Split Compilation for Security of Quantum Circuits

The relationship between efficient verification and quantum computing is one of the most important and least well-understood questions in the theory of computation. In particular, is there a problem that can be solved efficiently on a quantum computer that cannot be verified? In this thesis we give evidence that BQP ⊄ PH, relating the classes of languages decidable with a quantum computer to a generalization of NP. In so doing we connect a question in pseudorandomness, first studied [BSW03] to the problem of finding an oracle relative to which BQP ⊄ PH. The primary technical challenge is to construct a unitary matrix, realized by an efficient quantum circuit and whose rows are supported on nearly disjoint subsets. Using this matrix and assuming the validity of the aforementioned question in pseudorandomness, we show an instantiation of the Nisan-Wigderson pseudorandom generator that can be broken with quantum computers, but not with the relevant mode of classical computation.

Quantum information theory has provided the formal framework for describing how information is stored, transmitted, and transformed in physical quantum systems [Renes, 2022; Tomamichel, 2015; Wilde, 2013]. Its entropic formulations underpin our understanding of quantum computation, communication, and cryptography. Yet this theory traditionally treats all quantum operations as freely available, ignoring computational restrictions. In practice, however, any manipulation of quantum information must be performed by devices of bounded complexity and runtime. Capturing such realistic constraints requires extending quantum information theory to include computational efficiency as a fundamental component. This work takes a first step toward building a computational version of quantum information theory, one that treats efficiency as part of the theory itself. The goal is to understand how the behavior of quantum information changes when the parties involved can only perform computationally efficient operations. This approach bridges the abstract, ideal setting of quantum information theory with the practical limitations of real quantum devices, offering a means to study information processing under realistic resource constraints. At the center of this work are two new quantities: the quantum computational min-entropy and the quantum computational max-entropy. These entropies extend standard quantum entropies by explicitly limiting the computational power of the observer or adversary. The quantum computational min-entropy captures how unpredictable a quantum system A remains to an observer holding system B, when that observer is restricted to quantum circuits of bounded size. Formally, for a bipartite state ρ_{AB}, we define {H^c}^s_{min}(A|B)_{ρ} ≔ -log d_A max_{ℰ^s_{B→A'}} F((𝕀_A ⊗ ℰ^s)(ρ_{AB}),|Φ_{AA'}⟩⟨Φ_{AA'}|) , where the maximization is over quantum channels that can be implemented by circuits of size at most s, and F denotes fidelity with a maximally entangled state. In the classical setting, the min-entropy can be expressed through the maximal probability of correctly guessing a random variable given some side-information. In the fully quantum setting, this idea extends to uncertainty about quantum information [König et al., 2009], quantifying how well one system can be inferred from another using local quantum operations. Our definition generalizes this operational viewpoint by restricting the computational power of the observer to efficient quantum circuits. This definition extends the operational meaning of the information-theoretic quantum min-entropy [König et al., 2009] by incorporating computational constraints, and it provides the fully quantum counterpart of the classical unpredictability entropy [Hsiao et al., 2007]. We establish fundamental properties for the computational min-entropy, including monotonicity in the circuit size and smoothing parameters, efficient data-processing inequalities, and fully quantum leakage and purification chain rules, which were left as open questions in earlier definitions of quantum computational entropies [Yi-Hsiu Chen et al., 2017; Munson et al., 2025]. For classical–quantum states, it coincides with the previously defined quantum computational unpredictability entropy [Noam Avidan and Rotem Arnon, 2025], showing that the new definition correctly generalizes known results. We also introduce the quantum computational max-entropy through a duality relation [Tomamichel et al., 2010] with the min-entropy using a fixed purification. Finally, we prove unconditional separations between the computational and information-theoretic entropies, demonstrating that computational restrictions can fundamentally alter entropic behavior even for simple states. These results establish the fundamental mathematical framework for studying quantum information within realistic computational constraints. By integrating efficiency directly into entropic quantities, they open the door to a fully developed computational quantum information theory that parallels its information-theoretic counterpart. Such a framework provides the foundation for analyzing cryptographic security against computationally bounded quantum adversaries [Noam Avidan and Rotem Arnon, 2025] and the limits of efficient quantum state manipulation. More broadly, it suggests that many core notions in quantum information theory may have refined computational analogues yet to be explored.

