- Research Article
46
- 10.3382/ps.0561457
Sources of Error in Egg Specific Gravity Measurements by the Flotation Method
- Sep 01, 1977
- Poultry Science
- Peter W Voisey
Sources of Error in Egg Specific Gravity Measurements by the Flotation Method
Nutritional epidemiology is the assessment of diet and its relationship to disease aetiology in populations. The choice of dietary assessment method depends on the disease pathology. Events such as cancer that are chronic and complicated by exposure time require methods that capture consumption patterns of populations over a period of years. Although several methods of dietary assessment exist for collecting information on groups of individuals, their application to epidemiologic studies requires an understanding of the effect of variability in nutrient intake, sources of measurement error, and statistical issues unique to the study of nutritional epidemiology. This review provides an overview of commonly-used methods of dietary assessments in epidemiologic studies, and identifies their strengths and limitations and application to epidemiologic study designs. It concludes with a brief discussion of assumptions of nutrient databases and objectives of energy-adjustment and measurement error correction models. Nutritional epidemiology has contributed significantly to our understanding of the relationships between diet and disease. Ongoing investigations that further characterize important exposure periods (early life, in utero) and clarify associations within the context of genetic susceptibility will continue to elucidate our understanding of the pathophysiology of complex diseases, and support future recommendations for disease prevention.
Sources of Error in Egg Specific Gravity Measurements by the Flotation Method
Sources of Error in Egg Specific Gravity Measurements by the Flotation Method
What did you Really Earn Last Year?: Explaining Measurement Error in Survey Income Data
SummaryThe paper analyses the sources of income measurement error in surveys with a unique data set. We use the Austrian 2008–2011 waves of the European Union ‘Statistics on income and living conditions’ survey which provide individual information on wages, pensions and unemployment benefits from survey interviews and officially linked administrative records. Thus, we do not have to fall back on complex two-sample matching procedures like related studies. We empirically investigate four sources of measurement error, namely social desirability, sociodemographic characteristics of the respondent, the survey design and the presence of learning effects. We find strong evidence for a social desirability bias in income reporting, whereas the presence of learning effects is mixed and depends on the type of income under consideration. An Owen value decomposition reveals that social desirability is a major explanation of misreporting in wages and pensions, whereas sociodemographic characteristics are most relevant for mismatches in unemployment benefits.
Read moreComputing levels of nutrient inadequacy from household consumption and expenditure surveys: A case study
This paper presents an approach to estimate the between-subject variability in nutrient intake (through the coefficient of variation [CV]) and a method to estimate the prevalence of nutrient inadequacy (PoNI) (for eight micronutrients) using household consumption and expenditure survey (HCES) data. Prevalence values are compared to individual-level estimates derived using the National-Cancer-Institute method. Data come from the 2015 Bangladesh Integrated-Household-Survey, which conducted a household-level 7-day recall (7DR) and two rounds of individual-level 24-hour recall (24HR), filled by one respondent on behalf of all members, for the same rural households. The PoNI values based on 7DR are lower than those calculated from 24HR data, due to the larger average intake estimates from 7DR data. After controlling for differences in average intake estimates and adjusting household-level data for random measurement errors, the PoNI values from 7DR and 24HR data are remarkably close. This highlights the potential use of HCES data (conducted according to international agreed standards) for estimating the level of between-subject variability in usual nutrient intake in a population. The CVs from HCES could be used to compute the PoNI using average intake estimates from individual-level data; and the inadequacy of global nutrient supply using Supply and Utilization Accounts data.
Read moreSources of Measurement Error in Noninvasive Electronic Instrumentation
Sources of Measurement Error in Noninvasive Electronic Instrumentation
MEASUREMENT ERROR IN RESEARCH ON HUMAN RESOURCES and FIRM PERFORMANCE: HOW MUCH ERROR IS THERE AND HOW DOES IT INFLUENCE EFFECT SIZE ESTIMATES?
