PROTOCOL: A systematic review of mobile device use in the primary school classroom and its impact on pupil literacy and numeracy attainment
Children today are born into a world surrounded by technology. For this "i-Generation" (Twenge, 2017), most aspects of daily life can be conducted online, including socialising, shopping, learning and engaging with the world around them, and the lines between the online and offline life are becoming increasingly blurred. OFCOM, (2019) reports that 82% of 5–7-year-olds go online regularly, averaging 9.5 h per week, while for 12–15-year olds, 99% go online regularly, averaging 20.5 h per week. This increasingly technological world has influenced educational practice, with the use of technology in classrooms evolving from desktop computers, to interactive whiteboards, to the more recent use of tablets and other mobile devices to deliver the school curriculum. A recent development (UNCRC, 2021) has seen the Convention on the Rights of the Child adopt General Comment 25 which recognises children's rights in the digital world. This includes children's right to the educational benefits that technology can bring, and places responsibilities on States to ensure schools are equipped with the infrastructure, knowledge and skills to support this. Access to technology in the classroom is increasing, however remains disparate across the globe. OECD (2015) reported that in 2012, 72% of 15-year-olds in OECD countries use a computer, laptop or tablet at school (unchanged from 2009), although usage in some countries was as low as 50%. The latest OECD (2020) figures report a global average of almost one computer for every 15-year-old pupil, with variation between 1.25 computers per pupil in countries such as UK or United States, and 0.25 computers per pupil in countries such as Brazil or Greece. While these figures do not reflect practice in primary-aged schools, they give some idea of the scale of usage and the potential impact for children and young people around the world. For this reason, the role and impact of technology in the classroom has been a growing area of interest for researchers, spanning topics including the impact on educational outcomes (such as reading, numeracy attainment and critical thinking) (e.g., Bebell & Pedulla, 2015); classroom interaction and pupil motivation to learn (e.g., Campbell & Jane, 2012; Ciampa, 2014) and teacher skills and attitudes to technology (e.g., Ciampa & Gallagher, 2013; Lincoln & Barney, 2017). As technology has advanced, so too has the range of classroom activities it can be used for. Technology can be used to enhance and support teacher presentation, or can directly engage each child with an individual device or in groups. The integration of technology with pedagogical approaches is therefore of critical importance. Baskerville (2012); Grieffenhagen (2004); Murcia (2014), and others, have considered the ways in which technology can be used to enhance and indeed transform pedagogy, rather than to deliver the same activities with new tools (e.g., a teacher writing a question on a blackboard versus writing it on an interactive whiteboard—the activity has not changed, just the means by which it is presented). The most recent technological advances, specifically mobile devices, provide an unprecedented opportunity for transformative pedagogy. While tablet-style computers have been available since the early 2000s, the introduction of the user-friendly and innovative Apple iPad in 2010, closely followed by similar tablets of other brands, made these tools more accessible to the wider population. Children are particularly skilled in the use of mobile devices from an early age; OFCOM (2019) report that 58% of 3–4-year olds, and 76% of 5–15-year olds use a tablet device regularly, while just under half of 5–11-year olds own one of their own. Additionally, while only 35% of 7–11-year olds own a smartphone, this figure has been steadily rising (from 24% in 2015). Research by the British Educational Suppliers Association (BESA, 2015) found that 71% of UK primary schools surveyed reported using tablets in the classroom. This was a significant increase from the previous year, with figures predicted to rise significantly by 2020. More recently, and as individual ownership of tablets and indeed smartphones rises, "bring your own device" policies are beginning to be seen across schools to harness the resource now available in pupils' own pockets. The intuitive nature of tablets and smartphones, coupled with affordability and the potential to "bring your own", make them ideally placed to influence traditional teaching methods. The NMC Horizon Report K-12 Edition (Johnson et al., 2014) identified such "intuitive technology" as having the potential to significantly impact educational practice over the next 5 years. Children now learn through game-playing, use the endless body of information available to research topics of interest, and are adept at recording, editing and presenting videos as part of the ordinary school day. Literacy and numeracy are a central focus of primary education, and not only provide the tools through which a child can engage in wider curricular subjects, but also have far-reaching application across the life-course. Indeed, research by the National Literacy Trust (Clark & Teravainen-Goff, 2018) shows that children who are more engaged with literacy have better mental wellbeing. Yet the National Literacy Trust website also reports that 16.4% of adults in England, 26.7% in Scotland, 17.9% in Northern Ireland and 12% in Wales have "very poor literacy skills", while OECD (2016) finds that UK young adults (age 16–24) have lower basic literacy and numeracy skills than young adults in many other countries. The 2018 round of PISA tests (OECD, 2019), designed to assess reading, science and maths skills of 15 year-olds globally, show the UK moving up the rankings in maths (18th, up from 27th in 2016) and in reading (14th, up from 22nd in 2016), yet still falling below many other countries. It is clear that a focus on literacy and numeracy must be a priority for primary age children. Mobile devices are one way in which teachers in primary schools are enhancing literacy and numeracy education, and there is a general feeling amongst