Laser plasma instabilities and their suppression strategies

Laser plasma instabilities (LPIs) cause laser energy loss, asymmetric and insufficient compression, and target preheating, thus are assumed to be among the major concerns of inertial confinement fusion research. Mitigation of LPIs can enhance the laser–target coupling efficiency and optimize the target compression dynamics, which is critical for the realization of robust and high-efficiency fusion ignition. Broadband lasers with polychromatic components or random phases have been investigated for decades as an effective alternative to mitigate LPIs. Here, we present a brief overview on the progress of broadband LPIs, including the models of broadband lasers, the involved physics, the conditions for effective suppression of LPIs, and some schemes to produce broadband lasers.

In laser-driven inertial confinement fusion (ICF) specifically with high laser intensities, energetic (hot) electrons (HEs) can be generated via laser-plasma instabilities. HEs can significantly impact the target performance by modifying the implosion hydrodynamics. In this paper, the effects of moderate-energy (about 20 to 40 keV) HEs on the evolution of two-dimensional single-mode ablative Rayleigh–Taylor instability (ARTI) are studied through numerical simulations with a multigroup diffusion model in which the HE population is treated as a high-energy group launched from the boundary. With HEs present, it is found that ARTI linear growth rates are reduced even though the acceleration of the implosion shell is enhanced by HEs. The reduction in the linear growth rate is owing to the increase in the ablation velocity and the density scale length, and this stabilization effect is greater in the shorter-wavelength modes and/or higher-energy HE cases. The ARTI linear growth does not get mitigated monotonically as the HE number density increases for a given fixed HE kinetic energy. The HE number density minimizing the ARTI growth rate is found, likely due to the competition of the stabilizing and destabilizing hydrodynamic-parameter variations caused by HEs.

Energetics measurements of silver halfraum targets at the National Ignition Facility

Experiments have been performed to investigate laser-plasma instabilities (LPIs) relevant to the direct-drive inertial confinement fusion (ICF) conditions at the Shenguang-II Upgrade (SG-II UP) laser facility during the double-cone ignition (DCI) experimental campaigns, with the overlapped laser intensity ranging from 6×1014Wcm−2 to 1.8×1015Wcm−2 . An overall LPI scenario has been built from the collection and investigation of angularly distributed scattered light. Across broad ranges of laser and plasma parameters, relevant to the direct-drive ICF conditions, the dominance of the stimulated Raman side scattering (SRSS) was confirmed, and its coexistence with the two-plasmon decay (TPD) was also observed. Significant SRSS scattered light was observed across an extremely wide range of emission angles, concentrated at large angles, and demonstrated to be robust throughout the parameter space. Time-resolved spectral measurements show distinctly different SRSS behaviors along different angles and a slightly higher threshold compared to the TPD. The overall SRSS energy loss was measured, indicating a scattered light energy fraction of up to 6%. These results are of crucial importance for the precise assessment of the LPIs in the DCI as well as other laser directly driven ICF schemes.

Laser-plasma interaction is a major issue for achieving ignition in inertial confinement fusion schemes, and still a major concern for the upcoming french laser mégajoule (LMJ) program. In order to mitigate the deleterious effects due to laser-plasma instabilities (LPI), clearly evidenced during the recent US National Ignition Campaign conducted on the National Ignition Facility, we use the LIL facility as a demonstrator for LPI studies. In this article, we focus on preliminary results regarding the propagation of a typical LMJ quadruplet through gas-filled hohlraums. Results on hohlraum energetics will then be discussed.

Laser–plasma instabilities that produce an unacceptably high level of hot electrons are potentially dangerous for both direct-drive and indirect-drive inertial confinement laser fusion. The hot electrons preheat the fuel and prevent compression of the capsule to the requisite conditions for ignition. Fast electron generation and preheat can be inferred from the hard x-ray radiation generated by the interaction of the hot electrons with the target. On the University of Rochester’s OMEGA laser system, time-resolved hard x-ray detectors have been operating in an energy range from 10 to 500 keV. In this article we will present initial results for the yield and spectrum of the hard x-ray radiation. The concept used on OMEGA can be easily extended to infer the amount of laser energy coupled to suprathermal electrons and to the target for both direct- and indirect-drive implosions on the upcoming National Ignition Facility, as well as to measure the conversion efficiency in high-x-ray-yield experiments.

