Feasibility of creating an enriched environment and subsequent impact on activity levels for stroke patients in an acute stroke unit
Individuals with stroke in an acute stroke unit spend the majority of their day inactive and alone. There is strong evidence that greater physical activity, and emerging evidence that greater social and cognitive activity after stroke promotes functional recovery. One approach found to increase activity levels in all these activity domains following stroke is an enriched environment, which is an intervention designed to stimulate physical, social and cognitive activity. The enriched environment is well investigated in animal models post stroke and refers to housing conditions that are designed to stimulate motor and sensory functions, as well as social and cognitive activity. Evidence has shown that rodents recovering within an enriched environment starting 24-hours post stroke showed greater functional recovery than recovery in standard housing conditions. The first clinical translation of an enriched environment was undertaken in the subacute inpatient rehabilitation setting, which showed that individuals with stroke (n=14) undergoing enriched rehabilitation were 1.2 times more engaged in ‘any activity’ as compared to no enrichment. However, the enriched environment has not yet been explored in an acute stroke unit. Thus, the primary aim of this thesis was to investigate whether an enriched environment embedded in an acute stroke unit could increase activity levels in physical, social, cognitive and combined activity domains across individuals with acute stroke.Study 1 examined the effect of embedding an enriched environment in an acute stroke unit on activity levels using a controlled before-after observational design. Activity levels were observed in a control group receiving usual care, and subsequently in a group who recovered in an enriched acute stroke unit. The enriched environment focused on three key areas: 1) creating a stimulating environment including communal areas for eating, socialising and group activities, and provision of resources throughout the ward and at the patient bedside; 2) involvement of patients and families to increase activity outside therapy hours, and 3) using change management strategies to support staff to implement the enriched environment within existing staffing levels. Behavioural mapping was used to determine the primary outcome measure ‘any’, physical, social and cognitive activity. Participants were observed every 10-minutes from 7.30am till 7.30pm on weekday and weekends. We found that the enriched group (n=30) spent a significantly greater proportion of their day engaged in ‘any activity’ (p=0.005), physical (p<0.001), social (p=0.007) and cognitive activity (p=0.002) as compared to the control group (n=30). Furthermore, the enriched group spent a lower proportion in a supine position, in their room and being alone. The secondary aims were to explore the impact of an enriched environment on functional outcomes, adverse events and length of stay. No differences between groups were found for functional outcomes at discharge from the acute stroke unit and at 3-months post stroke. The enriched group experienced fewer adverse events (p=0.001) and a shorter length of stay (p=0.02).In study 2, the aim was to determine if increased activity levels were sustained 3-months after completion of the before-after pilot study. After completion of study 1, the environmental enrichment was continued in the acute stroke unit, but change management strategies to support staff were withdrawn. Thirty stroke patients were recruited to the sustainability group. Increased patient activity levels were sustained 6-months post implementation of the enriched environment.In study 3 the impact of the enriched environment on timing and nature of activity levels, and the amount of staff assistance provided to patients to undertake activities was examined. We specified time periods to determine the effect of enrichment strategies on activity levels. Activity was significantly increased during periods of scheduled communal activity, weekday hours outside scheduled activity and weekends, but no effect was observed on weekdays after 5pm. Specific activities, which increased significantly, included upper limb, communal socialising, listening and iPad activities. No difference in amount of staff assistance was observed during activities.In study 4, nursing and allied health professionals (n=10) were interviewed to evaluate their perceptions and experiences while working in an enriched environment. Thematic analysis showed that staff perceived the enriched environment to make a positive contribution to recovery after stroke and that interdisciplinary teamwork was more visible. Staff surveys supported this view. In addition, staff experienced that change management strategies were critical to not relapse into old work routine. Brief patients and carers surveys showed that consumers appeared to be positive towards the enriched environment in the acute stroke unit.Taken together, these studies demonstrated that embedding an enriched environment into an acute stroke unit was feasible, significantly increased activity levels in individuals with stroke and activity levels were sustained 6-months post implementation. Furthermore, staff perceived that the enriched environment made a positive contribution to patient recovery after stroke. The promising results of an enriched environment in an acute stroke unit warrant larger studies to determine our ultimate goal: can an enriched environment result in greater functional recovery after stroke.
Read more