teachers that this is a positive development. The National Literacy Trust (Picton, 2019) surveyed 219 teachers across the UK, and found that just under 60% believe technology can help pupils to overcome learning barriers, and over three quarters feel technology should be available for pupils right across the curriculum to support their literacy development. However despite this belief, trends in technology access and training do not follow. Just under half of the sample of teachers stated that their pupils had access to technology (either laptops or tablets) in the classroom, around 20% of teachers said they never use technology to support literacy, and a quarter reported never having had training to make use of technology to support literacy. Similarly, BESA, 2015 reported that 34% of schools felt their technology implementation was poor, citing an ineffective infrastructure and lack of adequate training and support as barriers. Given the rapid increase in use of mobile devices in the classroom, it is critical that teachers are adequately equipped with the skills, resources and guidance to enable them to effectively and safely embed such mobile technology within pedagogy. Ultimately, this technology must benefit pupils and support learning. The OECD (2015) report also found that those countries reporting heavy investment in technology in schools demonstrated no significant improvement in reading, writing or maths. While mobile device usage in the classroom continues to grow, its application therefore remains an area of uncertainty, particularly in terms of the impact on pupils' educational experience, and, critically, learning outcomes and attainment. It is important that we can identify what works, for whom, and why. For this reason, this systematic review of existing research on mobile devices in the classroom (specifically tablet devices, smartphones and handheld games consoles), and their impact on attainment, is timely, with an important contribution to make towards ensuring that future developments across educational policy and practice, and in the professional development of educational practitioners, are informed by evidence of good practice. There are three key elements for consideration in how mobile technology is used in the primary school classroom: Devices Activities Outcomes A logic model has been developed to demonstrate how these key components interact (see Figure 1). The most common mobile devices used in schools are tablet computers. On first introduction, Apple was the device of choice in US schools, reporting a 95% education market share (Apple, 2013), and while Apple remains the market leader in tablet sales with 36.5% of sales (International Data Corporation, 2020), advances from other brands using Android or Chrome operating systems, and producing less expensive devices, have seen Apple market share in education drop (Futuresource Consulting, 2019). Smartphones are less commonly used in schools; indeed, there is ongoing discussion in the media as to whether children should be permitted to bring such devices to school. In late 2018, the French government passed legislation to ban children and young people (up to age 15) from using their phone in the school grounds during the school day. This move has prompted much debate; those in agreement with this approach feel it addresses concerns such as cyber-bullying and distraction from studies. Research from the London School of Economics is commonly cited; Beland and Murphy (2015), reviewed exam results following mobile phone bans in schools across England and found not only an improvement in results, but a more significant improvement for those pupils from disadvantaged backgrounds, therefore contributing to a reduction in educational inequalities. Yet the increase in children's ownership of mobile devices undoubtedly presents an opportunity for schools. As ownership of smartphones and tablets increases among children, schools are now considering how they can harness the opportunities presented by children having an Internet-enabled device in their own pockets (e.g., Rae et al., 2017). Such "Bring your Own Device" approaches also bring challenges, with online safety, appropriate behaviour policies, infrastructure capacity and ensuring equality of access only some of the necessary considerations. For the purposes of this systematic review, the focus will be on mobile devices. These are defined as handheld computing devices, including: tablet computers of varying sizes (iPad and other brands) smartphones (defined as those with a touch screen interface which can connect to the Internet) small handheld games consoles, such as a Nintendo Switch or Nintendo 2DS (again, with a touch screen or integrated buttons and can connect to the Internet or have games loaded). Within the classroom, the mobile devices will either directly access the Internet, or make use of device applications ("apps") or inbuilt device functions. While overall, the functionality of these different types of mobile devices will be similar, the screen size of a tablet is likely to be larger than on smartphones or games consoles. Tablets are typically anything between 7 and 10 inches, with some of the more professional models measuring up to 12 inches, while smartphones range in size from 3 to 6.5 inches. There is some evidence that screen size may impact effectiveness, depending on usage. Alghamdi et al. (2014) found that it took longer to read the same information on a small screen than a larger one, however there was no difference in information understanding or retention, while Albó et al. (2019) found there was less opportunity for pupils to collaborate on a small smartphone when used in class, as compared to a larger tablet. Mobile devices have applicability right across the curriculum, and can be used in any number of ways, both individually by pupils or in groups. There are also many ways in which the teacher can use mobile devices to support his or her teaching, however these will not be included within the scope of this review. From a brief review of relevant publications, a summary of potential usage and types of activities is included below. Researching topics of interest Watching instructional videos Taking and editing photographs or videos. Undertaking formal