Studies of the relationship between human resource (HR) practices and firm performance typically use a single respondent to assess firm level HR practices or HR effectiveness. However, previous research in other substantive areas suggests that rater differences are a potentially important source of measurement error. We demonstrate analytically the potential consequences of both random and systematic measurement error in research on HR and firm performance. However, our main focus is on random error and we show how generalizability theory can be applied to obtain better estimates of reliability by simultaneously recognizing multiple sources (e.g., items, raters) of random measurement error. These more inclusive reliability estimates, in turn, offer the possibility of more precisely quantifying substantive relationships in the HR and firm performance literature. In our sample, reliabilities (as estimated by generalizability coefficients) for single‐rater assessments of HR variables were generally below .50. This degree of measurement error, if present in substantive studies on HR and firm performance, could lead to considerable bias, given that an unstandardized regression coefficient is corrected for measurement error in the independent variable by dividing by its reliability coefficient (not its square root). We also found only limited convergent validity between HR and line managers ratings of a second type of HR measure, HR effectiveness. In general, our findings suggest that future researchers need to devote greater attention to measurement error and construct validity issues. Our study provides an example of how generalizability theory can be useful in this pursuit.
Read moreEvaluation of magnetic materials for very high frequency power applications
This paper investigates the loss characteristics of several commercial rf magnetic materials forpower conversion applications in the 10 MHz to 100 MHz range. A measurement method is proposed that provides a direct measurement of inductor quality factor QL as a function of inductor current at rf frequencies, and enables indirect calculation of core loss as a function of flux density. Possible sources of error in measurement and calculation are evaluated and addressed. The proposed method is used to identify loss characteristics of different commercial rf magnetic core materials. The loss characteristics of these materials, which have not previously been available, are illustrated and compared in tables and figures. The results of this paper are thus useful for design of magnetic components for very high frequency applications.
Read moreLong-term evaluation of bone mass in free fibula flap mandible reconstruction
Long-term evaluation of bone mass in free fibula flap mandible reconstruction
A γ-ray tomographic scanner for imaging voidage distribution in two-phase flow systems
A γ-ray tomographic scanner for imaging voidage distribution in two-phase flow systems
A Microcomputer-Based System for Area Measurement
An electronic system developed for area measurement is described. A standard X-Y recorder specially adopted with a light pen was made to scan the area under test and give a TTL logic signal that changes state whenever the area circumference is crossed. From such information the microcomputer is programmed to calculate the area using Simpson's rule and display the result on a seven-segment display. Sources of error in measurement and its nature are investigated. Modifications in the basic system to reduce the error are included. The designed system can also be used for determining the perimeter and locating the centroid of an object.
Read moreStructured Measurement Error in Nutritional Epidemiology
Preterm birth, defined as delivery before 37 completed weeks' gestation, is a leading cause of infant morbidity and mortality. Identifying factors related to preterm delivery is an important goal of public health professionals who wish to identify etiologic pathways to target for prevention. Validation studies are often conducted in nutritional epidemiology in order to study measurement error in instruments that are generally less invasive or less expensive than “gold standard” instruments. Data from such studies are then used in adjusting estimates based on the full study sample. However, measurement error in nutritional epidemiology has recently been shown to be complicated by correlated error structures in the study-wide and validation instruments. Investigators of a study of preterm birth and dietary intake designed a validation study to assess measurement error in a food frequency questionnaire (FFQ) administered during pregnancy and with the secondary goal of assessing whether a single administration of the FFQ could be used to describe intake over the relatively short pregnancy period, in which energy intake typically increases. Here, we describe a likelihood-based method via Markov chain Monte Carlo to estimate the regression coefficients in a generalized linear model relating preterm birth to covariates, where one of the covariates is measured with error and the multivariate measurement error model has correlated errors among contemporaneous instruments (i.e., FFQs, 24-hour recalls, and biomarkers). Because of constraints on the covariance parameters in our likelihood, identifiability for all the variance and covariance parameters is not guaranteed, and, therefore, we derive the necessary and sufficient conditions to identify the variance and covariance parameters under our measurement error model and assumptions. We investigate the sensitivity of our likelihood-based model to distributional assumptions placed on the true folate intake by employing semiparametric Bayesian methods through the mixture of Dirichlet process priors framework. We exemplify our methods in a recent prospective cohort study of risk factors for preterm birth. We use long-term folate as our error-prone predictor of interest, the FFQ and 24-hour recall as two biased instruments, and the serum folate biomarker as the unbiased instrument. We found that folate intake, as measured by the FFQ, led to a conservative estimate of the estimated odds ratio of preterm birth (.76) when compared to the odds ratio estimate from our likelihood-based approach, which adjusts for the measurement error (.63). We found that our parametric model led to similar conclusions to the semiparametric Bayesian model.
