Applying the science impact framework to understand real-world applications and impacts of ICESat and ICESat-2 data on decision-making
Assessing the societal impact of satellite remote sensing datasets is essential to understanding how these data influence decision-making and to identifying opportunities for further engagement. However, measuring such impacts remains challenging for missions serving diverse stakeholder communities. In this study, we evaluate the broader impact of NASA's Ice, Cloud, and land Elevation Satellite (ICESat) and its successor mission, ICESat-2 by adapting the scientific impact framework (SIF), originally developed to assess public health research, into an Earth science-specific version (e-SIF). This framework captures data dissemination, community awareness, data-driven actions, measurable changes, and future influence, moving beyond traditional academic metrics to assess the missions' reach and effectiveness. Our findings reveal extensive global usage of ICESat and ICESat-2 data, with applications including, but not limited to, shallow water bathymetry, climate mitigation strategies, and forest management. By comparing the prevalence of topical areas in academic literature to real-world applications, we found that althoughthe cryosphere is the most frequently studied domain, differences between research focus and practical use highlight potential areas where further research could better support stakeholders. We found that ICESat and ICESat-2 data are widely employed by national and international governmental and non-governmental organizations but found only limited use by private sector and local governments. We recommend that the ICESat-2 Applications Team expand outreach efforts to these sectors to enhance dissemination of mission data. Furthermore, numerous ICESat-2 applications benefit from long-term data continuity, reinforcing the need for a successor mission. This study demonstrates the feasibility to use e-SIF to evaluate the impact of Earth science missions. • This study involves an innovative application of the CDC Scientific Impact Framework. • ICESat and ICESat-2 provide global altimetry data that empowers diverse applications. • Application topics vary between the academic and broader stakeholder communities. • The study models methods of how to examine real-world outcomes in the Earth sciences. Open scientific data empowers diverse communities to generate knowledge and insights that support decision-making across public policy, economic planning, and environmental management. Through Earth-observing missions, NASA aims to improve scientific understanding of our planet's current state and possible future changes. The NASA missions Ice, Cloud, and land Elevation Satellite (ICESat) and ICESat-2 have contributed to this effort by providing highly accurate elevation data using laser altimetry. In this study, we examined the impact of these missions beyond the academic community to identify key stakeholders and assess how these missions influence decision-making. To do so, we modified the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) Scientific Impact Framework (SIF), originally designed to evaluate public health research, to create an Earth science relevant SIF (e-SIF) in order to discover and analyze the applications of Earth science missions beyond the academic sector. Our findings show that these data products have had a strong policy impact at the intergovernmental level but have been used less frequently by local governments and corporations. Moreover, we observed notable differences between the scientific topics emphasized in academic literature and those found in reports and real-world applications. This study highlights the importance of evaluating how scientific research translates into real-world impacts, including for technological advancements, policy changes, economic effects, and more. As ICESat-2 approaches the end of its mission, ensuring data continuity is critical to supporting current and future applications that rely on these observations.
Read more