• Home
  • Search
  • Quantitative comparison between two different methodologies to define rainfall thresholds for landslide forecasting
  • Open Access IconOpen Access
  • Cite Icon67
  • https://doi.org/10.5194/nhess-15-2413-2015Copy DOI Icon

Quantitative comparison between two different methodologies to define rainfall thresholds for landslide forecasting

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Highlights & Summary
  • PDF
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

Abstract. This work proposes a methodology to compare the forecasting effectiveness of different rainfall threshold models for landslide forecasting. We tested our methodology with two state-of-the-art models, one using intensity–duration thresholds and the other based on cumulative rainfall thresholds. The first model identifies rainfall intensity–duration thresholds by means of a software program called MaCumBA (MAssive CUMulative Brisk Analyzer) (Segoni et al., 2014a) that analyzes rain gauge records, extracts intensity (I) and duration (D) of the rainstorms associated with the initiation of landslides, plots these values on a diagram and identifies the thresholds that define the lower bounds of the I–D values. A back analysis using data from past events is used to identify the threshold conditions associated with the least number of false alarms. The second model (SIGMA) (Sistema Integrato Gestione Monitoraggio Allerta) (Martelloni et al., 2012) is based on the hypothesis that anomalous or extreme values of accumulated rainfall are responsible for landslide triggering: the statistical distribution of the rainfall series is analyzed, and multiples of the standard deviation (σ) are used as thresholds to discriminate between ordinary and extraordinary rainfall events. The name of the model, SIGMA, reflects the central role of the standard deviations. To perform a quantitative and objective comparison, these two models were applied in two different areas, each time performing a site-specific calibration against available rainfall and landslide data. For each application, a validation procedure was carried out on an independent data set and a confusion matrix was built. The results of the confusion matrixes were combined to define a series of indexes commonly used to evaluate model performances in natural hazard assessment. The comparison of these indexes allowed to identify the most effective model in each case study and, consequently, which threshold should be used in the local early warning system in order to obtain the best possible risk management. In our application, none of the two models prevailed absolutely over the other, since each model performed better in a test site and worse in the other one, depending on the characteristics of the area. We conclude that, even if state-of-the-art threshold models can be exported from a test site to another, their employment in local early warning systems should be carefully evaluated: the effectiveness of a threshold model depends on the test site characteristics (including the quality and quantity of the input data), and a validation procedure and a comparison with alternative models should be performed before its implementation in operational early warning systems.

Loading PDF

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations306

Calibration and validation of rainfall thresholds for shallow landslide forecasting in Sicily, southern Italy

  • Oct 24, 2014
  • Geomorphology
  • S.L Gariano +7
  • Research Article
  • Citations81

Estimation of rainfall thresholds for landslide occurrences in Kalimpong, India

  • Feb 07, 2018
  • Innovative Infrastructure Solutions
  • Abhirup Dikshit +1
  • Preprint Article

Development of a local impact-based Landslide Early Warning System using physically-based multi-hazards modelling and machine learning in Java, Indonesia.

  • Mar 28, 2022
  • Andy Subiyantoro +7
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations34

Eighty Years of Data Collected for the Determination of Rainfall Threshold Triggering Shallow Landslides and Mud-Debris Flows in the Alps

  • Dec 31, 2019
  • Water
  • Fabio Luino +6
  • Research Article
  • Citations19

Applying rainfall threshold estimates and frequency ratio model for landslide hazard assessment in the coastal mountain setting of South Asia

  • Aug 21, 2023
  • Natural Hazards Research
  • Akhtar Alam +3
  • PDF
  • Preprint Article

Landslide Early Warning in Indonesia: A Gap Analysis

  • Jun 18, 2021
  • Ratna Satyaningsih +5
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations45

Hydrological control of soil thickness spatial variability on the initiation of rainfall-induced shallow landslides using a three-dimensional model

  • May 22, 2021
  • Landslides
  • Rita Tufano +3
  • Preprint Article

Development of a WEB-GIS real-time dynamic landslide risk scenarios procedure – Umbria Region civil protection early warning system, a case study

  • Jul 13, 2016
  • Francesco Ponziani +2
  • Book Chapter
  • Citations4

Defining Physically-Based Rainfall Thresholds for Early Warning Systems

  • Jan 01, 2013
  • Diana Salciarini +3
  • Research Article
  • Citations73

Probabilistic rainfall thresholds for debris flows occurred after the Wenchuan earthquake using a Bayesian technique

  • Dec 11, 2020
  • Engineering Geology
  • Zhuoyan Jiang +6
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations300

Invited perspectives: Hydrological perspectives on precipitation intensity-duration thresholds for landslide initiation: proposing hydro-meteorological thresholds

  • Jan 04, 2018
  • Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences
  • Thom Bogaard +1
  • Preprint Article

Examining flood damage occurrence at the local level as a function of rainfall, based on insurance claims across an urban Mediterranean region

  • Jul 07, 2022
  • Katerina Papagiannaki +7
  • Research Article
  • Citations12

Forecasting Landslides Using Mobility Functions: A Case Study from Idukki District, India

  • Feb 22, 2021
  • Indian Geotechnical Journal
  • Minu Treesa Abraham +2
  • PDF
  • Preprint Article

Effects of earthquakes and antecedent droughts on landslide initiation in Italy

  • Mar 23, 2020
  • Xuehong Zhu +4
  • PDF
  • Research Article
  • Citations27

Adapting the EDuMaP method to test the performance of the Norwegian early warning system for weather-induced landslides

  • Jun 06, 2017
  • Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences
  • Luca Piciullo +4
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.