- Research Article
8
- 10.1016/s2155-8256(23)00033-9
Keeping Healthcare Workers Safe Through Policy Initiatives
- Jan 01, 2023
- Journal of Nursing Regulation
- Nicole Livanos
Keeping Healthcare Workers Safe Through Policy Initiatives
Healthcare workers face escalating violence despite significant security investments, suggesting current approaches miss fundamental causes. We argue that most healthcare violence stems not from individual pathology but from systemic failures-financial barriers, insurance denials, access delays, and administrative complexity-that create volatile patient-provider interactions. Healthcare workers become targets for anger about institutional dysfunctions they cannot control. Current prevention strategies emphasizing individual risk assessment and physical security fail to address these root causes. We propose a research agenda examining connections between system failures and violence, potentially identifying upstream interventions that complement existing security measures while targeting the healthcare dysfunctions driving this epidemic.
Keeping Healthcare Workers Safe Through Policy Initiatives
Keeping Healthcare Workers Safe Through Policy Initiatives
Principles Ensuring Anti-fragility
This chapter first introduces four design principles that together isolate local failures before they propagate and cause systemic failures. It then presents one operational principle to quickly remove exploitable vulnerabilities. Finally, the chapter discusses how a systemic failure can occur in a complex adaptive system even when no parts fail, as well as the need to build models to understand such extreme global behavior.
Read moreThe Shocking Reality of Violence in Healthcare and What We Can Do About It
The Shocking Reality of Violence in Healthcare and What We Can Do About It
Psychopathology in Violent Offenders Against Healthcare Workers.
Workplace violence in healthcare is gradually becoming a major concern in many countries around the world and research has usually been focused on the victims of violence. The aim of this study was to investigate the psychopathology of individuals who commit violence against healthcare workers. The study included 50 subjects (patient or relative of patient) aged 18-65 years who had committed violence against a healthcare worker (study group) and a control group of 55 subjects with no history of violence. A Sociodemographic Questionnaire, Beck Depression Inventory (BDI), Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI), Barratt Impulsiveness Scale (BIS-11), State-Trait Anger Expression Inventory (STAXI), and Eysenck Personality Questionnaire-Revised Short Form (EPQ-RSF) were administered to both the study group and the control group. A psychiatric disorder was diagnosed in 50% of the violent offenders group and in 16.4% of the control group. It was determined that 54.8% of the patient relatives and 44.4% of the patients themselves who committed a violent act against healthcare workers had at least one psychiatric diagnosis and these rates did not differ between the patients and their relatives (χ2 = 0.492, p = 0.483). Comparisons of the scale scores between the groups revealed that the STAXI scores (p < .001), BIS-11 total scores (p < .001), BDI, and BAI scores were statistically significantly higher in the violent offenders group. Considering the higher rates of psychiatric disorders and higher levels of anger and impulsivity among people who commit violent acts against healthcare workers, psychotherapeutic interventions such as stress and anger management interventions, improvement of interaction and communication between patients, their relatives and healthcare workers, and the implementation of rehabilitating punitive programs for violent offenders may be beneficial to reduce the rates of violent behavior against healthcare workers.
Read moreExploring verbal and physical workplace violence in a large, urban emergency department
Exploring verbal and physical workplace violence in a large, urban emergency department
Social worker experience of fatal child abuse; An interpretive phenomenological analysis
This research project is an interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) of the lived experiences of four social work practitioners who have been directly involved in cases of fatal child abuse. The research examines how the tragedies impacted upon the workers in both personal and professional capacities and locates those experiences within the relevant organisational context. The study reveals that all the workers were significantly affected in different ways by the tragedies; however their emotional and support needs were largely ignored by the organisations in which they practiced. The study reveals that following the children's deaths, the support and supervision the social workers received was often inappropriate and inconsistent and the serious case reviews that were undertaken further contributed to the isolation and blame already being experienced by the workers involved. The theoretical analysis within the study relates the workers experiences to Doka's (2002) typology of disenfranchised grief. The study introduces a new concept developed by the author. Termed the personification of systemic failure, this concept highlights how such factors as media responses, organisational culture, working practices and the serious case review system, combine to provide a means by which systemic failures are minimised and ignored in favour of attributing blame to the actions or inaction of individual social work practitioners.