Experiments have been conducted on the OMEGA EP laser facility to study the effect of density scale length and overlapping beam geometry on laser-plasma instabilities near and below the quarter-critical density. Experiments were conducted in both planar geometry (density scale length L n ∼ 190 to 300 μm) and spherical geometry ( L n ∼ 150 μm) with up to four overlapping beams and were designed to have overlapped intensities and density scale lengths comparable to OMEGA spherical experiments, but with many fewer beams. In comparison with previous experiments on OMEGA and National Ignition Facility, it is confirmed that shorter density scale lengths favor the two-plasmon decay (TPD) instability, while longer density scale lengths favor stimulated Raman scattering (SRS). In addition, for experiments at the same scale length and overlapped laser intensity, higher single-beam intensities favor SRS, while a larger number of overlapping beams favor TPD.

Laser fusion, likely the ultimate solution to the crisis of human energy, is highly valued by the international community and has always been the focus of international research. It turns out that the biggest scientific obstacle of laser fusion is the effective control of the high-energy-density nonlinear flows during implosions. The research of high-energy-density nonlinear flows covers many different fields, such as high-energy-density physics, plasma physics, fluid mechanics, computing science, strong impact physics, and high pressure atomic physics. Meanwhile, the capability of multi-material and multi-scale numerical simulations as well as large laser facility with high output power is also needed. As an emerging research field, it is full of all kinds of novel phenomena to be explored. In addition, hydrodynamic instabilities and the subsequent turbulent mixing in high-energy-density flows, are also important processes in astrophysical phenomena (e.g., galaxy collision and merging, stellar evolution, formation of protostars and supernova explosion) and involve with the core content of astrophysics. This paper reviews, firstly the status and progress, as well as the challenges and opportunities of high-energy-density nonlinear flows research. Secondly, it introduces hydrodynamic instabilities during implosions in central ignition laser fusion, among which, key factors related to the bottleneck of implosion performance of the National Ignition Facility (NIF) in the United States are condensed. Next, it summarizes the development of hydrodynamic instability experiments in laser fusion abroad. Finally, it lists some key achievements on the fundamental issues of hydrodynamic instabilities by the laser fusion implosion physics team in China over the last three years. This team has been engaged in the research and control of nonlinear flows in laser fusion implosions, as well as the research and design of target physics. A lot of improvements have been made in recent years on the theoretical analysis and numerical simulation of outstanding issues for hydrodynamic instabilities in laser fusion implosions, and the design and analysis of experiments on large lasers, which greatly promoted the development of this research direction in China.

Z-beamlet experiments conducted at the PECOS test facility at Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) investigated the nonlinear processes in laser plasma interaction (or laser-plasma instabilities) that complicate the deposition of laser energy by enhanced absorption, backscatter, filamentation, and beam-spray that can occur in large-scale laser-heated gas cell targets. These targets and experiments were designed to provide better insight into the physics of the laser preheat stage of the Magnetized Liner Inertial Fusion scheme being tested on the SNL Z-machine. The experiments aim to understand the trade-offs between laser spot size, laser pulse shape, laser entrance hole window thickness, and fuel density for laser preheat. Gas cell target design evolution and fabrication adaptations to accommodate the evolving experiment and scientific requirements are described in this paper.

Large energetic laser facilities provide an amazing tool for bringing matter into high energy density states but achieving a good energy conversion requires to optically smooth the high-power laser beams. Optical smoothing reduces the laser spatial and temporal coherences, allowing to mitigate the development of unwanted laser–plasma instabilities (LPI). Two schemes have been mainly developed: polarization smoothing and smoothing by spectral dispersion. Here, we focus on the latter. Smoothing by spectral dispersion consists in broadening the spectrum usually through a sinusoidal phase modulation and dispersing it with an optical grating. It is usually considered that the modulation frequency should be equal to the inverse of the time delay of the grating, because it maximizes the number of uncorrelated speckles patterns at a given bandwidth. However, current optical smoothing designs are still not sufficient for mitigating LPI. Because the optical smoothing system possesses degrees of freedom, we propose to improve the optical smoothing efficiency by a better tuning of those parameters. Considering the Laser Mégajoule optical system framework, we show that an increase in the modulation frequency allows a better efficiency of the smoothing while keeping the same bandwidth. We assess the efficiency by looking at a better mitigation of the stimulated Brillouin scattering that, due to its dangerousness in hohlraums developed for inertial confinement fusion applications in the indirect drive scheme, serves as a witness instability.

