• Home
  • Search
  • Owning Data: Semantic Control as Inaccess to Information
  • https://doi.org/10.25148/lawrev.20.3.9Copy DOI Icon

Owning Data: Semantic Control as Inaccess to Information

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

This Article discusses the impacts of the introduction of a data ownership scheme on access to information. It does so with reference to the distinction between data, defined as some representation of information by a specific medium (the syntactic level), and the information itself (the semantic level). With respect to data, it then looks at the difference between standard property rights and intellectual property (IP) rights, similarly assessing impacts on access to information. Private control at the semantic level is bad policy as it effects particularly serious limitations, relative to private control at the syntactic level, on the availability of information in society. IP-type rights similarly effect more serious limitations on the availability of information in society than do standard property rights over data. Focusing on the syntactic-semantic divide to discuss the data ownership case clarifies a few things. First, although there are reasons to be more solicitous of the case for data ownership for data subjects than the case for data ownership for others, there must be an acknowledgment of the fact that the former case often requires data ownership over the information itself. The two premier rationales for granting data ownership to data subjects are that such rights would enable data subjects to protect their privacy, and that it would enable them to claim a share in the benefits of the data economy. This Article points out that any effective attainment of these rationales for data ownership for data subjects requires that data subjects be empowered to exclude others from information even before its collection—that is, even before its representation in syntactic form. This is exclusion power over semantic information. Second, the data ownership for data subjects case is less objectionable in the context of control at the syntactic level as such control is less likely to lead to indirect semantic-level control. By contrast, control at the syntactic level by data collectors creates the problem of indirect semantic control. There is, therefore, no meaningful case for data ownership for data collectors, even at the syntactic level. But the reduced likelihood of indirect semantic-level control in the context of data subjects means that there are sometimes prospects for propertarian rights for data subjects over data being structured to avoid semantic control. What emerges from this understanding is a pattern in which policy supports some syntactic bases for a propertarian remedy for data subjects, but otherwise counsels against data ownership. Finally, those bases for a propertarian remedy over data for data subjects are limited to discrete areas where data ownership for data subjects can be deployed with little, or no, control being exerted at the semantic level, and therefore at little to no cost in public access to information. This is likely to be especially true in the context of standard property as semantic-level control by data subjects is more likely to be a non-issue in this case.

Similar Papers
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

General Provisions of Intellectual Property Rights in Ukraine

  • Nov 17, 2023
  • Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
  • I.I Komarnytska +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations127

Individual Differences in the Acceptability of Unethical Information Technology Practices: The Case of Machiavellianism and Ethical Ideology

  • Oct 01, 2004
  • Journal of Business Ethics
  • Susan J Winter +2
  • Research Article

The Colour of Copyright

  • Jul 01, 2002
  • M/C Journal
  • Margaret Mcdonnell
  • Research Article

The Legal Dilemma of Intellectual Property Protection in Emei Martial Arts and its Mitigation Strategies

  • Dec 05, 2025
  • Law and Humanities
  • Lin Zhu +1
  • Research Article

Osiguranje od odgovornosti za povredu prava intelektualne svojine

  • Jan 01, 2025
  • Tokovi osiguranja
  • Ozren Uzelac +1
  • Research Article

Ensuring Fair Play: Abuse Of Dominance And Intellectual Property Rights Top Of Form Bottom Of Form

  • Dec 20, 2023
  • Journal of Namibian Studies : History Politics Culture
  • Akanksha Tripathi , Dr. S. K. Bose
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

FEATURES AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC COMPONENTS OF THE CONCEPTS “INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY” AND “RIGHT OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY”

  • Apr 30, 2019
  • European Cooperation
  • Oksana Korotiuk
  • PDF
  • Research Article

Intellectual rights of manufacturers of personal protective equipment in the context of national security threats: Between protection of intellectual property rights and the need for open innovation

  • Nov 01, 2024
  • Law. Human. Environment
  • Oleg Makarevych
  • Research Article

Study on Effects of Intellectual Property Rights, Animation and Publication on Trust and National Brand after Conclusion of South Korea-China FTA23) -Analysis on Mediating Roles of Trust-

  • Dec 13, 2016
  • Korean Logistics Research Association
  • Chul-Jung Kim
  • Research Article

Legal and Regulatory Mechanisms of Protecting Intellectual Property (IP) Rights in Sri Lanka: Challenges and Adaptation in the AI Era

  • Jul 03, 2025
  • Trends in Intellectual Property Research
  • Iqbal Saujan
  • Research Article

A Study on the Intellectual Property Rights in the New Media Era and Art Education

  • Mar 01, 2022
  • Society for Art Education of Korea
  • Jaehee Seo
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Administrative legal protection and enforcement of industrial property rights

  • Sep 15, 2025
  • Theory and Practice of Intellectual Property
  • Iryna Koval
  • Research Article

Traditional Knowledge on the Intellectual Property of the Indigenous People of Tenganan Pegringsingan Bali

  • Aug 05, 2025
  • Arena Hukum
  • Emilda Kuspraningrum +2
  • Research Article

СУЧАСНЕ БАЧЕННЯ ПРИРОДИ БЕЗПЕКИ ІНТЕЛЕКТУАЛЬНОЇ ВЛАСНОСТІ ПІДПРИЄМСТВ УКРАЇНИ

  • Jan 01, 2021
  • Law Journal of Donbass
  • Victoria Shekhovtsova
  • Research Article

Analyzing the Litigation Practice Concerned with the Consideration of Intellectual Property Cases in Kazakhstan

  • Mar 31, 2019
  • Journal of Advanced Research in Law and Economics
  • Saule M Demezhanova +2
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.