tests or informal quizzes In any discussion on the impact of mobile device usage in the classroom, the activities undertaken, and the context in which they occur, rather than the device itself, are the important factors. Given the breadth of potential activities, researchers and practitioners have sought a framework to help classify and therefore compare activities. One such model is the SAMR model, developed by Puentedura (2006) (Figure 2). The SAMR model compares activities undertaken using technology with the everyday activities they are replacing (e.g., reading an e-book rather than a paperback), and asks what the use of technology has added to the learning experience. Puentedura proposes four levels of activity: Substitution: Technology is used in substitution for the usual classroom tools or activities, for example, reading an online textbook rather than a paper copy. Augmentation: Technology substitutes for the usual tools however also improves function slightly, for example, a computer word processor used to write an assignment, therefore allowing for inclusion of pictures or diagrams. These are both considered to enhance pedagogy; Modification: Technology allows for an activity to be undertaken significantly differently, for example, accessing the Internet to independently research content for an assignment. Redefinition: Technology allows for new, previously unachievable activities to be undertaken, for example, creating a multimedia assignment using video, audio and other creative tools. These are both considered to transform pedagogy. Puentedura (2013) emphasises that in practical terms, the model should be seen as a spectrum along which classroom activities sit, and proposes that for true transformation of learning, activities using technology should aspire towards redefinition of pedagogy, rather than simply substituting one activity for another. Geer et al. (2017) also note that as mobile devices were not primarily designed as tools for an educational setting, effort will be needed to adapt them to and embed them within existing pedagogy. The SAMR model has duel purpose. While it contributes to the implementation discussion, it has been criticised for its focus on the technology and activities and ignoring wider modifiers such as teacher knowledge and attitudes, pupil skills and knowledge, and wider dynamics within the classroom (Hamilton et al., 2016). More commonly, SAMR is used as a practice framework to describe and categorise activities, and is increasingly being used to influence good practice and to support teaching professionals in their efforts to transform the pupil experience, informing the types of activities undertaken. A number of teaching websites and resources have sought to provide examples of how the SAMR model can be embedded in practice, and the types of activities that might reflect transformation rather than enhancement. TES, a global online resource for teachers and other educational professionals, highlights the model and the potential benefits in the classroom, and provides a number of resources to support teachers in embedding the approach. To encourage thinking around the model in real terms, Puentedura (2013) proposed a number of questions for educators to ask when introducing new technology or a new activity using technology. Has the original task been modified? How? Does the modification fundamentally depend on the new technology? What is the new task? Will any portion of the original task be retained? How is the new task uniquely made possible by the new technology? Numerous researchers interested in technology use in the classroom have used the SAMR framework to categorise activities taking place (e.g., Fabian & Topping, 2019; Geer et al., 2017). In this systematic review, the SAMR model will be used during the coding stage to classify activities undertaken within interventions in the selected studies, therefore bringing some homogeneity to what is expected to be a diverse range of activities. Research on the impact of technology in the classroom takes one of two approaches, either focused on the direct impact on pupils' learning outcomes, specifically academic achievement across a range of subjects and measures (primary outcomes), or on the impact that technology has on the teaching environment and pupils' classroom experience, for example, on motivation to learn, engagement, or collaboration with classmates (secondary outcomes). Improvements in secondary outcomes may in turn lead to improvement in primary outcomes. The Education Endowment Foundation (EEF, 2019) reports extensive evidence of "moderate learning gains" when technology is integrated in teaching across a wide range of subjects and age groups, resulting in an additional four months progress on average (EEF "toolkit for teaching and learning" calculations based on impact, cost and strength of evidence). However, EEF conclusions suggest that the type of technology, and the way in which it is integrated within the classroom, vary widely. Outcomes of interest in this review: this review aims to identify and synthesise evidence on the impact that mobile devices have on pupil attainment in terms of literacy and numeracy development, given their wide-ranging implications for all areas of education and wider life. Early literacy development usually focuses on speaking and listening, before moving onto reading and writing. In supporting children's literacy, there are various components on which the primary school curriculum focuses. The Rose Review (2006), an independent review of the teaching of early reading, carried out on behalf of the Department for Education and Skills, highlighted the need for the systematic teaching of phonics within primary education as a key building block of literacy. This is backed up by a growing body of research, as summarised by the Education Endowment Foundation (2019) Teaching and Learning Toolkit. Other key elements of literacy include vocabulary and spelling, grammar, comprehension (as spelling and grammar knowledge increase), and building fluency, as defined in primary-level curricula (such as the Northern Ireland Primary Curriculum set by the Council for the Curriculum, Examinations and Assessment (CCEA, 2016); or the National Curriculum for England, set by