Read moreThe Political Economy of TARP: A Public Opinion Approach
The Political Economy of TARP: A Public Opinion Approach
Cultural Dimensions of Workplace Violence in Healthcare: A Narrative Review
IntroductionWorkplace violence (WPV) against healthcare workers is a global concern, affecting safety, well‐being, and job satisfaction. Cultural factors significantly influence aggression dynamics, making their understanding crucial for targeted prevention strategies.AimThis study aims to identify and analyze the cultural factors contributing to WPV and to explore how these elements influence both aggression dynamics and the effectiveness of strategies for its prevention and mitigation.MethodsA narrative review was conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidelines. Literature searches in PubMed, CINAHL, and Scopus identified studies on cultural dimensions of WPV in healthcare. A thematic analysis synthesized findings.ResultsEight studies were included in the review. The analysis identified four primary cultural dimensions contributing to WPV: (1) Ethnic and linguistic disparities: Healthcare workers from minority backgrounds face higher risks due to language barriers and cultural biases, leading to miscommunication and increased aggression. (2) Female healthcare professionals, particularly in patriarchal or hierarchical workplaces, are disproportionately affected by WPV due to structural power imbalances and gender stereotypes. (3) Sociocultural perceptions of healthcare workers: Patients’ expectations of “unconditional care” can heighten frustration and aggression when unmet, particularly in underfunded or resource‐limited healthcare settings. (4) Cultural normalization and underreporting: In many cultures, WPV is perceived as an inherent part of the profession, discouraging formal reporting and institutional responses.ConclusionCultural factors shape WPV prevalence, reporting, and management. Addressing these factors through culturally competent interventions, language accessibility, gender‐sensitive policies, and institutional reforms is essential for safer workplaces. Future research should standardize WPV prevention strategies integrating cultural awareness and cross‐cultural communication training.Implications for Nursing ManagementNursing management plays a key role in WPV prevention through culturally competent strategies, gender‐sensitive policies, and systemic reforms. Implementing cultural competence training, language accessibility, and zero‐tolerance policies can enhance safety. Strengthening reporting mechanisms and advocating for adequate staffing are crucial steps in mitigating WPV and fostering a safer healthcare environment.
Read moreIndirect exposure to healthcare violence through social media and its impact on healthcare workers’ anxiety: a cross-sectional study
This cross-sectional study aimed to assess the relationship between indirect exposure to healthcare violence through social media and anxiety levels among physicians and nurses in Turkey. Data were collected between September and December 2024 from 301 healthcare professionals (61 physicians, 240 nurses) employed in three private hospitals. The Healthcare Violence Anxiety Scale–Social Media (HVAS-SM), developed and validated within this study, was used. Construct validity was evaluated using exploratory factor analysis, and internal consistency was assessed with Cronbach’s α. Group differences and associations were analyzed using t-tests, ANOVA/Kruskal–Wallis tests, and correlation analyses. The HVAS-SM demonstrated strong psychometric properties (α = 0.928) with a five-factor structure explaining 71.8% of variance. A total of 79.1% of participants reported experiencing anxiety when exposed to healthcare violence news on social media. Anxiety was significantly higher among nurses, single participants, and those with prior exposure to violence. Age, work experience, and job satisfaction were negatively correlated with anxiety. Indirect exposure to healthcare violence through social media is a measurable psychosocial risk. Institutional strategies that focus on building resilience and improving media literacy are therefore necessary.
Read moreRETIRED: A Guide for Health Professionals Working with Aboriginal Peoples: Executive Summary
RETIRED: A Guide for Health Professionals Working with Aboriginal Peoples: Executive Summary
What Determines Healthcare Workers to Seek Professional Psychological Support? A Cross-Sectional Study.
Although healthcare workers often experience significant mental health challenges, their willingness to seek professional psychological help remains relatively low. However, the factors associated with healthcare workers' psychological help-seeking remain unclear. This study aims to identify the determinants of professional psychological help-seeking intention among healthcare workers based on the theory of planned behaviour. Cross-sectional study. A questionnaire, incorporating demographic information and latent variable items, was developed and employed on 403 healthcare workers through online and offline surveys from December 2022 to January 2023 using convenience sampling. Structural equation modelling was applied to test the research hypotheses. The model explained 46.9% of the variance in help-seeking intention. Subjective norm had the strongest total association with help-seeking intention. Attitude towards help-seeking behaviour, subjective norm and perceived behavioural control were directly positively related to help-seeking intention. Moreover, self-stigma, public stigma, perceived barriers and perceived risk were indirectly associated with help-seeking intention mediated by attitude towards the behaviour and perceived behavioural control. Of the four constructs, public stigma showed the most significant indirect relation to behavioural intention. Healthcare workers' intention to seek psychological support is associated with multiple interacting factors, particularly subjective norm and public stigma. Targeted interventions addressing individual and systemic barriers are essential to create a supportive environment for healthcare workers to access mental health services. This study identified key barriers and facilitators to healthcare workers seeking psychological support, which can assist authorities in enhancing mental health services and implementing tailored intervention strategies, thereby promoting help-seeking behaviour among healthcare workers. Moreover, our research reinforces the applicability of the theory of planned behaviour in explaining healthcare workers' intention to seek professional psychological support. No patient or public contribution.
