration routes in prehospital opioid overdose management and beyond: a narrative review

  • Jan 22, 2025
  • Emergency Care Journal
  • Luigi Venuso +6
  • Research Article

Search strategy and review methods

  • Jan 01, 2026
  • Open Science Framework
  • Roman Sýkora
  • Research Article
  • Citations71

If it hasn’t failed, does it work? On ‘the worst we can expect’ from observational trial results, with reference to airway management devices

  • May 07, 2012
  • Anaesthesia
  • J J Pandit
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations9

‘It’s the same thing as giving them CPR training’: rural first responders’ perspectives on naloxone

  • Oct 03, 2022
  • Harm reduction journal
  • Matthew R Filteau +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations11

Real-world study of multiple naloxone administrations for opioid overdose reversal among emergency medical service providers

  • Jan 01, 2022
  • Substance Abuse
  • Randa Abdelal +7
  • Research Article

P010: A systematic review of the association between emergency medical services (EMS) time factors and survival

  • May 01, 2018
  • CJEM
  • I Blanchard +10
  • Research Article
  • Citations122

Opioid-Associated Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest: Distinctive Clinical Features and Implications for Health Care and Public Responses: A Scientific Statement From the American Heart Association.

  • Mar 08, 2021
  • Circulation
  • Cameron Dezfulian +11
  • Research Article
  • Citations11

Chest Compression Rate

  • May 23, 2012
  • Circulation
  • Jerry P Nolan +2
  • Front Matter
  • Citations10

Extracorporeal Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation: Prehospital or In-Hospital Cannulation?

  • Jan 20, 2023
  • Journal of Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia
  • Tommaso Scquizzato +2
  • Research Article

Naloxone Use, Carrying Practices, Prior Training, and Confidence in Overdose Response Among Attendees of a 4-Day Music Festival in Colorado.

  • Dec 23, 2025
  • Journal of addiction medicine
  • Cianna J Piercey +2
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.