- Research Article
6
- 10.1016/j.asr.2007.02.074
OPTIS – A Satellite test of Special and General Relativity
- Jan 01, 2007
- Advances in Space Research
- H Dittus + 3 more +3
OPTIS – A Satellite test of Special and General Relativity
The OPTIS mission is a satellite equipped with a variety of clocks and laser ranging and tracking facilities for performing improved tests of the foundations as well as predictions of special and general relativity. This mission makes advantage of the space conditions of large differences in the velocity and the gravitational potential. Here, we report on recent progress made in the studies of the behavior of the resonator in the field of a gravity gradient.
OPTIS – A Satellite test of Special and General Relativity
OPTIS – A Satellite test of Special and General Relativity
OPTIS—An Einstein Mission for Improved Tests of Special and General Relativity
The mission OPTIS aims at improving tests of the foundations of Special and General Relativity by up to three orders of magnitude. The individual tests concern • the isotropy and • constancy of the speed of light, • the time dilation (or Doppler effect), • the universality of the gravitational redshift with various combinations of high precision clocks. Furthermore, laser tracking and a laser link allows • a strongly improved measurement of the gravitomagnetic Lense–Thirring effect, • of the gravitoelectric Einstein perigee advance, • of the gravitational redshift, and • a search for deviations from Newtonian gravity. For this mission, technologies are required which have been used recently to carry through the most precise tests of Special Relativity. The precision of these tests can be further increased under space conditions thanks to longer integration times, larger changes in the orbital velocity, and larger differences of the gravitational potential. Furthermore, very precise laser tracking and linking of satellites is a well established technique and will provide, in combination with the active drag–free control system, very accurate orbit data. The core technologies for OPTIS are optical cavities, highly stabilized lasers, capacitive gravitational reference sensors, drag–free control, ion clocks, frequency combs, and laser tracking systems. These technologies are also key technologies for other future missions.
Read morePotential observations of false deviations from general relativity in gravitational wave signals from binary black holes
Detections of gravitational waves emitted by binary black holes allow for tests of General Relativity in the strong-field regime. In particular, deviations from General Relativity can be observed by comparing incoming signals to waveform templates that include parametrized deviations from General Relativity. However, it is essential that the General Relativity sector of these templates accounts for all predictable physics. Otherwise, missing physics might be mimicked by the "beyond General Relativity" sector of the templates, leading the analysis to report apparent deviations from General Relativity. Current parametrized tests implement templates that omit physical phenomena such as orbital eccentricity and higher-order modes. In this paper, we show how the omission of higher modes can lead to false deviations from General Relativity when these effects are strong enough. We study the extent of these deviations as a function of the mass ratio and the orbital orientation. We find that significant false deviations can arise when current tests are performed on signals emitted by asymmetric binaries whose orbital angular momentum is orthogonal to the line-of-sight. We estimate that the Advanced LIGO-Virgo network operating at its design sensitivity can observe false violations with a significance above $5 \sigma$ as often as once per year. Similar results are expected for other tests of General Relativity that use modified waveform models. Hence, we stress the necessity of accurate waveform models that include physical effects such as higher-order modes to trust future tests of General Relativity.