Read moreNutritional Epidemiology
This book is about the complex relationships between diet and risks of important diseases, such as cancer and cardiovascular disease. The book starts with an overview of research strategies in nutritional epidemiology—still a relatively new discipline that combines the vast knowledge compiled by nutritionists during this century with the methodologies developed by epidemiologists to study the determinants of diseases with multiple etiologies and long latent periods. A major section is devoted to the methods of dietary assessment using data on food intake, biochemical indicators of diet, and measures of body composition and size. The reproducibility and validity of each approach and the implications of measurement error are considered in detail. The analysis, presentation, and interpretation of data from epidemiologic studies of diet and disease are explored in depth. Particular attention is paid to the important influence of total energy intake on findings in such studies. To illustrate methodological issues in nutritional epidemiology, the relationships of dietary factors to the incidence of lung and breast cancer, heart disease, and birth defects are examined in depth. This new edition, in addition to updating existing chapters, includes new chapters on assessment of physical activity, nutrition, and genetic epidemic ology, and the role of nutritional epidemiology in policy.
Read moreRevisiting citizen preferences for who should govern and how. the case of cross-national surveys
A growing body of literature suggests that many citizens reject representative politics and demand instead that people or unelected experts direct governmental decision-making. This study contributes to this literature by highlighting how undetected response biases and other sources of measurement error have misled previous inquiries about patterns of support for political processes. Using recent cross-national surveys with innovative measurement proposals, the article finds that theorized dimensions of the political process represent citizens’ views consistently across citizen backgrounds only when measurement errors are corrected. This technical adjustment has substantive theoretical and empirical implications for further explanatory analyses. First, it shows when indicators measuring the political process are comparable across citizens’ groups, sharing understandings about and abilities to identify the dimensions of the political process with low response bias. Second, it finds that uncontrolled measurement errors obscure analyses of who supports political processes. Several patterns in explaining citizens’ preferences turn statistically non-significant, and new predictors emerge –mostly associated with citizens’ conservatism and resource mobilization theory. The findings offer new insights and methodological suggestions for future comparative research on citizens’ preferences for who should govern and how.
Read moreModeling of emission measurement error due to uneven distribution of particulate matter in stacks
Legislative requirements for emission limits from industrial processes are becoming increasingly stringent and therefore a lower uncertainty of measurement of emissions released to the atmosphere is needed and possible sources of measurement errors need to be reconsidered. In this paper, we investigate a measurement error of industrial emissions of particulate matter from stacks caused by the selection of sampling positions in stacks with uneven particle distribution and we determine its dependence on different flow fields inside the stacks and on the size of the particles. CFD modeling is used to analyze particle distributions in stacks with a diameter of 0.75m and with three different shapes of a supply pipe (straight, one or two bends) generating different flow fields, considering sizes of the particles from 10μm to 50μm (Stokes numbers from 0.007 to 0.18). Concentration fields in several cross-sections are compared and significant changes of the particle distribution are observed when the shape of the supply pipe or the emission particle diameter are changed. The error of the emission mass flow rate as it would be determined according to the EN 15259 standard can reach about 30% for particle diameters of 20μm. Larger particles and the presence of bends lead to stronger particle clustering and near-wall accumulation which tend to increase the error. This should be taken into account in the iso-kinetic sampling practice. Implications: This study highlights the significant impact of particulate matter distribution on the accuracy of emission measurements in industrial stacks. The findings demonstrate that uneven particle distribution, particularly in setups with bends causing stronger particle clustering and near-wall accumulation, can introduce measurement errors of up to 50% depending on flow conditions. These results suggest that current standard sampling methods (e.g., EN 15259) may not always provide accurate emission mass flow rate estimations, especially for larger particles. The study underscores the need for improved sampling strategies or mixing devices to ensure reliable regulatory compliance in emission monitoring.
Read moreWhat do we know about fatigue?
