- Research Article
17
- 10.1016/0165-4896(88)90046-7
Unique finite conjoint measurement
- Oct 01, 1988
- Mathematical Social Sciences
- Peter C Fishburn
Unique finite conjoint measurement
Abstract : This report presents the results of an attempt to propose a basis for an error theory of conjoint measurement methodology. Conjoint measurement methodology offers a new and potentially useful approach for obtaining psychological scale values for components of multidimensional attributes. This report describes the mathematical foundations of this methodology as well as a means of evaluating the fit of an additive conjoint measurement model to a three factor design. For each of the critical axioms of conjoint measurement, proportions of errors that would be expected by chance for different conditions of simple independence are examined. In addition, a computer-based algorithm that can be used to perform specific kinds of conjoint analysis has been generalized and documented as a technique for assessing the fit of an additive model to a set of data. The program is called SWAT and its current state of development is described in this report. Finally, the appendices provide a step-by-step explanation of data deck arrangements for SWAT as well as some actual printouts from the program.
Unique finite conjoint measurement
Unique finite conjoint measurement
Nontransitive Decomposable Conjoint Measurement
Nontransitive Decomposable Conjoint Measurement
Evaluating the Equal-Interval Hypothesis with Test Score Scales
The axioms of additive conjoint measurement provide a means of testing the hypothesis that testing data can be placed onto a scale with equal-interval properties. However, the axioms are difficult to verify given that item responses may be subject to measurement error. A Bayesian method exists for imposing order restrictions from additive conjoint measurement while estimating the probability of a correct response. In this study an improved version of that methodology is evaluated via simulation. The approach is then applied to data from a reading assessment intentionally designed to support an equal-interval scaling.
Read moreDetecting Model Misfit in Structural Equation Modeling with Machine Learning—A Proof of Concept
Despite the popularity of structural equation modeling in psychological research, accurately evaluating the fit of these models to data is still challenging. Using fixed fit index cutoffs is error-prone due to the fit indices’ dependence on various features of the model and data (“nuisance parameters”). Nonetheless, applied researchers mostly rely on fixed fit index cutoffs, neglecting the risk of falsely accepting (or rejecting) their model. With the goal of developing a broadly applicable method that is almost independent of nuisance parameters, we introduce a machine learning (ML)-based approach to evaluate the fit of multi-factorial measurement models. We trained an ML model based on 173 model and data features that we extracted from 1,323,866 simulated data sets and models fitted by means of confirmatory factor analysis. We evaluated the performance of the ML model based on 1,659,386 independent test observations. The ML model performed very well in detecting model (mis-)fit in most conditions, hereby outperforming commonly used fixed fit index cutoffs across the board. Only minor misspecifications, such as a single neglected residual correlation, proved to be challenging to detect. This proof-of-concept study shows that ML is very promising in the context of model fit evaluation.
Read moreThe major depressive disorder hierarchy: Rasch analysis of 6 items of the Hamilton depression scale covering the continuum of depressive syndrome
The major depressive disorder hierarchy: Rasch analysis of 6 items of the Hamilton depression scale covering the continuum of depressive syndrome
Read moreConjoint measurement in utility theory with incomplete product sets
Conjoint measurement in utility theory with incomplete product sets
Unification of the Revised Trauma Score
The Revised Trauma Score (RTS) calculated with Major Outcome Trauma Study weights (MTOS-RTS) is currently the standard physiologic severity score in trauma research and quality control. It is often confused with the Triage-RTS (T-RTS), a version that is easier to calculate but only intended for clinical triage. To compare the accuracy of the MTOS-RTS to the RTS calculated with weights derived from the study population (POP-RTS) and the T-RTS, for predicting mortality in a trauma population. The study population consists of 22,388 patients, drawn from the trauma registries of three Level I trauma centers. The predictive accuracy of the MTOS-RTS, POP-RTS, and the T-RTS were compared using measures of discrimination and model fit from logistic regression models. The MTOS-RTS, the POP-RTS, and the T-RTS had the same discrimination (Area under the Receiver Operating Curve [AUC] = 0.841). The POP-RTS and the T-RTS had a slightly better model fit than the MTOS-RTS (AIC = 8010, 8010, and 8067, respectively). The T-RTS had equal discrimination and equal or better model fit than the MTOS-RTS in the whole sample, in each of the three trauma centers and in the population of patients with severe head trauma. The T-RTS was also equivalent to the POP-RTS in all of these population sub-groups. The T-RTS could replace the MTOS-RTS as the standard physiologic severity score for trauma outcome prediction. The advantages of using the T-RTS over the MTOS-RTS are ease of calculation, the need for only one measure for triage and mortality prediction purposes and universal adaptation to a broad range of trauma populations.
