- Research Article
45
- 10.1097/ede.0b013e3182003276
Adjusting for Selection Effects in Epidemiologic Studies
- Jan 01, 2011
- Epidemiology
- Sara Geneletti + 2 more +2
Adjusting for Selection Effects in Epidemiologic Studies
On the causal interpretation of acyclic mixed graphs under multivariate normality
Adjusting for Selection Effects in Epidemiologic Studies
Adjusting for Selection Effects in Epidemiologic Studies
Stable mixed graphs
In this paper, we study classes of graphs with three types of edges that capture the modified independence structure of a directed acyclic graph (DAG) after marginalisation over unobserved variables and conditioning on selection variables using the $m$-separation criterion. These include MC, summary, and ancestral graphs. As a modification of MC graphs, we define the class of ribbonless graphs (RGs) that permits the use of the $m$-separation criterion. RGs contain summary and ancestral graphs as subclasses, and each RG can be generated by a DAG after marginalisation and conditioning. We derive simple algorithms to generate RGs, from given DAGs or RGs, and also to generate summary and ancestral graphs in a simple way by further extension of the RG-generating algorithm. This enables us to develop a parallel theory on these three classes and to study the relationships between them as well as the use of each class.
Read moreBayesian Causal Inference in Probit Graphical Models
We consider a binary response which is potentially affected by a set of continuous variables. Of special interest is the causal effect on the response due to an intervention on a specific variable. The latter can be meaningfully determined on the basis of observational data through suitable assumptions on the data generating mechanism. In particular we assume that the joint distribution obeys the conditional independencies (Markov properties) inherent in a Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG), and the DAG is given a causal interpretation through the notion of interventional distribution. We propose a DAG-probit model where the response is generated by discretization through a random threshold of a continuous latent variable and the latter, jointly with the remaining continuous variables, has a distribution belonging to a zero-mean Gaussian model whose covariance matrix is constrained to satisfy the Markov properties of the DAG; the latter is assigned a DAG-Wishart prior through the corresponding Cholesky parameters. Our model leads to a natural definition of causal effect conditionally on a given DAG. Since the DAG which generates the observations is unknown, we present an efficient MCMC algorithm whose target is the posterior distribution on the space of DAGs, the Cholesky parameters of the concentration matrix, and the threshold linking the response to the latent. Our end result is a Bayesian Model Averaging estimate of the causal effect which incorporates parameter, as well as model, uncertainty. The methodology is assessed using simulation experiments and applied to a gene expression data set originating from breast cancer stem cells.
Read moreA Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) Ensemble Classification Model
In this paper, a hierarchical ensemble classification approach that utilizes a Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) structure is proposed as a solution to the multi-class classification problem. Two main DAG structures are considered: (i) rooted DAG, and (ii) non-rooted DAG. The main challenges that are considered in this paper are: (i) the successive misclassification issue associated with hierarchical classification, and (i) identification of the starting node within the non-rooted DAG approach. To address these issues the idea is to utilize Bayesian probability values to: select the best starting DAG node, and to dictate whether single or multiple paths should be followed within the DAG structure. The reported experimental results indicated that the proposed DAG structure is more effective than when using a simple binary tree structure for generating a hierarchical classification model.