Read moreCauses of Death Abroad: Analysis of Data on Bodies Returned for Cremation to Scotland
The majority of travelers from the UK and Scotland visit Europe, particularly Spain and France, as well as North America, yet surveillance that aids in travel medicine guidance continues to focus on infectious diseases relating to developing countries. Here, we report on causes of death among all bodies returned to Scotland for cremation. Data collected by the Scottish Government on bodies being returned from abroad for cremation was collated for the period 2000 to 2004, and analyzed to identify the cause and location of death among travelers as well as to test the hypothesis that for death due to failure of the circulatory system among Scots there was a significant association between age at death and whether death occurred in Scotland or abroad. Of the 572 deaths reported between 2000 and 2004, 73% occurred in the European region and 10% in the Americas. With respect to the cause, trauma accounted for 20.4%, infectious diseases 1.5%, and other non-infectious causes accounted for 75.5% of deaths. Among the latter, the major cause of death was due to failure of the circulatory system (77.0%). A significant association was observed between death abroad due to failure of the circulatory system and younger age at death for all (χ(2) = 26.9, df = 3, p < 0.001) and for males (χ(2) = 20.7, df = 3, p < 0.001) but not for females (χ(2) = 2.7, df = 1, p = 0.099). The data indicates a low rate of death among Scots traveling abroad, with trauma and other non-infectious causes being the most common cause of death; failure of the circulatory system was the most common cause of death in the latter group. Europe and the Americas were the most common locations of death. Although travel health services should continue to advise travelers to developing countries on infectious disease risks, it is also important that travel health acts as venue for providing key advice and preventative means to all travelers, including those to developed countries. Those agencies, organizations, and companies who deal with travelers along their journey should also engage with travel health experts and practitioners to reduce the risk of adverse outcomes, including death, to travelers.
Read moreAssessing Counter-Terrorism Preparedness in the Hospitality Industry: Evidence from Dusit D2 Hotel, in Nairobi, Kenya
This paper quantitatively assessed employee perceptions regarding the operational counter-terrorism preparedness and the adequacy of mitigation strategies at the Dusit D2 Hotel in Nairobi, following the critical 2019 attack. The research employed a quantitative, cross-sectional design, utilising Stratified Random Sampling to survey 110 employees, achieving an 83.3% response rate from the target sample. Data analysis utilised descriptive statistics and One-Way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) to compare perceptions across three employment cadres: Top Management, Middle Management, and First-level Staff. The findings revealed a critical imbalance in the hotel's security posture. While the organisation shows high confidence in its physical and technological mitigation measures (e.g., Mass Notification Systems and Physical Barriers), its operational readiness is severely undermined by human and procedural deficiencies. The ANOVA results showed a statistically significant difference (p=0.033) in the perceived Overall Operational Preparedness across the employment cadres, confirming a distinct preparedness gradient where confidence diminishes significantly from Top Management to First-level Staff. Further analysis established that an overwhelming 74.0% of all employees deemed the counter-terrorism training to be inadequate, a systemic failure that held true across all hierarchical levels (p=0.331). The study concludes that the hotel's operational resilience is compromised by a critical failure to translate strategic security measures into confident, actionable capabilities among the frontline workforce
Read moreChallenges of Health Care Workers Caring for COVID-19 Patients in a Teaching Hospital, Nepal
Background: When working in Coronavirus Diseases (COVID-19) wards and ICUs, Health Care Workers (HCWs) face numerous physical and psychosocial challenges. The purpose of this study was to look into the difficulties that HCWs face when caring for COVID-19 patients. Method: A qualitative phenomenological study was used, and the study sample included 12 HCWs (8 nurses and 4 doctors) who worked specifically with COVID-19 patients. A semi-structured interview guideline was used for data collection, and Giorgi's method was used for analysis. Results: During the pandemic, HCWs faced numerous challenges while caring for COVID-19 patients in a hospital. HCWs faced five major challenges: (i) increased workload and staff shortages, (ii) mental stress, (iii) social stigma and isolation, (iv) resource scarcity, and (v) a lack of specific skill training. Conclusion: While caring for COVID-19 patients during the pandemic, health care workers faced numerous physical, psychological, and social challenges. As a result, these issues must be addressed in order to provide quality care in the hospital.
Read moreComparative tuberculosis risk in healthcare and educational workers: occupational synergy.
Healthcare workers (HCWs) face higher tuberculosis (TB) risk from occupational exposure. Whether their risk exceeds that of nonclinical institutional workers when matched on key factors is unclear. We compared HCWs with educational workers in South Korea while controlling for age, sex and TB infection (TBI). A retrospective cohort was conducted using national TBI screening data linked with the Korean National Health Insurance Service (NHIS) and TB Surveillance System. After 1:1 propensity score matching on age, sex and interferon-γ release assay (IGRA), 203 959 HCWs and 203 959 educational workers were included. Cox proportional hazards models estimated adjusted hazard ratios (aHRs) for TB incidence for at least 2 years. Additive interaction between IGRA positivity and healthcare employment was assessed. TB incidence was highest in untreated IGRA-positive HCWs (245.5 per 100 000), whereas untreated IGRA-positive educational workers had a lower incidence of 77.0 per 100 000. Among IGRA-positive participants, untreated HCWs had a significantly higher risk of developing TB than untreated educational workers (aHR 2.18, 95% CI 1.56-3.06). Even IGRA-negative HCWs demonstrated elevated risk compared with IGRA-negative educational workers (aHR 1.76, 95% CI 1.10-2.83). HCWs are at elevated risk of TB incidence, even after adjusting for infection status and demographics, most likely reflecting ongoing occupational exposure during follow-up. The simultaneous presence of two risk factors, employment in healthcare and IGRA positivity, substantially increased the incidence of TB. These findings highlight the need for targeted infection control, improved TBI treatment adherence and early detection strategies in healthcare settings.
Read more