• https://doi.org/10.1213/ane.0000000000002781Copy DOI Icon

In Response.

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

We thank Overdyk and Broens1 for their educational comments on our systematic review and meta-analysis. The prospective randomized controlled trial by Ochroch et al2 found that continuous pulse oximetry (CPOX) did not reduce intensive care unit (ICU) transfers on a postcardiothoracic surgery floor. However, in a subgroup analysis, they found that CPOX significantly decreased ICU transfers due to pulmonary complications. It is important to note that the study by Ochroch et al2 was underpowered to detect real subgroup effects, thereby increasing the risk of false-positive results. The other prospective controlled study by Taenzer et al3 included the cohort of elderly patients undergoing joint replacement surgeries in a patient surveillance system unit. The comparison unit included the cohort of patients from urology, gynecology, vascular surgery, and general surgery. They found that CPOX monitoring reduced the need for ICU transfers; however, no subgroup analysis was performed to detect whether ICU transfers were due to respiratory complications.3 Overdyk and Broens1 suggested that ICU transfers in the study by Taenzer et al3 are less likely to be skewed by hemodynamic causes. This hypothesis is not supported in the growing literature which shows that there is an increased incidence of major complications like pulmonary embolism, sepsis, nonischemic cardiac complications, and pneumonia after joint replacement surgeries.4 Thus, ICU transfers were not exclusively due to pulmonary causes. Having extracted data from the prospective controlled studies,2,3,5,6 we decided that it was not appropriate to pool results from trials comparing outcomes that are dissimilar. In other words, it would be inappropriate to pool the data on pulmonary causes of ICU transfer from Ochroch et al2 and data on all-cause ICU transfer from Taenzer et al.3 Overdyk and Broens1 suggested combining the 2 data sets from Taenzer et al3 and Ochroch et al.2 This may increase the risk of bias, raising questions on the validity of the results. To avoid bias in our meta-analysis, we pooled the data on all-cause ICU transfer from both studies.2,3 Based on these findings, we concluded that all-cause ICU transfer had a risk reduction of 34% with CPOX when compared to standard monitoring. Due to lack of data in the literature, our meta-analysis failed to differentiate ICU transfers with respect to pulmonary versus other causes. We agree with Overdyk and Broens1 that pulse oximetry is not a measure of circulatory insufficiency. Pulse oximetry device is designed to measure specific physiologic outcome (oxygen saturation), and as such, it measures respiratory adverse events better than cardiac adverse events.7 Our systematic review makes it clear that there are not enough outcome studies using oxygen saturation to evaluate its utility for improving patient outcomes with respect to pulmonary causes of adverse events. Mahesh Nagappa, MDDepartment of Anesthesia and Perioperative MedicineLondon Health Sciences Centre and St. Joseph Health CareWestern UniversityLondon, Ontario, Canada Thach Lam, MDFrances Chung, MBBSDepartment of Anesthesiology and Pain MedicineToronto Western HospitalUniversity Health NetworkUniversity of TorontoToronto, Ontario, Canada[email protected]

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Triaging acute chest syndrome clinical decision-making using bedside SaO2/FiO2 ratio.

  • Jun 13, 2025
  • Blood advances
  • Austin Wesevich +5
  • Discussion
  • Citations8

Exploring Entrustment: Housestaff Autonomy and Patient Readmission

  • May 04, 2014
  • The American Journal of Medicine
  • Shannon K Martin +5
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Opioid and Sedative Coprescription: Prescribing Patterns after an ICU Admission.

  • Jan 09, 2023
  • Canadian Journal of Hospital Pharmacy
  • Tiffany Tozer +4
  • Research Article

786: ATYPICAL SEDATION EVENTS IN CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE OUTSIDE THE ICU: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF CASES

  • Mar 01, 2026
  • Critical Care Medicine
  • Ali Moinuddin +6
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Forming a Partnership to Save Lives

  • Aug 01, 2006
  • Critical Care Nurse
  • Sandy Rankin
  • Abstract

Intravenous Fluid Replacement Therapy and Hospital Outcomes for Vaso-Occlusive Episodes in Patients with Sickle Cell Disease

  • Nov 15, 2022
  • Blood
  • Abraham Haimed +4
  • PDF
  • Research Article

Assessment of Continuous Pulse Oximetry Monitoring in Infants With Bronchiolitis in the Pediatric Emergency Department: A Cross-Sectional Study.

  • Nov 21, 2024
  • Cureus
  • Katie Gardner +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations66

Use of Intermittent vs Continuous Pulse Oximetry for Nonhypoxemic Infants and Young Children Hospitalized for Bronchiolitis: A Randomized Clinical Trial.

  • Oct 01, 2015
  • JAMA Pediatrics
  • Russell Mcculloh +7
  • Research Article

In Reply

  • Oct 01, 2010
  • Anesthesiology
  • Andreas Taenzer +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations9

Surgeons' Perceptions of the Causes of Preventable Harm in Arterial Surgery: A Mixed-Methods Study

  • Nov 15, 2017
  • European Journal of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery
  • Rachael Lear +5
  • Research Article

The impact of preoperative nutritional status, intraoperative fluid administration volume, operating room temperature, and anesthesia duration on intraoperative hypothermia in elderly patients undergoing total joint replacement under general anesthesia: a logistic regression analysis and nursing intervention strategies

  • Jan 05, 2026
  • Frontiers in Medicine
  • Mingming Lu +4
  • Research Article

Decision-making experience of elderly patients for joint replacement surgery in China: a qualitative study

  • Dec 01, 2025
  • BMJ Open
  • Kaili Liu +4
  • Research Article
  • Citations7

Endovascular repair versus open repair in the treatment of ruptured aortic aneurysms: a systematic review.

  • May 25, 2018
  • Minerva chirurgica
  • Bruno Amato +10
  • Research Article

Highlights from the Circulation Family of Journals.

  • Mar 28, 2017
  • Circulation
  • Addendum

Impact of Pulse Oximetry Surveillance on Rescue Events and Intensive Care Unit Transfers: A Before-and-After Concurrence Study: Erratum.

  • Mar 01, 2020
  • Anesthesiology
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.