Read moreCombining directed acyclic graphs and the change-in-estimate procedure as a novel approach to adjustment-variable selection in epidemiology
BackgroundDirected acyclic graphs (DAGs) are an effective means of presenting expert-knowledge assumptions when selecting adjustment variables in epidemiology, whereas the change-in-estimate procedure is a common statistics-based approach. As DAGs imply specific empirical relationships which can be explored by the change-in-estimate procedure, it should be possible to combine the two approaches. This paper proposes such an approach which aims to produce well-adjusted estimates for a given research question, based on plausible DAGs consistent with the data at hand, combining prior knowledge and standard regression methods.MethodsBased on the relationships laid out in a DAG, researchers can predict how a collapsible estimator (e.g. risk ratio or risk difference) for an effect of interest should change when adjusted on different variable sets. Implied and observed patterns can then be compared to detect inconsistencies and so guide adjustment-variable selection.ResultsThe proposed approach involves i. drawing up a set of plausible background-knowledge DAGs; ii. starting with one of these DAGs as a working DAG, identifying a minimal variable set, S, sufficient to control for bias on the effect of interest; iii. estimating a collapsible estimator adjusted on S, then adjusted on S plus each variable not in S in turn (“add-one pattern”) and then adjusted on the variables in S minus each of these variables in turn (“minus-one pattern”); iv. checking the observed add-one and minus-one patterns against the pattern implied by the working DAG and the other prior DAGs; v. reviewing the DAGs, if needed; and vi. presenting the initial and all final DAGs with estimates.ConclusionThis approach to adjustment-variable selection combines background-knowledge and statistics-based approaches using methods already common in epidemiology and communicates assumptions and uncertainties in a standardized graphical format. It is probably best suited to areas where there is considerable background knowledge about plausible variable relationships. Researchers may use this approach as an additional tool for selecting adjustment variables when analyzing epidemiological data.
Read moreDirected acyclic graphs in perioperative observational research–A systematic review and critique against best practice recommendations
The Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) is a graph representing causal pathways for informing the conduct of an observational study. The use of DAGs allows transparent communication of a causal model between researchers and can prevent over-adjustment biases when conducting causal inference, permitting greater confidence and transparency in reported causal estimates. In the era of ‘big data’ and increasing number of observational studies, the role of the DAG is becoming more important. Recent best-practice guidance for constructing a DAG with reference to the literature has been published in the ‘Evidence synthesis for constructing DAGs’ (ESC-DAG) protocol. We aimed to assess adherence to these principles for DAGs constructed within perioperative literature. Following registration on the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) and with adherence to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) reporting framework for systematic reviews, we searched the Excerpta Medica dataBASE (Embase), the Medical Literature Analysis and Retrieval System Online (MEDLINE) and Cochrane databases for perioperative observational research incorporating a DAG. Nineteen studies were included in the final synthesis. No studies demonstrated any evidence of following the mapping stage of the protocol. Fifteen (79%) fulfilled over half of the translation and integration one stages of the protocol. Adherence with one stage did not guarantee fulfilment of the other. Two studies (11%) undertook the integration two stage. Unmeasured variables were handled inconsistently between studies. Only three (16%) studies included unmeasured variables within their DAG and acknowledged their implication within the main text. Overall, DAGs that were constructed for use in perioperative observational literature did not consistently adhere to best practice, potentially limiting the benefits of subsequent causal inference. Further work should focus on exploring reasons for this deviation and increasing methodological transparency around DAG construction.
Read moreSimplifying and Characterizing DAGs and Phylogenetic Networks via Least Common Ancestor Constraints
Rooted phylogenetic networks, or more generally, directed acyclic graphs (DAGs), are widely used to model species or gene relationships that traditional rooted trees cannot fully capture, especially in the presence of reticulate processes or horizontal gene transfers. Such networks or DAGs are typically inferred from observable data (e.g., genomic sequences of extant species), providing only an estimate of the true evolutionary history. However, these inferred DAGs are often complex and difficult to interpret. In particular, many contain vertices that do not serve as least common ancestors (LCAs) for any subset of the underlying genes or species, thus may lack direct support from the observable data. In contrast, LCA vertices are witnessed by historical traces justifying their existence and thus represent ancestral states substantiated by the data. To reduce unnecessary complexity and eliminate unsupported vertices, we aim to simplify a DAG to retain only LCA vertices while preserving essential evolutionary information. In this paper, we characterize LCA-relevant and lca-relevant DAGs, defined as those in which every vertex serves as an LCA (or unique LCA) for some subset of taxa. We introduce methods to identify LCAs in DAGs and efficiently transform any DAG into an LCA-relevant or lca-relevant one while preserving key structural properties of the original DAG or network. This transformation is achieved using a simple operator “⊖” that mimics vertex suppression.
