IEEE 1900.6b: Sensing support for spectrum databases

Spectrum scarcity demands for additional bandwidth where new services can be deployed on. However, today's spectrum allocation leaves almost no bands unallocated. Thus, Cognitive Radio has been studied to bring relief to the lack of spectrum, moving towards a more efficient and dynamic spectrum access. In this domain TV White Space have been proposed as a possible solution to bring new, valuable spectrum for opportunistic services. However, their availability is quite low in highly populated areas, and thus their viability is limited. This is mainly because the availability of TV White Space is typically considered at the rooftop, through two-dimensional propagation models which do not account for possible spectrum re-utilization policies within a building, or in a small-scale area. In this paper, we show that much more communication opportunities can be found when we consider also the third-dimension, i.e. the height from the terrain, and novel per-floor allocation policies. We propose three main contributions in this paper. First, we describe an analytical model through which we derive the number of available spectrum resources for indoor secondary networks, considering PU protection policies in the same building, and in surrounding buildings. Second, we estimate the number of TV Gray Space (TVGS) over realistic scenarios in candidate cities, considering realistic street topology and buildings locations, and we show that this value can be much higher than what reported in the spectrum database. Finally, we investigate co-existence of secondary networks on TVWS, when novel per-floor spectrum sharing models are used.

The IEEE 802.22 is a standard for wireless regional area networks to opportunistically operate in TV bands; however, sharing TV White Space (TVWS) spectrum creates a problem of coexistence because no mechanism is defined for coordinating channel usage among secondary networks. We propose a White Space Resource Sharing mechanism (WSRS) for fixed secondary and mobile IEEE 802.22 networks to improve network coexistence and spectrum efficiency. Based on power control and channel allocation, our mechanism allows the TVWS system to serve vehicular networks in scenarios where there are active secondary fixed networks and no more TVWS channels available for opportunistic usage. Unlike state-of-the-art mechanisms for coexistence in TVWS spectrum, our mechanism allocates resources to vehicles even when the density of fixed nodes and the transmission power of the fixed network cause high interference to the vehicular network. Our results show the offered channel capacity increases up to 50% using the proposed WSRS mechanism compared to the recent IEEE 802.22 standard that does not have a defined TVWS channel sharing mechanism. Furthermore, our WSRS mechanism implements a strategy to protect the fixed secondary network from interference caused by vehicular transmissions while promoting fair usage for both secondary networks.

In this paper, we propose a novel information market for TV white space networks, where the spectrum database operator sells the information regarding TV white space to secondary users. Different from the traditional spectrum market, the information market processes the unique property of positive externality, as more users purchasing the information service will increase the value of the service to each buyer. We systematically characterize the market equilibrium and the database operator's optimal information pricing strategy. Specifically, we first study how the market share dynamically evolves over time and eventually converge to a market equilibrium. We show that the market equilibrium increases with the initial market share, and there exist several tipping points of the initial market share, around which a slight change will lead to a significant change on the emerging market equilibrium. Based on the market equilibrium analysis, we further study the impact of the database operator's information pricing strategy on the market equilibrium, and derive the optimal information price that maximizes the database operator's revenue. Theoretical analysis and numerical result indicate that this is a promising business model for creating incentives for the database operator in TV white space networks.

Optimal crowd-augmented spectrum mapping via an iterative Bayesian decision framework

The lack of sufficient fixed-line communication infrastructure in African rural areas has resulted in wireless communication being the only cost effective alternative solution for broadband connectivity. However, access to valuable spectrum—specifically sub-1 GHz spectrum—is mostly allocated to broadcasting or mobile telephony. The global digital switch over (DSO) of television (TV) broadcasting systems will see more sub-1 GHz TV band spectrum being made available for the digital dividend and also result in more TV white space (TVWS) spectrum. In order to ensure dynamic and efficient utilization of the TV white space spectrum, there is an increasing trend to use cognitive radiosystems that use geo-location spectrum databases and spectrum sensing as an enabling technology. In this paper, we overview the relevant signals and standards and present field measurement results showing the actual usage of TV bands before the DSO in selected urban and rural areas of Southern Africa. Measurements were conducted using low-cost and high-grade radio instruments. The low-cost spectrum analyser was built in-house using the Universal Software Radio Peripheral (USRP-2) and GNU Radio software. A metric to quantify available TV white space, based on the minimum acceptable field strength, is introduced and applied to quantify the availability of TV white space. Our results show medium spectrum usage in urban areas and very low spectrum usage in rural areas, making TVWS an attractive solution for rural broadband connectivity.