The compression of direct-drive inertial confinement fusion (ICF) targets is strongly impacted by cross-beam energy transfer (CBET), a laser-plasma instability that limits ablation pressure by redirecting laser energy outward and that is projected to be mitigated by laser bandwidth. Here, we explore various CBET mitigation constraints to guide the design of future ICF facilities. First, we find that the flat, Gaussian, and Lorentzian spectral shapes have similar CBET mitigation properties, and a flat shape with nine spectral lines is a good surrogate for what can be obtained with other spectral shapes. Then, we conduct a comprehensive study across energy scales and ignition designs. 3D hydrodynamic simulations are used to derive an analytical model for the expected CBET mitigation as a function of laser and plasma parameters. From this model, we study the bandwidth requirements of conventional and shock ignition designs across four different energy scales and find that they require between 0.5 and 3±0.2% relative bandwidth. Best mitigation is achieved when the beam radius over critical radius Rb/Rc is kept low during the drive while the plasma temperature is kept high. In a steady state, we find that the bandwidth required to mitigate 85% of CBET scales as (Rb/Rc)2.15Ln−0.58I0.7, where Ln is the density scale length, and I the laser intensity. Finally, we find that the chamber beam port layout does not influence CBET mitigation. In the case of a driver using many monochromatic beamlets, we find that ∼10 beamlets per port is required, with diminishing returns above ∼20.

The direct-drive, laser-based approach to inertial confinement fusion (ICF) is reviewed from its inception following the demonstration of the first laser to its implementation on the present generation of high-power lasers. The review focuses on the evolution of scientific understanding gained from target-physics experiments in many areas, identifying problems that were demonstrated and the solutions implemented. The review starts with the basic understanding of laser–plasma interactions that was obtained before the declassification of laser-induced compression in the early 1970s and continues with the compression experiments using infrared lasers in the late 1970s that produced thermonuclear neutrons. The problem of suprathermal electrons and the target preheat that they caused, associated with the infrared laser wavelength, led to lasers being built after 1980 to operate at shorter wavelengths, especially 0.35 μm—the third harmonic of the Nd:glass laser—and 0.248 μm (the KrF gas laser). The main physics areas relevant to direct drive are reviewed. The primary absorption mechanism at short wavelengths is classical inverse bremsstrahlung. Nonuniformities imprinted on the target by laser irradiation have been addressed by the development of a number of beam-smoothing techniques and imprint-mitigation strategies. The effects of hydrodynamic instabilities are mitigated by a combination of imprint reduction and target designs that minimize the instability growth rates. Several coronal plasma physics processes are reviewed. The two-plasmon–decay instability, stimulated Brillouin scattering (together with cross-beam energy transfer), and (possibly) stimulated Raman scattering are identified as potential concerns, placing constraints on the laser intensities used in target designs, while other processes (self-focusing and filamentation, the parametric decay instability, and magnetic fields), once considered important, are now of lesser concern for mainline direct-drive target concepts. Filamentation is largely suppressed by beam smoothing. Thermal transport modeling, important to the interpretation of experiments and to target design, has been found to be nonlocal in nature. Advances in shock timing and equation-of-state measurements relevant to direct-drive ICF are reported. Room-temperature implosions have provided an increased understanding of the importance of stability and uniformity. The evolution of cryogenic implosion capabilities, leading to an extensive series carried out on the 60-beam OMEGA laser [Boehly et al., Opt. Commun. 133, 495 (1997)], is reviewed together with major advances in cryogenic target formation. A polar-drive concept has been developed that will enable direct-drive–ignition experiments to be performed on the National Ignition Facility [Haynam et al., Appl. Opt. 46(16), 3276 (2007)]. The advantages offered by the alternative approaches of fast ignition and shock ignition and the issues associated with these concepts are described. The lessons learned from target-physics and implosion experiments are taken into account in ignition and high-gain target designs for laser wavelengths of 1/3 μm and 1/4 μm. Substantial advances in direct-drive inertial fusion reactor concepts are reviewed. Overall, the progress in scientific understanding over the past five decades has been enormous, to the point that inertial fusion energy using direct drive shows significant promise as a future environmentally attractive energy source.

