Figure 2: Verbotonal training allows a child to hear her own voice using a microphone and headphones and to feel speech through the soundboard on her wrist.Neuroplasticity allows patients' brains to restructure themselves when the optimal frequency response (OFR) with hearing devices and regular auditory therapy are provided. But are we doing enough to facilitate this restructuring? Verbotonal rehabilitation, an auditory-based strategy that maximizes listening skills of those with hearing impairment and other communications disorders, simultaneously allows the development of intelligible spoken language through binaural listening. The verbotonal system includes diagnostic therapy, habilitation, rehabilitation, speech disorders, and foreign languages. First introduced in 1967 at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, the method quickly expanded worldwide due to positive clinical outcomes, but clinicians still may not be taking advantage of some tools to improve word understanding for patients using hearing aids and cochlear implants. THE VIBROTACTILE PHASE What's the difference between the infant, child, and adult brain? Under age 5, a child can learn to speak two languages fluently. After puberty, a teenager has an adult brain, and it's difficult for him to learn a second language. Vibrotactile learning is optimal below age 2, which is why it is best to place hearing aids and cochlear implants in children under 5. Hearing specialists must adapt their strategy to infant, child, and adult brains. All infants learn from vibrotactile and proprioceptive input; the fetus feels and hears his mother's body and speech rhythms. After birth, the infant first feels and then hears through wide bandwidths of 2 Hz to 20,000 Hz. Verbotonal always begins with this wideband amplification regardless of the patient's age. At birth, vibrotactile and proprioceptive senses are more dominant than auditory senses, which strengthen as the child's brain develops. Verbotonal rehabilitation takes advantage of the early dominant vibrotactile sense with body movements to develop sound awareness using a VTU speech vibrator with a common bone vibrator. (Figure 1.) The vibrator responds from 2 Hz to 1000 Hz, and is attached to the infant's wrist or to a speech board. Using a speech vibrator, speech board, and headphone during therapy, a child can feel and hear his parent's voice and via a special microphone, a child can hear his own voice. (Figure 2.)Figure 1: Verbotonal rehabilitation takes advantage of the early dominant vibrotactile sense with body movements to develop sound awareness using a VTU speech vibrator with a common bone vibrator.Early vibrotactile input will establish sound awareness, and prepare the child's brain to accept speech through hearing aids, cochlear implants, or both. Most infants go through a preimplant evaluation stage where hearing aids are fitted bilaterally. With effective training, some infants can continue with hearing aids while others will need binaural cochlear implants as soon as possible. Developing a successful training program, however, takes careful planning. SPEECH, RHYTHM, INTONATION Hearing aids and cochlear implants should be adjusted to include low speech frequencies so the patient can hear the octave changes when a speaker's words have an emotional pitch. Changing vocal pitch adds meaning to speech, and is essential to word understanding. Verbotonal therapy sets hearing aids and cochlear implants to include speech frequencies below 300 Hz with a speech vibrator. A cochlear implant electrode at 188 Hz or lower is set to stimulate the client's neural reserve in the cochlea. Seven perceptual parameters are used for error analysis and correction. (Table 1.) Begin with speech modifications and move on to body movements. These corrections may be difficult at first, but because the hearing specialist has normal speech patterns, he can effectively correct errors. Infants and children may have balance and coordination problems so vestibular function should be assessed when possible. Reporting optimal octaves for each of the 40 phonemes is a helpful tool for analyzing perceptual errors, such as why a patient with a certain audiometric pattern makes a particular mistake. Optimal octaves also provide a foundation for the tonality perceptual continuum.Table 1: Body movements and speech modifications based on the parameters.OPTIMAL FREQUENCY RESPONSE The optimal frequency response changes with brain maturation and the progress patients make with therapy. Some clients may always need the speech vibrator while others will progress with only auditory input. The verbotonal clinician uses the VLU by changing the center frequency, bandwidth, and slopes to 0, 6, 12, 18, 20, or 60 dB/octave. Once the client's brain is trained under the OFR with the verbotonal system, the OFR is shifted toward an optimal hearing aid setting. As Robert Martin, PhD, noted in his March Hearing Journal column, patients will often comment during training, “If I could only hear like this with my hearing aids.” (See FastLinks.) With digital hearing aids and cochlear implants, gain needs to be adjusted independently in each of the 10 to 15 frequency bands to create the optimal frequency response. The slope toward low frequencies is an important adjustment for the wide flat frequency and bimodal (discontinuous) responses on the VTU and the hearing aid response. In 1972, Guberina constructed eight nonsense syllables as logatomes: /bru-bru, mu-mu, bu-bu, vo-vo, la-la, ke-ke, shi-shi, and si-si/. Asp developed a shortened three logatome test —/mu-mu, la-la, si-si/ — to evaluate detection and perception through VTU, hearing aids, and cochlear implants. Most often it is used without amplification in distance evaluation. Can the client repeat si-si correctly without using amplification or visual cues? If not, he has a high-frequency hearing loss. This is an effective screening tool for the tonality perceptual continuum. TONALITY PERCEPTUAL CONTINUUM The tonality perceptual continuum (TPC) is based on filtered optimal-octaves and the spectral pitch (tonality) of each phoneme. The TPC ranges from low to mid to high tonality. Verbotonal uses a phoneme, logatome, and word or sentence that is homogenous in tonality. For instance, /i/, /si-si/, cease, and “she is my sister” are all homogenous and in high tonality. At the low end of the tonality continuum are /u/, /mu-mu/, moon, and “mama blew a bubble.” Remember, the tonality continuum represents the frequencies on the cochlear continuum. If an error occurs in a lower tonality than the target tonality, change the optimum frequency response by adding high frequencies, reducing low frequencies, or both. Use the continuum for correcting errors. Phoneme and logatome testing are preferred because they minimize client guessing. The phoneme /i/ minimizes guessing but a word or a sentence includes guessing. Because the word level is important, we've included a list of homogenous tonality words in five categories: low, low-mid, mid, mid-high, and high. (Table 2.) These test words can be presented inside or outside the sound booth. Note that adding more gain in the high-frequency region may not always be the solution when a patient makes an error. With digital technology, the OFR can be used by altering the gain in individual frequency bands until good results are obtained. The prescribed frequency response is a starting point; the client's preference is key.Table 2: Homogenous tonality words.Conversational speaker-to-listener distance is three feet; the speech level is 65 dB SPL (50 dB HL) at the listener's ear. At two inches, the speech level is 95 dB SPL (80 dB HL). Use this as a reference. The hearing specialist must keep his normal speaking loudness at different distances to be effective. This takes discipline and training. Outside the booth, doubling the distance between the clinician and the client's ear reduces the speech signal by 6 dB; half the distance increases it 6 dB. With a tape line on the floor, increase the distance gradually until the client misses a word, then decrease the distance until the client correctly repeats it. This will help the client manage louder or softer speech and distances. Closer distances increase loudness and reduce the effect of noise and reverberation. MAKING UP FOR LOST TIME Placing hearing aids or cochlear implants at age 1 means the infant missed a whole year not hearing. How do we make up for lost time? Will he always be behind? Verbotonal uses intensive vibrotactile, proprioceptive, and body movement training to treat the infant because he needs to hear and feel speech all the time. Some hearing specialists use aided pure-tone thresholds within 20 dB HL to indicate normal hearing, but it's not that simple. Current thinking holds that normal cochlear implant thresholds mean normal hearing. That is, once the implant is programmed, the client will hear like normal hearing people. If this were true, the hearing specialist's job would be easy. Ironically, cochlear implants have created a need for effective habilitation or rehabilitation. Diagnostic therapy involves evaluation for implant candidacy, examination of speech recognition through hearing aids, preimplant counseling, initial programming of the implants, counseling, and the client repeating words, sentences, and paragraphs. As an option, verbotonal treatment includes perceptual parameters, tonality error analysis, and correction with a speech vibrator to feel and hear speech. OVERCOMING OBSTACLES Implementing verbotonal therapy is not without financial obstacles. Medicare and private insurers offer low reimbursement for aural rehabilitation and cochlear implant programming. Habilitation and rehabilitation therapy should already be included in the initial or follow-up hearing aid or cochlear implant visit. While using the verbotonal system will add 30 to 40 minutes to the visit, the patient will be satisfied with the new optimum frequency response, and will refer others to your clinic. The initial financial setback will provide an opportunity for increased earnings if the practitioner improves his client's word understanding. Remember, the best form of advertisement is good hearing aid or cochlear implant results. The Hearing Journal article, “Retraining the brain when hearing aids aren't enough,” noted that digital hearing aid technology has advanced, but the technology itself has not been able to resolve all the communication problems of the hearing impaired. (See FastLinks.) Whether the hearing specialist uses advanced hearing aid technology or cochlear implants, these devices are only a remediation tool for the defective peripheral hearing organ to send information to the brain. Unless we as hearing health care providers modify our thinking to change the way we practice, we are not doing enough to serve our clients. FastLinks • Read Dr. Robert Martin's Nuts and Bolts column on word understanding at http://bit.ly/WordUnderstanding. • Read “Retraining the brain when hearing aids aren't enough” at http://bit.ly/HJRetraining. • Comment about this article by writing to [email protected]. • Follow us on Twitter at twitter.com/hearingjournal.
Read more