Read moreFilozofia w nauce – studium przypadku recepcji szczególnej i ogólnej teorii względności w Krakowie oraz we Lwowie przed rokiem 1925
Setna rocznica sformułowania przez Alberta Einsteina ogólnej teorii względności jest doskonałą okazją do ponownego postawienia pytań o wpływ wspomnianej teorii na filozofię. Interesującą perspektywę oferują badania z zakresu historii nauki i historii filozofii, które pozwalają dokładniej przyjrzeć się procesowi recepcji wspomnianej teorii. Proces ten jest waż- nym źródłem wiedzy o kształtowaniu się relacji nauk przyrodniczych i filozofii, gdyż poprzez analizę wskazywanych trudności i kontrowersji pozwala zidentyfikować wiele ukrytych założeń o charakterze filozoficznym, które trudno dostrzec na innych etapach rozwoju nauki. Dzięki temu analiza procesu recepcji nowych teorii naukowych staje się wyróżnionym przedmiotem analiz relacji matematyki, nauk przyrodniczych i filozofii. Z tych względów warto przyjrzeć się interesują- cym dyskusjom i polemikom, które miały miejsce w obrębie nauki polskiej.Szczególnie interesujące polemiki i dyskusje wokół teorii względności rozegrały się w Krakowie i we Lwowie przed rokiem 1925. Wspomniane ośrodki zostały wybrane również z tego względu, że w początkach XX wieku, wykorzystując możliwości polityczno-kulturalne powstałe w związku z istnieniem stosunkowo szerokiego zakresu autonomii Galicji, stały się one najważniejszymi centrami rozwoju nauki polskiej. Sytuacja ta zadecydowała również o połączeniu wymienionych ośrodków stosunkowo silną siecią powiązań, widocznych szczególnie na gruncie fizyki. W obu miastach powstała również specyficzna (choć z zachowaniem pewnych lokalnych odrębności) odmiana refleksji nad nauką, którą dogodnie jest określić przy pomocy pojęcia „filozofii w nauce” stworzonego przez M. Hellera.Opracowanie rozpoczyna się od krótkiego przybliżenia historii recepcji szczególnej teorii względności w Krakowie. W procesie tym najistotniejszą rolę odegrał August Witkowski, który już w 1905 roku docenił znaczenie pierwszych prac Einsteina. Kolejne punkty zwrotne w procesie recepcji teorii Einsteina wyznaczyły dwa kolejne Zjazdy Lekarzy i Przyrodników Polskich, które odbyły się kolejno we Lwowie w 1907 r. i w Krakowie w 1911 r. Pierwszy z nich zadecydował o popularyzacji idei relatywistycznych pośród przyrodników polskich, a kolejny – o popularyzacji ich wśród filozofów. Dla zrozumienia lokalnej specyfiki filozoficznych rozważań prowadzonych w ośrodku lwowskim odwołamy się do rozwoju recepcji wokół podstaw mechaniki. Zagadnienie to szczególnie mocno interesowało lwowskich uczonych z tej racji, że Lwów był do 1915 roku jedynym polskim ośrodkiem akademickim rozwijającym nauki techniczne i koncentrował w naturalny sposób większość polskich uczonych zajmujących się nauką mechaniki. To właśnie środowiska związane z lwowską Szkołą Politechniczną odegrały ważną rolę w późniejszych dyskusjach wokół szczególnej i ogólnej teorii względności.W dalszej kolejności szkicowo zaprezentowana zostanie lwowska polemika wokół teorii względności i dla kontrastu ukazana zostanie o wiele krótsza polemika rozgrywająca się w Krakowie. Szczególna uwaga zostanie poświęcona dorobkowi Zygmunta Zawirskiego, który w swej działalności podjął problematykę poruszoną w obu ośrodkach i przedstawił najbardziej interesujące rozważania ukazujące nowoczesną wizję filozofii uprawianej w ścisłym kontakcie z naukami przyrodniczymi.Prezentowany styl filozofii w nauce rozwijany w Krakowie i Lwowie został również skrótowo skonfrontowany z konkurencyjnymi filozoficznymi reakcjami na teorie Einsteina: z refleksją rozwijaną w obrębie Szkoły Lwowsko-Warszawskiej (Kazimierz Ajdukiewicz) i z wybraną refleksją neoscholastyczną (Feliks Hortyński SJ, Ludwik Wrzoł SJ, Jan Stepa). Na tym tle lepiej można dostrzec specyfikę filozofii analizowanej w tym studium przypadku – najważniejsze uwagi na ten temat zostały zawarte w zakończeniu niniejszej pracy.Niniejszy artykuł ukazuje fakt, że szczególna i ogólna teoria względności Einsteina znacząco wpłynęły na rozwój refleksji filozoficznej w Polsce. Warto również zaznaczyć, że refleksja filozoficzna stała się w opisywanym okresie ważnym uzupełnieniem pracy naukowej przyrodników, co decyduje również o specyfice rozwoju ówczesnej nauki.