Because isolated contaminants on an inertial confinement fusion (ICF) ablator capsule can lead to undesirable instabilities during implosion, it is critical to remove particles from the surface of plastic capsules prior to target assembly. Current National Ignition Facility (NIF) specifications require that the capsule surface contain no particles larger than 30 μm3. We have developed a solvent-based cleaning process in which a combination of wetting and hydrodynamic forces is used to dislodge, entrain, and remove particles from the surface of plastic NIF ICF ablators. The process was conceptualized by considering the adhesive force acting between particles and a surface, the hydrodynamic force acting on particles near a surface, and the effect of solvent on these forces. We also performed experiments that showed that, in addition to utilizing the appropriate solvent and hydrodynamic force, the dwell time and surface coverage of the impinging solvent stream govern particle removal efficiency. The results from this combined approach allowed us to develop the engineering and design parameters for a prototype automated cleaning station for NIF capsules. This station can remove particles at efficiencies high enough to meet ignition cleanliness requirements.

Laser plasma instabilities are problematic for inertial confinement fusion because they can spoil illumination uniformity, reduce laser-target coupling, and create unwanted fast electrons. Recent experiments and simulations have shown that self-seeded stimulated rotational Raman scattering (SRRS) in air might achieve enough spectral broadening to mitigate these instabilities with only moderate unwanted broadening of the focal spot. The theoretical model for the simulations included chaotic broadband and spatially multimode light, but was a scalar formulation suitable for only linear polarization, where the SRRS gains and spectral broadening are limited by Stokes--anti-Stokes coupling. This paper derives a tensor formulation of SRRS theory suitable for modeling spectral broadening of arbitrarily polarized spatially and temporally incoherent light; it then describes the algorithms used to simulate the theory and provides some preliminary results that compare linear and elliptical polarizations. It begins with a paraxial wave equation for an arbitrarily polarized optical field envelope, which is phase modulated by a term proportional to a Raman driven molecular polarizability tensor. Treating the air molecules as rigid rotators, it uses a quantum treatment to derive a driven harmonic oscillator equation for that polarizability, then expresses these vector and tensor equations in terms of the field's right- and left-handed circular polarization components to derive the final coupled equations for arbitrary polarization. The formulation includes possible ac Stark shift contributions, but shows that they are negligible for intensities below $10\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}\mathrm{GW}/{\mathrm{cm}}^{2}$. It then describes the algorithms used in the simulation code and the numerical model of the chaotic light, whose initial spectral bandwidth is broad enough to self-seed the SRRS. In this algorithm, the SRRS process accurately conserves the total energy at each axial plane along the propagation path. Finally, it compares simulations of power spectra and far-field profiles for elliptical vs linear polarization, which show that elliptically polarized light produces significantly more broadening of both profiles than linear polarization. For linear polarization, the SRRS process reduces the incident coherence time from 0.54 to 0.27 ps; for elliptical polarization, it reduces to 0.19 ps. The theory and simulation algorithms presented here provide a framework for evaluating techniques that combine beams of alternating circular polarizations with different spectra and angular divergences to improve SRRS spectral broadening without excessive focal spot broadening.

Currently, laboratory created energy density of laser-driven inertial confinement fusion (ICF) is extremely close to that for ignition, while the divergence between experiment and simulation is increasing. One of the key issues is the lack of advanced knowledge of laser-hohlraum coupling process, which has shown the complexity of hohlraum environment. Optical Thomson scattering (OTS) becomes the standard technique for diagnosing the ICF hohlraum plasma parameters, due to its capability of providing unperturbed, local and precise measurement. The development of OTS in China is closely related with the Shenguang series laser facilities, on which most of the ICF experiments are carried out. In recent years, 4ω(263 nm) Thomson scattering technique has been set up on Shenguang-III prototype and 100 kJ-level laser facility, the corresponding results help the understanding of ICF physics. In the near future, several novel methods will be developed, for high-precision diagnostics of ICF ignition hohlraum plasmas and the research of new physical phenomena.