Read moreExploring Pakistan’s Legal Challenges in Artificial Intelligence Regulation: A Data-Driven Approach
Purpose: The study aims to analyze the interaction between technological access and institutional quality in determining GDP per capita within a developing country context. Design/methodology/approach: Using time-series data from 1996 to 2023, the study utilizes Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) for the purpose of assessing direct and indirect effects among the variables: internet users, patent applications, rule of law, and per capita GDP. Model fit was assessed using indicators such as SRMR and NFI to evaluate robustness. Findings: The results show that internet utilization significantly enhances GDP per capita (β = 0.657, p < 0.001) and stimulates innovation through increased patent applications (β = 0.799, p < 0.001). Patent applications also significantly enhance economic growth (β = 0.297, p = 0.024), confirming the mediating variable of innovation (β = 0.237, p = 0.033). Although internet usage has a positive impact on the Rule of Law Index (β = 0.362, p = 0.055), its indirect effects on GDP through the rule of law were not significant (β = 0.041, p = 0.366). Measures of model fit (SRMR = 0.078; NFI = 0.948) indicate a good-fitting structural model. Research limitations/implications: The analysis is also limited to using secondary data, which may not capture micro-level socio-economic impacts. The generalizability of findings is also restricted to Pakistan and may differ in other developing nations with different governance systems. Practical implications: Policymakers need to give priority to broadening internet penetration and encouraging innovation infrastructure as the principal drivers of economic growth. Intellectual property protection and R&D policies can be strengthened to enhance the financial contributions of digital change. Although governance enhancements are significant, the research here indicates that technology adoption and innovation have the potential to contribute directly to GDP. Originality/value: This study makes an important empirical contribution by bringing together digital access, innovation, and institutional governance research in one framework to explain economic development in an emerging economy. The study offers empirical evidence that internet-driven innovation is a key channel through which digital infrastructure boosts national economic performance in the case of Pakistan.
Read moreA Comparison of Four Estimators of a Population Measure of Model Fit in Covariance Structure Analysis
A major issue in the utilization of covariance structure analysis is model fit evaluation. Recent years have witnessed increasing interest in various test statistics and so-called fit indexes, most of which are actually based on or closely related to F 0, a measure of model fit in the population. This study aims to provide a systematic investigation about the performance of 4 available estimators of F 0. [Fcirc]01 is the conventional estimator and is based on noncentral chi-square approximation. [Fcirc]02 is newly proposed and does not assume noncentral chi-square approximation. [Fcirc]03 and [Fcirc]04 are variations of [Fcirc]02. A Monte Carlo simulation study is conducted to examine how these four estimators of F 0 perform across varying model misspecifications, data distributions, model sizes, and sample sizes. The results show that under normality all 4 quantities estimate F 0 equally well, and under nonnormality [Fcirc]02, [Fcirc]03, and [Fcirc]04 outperform [Fcirc]01. Issues related to these findings are discussed.
Read moreAdditive conjoint measurement with ordered categories
Additive conjoint measurement with ordered categories
Comparing Trends in Modeled and Observed Streamflows at Minimally Altered Basins in the United States
We compared modeled and observed streamflow trends from 1984 to 2016 using five statistical transfer models and one deterministic, distributed-parameter, process-based model, for 26 flow metrics at 502 basins in the United States that are minimally influenced by development. We also looked at a measure of overall model fit and average bias. A higher percentage of basins, for all models, had relatively low trend differences between modeled and observed mean/median flows than for very high or low flows such as the annual 1-day high and 7-day low flows. Mean-flow metrics also had the largest percentage of basins with relatively good overall model fit and low bias. The five statistical transfer models performed better at more basins than the process-based model. The overall model fit for all models, for mean and/or high flows, was correlated with one or more measures of basin precipitation or aridity. Our study and previous studies generally observed good model performance for high flows up to 90th or 95th percentile flows. However, we found model performance was substantially worse for more extreme flows, including 99th percentile and annual 1-day high flows, indicating the importance of including more extreme high flows in analyses of model performance.