Read moreMATHEMATICAL EXPANSION OF SPECIAL THEORY OF RELATIVITY ONTO ACCELERATIONS
The special theory of relativity (STR) is operationally expanded onto orthogonal accelerations: normal and binormal that complement the instantaneous tangential speed and thus can be structurally extended into operationally complete 4D spacetime without defying the STR. Thus the former classic Lorentz factor, which defines proper time differential can be expanded onto within a trihedron moving in the Frenet frame (T,N,B). Since the tangential speed which was formerly assumed as being always constant, expands onto effective normal and binormal speeds ensuing from the normal and binormal accelerations, the expanded formula conforms to the former Lorentz factor. The obvious though previously overlooked fact that in order to change an initial speed one must apply accelerations (or decelerations, which are reverse accelerations), made the Einstein’s STR incomplete for it did not apply to nongravitational selfpropelled motion. Like a toy car lacking accelerator pedal, the STR could drive nowhere. Yet some scientists were teaching for over 115 years that the incomplete STR is just fine by pretending that gravity should take care of the absent accelerator. But gravity could not drive cars along even surface of earth. Gravity could only pull the car down along with the physics that peddled the nonsense while suppressing attempts at its rectification. The expanded formula neither defies the STR nor the general theory of relativity (GTR) which is just radial theory of gravitation. In fact, the expanded formula complements the STR and thus it supplements the GTR too. The famous Hafele-Keating experiments virtually confirmed the validity of the expanded formula proposed here.
Read moreEinstein’s Mistakes
Science sets itself apart from other paths to truth by recognizing that even its greate practitioners sometimes err.
The Symmetries of Quantum and Classical Information. The Ressurected “Ether" of Quantum Information
The Symmetries of Quantum and Classical Information. The Ressurected “Ether" of Quantum Information
Effect of type II strong gravitational lensing on tests of general relativity
Gravitational wave (GW) observations of binary black hole (BBH) coalescences provide a unique opportunity to test general relativity (GR) in the strong-field regime. To ensure the reliability of these tests, it is essential to identify and address potential sources of error, particularly those arising from missing physics in the waveform models used in GW data analysis. This paper investigates potential biases in these tests arising from strong gravitational lensing, an effect not currently incorporated into the standard framework for GR tests. In the geometric optics approximation, strong lensing produces three types of images: Type I, Type II, and Type III. While Type I and Type III images do not distort the signal, Type II images introduce a characteristic phase shift that can mimic GR deviations for signals with higher-order modes, precession, or eccentricity. We assess the response of four standard GR tests on simulated Type II lensed BBH signals, including the two parameterized tests (TIGER and FTI), the modified dispersion relation test and the inspiral-merger-ringdown consistency test. We focus on precessing waveforms for binaries with total masses of $20M_{\odot}$ and $80M_{\odot}$, and dimensionless spins of 0.5 and 0.95, considering a fixed signal-to-noise ratio of 25 using the design A+ sensitivity of the LIGO-Virgo network. Our findings indicate that more mass-asymmetric and higher-spin binaries show larger false deviations from GR in the TIGER and modified dispersion relation tests when applying GR tests to Type II lensed signals. These results highlight the risk of false GR violations as detector sensitivity improves in future observational runs. Therefore, it is crucial to consider the possibility of strong lensing before drawing conclusions about deviations from GR in GW signals.
Read moreGravitational redshift of galaxies in clusters as predicted by general relativity
The theoretical framework of cosmology is mainly defined by gravity, of which general relativity is the current model. Recent tests of general relativity within the Lambda Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM) model have found a concordance between predictions and the observations of the growth rate and clustering of the cosmic web. General relativity has not hitherto been tested on cosmological scales independently of the assumptions of the ΛCDM model. Here we report an observation of the gravitational redshift of light coming from galaxies in clusters at the 99 per cent confidence level, based on archival data. Our measurement agrees with the predictions of general relativity and its modification created to explain cosmic acceleration without the need for dark energy (the f(R) theory), but is inconsistent with alternative models designed to avoid the presence of dark matter.
