To the Editor: We thank Ms Kress for her letter to the editor and interest in our article “Respiratory Symptoms Necessitating Spirometry Among Soldiers With Iraq/Afghanistan War Lung Injury (IAW-LI)” (JOEM September 2011).1 In reply to her concerns about “questionable generalizability,” our VA patient population is, in fact, quite similar to the general soldier and veteran population that we would consider generalizing our results with respect to demographic, socioeconomic, and other factors, which could potentially modify the relationship between deployment and the frequency of symptoms requiring spirometry. We did indicate in the article that our finding that the respiratory symptom rate of 14% of soldiers deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan who were seen at the Northport Veterans Affairs Hospital, is very similar to the 14% rate of ALL active-duty US Army soldiers answering surveys for the Millennium Study on whether they have respiratory symptoms while stationed in Iraq.2 Both groups include a subset of (1) those without a prior diagnosis of asthma, (2) who were nonsmokers, (3) graduates of basic training, and (4) fit for active duty and deployment after clearance at Fort Hood, TX. We agree that there are differences in demographics among VA users and non-VA users in the pre-Iraq War 2004 study by other authors cited by Ms Kress; however, our cohort comprises military personnel with Long Island zip codes, a region of relative affluence.3 The reader is incorrect in stating that veterans in our study were living in New York City; our catchment area comprises Nassau and Suffolk Counties of Long Island. Northport is 46 miles from Manhattan. There are separate VA Medical Centers in Brooklyn, Manhattan, and the Bronx not included in the study. We disagree that these VA users in our study had poorer baseline health status compared with nonusers since all were (1) young, (2) healthy, (3) combat-ready graduates of basic training, and (4) deemed fit for deployment prior to their 12-month tour of duty. Rather than having a “lower socioeconomic status and overall poorer health status” as the reader suggests, our patients are self-selected young, healthy Long Island athletes from higher socioeconomic strata drawn to the rigors of military service. Although combat veterans may receive free medical care for any condition related to their service in the Iraq/Afghanistan theatre, first they must qualify for a compensation and pension (C&P) examination, which is conducted by limited numbers of members of the physician staff. Although it may be more likely that veterans deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan are more aware of benefits and may seek out the VA more often than those stationed elsewhere, however, the respiratory symptom rate is not only sevenfold higher among those deployed to Iraq/Afghanistan, but also the rate among stateside troops is extremely low at 1.8%, suggesting that it is an uncommon occurrence to have new-onset respiratory symptoms while stationed stateside. The process upon entering the Northport VA is to check-in with a survey in the Operation Iraqi Freedom/Operation Enduring Freedom/Operation New Dawn (OIF/OEF/OND) clinic. The patient is then assigned a primary care physician outside the OIF/OEF/OND clinic. More than 70% of patients who went to Iraq or Afghanistan in our study were seen in a pulmonary clinic. To get complete pulmonary function tests, a given patient must be seen in pulmonary clinic because only a pulmonary fellow or pulmonary attending can order body box plethysmography (complete pulmonary function tests), and these data are interpreted and signed by both the fellow and the pulmonary attending. We used the pulmonary fellow note to check the values of the scanned in PDF file of complete pulmonary function testing. If there was a standard interpretation of basic spirometry without numerical values, we did not include the patient. The reader says we “do not account for confounding for a variety of established risk factors for respiratory symptoms despite having adequate sample size for multivariable analysis.” We indeed did conduct a multivariable analysis in an earlier version of the article, adjusting for important covariates, such as age, gender, smoking. Even after adjusting for these confounders, smoking, gender, age, and so forth, the effect is still statistically significant though the effect size is slightly lower. Critically important is that there is a subset of nonsmoking soldiers with new-onset symptoms after deployment to Iraq/Afghanistan warranting treatment with medications. The role of smoking as a covariate is complicated, in that it is likely both a confounder and an intermediate in the causal pathway between deployment and incidence of respiratory symptoms. Smoking behaviors change during deployment (increasing in prevalence and intensity, on average). Anecdotally, we understand that many soldiers only smoke while deployed, and many who continue to smoke subsequent to their deployment reduce their cigarette consumption. We are fortunate to have data on smoking status to be able to adjust for confounding by smoking. However, we are not able to distinguish between smoking prior to deployment and during deployment. As such, the analysis, which includes smoking as a covariate, provides an estimate of the effect of deployment on symptoms/spirometry independent of the deployment-smoking-respiratory symptom pathway. Similarly, traumatic brain injury (TBI) and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are intermediates in the causal pathway and are not confounders. Deployment increases the risk of TBI and PTSD, which may lead to respiratory symptoms, since blast overpressure associated with TBI is also associated with lung injury, and PTSD is a risk factor for asthma. We reported very high rates of traumatic brain injury in the article. Surveillance bias is suggested by the reader on the basis of the assumption that health care providers are likely to request additional tests. Referring physicians are licensed physicians and faculty members at Stony Brook University who order tests as they deem necessary. They do not have financial incentives to order more tests. Both groups—Iraq/Afghanistan deployed and those deployed elsewhere—have lung function deficits. We agree with the reader that well-designed, prospective cohort studies of deployment-associated chronic respiratory symptoms and diseases are warranted. Regarding the semantics of lung injury, we note these are previously healthy soldiers without asthma and with athletic performance at the level of basic training, including the ability to run 2 miles. We coined the term of this new-onset clinical syndrome Iraq Afghanistan War lung injury (IAW-LI) because this was particular to deployment, analogous to the initial reports of “World Trade Center Cough.” New-onset respiratory health problems are not limited to those on Long Island. In a recent New England Journal of Medicine article, King et al4 recently published a case series of symptomatic post-Iraq deployment troops from Fort Campbell Kentucky who had constrictive bronchiolitis despite all subjects having normal spirometry. We believe that the rate of lung disease is under-diagnosed in our population because the Northport VA does not have on-site sophisticated testing such as impulse oscillometry, methacholine challenge, cardiopulmonary exercise testing with pre- and postspirometry, exhaustive aeroallergen testing including regional aeroallergens from Iraq and Afghanistan, which may cross-react with antigens in America, and, most importantly, only one soldier has had an open lung biopsy (and was not included in this study), so we would have missed all cases of constrictive bronchiolitis and hypersensitivity pneumonitis in the study by King et al. We thank Ms Kress for interest in our article and the journal editors for the opportunity to clarify concepts. We look forward to conducting more research in this emerging field and reading the work of other investigators. Anthony M. Szema, MD, FCCP Walid Salihi, DO Stony Brook University School of Medicine & Medical Center Veterans Affairs Medical Center Northport, NY Khalil Savary, MD Jacobi Medical Center, Bronx, NY John J. Chen, PhD John A. Burns School of Medicine, University of Hawaii Manoa, Hawaii
Read more