Simulation of the dynamics of quantum materials is emerging as a promising scientific application for noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers. Due to their high gate-error rates and short decoherence times, however, NISQ computers can only produce high-fidelity results for those quantum circuits smaller than some given circuit size. Dynamic simulations, therefore, pose a challenge as current algorithms produce circuits that grow in size with each subsequent time-step of the simulation. This underscores the crucial role of quantum circuit compilers to produce executable quantum circuits of minimal size, thereby maximizing the range of physical phenomena that can be studied within the NISQ fidelity budget. Here, we present two domain-specific (DS) quantum circuit compilers for the Rigetti and IBM quantum computers, specifically designed to compile circuits simulating dynamics under a special class of time-dependent Hamiltonians. The compilers outperform state-of-the-art general-purpose compilers in terms of circuit size reduction by around 25%–30% as well as wall-clock compilation time by around 40% (dependent on system size and simulation time-step). Drawing on heuristic techniques commonly used in artificial intelligence, both compilers scale well with simulation time-step and system size. Code for both compilers is open-source and packaged into a full-stack quantum simulation software with tutorials included for ease of use for future researchers wishing to perform dynamic simulations of quantum materials on quantum computers. As our DS compilers provide significant improvements in both compilation time and simulation fidelity, they provide a building block for accelerating progress toward physical quantum supremacy.

Machine learning tasks are an exciting application for quantum computers, as it has been proven that they can learn certain problems more efficiently than classical ones. Applying quantum machine learning algorithms to classical data can have many important applications, as qubits allow for dealing with exponentially more data than classical bits. However, preparing the corresponding quantum states usually requires an exponential number of gates and therefore may ruin any potential quantum speedups. Here, we show that classical data with a sufficiently quickly decaying Fourier spectrum after being mapped to a quantum state can be well-approximated by states with a small Schmidt rank (i.e., matrix-product states) and we derive explicit error bounds. These approximated states can, in turn, be prepared on a quantum computer with a linear number of nearest-neighbor two-qubit gates. We confirm our results numerically on a set of 1024×1024-pixel images taken from the `Imagenette' and DIV2K datasets. Additionally, we consider different variational circuit ansätze and demonstrate numerically that one-dimensional sequential circuits achieve the same compression quality as more powerful ansätze.

While current quantum computers, referred to as Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) computers, are expected to be beneficial for different applications, they are prone to different types of errors. In order to enhance the reliability of quantum systems, noise-aware quantum compilers are used to generate physical quantum circuits to be executed on NISQ computers. The quantum hardware is calibrated very frequently and its error rates are computed accordingly. Based on the hardware error rates, a quantum compiler allocates physical qubits and schedules quantum operations. However, error rates may change post-calibration. To incorporate dynamic error rates into quantum circuit compilation with minimum cost, we propose a Machine Learning (ML)-based scheme to detect the incorrect output of the quantum circuit and predict the Probability of Successful Trials (PST) with high accuracy. Our approach can verify the error rates of the quantum hardware and validate the correctness of the extracted quantum circuit output. We provide a case study of our ML-based reliability models using IBM Q16 Melbourne quantum computer. Our results show that the proposed scheme achieves a very high prediction accuracy.

Quantum computing simulation platform can simulate the computation results of the quantum computer based on traditional computers, which is an effective way to promote the development of quantum computing software, algorithms and hardware at the current immature stage of the real quantum computer. Since quantum computers have exponential calculation acceleration compared with traditional computers, the main problems in implementing quantum computing simulation on traditional computers are low computational efficiency and long time-consuming. A quantum circuit which is a sequence of quantum gates acting on a collection of qubits is the general quantum computing model. So by the means of quantum circuit optimization, the calculation speed can be significantly increased while keeping the calculation result unchanged. The existing empirical rules of quantum circuit optimization methods have limitations and there is no common and automatic quantum circuit optimization method. In this paper, a general and automatic quantum circuit optimization method based on the genetic algorithm is proposed, by which the equivalent optimal quantum circuit is obtained through a finite number of searching in a large searching space. This method is not limited by the hardware of the quantum computing simulation and the composition of the quantum circuit. The experimental results show that for the QFT algorithm of 29 qubits, the running time can be shortened by 41.4% and for the variational circuit of 6 qubits, the running time can be shortened by 18.8% compared with the state-of-the-art quantum circuit optimization method. So this method can improve the quantum computing simulation capability and operating efficiency and provide a rapid development way for quantum algorithms and applications.