Read moreRelativity Theory May not Have the Last Word on the Nature of Time: Quantum Theory and Probabilism
Two radically different views about time are possible. According to the first, the universe is three dimensional. It has a past and a future, but that does not mean it is spread out in time as it is spread out in the three dimensions of space. This view requires that there is an unambiguous, absolute, cosmic-wide “now” at each instant. According to the second view about time, the universe is four dimensional. It is spread out in both space and time—in space-time in short. Special and general relativity rule out the first view. There is, according to relativity theory, no such thing as an unambiguous, absolute cosmic-wide “now” at each instant. However, we have every reason to hold that both special and general relativity are false. Not only does the historical record tell us that physics advances from one false theory to another. Furthermore, elsewhere I have shown that we must interpret physics as having established physicalism—in so far as physics can ever establish anything theoretical. Physicalism, here, is to be interpreted as the thesis that the universe is such that some unified “theory of everything” is true. Granted physicalism, it follows immediately that any physical theory that is about a restricted range of phenomena only, cannot be true, whatever its empirical success may be. It follows that both special and general relativity are false. This does not mean of course that the implication of these two theories that there is no unambiguous cosmic-wide “now” at each instant is false. It still may be the case that the first view of time, indicated at the outset, is false. Are there grounds for holding that an unambiguous cosmic-wide “now” does exist, despite special and general relativity, both of which imply that it does not exist? There are such grounds. Elsewhere I have argued that, in order to solve the quantum wave/particle problem and make sense of the quantum domain we need to interpret quantum theory as a fundamentally probabilistic theory, a theory which specifies how quantum entities—electrons, photons, atoms—interact with one another probabilistically. It is conceivable that this is correct, and the ultimate laws of the universe are probabilistic in character. If so, probabilistic transitions could define unambiguous, absolute cosmic-wide “nows” at each instant. It is entirely unsurprising that special and general relativity have nothing to say about the matter. Both theories are pre-quantum mechanical, classical theories, and general relativity in particular is deterministic. The universe may indeed be three dimensional, with a past and a future, but not spread out in four dimensional space-time, despite the fact that relativity theories appear to rule this out. These considerations, finally, have implications for views about the arrow of time and free will.
Read moreFailure of Einstein's theory of relativity. II. Arguments of Einstein disproving his own theory of general relativity and absurd consequences of relativistic physics
The theory of special and general relativity causes a “schizophrenic” dilemma in physics. It undeniably provides mathematically correct values, but it is undeniably epistemologically wrong in many respects. Including the relativistic explanation of the gravitational “time dilation” and the curvature of light beams at the surfaces of large masses, the author demonstrates the illogical character of relativistic physics. When one thinks the relativistic explanations of gravitational time dilatation and of the curvature of light rays by masses through to the end, they lead to absurd and contradictory logical conclusions.
Read moreCosmic time slip: Testing gravity on supergalactic scales with strong-lensing time delays
We devise a test of nonlinear departures from general relativity (GR) using time delays in strong gravitational lenses. We use a phenomenological model of gravitational screening as a step discontinuity in the measure of curvature per unit mass, at a radius $\Lambda$. The resulting slip between two scalar gravitational potentials leads to a shift in the apparent positions and time delays of lensed sources, relative to the GR predictions, of size $\gamma_{\rm PN}-1$. As a proof of principle, we use measurements of two lenses, RXJ1121-1231 and B1608+656, to constrain deviations from GR to be below $|\gamma_{\rm PN}-1| \leq 0.2 \times (\Lambda/100\, \rm kpc)$. These constraints are complementary to other current probes, and are the tightest in the range $\Lambda=10-200$ kpc, showing that future measurements of strong-lensing time delays have great promise to seek departures from general relativity on kpc-Mpc scales.