Read morePlanning in Intelligent Sensor Fusion
Planning in Intelligent Sensor Fusion
Can we believe the DAGs? A comment on the relationship between causal DAGs and mechanisms
Directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) play a large role in the modern approach to causal inference. DAGs describe the relationship between measurements taken at various discrete times including the effect of interventions. The causal mechanisms, on the other hand, would naturally be assumed to be a continuous process operating over time in a cause–effect fashion. How does such immediate causation, that is causation occurring over very short time intervals, relate to DAGs constructed from discrete observations? We introduce a time-continuous model and simulate discrete observations in order to judge the relationship between the DAG and the immediate causal model. We find that there is no clear relationship; indeed the Bayesian network described by the DAG may not relate to the causal model. Typically, discrete observations of a process will obscure the conditional dependencies that are represented in the underlying mechanistic model of the process. It is therefore doubtful whether DAGs are always suited to describe causal relationships unless time is explicitly considered in the model. We relate the issues to mechanistic modeling by using the concept of local (in)dependence. An example using data from the Swiss HIV Cohort Study is presented.
Read moreMisleading arrows? Fitness landscapes and cancer progression models
Cancer progression models such as Oncogenetic Tress [1], Conjunctive Bayesian Networks [2], or CAPRI [3], try to infer possible restrictions in the order of accumulation of mutations using cancer cross-sectional data. These restrictions would arise from epistatic interactions between mutations. The Directed Acyclic Graphs (DAGs) returned by these methods predict the genotypes that can and cannot be observed. Since fitness landscapes are shaped by those same epistatics interactions and also specify what genotypes are accessible and inaccessible [4] we would expect a close correspondence between a fitness landscape and the DAGs inferred from evolutionary processes in that landscape. I will show here, however, that there is a many-to- many mapping between fitness landscapes and DAGs inferred from cancer progression models. I show that many fitness landscapes cannot be represented by a cancer progression DAG in the sense that no DAG can codify the genotypes that are accessible under that landscape and I propose two measures of “DAG-non-representability”. Next, using 500 different random fitness lanscapes (with 100 begin perfectly DAG-representable) I simulate cancer progression using different mutation rates and sampling regimes; I analyze 20 replicates (of 1000 genotypes) under each condition with CAPRI[3] and CBN[2]. I show that, even under constant mutation and sampling regime conditions, data obtained from the same landscape lead to inferring widely different DAGs (e.g., median Gini-Simpson index of 0.5); this one-landscape-to-many-DAGs phenomenon increases with DAG-non-representability. I also show the one-DAG-to-many-landscapes phenomenon where the same DAG is frequently inferred from very different fitness landscapes (e.g., > 50% difference in accessible genotypes). Finally, I “reverse landscape engineer” the pancreatic cancer data used in [6]: using 190 random fitness landscapes, I show that genotype frequencies similar to the empirically observed one can be obtained under fitness landscapes that are very different from each other and that produce data that lead to the inference of DAGs that are also widely different among themselves (e.g., pairwise difference in edges of DAGs > 50%). I discuss the implications of these results for the interpretation and applied use of cancer progression models. Novelty and significance This paper explicitly establishes a connection between the inference of cancer progression models and the fitness landscapes that condition that cancer progression. It shows there is a many-to- many mapping between them, even under large sample sizes, that can limit their interpretability.
Read moreHigh dimensional sparse covariance estimation via directed acyclic graphs
We present a graph-based technique for estimating sparse covariance matrices and their inverses from high-dimensional data. The method is based on learning a directed acyclic graph (DAG) and estimating parameters of a multivariate Gaussian distribution based on a DAG. For inferring the underlying DAG we use the PC-algorithm and for estimating the DAG-based covariance matrix and its inverse, we use a Cholesky decomposition approach which provides a positive (semi-)definite sparse estimate. We present a consistency result in the high-dimensional framework and we compare our method with the Glasso for simulated and real data.
