Comparative study of Wavefront-guided Sub-Bowman-Keratomileusis versus conventional Sub-Bowman-Keratomileusis for correcting myopia
Objective To compare outcomes in visual acuity,refraction,higher-order aberrations (HOAs),and contrast sensitivity function (CSF) in myopic patients undergoing wavefront-guided sub-bowman-keratomileusis (WG-SBK) or sub-bowman-keratomileusis (SBK).Methods In this prospective,randomized,comparative study,244 eyes (122 patients) of myopia or myopic astigmatism were recruited randomized from the myopic surgery candidates and were random allocated into WG-SBK group and SBK group using random digits table.Wavefront-guided custom ablation was performed on the patients from WG-SBK group and standard ablation was performed on the patients from SBK group.Visual acuity,refraction,HOAs and CSF were measured preoperatively at 1 day,1 week,1 month,3 months and 6 months postoperatively.The results were compared between the two groups.Results After 6 months,98.07% of Wavefront-guided ablation eyes and 98.57% of standard ablation had uncorrected visual acuity of 1.0 or better (P =0.764).None treated eyes in either group lost more than two lines of best corrected visual acuity (BCVA).The percentage of eyes gained 1 line or more improved in BCVA was 84.61% and 65.71% in the WG-SBK and SBK groups (P <0.01),respectively.WG-SBK group 69.23% eyes and SBK group of 57.86% eyes spherical equivalent within ±0.50 D (P =0.069),WG-SBK group of 92.31% eyes and SBK group of 86.43% eyes spherical equivalent within ±1.00 D (P =0.148).Mean residual astigmatism in WG-SBK group and SBK group were-0.30±0.32 DC and-0.34±0.33 DC,respectively (P =0.344).There were no statistically significant in mean residual spherical equivalent between WG-SBK group and SBK group at preoperative,postoperative 1 day and 1 week,respectively (P >0.05).However,there were statistically significant in mean residual spherical equivalent between WG-SBK group and SBK group at postoperative 1 month,3 months and 6 months.Mean postoperative absolute changes of six months in HOAs,coma,trefoil and spherical aberration root-mean-square (RMS) in the WG-SBK group and SBK group were 0.25±0.26μm,0.05±0.15μm,0.05±0.12μm,0.14±0.24μm and 0.39±0.34μ m,0.10±0.27μm,0.03±0.10μm,0.29±0.26μm,respectively (P <0.01,P =0.089,P =0.157,P <0.01).Mean postoperative changes in 3 c/d,6 c/d,12 c/d and 18 c/d CSF in the WG-SBK group and SBK group were 0.17±0.36,-0.04±0.35,0.18±0.29,0.29±0.31 and-0.22±0.44,-0.01±0.51,-0.05± 0.40,-0.02±0.46,respectively (P <0.01,P =0.6062,P <0.01,P <0.01).Conclusions Both wavefront-guided ablation and standard ablation in sub-bowman-keratomileusis for myopia can gain satisfactory postoperative visual acuity and refraction,however,wavefront-guided SBK is efficient to decrease the new induce higher-order aberrations and improve low and high spatial frequency contrast sensitivity of postoperative compared with standard SBK. Key words: Sub-Bowman-Keratomileusis (SBK) ; Wavefront-guided ; Myopia ; Comparative study ;
Read more