Read moreTests of general relativity with gravitational-wave observations using a flexible theory-independent method
We perform tests of general relativity (GR) with gravitational waves (GWs) from the inspiral stage of compact binaries using a theory-independent framework, which adds generic phase corrections to each multipole of a GR waveform model in frequency domain. This method has been demonstrated on Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory-Virgo observations to provide stringent constraints on post-Newtonian predictions of the inspiral and to assess systematic biases that may arise in such parametrized tests. Here, we detail the anatomy of our framework for aligned-spin waveform models. We explore the effects of higher modes in the underlying signal on tests of GR through analyses of two unequal-mass simulated binary signals similar to GW190412 and GW190814. We show that the inclusion of higher modes improves both the precision and the accuracy of the measurement of the deviation parameters. Our testing framework also allows us to vary the underlying baseline GR waveform model and the frequency at which the non-GR inspiral corrections are tapered off. We find that to optimize the GR test of high-mass binaries, comprehensive studies would need to be done to determine the best choice of the tapering frequency as a function of the binary's properties. We also carry out an analysis on the binary neutron-star event GW170817 to set bounds on the coupling constant ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{0}$ of Jordan-Fierz-Brans-Dicke gravity. We take two plausible approaches; the first approach involves translating directly the ``theory-agnostic'' bound on dipole-radiation into a bound on ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{0}$ for different neutron-star equations of state (EOS). The second ``theory-specific'' approach involves reparametrizing the test such that the deviation parameter is ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{0}$ itself. The two approaches provide slightly different bounds, namely, ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{0}\ensuremath{\lesssim}2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ and ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{0}\ensuremath{\lesssim}4\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$, respectively, at 68% credible level. These differences arise mainly since in the theory-specific approach the tidal and scalar-charge parameters are fixed coherently for each neutron-star EOS and mass.
Read moreEffect of Deviations from General Relativity on Searches for Gravitational-wave Microlensing and Type II Strong Lensing
As the gravitational-wave (GW) detector network is upgraded and the sensitivity of the detectors improves, novel scientific avenues open for exploration. For example, tests of general relativity (GR) will become more accurate as smaller deviations can be probed. Additionally, the detection of lensed GWs becomes more likely. However, these new avenues could also interact with each other, and a GW event presenting deviations from GR could be mistaken for a lensed one. Here, we explore how phenomenological deviations from GR or binaries of exotic compact objects could impact those lensing searches focusing on a single event. We consider strong lensing, millilensing, and microlensing, and find that certain phenomenological deviations from GR may be mistaken for all of these types of lensing. Therefore, our study shows that future candidate lensing events would need to be carefully examined to avoid a false claim of lensing where instead a deviation from GR has been seen.
Read moreConstraints and tensions in testing general relativity from Planck and CFHTLenS data including intrinsic alignment systematics
We present constraints on testing general relativity (GR) at cosmological scales using recent data sets and assess the impact of galaxy intrinsic alignment (IA) in the CFHTLenS lensing data on those constraints. We consider CMB temperature data from Planck, the galaxy power spectrum from WiggleZ, weak lensing tomography from the CFHTLenS, ISW-galaxy cross correlations, and BAO data from 6dF, SDSS DR7, and BOSS DR9. We use a parameterization of the modified gravity (MG) that is binned in redshift and scale, a parameterization that evolves monotonically in scale but is binned in redshift, and a functional parameterization that evolves only in redshift. We present the results in terms of the MG parameters $Q$ and $\Sigma$. We employ an IA model with an amplitude $A_{CFHTLenS}$ that is included in the parameter analysis. We find an improvement in the constraints on the MG parameters corresponding to $40-53\%$ increase on the figure of merit compared to previous studies, and GR is found consistent with the data at the $95\%$ CL. The bounds found on $A_{CFHTLenS}$ are sensitive to the MG parameterization used, and the correlations between $A_{CFHTLenS}$ and MG parameters are found to be weak to moderate. For all 3 MG parameterizations $A_{\rm CFHTLenS}$ is found consistent with zero when the whole lensing sample is used, however, when using the optimized early-type galaxy sample a significantly non-zero $A_{\rm CFHTLenS}$ is found for GR and the third MG parameterization. We find that the tensions observed in previous studies persist, and there is an indication that CMB data and lensing data prefer different values for MG parameters, particularly for the parameter $\Sigma$. The analysis of the confidence contours and probability distributions suggest that the bimodality found follows that of the known tension in the $\sigma_8$ parameter. (Abridged)
Read more