Quantum computing furnishes exponential speed up over classical computing in specific areas. For example, Shor’s algorithm can factor two numbers in a polynomial time complexity. Thus, many encryption algorithms that rely on large number factorization are potentially vulnerable to quantum computers. In order to address this, the National Institute of Standard and Test (NIST) has organized a competition to evaluate several post quantum cryptography (PQC) algorithms, that are secure from the attacks from quantum computers. Several of these lattice-based PQC encryption algorithms are based on Learning With Errors (LWE) computation. Conversely, LWE is the heaviest computation in a classical computer, which incurs significant portion of the latency overhead for the entire encryption algorithm. In this paper, we design an optimized quantum circuit for LWE computation. The proposed quantum circuit does not need any ancillary qubits and scales efficiently and easily if there are more qubits available on a higher qubit quantum computer.

The complexity of the commuting local Hamiltonians (CLH) problem still remains a mystery after two decades of research of quantum Hamiltonian complexity; it is only known to be contained in NP for few low parameters. Of particular interest is the tightly related question of understanding whether groundstates of CLHs can be generated by efficient quantum circuits. The two problems touch upon conceptual, physical and computational questions, including the centrality of non-commutation in quantum mechanics, quantum PCP and the area law. It is natural to try to address first the more physical case of CLHs embedded on a 2D lattice, but this problem too remained open apart from some very specific cases [Aharonov and Eldar, 2011; Hastings, 2012; Schuch, 2011]. Here we consider a wide class of two dimensional CLH instances; these are k-local CLHs, for any constant k; they are defined on qubits set on the edges of any surface complex, where we require that this surface complex is not too far from being Euclidean. Each vertex and each face can be associated with an arbitrary term (as long as the terms commute). We show that this class is in NP, and moreover that the groundstates have an efficient quantum circuit that prepares them. This result subsumes that of Schuch [Schuch, 2011] which regarded the special case of 4-local Hamiltonians on a grid with qubits, and by that it removes the mysterious feature of Schuch's proof which showed containment in NP without providing a quantum circuit for the groundstate and considerably generalizes it. We believe this work and the tools we develop make a significant step towards showing that 2D CLHs are in NP.

Our aim in this paper is to present experimental evidence of a side-channel attack on superconducting cloud-based quantum computers, demonstrating that a quantum circuit can be analyzed indirectly using data gathered before and after its execution on a quantum computer. We hope that this can motivate further research into hardware and system stability of quantum computers as well as into more-nuanced systems-level attacks. Although much work has been done on establishing error correcting codes to address issues of decoherence, and schemes can be utilized to leverage quantum effects for the sake of intrusion detection over quantum communication channels, there is a lack of literature in the field regarding side-channel attacks on transpiled quantum circuits, particularly those which leverage quantum effects to gather information about quantum circuits running in the cloud. We explored issues of decoherence by examining quantum circuit behavior both before and after a specified circuit was executed in order to ascertain decalibration rates and potential sources of decoherence: our data clearly shows that information on an interim circuit can be acquired in this manner. Using convenient data classification techniques and various circuit diagrams consisting of one quantum gate and several measurements, we were able to distinguish between these various circuits when executed at position n in the interim phase by training our classifier on data from probing circuits executed at queue positions n-1 and n+1. This shows that there is sufficient information residing in the data before and after a circuit is executed on a cloud-based superconducting quantum computer to allow an attacker to ascertain information about an otherwise unknown third-party circuit and shows potential to form the basis of a side-channel attack in cases where queue positions can be examined to target a third party’s transpiled circuit during experimentation. This side channel attack merits further examination and extrapolation to identify more-complex circuits, and deeper statistical consideration to determine potential sources of information leakage and mitigation strategies.