Fatigue is experienced by patients inmany phases of cancer— at presentation, with chemotherapy, with radiation therapy, after surgery, in survivors, and in advanced cancer. The universality of fatigue as a symptom and its effects on the quality of life in patients with advanced cancer [Lundh Hagelin C, Seiger A, Furst CJ, Quality of life in terminal care—with special reference to age, gender, and marital status, Support Care Cancer 14:320–8, 2006] makes it important, but fatigue has been a very difficult symptom to define and study. One approach to understanding fatigue has been to characterize the epidemiology of fatigue and other symptoms. Many studies in different groups of cancer patients have shown statistically significant correlations between fatigue and other symptoms. This approach has been advanced by the current paper by Yennurajalingam et al. [Yennurajalingam S, Palmer JL, Zhang T, Poulter V, Bruera E, Association between fatigue and other cancer-related symptoms in patients with advanced cancer, Supp Care Cancer, 2008]. They analyzed cancer patients who had enrolled for clinical trials for fatigue, who were rigorously evaluated for other possible causes of fatigue, and assessed for fatigue and symptom covariates obtained with widely accepted instruments, the Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale and the FACIT Fatigue subscale. Such a relatively uniform and carefully selected group should make it easier to detect associations. On the other hand, findings from a research population may not always be generalizable to the overall population. Yennurajalingam et al. confirmed many of the associations between symptoms by using stepwise linear regression models in an adequately powered population, with the FACIT F fatigue subscale score as the dependent variable. Anxiety, drowsiness, anorexia, and well being were correlated with fatigue, but interestingly, depression, dyspnea, and insomnia were not present in the final model. One finding from this approach was that the R for their model was 0.21, which the authors suggest accounts for a small amount of the variance. This small R2 may not necessarily indicate low levels of association of the underlying variables with fatigue, but could be an artifact. Sources of variation include measurement error both in fatigue and predictor variables in addition to variables that have not been included for analysis. Patient-reported outcomes, like other variables, also have error terms. These sources of measurement error may include different perceptions of fatigue by patients, and within a single patient, that person’s perception can vary over time. Variations from measurement error can sometimes contribute considerably to the variance, and this should be noted when interpreting the R term. We still do not know whether the relationship between fatigue and the other symptoms is causal or if these symptoms are part of a more general response. Fatiguerelated symptom clusters will be helpful in clinical assessment and management of patients and allow advances in the understanding of other symptoms to generate new hypotheses about fatigue. To gain further insights into fatigue, we will eventually need to consider other study designs. If one thinks of fatigue as a common form of illness behavior in response to various kinds of stress, then a context-related definition of fatigue patients may be Support Care Cancer (2008) 16:1095–1096 DOI 10.1007/s00520-008-0483-4
Read moreMoving beyond Cronbach's Alpha and Inter-Rater Reliability: A Primer on Generalizability Theory for Pharmacy Education.
When available, empirical evidence should help guide decision-making. Following each administration of a learning assessment, data becomes available for analysis. For learning assessments, Kane's Framework for Validation can helpfully categorize evidence by inference (i.e., scoring, generalization, extrapolation, implications). Especially for test-scores used within a high-stakes setting, generalization evidence is critical. While reporting Cronbach's alpha, inter-rater reliability, and other reliability coefficients for a single measurement error are somewhat common in pharmacy education, dealing with multiple concurrent sources of measurement error within complex learning assessments is not. Performance-based assessments (e.g., OSCEs) that use raters, are inherently complex learning assessments. Generalizability Theory (G-Theory) can account for multiple sources of measurement error. G-Theory is a powerful tool that can provide a composite reliability (i.e., generalization evidence) for more complex learning assessments, including performance-based assessments. It can also help educators explore ways to make a learning assessment more rigorous if needed, as well as suggest ways to better allocate resources (e.g., staffing, space, fiscal). A brief review of G-Theory is discussed herein focused on pharmacy education. G-Theory has been common and useful in medical education, though has been used rarely in pharmacy education. Given the similarities in assessment methods among health-professions, G-Theory should prove helpful in pharmacy education as well. Within this Journal and accompanying this Idea Paper, there are multiple reports that demonstrate use of G-Theory in pharmacy education.
Read more