• Home
  • Search
  • P-225 Trustworthy AI algorithm for embryo ranking
  • Open Access IconOpen Access
  • Cite Icon1
  • https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/dead093.583Copy DOI Icon

P-225 Trustworthy AI algorithm for embryo ranking

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

Abstract Study question Deep-learning algorithms are known to be non-robust: can the variability and inconsistency of AI algorithms be reduced in embryo selection? Summary answer We reduced the variability of algorithms (measured on different tasks like rotations and brightness changes) by 86% while preserving their quality. What is known already Deep-learning methods are generally known to be non-robust, i.e., decisions change with even slight modification of input data. Current solutions for embryo scoring are not robust - for example rotating the input image results in a different score in most solutions on the market. Despite this fact and expressed concerns of embryologists, there are no other publications focusing on the problem of variance in AI solutions used in IVF. Most of the publications measure accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and ROC AUC; there are no variance metrics. Study design, size, duration The data-set was collected within multiple clinics using various devices. It contains 34,821 embryos (4,510 were transferred with known pregnancy results), represented by time-lapse videos or images. This gives 3,290,481 frames of embryos at various maturity levels. From the data-set 925 randomly selected embryos were chosen as a test set. The frames were modified by methods that are not supposed to change the results of the algorithm. We measured the variability of the scores given by our algorithm. Participants/materials, setting, methods We have considered seven different modifications of images that should not influence embryo scoring: • Rotations (10 different angles); • Brightness and Contrast modifications; • Substitutions of Frames (from time-lapse monitoring taken from a 2 hours interval); • Blur (Generalised Normal filter); • Gaussian Noise; • Gaussian Blur; • Sharpening. We used several techniques to reduce variance of our deep neural network model (architecture commonly used for embryo selection): • Ensemble (of different models in cross validation); • Test time augmentation (TTA); • Robust training. Main results and the role of chance In order to measure the variance we have used the following method. First, the scores are stretched to the standard uniform distribution. In other words we look in which percentile the score lies. This way the range of the scores are normalised thus the variance can be compared. Second, we train the EMBROAID model on the augmented data that includes all the above modifications. Third, we compute the variance of the normalised scores on the test set. The mean variance dropped by 86% (0.0055 to 0.0008) across all measured input modifications. The individual drops in the variance on measured input modifications: Rotations: 77% (0.009 -> 0.002), Brightness and Contrast: 81% (0.0036 -> 0.0007), Substitution of Frames: 76% (0.0076 -> 0.0019), Blur 94% (0.012 -> 0.0008), Gaussian Noise: 96% (0.0049 -> 0.0002), Gaussian Blur: 95% (0.0052 -> 0.0003), Sharpening: 77% (0.0015 -> 0.0003). The significance was tested with Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test giving the p-value < 0.01 on all input modifications. Finally, we stress that these results were obtained without any loss in the ROC AUC metric. We have tested the algorithm both on the original test-set. Both models achieved an ROC AUC of 0.66 (CI 0.63-0.69) on both test-sets. Limitations, reasons for caution Further work needs to be done to extend the set of possible augmentations of data. Wider implications of the findings Increased reliability of AI scoring algorithms for embryo selection. It is possible to obtain consistent results over a wide range of data modifications. Trial registration number not applicable

Similar Papers
  • Research Article

민사소송에서의 AI 알고리즘 심사

  • Feb 28, 2023
  • Korea Association of the Law of Civil Procedure
  • 애라 한
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations7

Assessment of Therapeutic Responses Using a Deep Neural Network Based on 18F-FDG PET and Blood Inflammatory Markers in Pyogenic Vertebral Osteomyelitis

  • Nov 21, 2022
  • Medicina
  • Hyunkwang Shin +4
  • Research Article

Assessing workflow impact and clinical utility of AI-assisted brain aneurysm detection: A multi-reader study

  • Jan 01, 2025
  • NeuroImage : Clinical
  • Tommaso Di Noto +11
  • Research Article

Artificial Intelligence in Enhancing High Frequency Trading Strategies

  • Jul 01, 2025
  • Business & Social Sciences
  • Sanjana Ahmed Chaity +1
  • Book Chapter
  • Citations5

Azure Cognitive Services

  • Dec 07, 2017
  • Srikanth Machiraju +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations28

Statistical considerations for testing an AI algorithm used for prescreening lung CT images

  • Aug 22, 2019
  • Contemporary Clinical Trials Communications
  • Nancy A Obuchowski +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations16

Assessment of rapidly advancing bone age during puberty on elbow radiographs using a deep neural network model.

  • Jun 11, 2021
  • European Radiology
  • Kyung-Sik Ahn +12
  • Research Article

Utilization of an integrated artificial intelligence system in the diagnosis of acute ischemic strokes and intracranial hemorrhages: a retrospective study

  • Nov 12, 2025
  • Diagnostic radiology and radiotherapy
  • M Yu Kazieva +4
  • Research Article
  • Citations20

Report of clinical bone age assessment using deep learning for an Asian population in Taiwan

  • Sep 01, 2021
  • BioMedicine
  • Chi Fung Cheng +4
  • Abstract

Predicting Caregiver Burden in Multiple Myeloma: Insights from the Carmma Study Using Machine Learning Models

  • Nov 05, 2024
  • Blood
  • Carlos Costa +23
  • Research Article

An improved dataset for predicting mammal infecting viruses from genetic sequence information

  • Mar 27, 2026
  • PLOS Computational Biology
  • Tyler Reddy +8
  • Research Article

An improved dataset for predicting mammal infecting viruses from genetic sequence information.

  • Mar 27, 2026
  • PLoS computational biology
  • Tyler Reddy +4
  • Research Article
  • Citations4

Hospitalization prediction from the emergency department using computer vision AI with short patient video clips

  • Dec 19, 2024
  • npj Digital Medicine
  • Wui Ip +17
  • Research Article

PD50-06 PERFORMANCE OF A PROSTATE CANCER DETECTION SYSTEM ON IHC-REQUESTED CASES

  • May 01, 2024
  • The Journal of Urology
  • Ramin Nateghi +9
  • Research Article

Abstract PO-076: Unsupervised learning of image embeddings enables new opportunities to extract novel information from digital pathology H&E images

  • Mar 01, 2021
  • Clinical Cancer Research
  • Jason Hipp +5
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.