Read moreNon-negative DAG Learning from Time-Series Data
This work aims to learn the directed acyclic graph (DAG) that captures the instantaneous dependencies underlying a multivariate time series. The observed data follow a linear structural vector autoregressive model (SVARM) with both instantaneous and time-lagged dependencies, where the instantaneous structure is modeled by a DAG to reflect potential causal relationships. While recent continuous relaxation approaches impose acyclicity through smooth constraint functions involving powers of the adjacency matrix, they lead to non-convex optimization problems that are challenging to solve. In contrast, we assume that the underlying DAG has only non-negative edge weights, and leverage this additional structure to impose acyclicity via a convex constraint. This enables us to cast the problem of non-negative DAG recovery from multivariate time-series data as a convex optimization problem in abstract form, which we solve using the method of multipliers. Crucially, the convex formulation guarantees global optimality of the solution. Finally, we assess the performance of the proposed method on synthetic time-series data, where it outperforms existing alternatives.
Read moreSimulation-based evaluations of DAG scheduling in hard real-time multiprocessor systems
The scheduling of parallel real-time tasks on multiprocessor systems is more complicated than the one of independent sequential tasks, specially for the Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) model. The complexity is due to the structure of DAG tasks and the precedence constraints between their subtasks. The trivial DAG scheduling approach is to directly apply common real-time scheduling algorithms on DAGs despite their lack of compatibility with the parallel model. Another scheduling approach, which is called the stretching method, aims at transforming each parallel DAG task in the set into a collection of independent sequential threads that are easier to be scheduled. In this paper, we are interested in analyzing global preemptive scheduling of DAGs using both approaches by showing that they are not comparable when associated with Deadline Monotonic (DM) and Earliest Deadline First (EDF) scheduling algorithms. Then we use extensive simulations to evaluate their schedulability performance. To this end, we use our simulation tool YARTISS to generate random DAG tasks with many parameter variations so as to guarantee reliable experimental results.
Read moreDirected Gaussian graphical models with toric vanishing ideals
Directed Gaussian graphical models with toric vanishing ideals
Self-Stabilizing Construction of a Minimal Weakly ST-Reachable Directed Acyclic Graph
We propose a self-stabilizing algorithm to construct a minimal weakly $\mathcal{ST}$-reachable directed acyclic graph (DAG), which is suited for routing messages on wireless networks. Given an arbitrary, simple, connected, and undirected graph $G=(V, E)$ and two sets of nodes, senders $\mathcal{S} (\subset V)$ and targets $\mathcal{T} (\subset V)$, a directed subgraph $\vec{G}$ of $G$ is a weakly $\mathcal{ST}$-reachable DAG on $G$, if $\vec{G}$ is a DAG and every sender can reach at least one target, and every target is reachable from at least one sender in $\vec{G}$. We say that a weakly $\mathcal{ST}$-reachable DAG $\vec{G}$ on $G$ is minimal if any proper subgraph of $\vec{G}$ is no longer a weakly $\mathcal{ST}$-reachable DAG. This DAG is a relaxed version of the original (or strongly) $\mathcal{ST}$-reachable DAG, where every target is reachable from every sender. This is because a strongly $\mathcal{ST}$-reachable DAG $G$ does not always exist; some graph has no strongly $\mathcal{ST}$-reachable DAG even in the case $|\mathcal{S}|=|\mathcal{T}|=2$. On the other hand, the proposed algorithm always constructs a weakly $\mathcal{ST}$-reachable DAG for any $|\mathcal{S}|$ and $|\mathcal{T}|$. Furthermore, the proposed algorithm is self-stabilizing; even if the constructed DAG deviates from the reachability requirement by a breakdown or exhausting the battery of a node having an arc in the DAG, this algorithm automatically reconstructs the DAG to satisfy the requirement again. The convergence time of the algorithm is $O(D)$ asynchronous rounds, where $D$ is the diameter of a given graph. We conduct small simulations to evaluate the performance of the proposed algorithm. The simulation result indicates that its execution time decreases when the number of sender nodes or target nodes is large.
Read more