Utilization of the TV white-spaces (TVWS), which are spatially or temporally unused frequency in TV bands, is promising technology to alleviate spectrum resource shortage. Services using the TVWS have been already started in the U.S.A., and the TVWS pilot program has been performed and test operation of qualified white-spaces database (WSDB) has been started by the Ofcom in the U.K. Authors have developed TVWS LTE (Long Term Evolution) system with white-space devices (WSDs) licensed by the Ofcom and WSDB qualified by also the Ofcom, and participated in the pilot program performed in the U.K. In this paper, developed TVWS LTE system is summarized and field experiment of throughput measurement is performed in the London urban area is described. As a result of the field experiment, maximum downlink throughput of 45.4 Mbps in the FDD mode and 19.5 Mbps in the TDD mode were obtained under the condition of SISO with a signal bandwidth of 20 MHz. This is the first report on the field experiment of the TVWS LTE system aiming for practical use.

TV White Space (TVWS) spectrum utilization is totally a new idea in wireless communication technology. It refers to some portion of TV spectrum that is not used by TV channels and available for other applications. This unused spectrum has been opened up for the free and unlicensed users. This spectrum can be utilized greatly if a noninterference environment is created between the users of this spectrum. Therefore, a coexistence of multiple networks requires interference management. In this paper, an interference management algorithm is developed. It ensures that a network can access the TVWS spectrum without causing interference to other networks. This is done by using three stages. The first stage is for finding the group of networks that will not cause interference to one another. For this graph coloring algorithm is used. The second stage is for assigning different channels to each group of networks. Here, channel assignment gives priority to the user requirement of each group. If any bandwidth is left after second stage, then the third stage is performed where performance of each network will be increased. This is done by considering the number of networks in a group. Simulation results show that the proposed scheme provides better channel assignment along with bandwidth utilization.

Spectrum regulation for cellular networks, last-mile wireless broadband access, but also for the new secondary usage of the TV white space, often favor a paired radio spectrum so that different frequency channels are used for down- and uplink (base vs. mobile devices). This setup is also referred to as frequency division duplex. However, such a setup makes it difficult to apply contention-based protocols like those standardized by IEEE 802.11, because they were designed so that downlink and uplink share the same frequency channel. Yet the simplicity of the 802.11 protocol and its decentralized operation make it attractive for smart grid and consumer electronics applications using TV white space or licensed spectrum. Therefore we investigate a contention-based 802.11-like protocol for paired spectrum. We leverage its downlink-uplink separation into a protocol design that combines contention-based distributed medium access with a managed reaction to packet collisions. We also demonstrate why this paired spectrum approach is relevant and desirable for TV white space secondary spectrum access. The main advantages of this protocol are (1) enabling the usage of simple and low cost contention-based 802.11-like devices in paired spectrum, (2) providing collision detection management in the uplink, and (3) an inherent resource reservation for downlink traffic. The evaluation results confirm the validity of the proposed protocol design and demonstrate the benefits obtained from collision detection management.

The television white space (TVWS) spectrum presents a promising opportunity to extend wireless broadband access, particularly in rural, underserved, and hard-to-reach communities. To leverage this potential, low-power radio communication equipment must efficiently utilise the TVWS spectrum on a secondary basis while ensuring strict compliance with regulatory requirements to prevent harmful interference to primary services. This paper presents a comparative performance analysis of TVWS radio equipment from three original equipment manufacturers (OEMs). The equipment under test was identified to reflect each OEM, as follows: OEM 1 and OEM 2 from South Korea and OEM 3 from the USA. We evaluated their performance in two real-world field scenarios, namely outdoor short-distance and outdoor long-distance. The evaluation was based on the following key metrics: (i) spectrum utilisation efficiency (SUE), (ii) received signal strength (RSS), (iii) downlink throughput, and (iv) connectivity to the Geo-Location Spectrum Database (GLSD) in compliance with the South African TVWS regulatory framework. The overall preliminary experimental results indicate that in both scenarios, white space devices (WSDs) based on the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) 802.11af Standard demonstrated better performance than those based on the 3rd Generation Partnership Project Long-Term Evolution-Advanced (3GPP LTE-A) Standard in terms of the SUE, downlink throughput, and RSS metrics. All WSDs under test demonstrated sufficient compliance with the regulatory requirement metric.