the Department for In the same curricula for early numeracy education focus on such as basic number and and these are usually through activities. these are teaching on to common such as and to application of numeracy skills through such areas as and The Northern Ireland Primary Curriculum highlights the need for children's skills to be to everyday and across the curriculum. The elements of literacy and numeracy will be in terms for this review. A rapid review of a sample of shows that for children in the researchers have a common interest in in numeracy and literacy attainment. The following research examples demonstrate the range of activities undertaken, outcomes of interest, measures and and (2014) compared the on of children Internet to research their before writing. pupils within a school were to one of three a as Internet and one Internet or two three by on Internet followed by independent Internet research were by independent using a developed by the Department of which a from to across three of to and an and and spelling, et al. used a to how a maths tablet training might basic for pupils (age in the and pupils across schools were to one of four reading activities one maths training per tablet and two per maths an additional 10 per on activities to their A of tests and school tests were including the et al., which measures and the et al., which measures and and National for a which measures and A number of potential were considered in this including pupil and et al. (2017) used a and to the of a literacy on primary school in The is at building reading and writing skills in either for or those for is not their first A number of and measures were such as Assessment and a measuring such as word reading, comprehension and in reading and the Literacy teacher designed specifically for the The researchers also usage from each individual pupil over the of the to the The focus of this review is on the use of mobile devices in the classroom. Children using the devices will therefore be between four and Given the age there will be a wide in the types of the and and the aims and potential outcomes. The use of the SAMR model to classify the types of activities that might be undertaken and what they can to existing has been There have also been a number of proposed which can help to how digital interventions might to positive learning outcomes. of these are below. has a central role in early and primary education with a body of research the of in learning, from through to interventions can make learning more creating a positive towards a (e.g., and enhancing of learning et al., and Geer et al. (2017) report that teachers found tablets to to learning, with pupils more in of their learning than traditional teaching have This allows to learn at their own teachers to provide one to one support needed and allowing more pupils to move on to more a common focus of research is the role of mobile devices in motivation to learn, which can give pupils a more positive to school help them engage more in and in turn to academic achievement & 2015). with motivation should provide be being the and provide an of with or one & The use of mobile devices provides opportunity across all these opportunity for The use of digital devices in the classroom provides additional opportunities for teachers to review and assess pupil progress in real and on the which can support learning & 2019). digital interventions are designed with an function which allows the child to their and learn from While the content of interventions will the activities (as through the SAMR and the highlighted are key in how interventions might and therefore the potential impact they can have on child outcomes. examples of the available interventions at primary age children are below. A website with a range of maths and literacy games for As it is it can be a smartphone or other Internet-enabled or the vary in and are into age provides so the can they a question The website also includes resources for teachers to use as teaching tools an interactive and can be at to learning for A website developed and by the The can be at any tablet or smartphone, as as traditional computer, so can be used at or school. resources are to the curricula across the four A wide range of resources and areas are for secondary and and videos and For the activities are and while for activities make use of The impact that mobile devices have on educational outcomes remains investment in tablets for use in the primary school classroom is on (BESA, 2015). Given that to wider are in education as in other areas of it is critical that investment is made in the most tools and approaches to support educational outcomes. must therefore be to access the most up to evidence to support A systematic review of existing will provide one such accessible The review has to focus on primary education, rather than the spectrum of educational experience. Primary and education, and the use of technology within are in terms of the subjects the approach to pedagogy, and activities undertaken. As a with and a to a review which has the potential to influence practice, we rather in the of primary education rather than to both and of the Within the systematic review a number of or in & have of which the Campbell is The primary role of such is to support the review and provide through review, so that practitioners, policy and the available evidence can in the of the review. There is no existing systematic review on this therefore the feel it will be an important to the evidence There are some or on a similar these are below. et al. (2015) review: use in a critical review of the evidence for learning is the most similar to the proposed review, however a number of key that there remains in the proposed review: This is not a systematic review. The in et review were carried out in The 5 since the was carried out has seen rapid and of the use of mobile technology in the classroom. have found a of research since the proposed review on this up to et review considered both primary and secondary school not include smartphones, and focused on wider learning outcomes. There is no either across age or learning outcomes, therefore the proposed review will et to better primary use This is particularly important as
Read more