Read moreAttribute non-attendance in wine choice: Contrasts between stated and inferred approaches
Attribute non-attendance in wine choice: Contrasts between stated and inferred approaches
The effect of different data structures, sample sizes on model fit measures
ABSTRACTIn this study, our aim was to investigate the changes of different data structures and different sample sizes on the structural equation modeling and the influence of these factors on the model fit measures. Examining the created structural equation modeling under different data structures and sample sizes, the evaluation of model fit measures were performed with a simulation study. As a result of the simulation study, optimization and negative variance estimation problems have been encountered depending on the sample size and changing correlations. It was observed that these problems disappeared either by increasing the sample size or the correlations between the variables in factor. For upcoming studies, the choice of RMSEA and IFI model fit measures can be suggested in all sample sizes and the correlation values for data sets are ensured the multivariate normal distribution assumption.
Read more대학생 과학영재의 합리적 의사결정, 내재적 동기와 전공선택 확신의 관계에서 진로결정 효능감의 매개효과
이 연구는 우리나라 대학생 과학영재의 전공선택 확신에 영향을 미치는 요인들을 탐색하고 제변인과의 관계를 살펴봄으로써 전공선택 확신 모형을 제시하는데 목적이 있다. 연구대상은 학창시절 영재교육 경험이 있는 대학생 292명 이었으며, 자료수집을 위해 사용한 측정도구는 합리적 진로의사결정 척도, 동기검사, 진로결정 효능감 검사, 전공선택 확신 검사이다. 자료의 통계분석을 위하여 SPSS Program과 AMOS Program을 사용하였다. 연구 결과 대학생 과학영재의 전공선택 확신 연구모형의 적합도는, TLI=.923, CFI=.951, RMSEA=.077로 적합한 모형임을 확인하였다. 합리적 의사결정과 내재적 동기에서 전공선택 확신으로의 경로는 유의하지 않아서 두 경로를 제거한 후 최종 수정모형을 제시하였다. 최종수정 모형의 적합도 TLI=.926, CFI=.951, RMSEA=.075로 적합한 모형이라 할 수 있으며 합리적 의사결정과 전공선택 확신에서 진로결정 효능감이 완전 매개하며, 또한 내재적 동기에서도 전공선택 확신으로 가는데 진로결정 효능감이 완전 매개하는 것으로 나타났다. 본 연구 결과는 과학영재들이 대학에서 전공을 선택하고 진로를 결정하는데 진로결정 효능감이 매우 중요한 요인임을 밝힘으로써, 영재들의 진로교육 및 진로상담에 유용한 기초자료로 제공될 수 있을 것으로 사료된다. The purpose of this study is to explore related variables to influence gifted college students' career conviction and to propose a structural model. For the study, 292 college students who have experienced university affiliated gifted education program during their school days. Rational decision making test, intrinsic motivation test, career decision efficacy test, and major conviction test were utilized. SPSS program and AMOS were used for statistical analyses. The results are summarized as follows. The fit of measurement model was found to be TLI=.923, CFI=.951, RMSEA=.077, indicating most of the fit indexes were acceptable. The path to career conviction from rational decision making and intrinsic motivation was found to be insignificant, suggesting a revised model. The fit of final revised measurement model was found to be TLI =.926, CFI=.951, RMSEA=.075, indicating the model was acceptable. Interestingly, the career decision efficacy was found to be the complete mediator among the rational decision making, intrinsic motivation, and career conviction. The results of the study showed that career decision efficacy has a very important role in gifted college students'career choice and decision. Implication of the study related to the career education and counseling has been discussed in depth.
Read moreUniqueness in Finite Measurement
This article surveys recent investigations of real sequences (d 1,..., d n ) which arise in the theory of measurement from considerations of uniqueness for numerical representations of qualitative relations on finite sets. The sequences we discuss arise from measurement problems which include measurement of subjective probability, extensive measurement, difference measurement, and additive conjoint measurement. The measurement problems lead to sequences with fascinating combinatorial and number-theoretic properties.The unifying mathematical framework under which we analyze uniqueness of measurement in these diverse areas involves the analysis of the sequences (d 1,...,d n)as the solutions of finite systems of linear equations. Different applications are translated into different restrictions on the types of linear equations that are admissible for each area.Two primary concerns of measurement theory are involved in the work being surveyed: (1) axioms for the qualitative relation that are necessary and sufficient, or at least sufficient, for unique represent ability; (2) the structure of sets of unique solutions. The latter concern leads to combinatorial and number-theoretic problems involving characterizations of unique solutions, counts of numbers of unique solutions, and extreme-value questions. Definitive results and presently open problems are described for the areas covered by the basic theory.KeywordsSubjective ProbabilityIndependent EquationRegular SequenceExtensive MeasurementFibonacci SequenceThese keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Read more