In this paper, we propose a reinforcement learning-based approach for enabling vehicles to make intelligent channel selection choices across TV whitespace spectrum. In order for vehicle communication networks to dynamically access TV whitespace in a secondary manner, it is imperative that these communication systems be capable of coexisting with other types of secondary wireless networks operating within the same frequency range. Consequently, we first propose a TV whitespace channel sharing scheme that would facilitate the coexistence between WLAN, WRAN, and vehicular communication networks. Using the channel utilization variations observed by a collection of mobile vehicular communication systems, we then devised a reinforcement learning-based adaptive channel selection algorithm that employs channel utilization sensing in order to reinforce the decisions made by the vehicular communication system. Moreover, the parameters of the proposed learning approach are adaptively tuned in order to achieve better adaptation to a particular environment. A computer emulation environment composed of actual real-world sensing measurement data and a simulated TV whitespace network is created in order to accurately model the characteristics of future wireless environment, as well as to test the proposed learning-based channel access approach. Experimental results show a significant performance improvement with respect to vehicle communication.

Monitoring and sensing of spectrum are becoming more and more important, as the subject of using underused TV White Spaces (TVWS) spectrum by software defined radios (SDR) and cognitive radios is advanced forward towards practical applications. Correctly identifying available TVWS bands is critical for success of TVWS based broadband communications, not causing interference to reception of TV broadcast by TV receivers. This paper discusses side effects encountered with a popular design of a wire discone antenna. AntennaCraft model ST4 is exampled as an inexpensive candidate for spectrum monitoring and sensing in UHF frequency band. The study was done by both simulation and measurements, with well matching results. The candidate antenna was found to introduce notch banded loss in the system sensitivity. The influence of a potential mechanical damage onto the sensitivity of the antenna system has also been considered, and was found to be relatively small, under 3 dB.

Cognitive radio (CR) vehicular networks are poised to opportunistically use the licensed spectrum for high bandwidth inter-vehicular messaging, driver-assist functions, and passenger entertainment services. Recent rulings that mandate the use of spectrum databases introduce additional challenges in this highly mobile environment, where the CR enabled vehicles must update their spectrum data frequently and complete the data transfers with roadside base stations. As the rules allow local spectrum sensing only under the assurance of high accuracy, there is an associated tradeoff in obtaining assuredly correct spectrum updates from the database at a finite cost, compared to locally obtained sensing results that may have a finite error probability. This paper aims to answer the question of when to undertake local spectrum sensing and when to rely on database updates through a novel method of exploiting the correlation between 2G spectrum bands and TV whitespace. We describe experimental studies that validate our approach and quantify the cost savings made possible by intermittent database queries.

Opportunistic secondary usage of underutilised radio spectrum is currently of great interest and the use of TV White Spaces (TVWS) has been considered for Long Term Evolution (LTE) broadband services. However, wireless microphones operating in TV bands pose a challenge to TVWS opportunistic access. Efficient and proactive spectrum sensing could prevent harmful interference between collocated devices, but existing spectrum sensing schemes such as energy detection and schemes based on Random Matrix Theory (RMT) have performance limitations. We propose a new blind spectrum sensing scheme with higher performance based on RMT supported by a new formula for the estimation of noise variance. The performance of the proposed scheme has been evaluated through extensive simulations on wireless microphone signals. The proposed scheme has also been compared to energy detection schemes, and shows higher performance in terms of the probability of false alarm (P fa ) and probability of detection (P d ).

Low power wide area network (LPWAN) is a wireless communication technology that offers large coverage, low data rates, and low power consumption, making it a suitable choice for the growing Internet of Things and machine-to-machine communication applications. Long range (LoRa), an LPWAN technology, has recently been used in the industrial, scientific and medical (ISM) band for various low-power wireless applications. The coverage and data rate supported by these devices in the ISM band is well-studied in the literature. In this paper, we study the usage of TV white spaces (TVWS) for LoRa transmissions to address the growing spectrum demand. Additionally, the range and data rate of TVWS-based LoRa, for different transmission parameter values using different path-loss models and for various scenarios such as free space, outdoor and indoor are investigated. A path-loss model for TVWS-based LoRa is also proposed and explored, and the evaluations show that TVWS offers a longer range. This range and data rate study would be useful for efficient network planning and system design for TVWS-based LoRa LPWANs.

Cognitive Radio has now become a realistic option for the solution of the spectrum scarcity problem in wireless communication. TV channels (the primary user) can be protected from secondary-user interference by accurate prediction of TV White Spaces (TVWS) by using appropriate propagation modelling. In this paper we address two related aspects of channel occupancy prediction for cognitive radio. Firstly we investigate the best combination of empirical propagation model and spatial resolution of terrain data for predicting TVWS by examining the performance of three propagation models (Extended-Hata, Davidson-Hata and Egli) in the TV band 470 to 790 MHz along with terrain data resolutions of 1000, 100 and 30 m, when compared with a comprehensive set of propagation measurements taken in randomly-selected locations around Hull, UK. Secondly we describe how such models can be integrated into a database-driven tool for cognitive radio channel selection within the TVWS environment.