• https://doi.org/10.1007/s12262-012-0455-2Copy DOI Icon

Review Article: A Critique

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

Dear Editor, I read the review article ‘Principles of Physics in Surgery: The Laws of Flow Dynamics Physics for Surgeons—Part I’ by Srivastava et al. [1] in July–August 2009 issue, pages 182–187 with great interest. The authors have very well summarized the various laws of physics applicable to haemodynamics. I am a regular reader of the Indian Journal of Surgery, but the publication of this ‘Review Article’ raises certain issues, which I believe should be considered by the editorial board. The title of the article gives an impression as if the laws of physics cited are applicable only to surgery. On the contrary, the authors could have used the word ‘Medical Science’ rather than surgery, because these laws are applicable to haemodynamics with which all clinical specialties have to deal with and not only surgeons. The article is nothing but a summary of well-established facts and chapters published in various text books of physics and physiology. A look at the reference list clearly brings this to light: Of the 17 references, 11 are textbooks and 6 of these are from only two textbooks [2, 3]. I wish to bring forth the fact, that the laws and their applications summarized are taught to undergraduate (MBBS) medical students during their first year of graduation, and hence it is difficult to believe that surgeons are unaware of these basic principles and a review article is required. A review article should not be just a mere presentation of facts that are well documented. It’s hard to believe that a journal like Indian Journal of Surgery has published nothing more than textbook knowledge as a review article. This letter should be viewed as a healthy comment for the growth and betterment of Indian medical journals in general.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Intelligent computational techniques for physical object properties discovery, detection, and prediction: A comprehensive survey

  • Dec 13, 2023
  • Computer Science Review
  • Shaili Mishra +1
  • PDF
  • Research Article

Comparative analysis of perceived medical school stress among freshman & graduate year senior students

  • Dec 10, 2019
  • Annals of Psychophysiology
  • Farhat Minhas +5
  • Research Article

Trends in publications of review of literature in forensic journals: A five years retrospective study

  • Sep 09, 2025
  • Indian Journal of Forensic and Community Medicine
  • Mohammad Abdurrahman Khan +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Investigating the adequacy of physics textbooks used in Nigeria secondary schools for conceptual understanding with new physics curriculum in view

  • Apr 19, 2018
  • AFRREV STECH: An International Journal of Science and Technology
  • Joy Nkiruka Chukwunenye +2
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Prevalence and associated factors of obsessive compulsive symptoms among under graduate medical and health science students in Dilla university, Ethiopia: a cross-sectional study

  • Apr 15, 2025
  • BMC Psychiatry
  • Derebe Madoro +4
  • Supplementary Content

Cytoskeletal prestress homeostasis is a biological principle that governs living cell structure and function

  • Mar 03, 2026
  • Mechanobiology in Medicine
  • Fazlur Rashid +1
  • Front Matter

Author Guidelines Are Here!

  • Dec 22, 2007
  • Journal of the American Dietetic Association
  • Linda Van Horn
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Editorial: Twenty‐Five Years Later…

  • Dec 23, 2012
  • Electroanalysis
  • Joseph Wang
  • PDF
  • Research Article

Cinematic Time-Space

  • Aug 01, 2019
  • New Media and Mass Communication
  • Cedric Vaneenoo
  • Front Matter
  • Citations4

Medical science, medical services and medical education.

  • Jan 01, 1980
  • Medical education
  • Research Article

General Variational Principle, General Noether Theorem, Their Classical and Quantum New Physics and Solution to Crisis Deducing All Basic Physics Laws

  • Nov 13, 2024
  • Advances in Theoretical & Computational Physics
  • Changyu Huang +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Physical Laws and Human Behavior: A Three-Tier Framework

  • Jul 18, 2020
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • Shabnam Mousavi +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations7

Magnitude of behavioural risk factors for cardiovascular diseases among college going young adults (18-25 years) in Mysuru, Karnataka, India

  • Dec 21, 2016
  • International Journal Of Community Medicine And Public Health
  • Lakshmi Malavika Nair +4
  • Book Chapter

Comments on “Concepts of Function and Mechanism in Medicine and Medical Science” and “Organs, Organisms and Disease”

  • Jan 01, 1975
  • Patrick A Heelan
  • Research Article
  • Citations3

A Discussion on an Expression Written About Dimensional Analysis in a Physics Textbook

  • Sep 15, 2015
  • European Journal Of Physics Education
  • Ali Yıldız
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.