Chapter 5 - Quantum Algorithms and Methods

The current advancement in quantum computers has been focusing on increasing the number of qubits and enhancing their fidelity. However, the available quantum devices, known as Intermediate Scale Quantum (NISQ) computers, still suffer from different sources of noise that impact their reliability. Thus, practical noise modeling is of great importance in the development of quantum error mitigation approaches. In this paper, we propose a Machine Learning (ML)-based scheme to predict the output fidelity of the quantum circuit executed on NISQ devices. We show the benefit of using Graph Neural Network (GNN)-based models compared to traditional ML-based models in capturing the quantum circuit structure in addition to its gates’ features, which enable characterizing unpredicted quantum circuit errors. We use different metrics to measure the fidelity of the quantum circuit output. Our experimental results using different quantum algorithms executed on IBM Q Guadalupe quantum computer show the high prediction accuracy of our ML reliability models. Our results also show that our models can guide the single-qubit gate rescheduling to improve the output fidelity of the quantum circuit without the need for prior execution of dedicated calibration circuits.

Quantum computation can solve certain problems much faster than classical computation. However, quantum computations are more susceptible to errors than conventional digital computations. Thus, a fault-tolerant (FT) quantum circuit design is required for a practical implementation. Quantum circuits consist of a cascade of quantum gates. These gates are themselves realized using primitive quantum operations that are supported by the quantum physical machine description (PMD). As different quantum systems are associated with different Hamiltonians, they have different PMDs. In addition, the quantum cost for implementing a quantum operation may differ from one PMD to another. Thus, a quantum logic circuit needs to be realized with and optimized for the set of primitive quantum operations supported by the given PMD. In this paper, an FT quantum logic synthesis (FTQLS) methodology and tool is described for six different PMDs. A methodology, such as this, which can be targeted at multiple PMDs, has not been attempted before, to the best of our knowledge. The input to FTQLS is an unoptimized quantum circuit realized using a set of commonly used gates and its output is an optimized FT quantum circuit that only comprises of primitive quantum operations supported by the given PMD. FTQLS does technology mapping for different PMDs and then converts non-FT circuits to FT circuits. For technology mapping, it utilizes an optimized quantum gate library targeted at various PMDs that decomposes gates into primitive operations. Efficient conversion to FT circuits is done by integrating two quantum compilers and an FT cache table into FTQLS. For improving the synthesis results, an FT set of gates that is directly supported by each PMD is proposed. Quantum circuit optimization is done by utilizing quantum identity rules. The performance of FTQLS is evaluated using two cost metrics: number of primitive operations (#ops) and execution cycles on the critical path (#cycles). Experiment results show that the decrease in #ops varies between 58.1% and 87.0% and in #cycles between 42.8% and 76.4%, on an average, depending on the PMD.

This work contains the analysis of results received after running synthesized quantum circuits for training perceptron neural networks. The training is performed by creating a Grover's algorithm with a custom oracle function. The concept of synthesizing quantum circuits was showcased in the process of generating training circuits for three perceptron topologies, which were designed to test the accuracy of the synthesis process. The test circuits serve to prove that the proposed synthesis approach could be scaled to utilize more complex quantum computing systems and to solve more practical tasks. IBM's 100-qubit cloud quantum simulator was used as the debugging environment. Quantum circuits for described algorithms are generated by the "Naginata" quantum synthesizer, its source code is published and further documented on GitHub along with the code for the provided example algorithms. The article describes the processes behind the algorithm for synthesizing quantum circuits that perform the training process of single-layer perceptrons by finding their weights by filtering all possible input values through a predefined accuracy criterion. Since quantum computing is still in its early development phase, quantum circuits are created mainly by manual placement of logic elements. Implementing quantum algorithms, especially more use-case specific ones, directly on the quantum circuit level could lead to the circuit easily becoming too complex for human comprehension. Quantum Circuit Synthesizer "Naginata" was created to simplify the development and debugging process of quantum algorithms, by adding better clarity to their development process. In our case, better clarity for the development process is achieved by composing functions for commonly used operations performed in the implemented quantum algorithm. The programmer could now implement the quantum algorithm as a set of functions, instead of manually creating a circuit from single logic elements. After this, the synthesizer would handle the task of creating the data for placing logic elements on the circuit. This enables an opportunity of implementing quantum algorithms with higher-level commands. In the scope of this work, parametrically generated generic blocks for frequently used operations such as: the adder, multiplier and digital comparator were created and utilized to form the training circuits. The test results, proved that with the help of the proposed quantum synthesizer, these compositions could be used efficiently as building blocks for implementing quantum algorithms. And by visually comparing sizes of both code and circuit representations of the synthesized circuits, to the code examples used to synthesize these circuits, it is determined that the proposed approach for implementing quantum circuits greatly simplifies the processes of development and debugging a quantum algorithm.

The construction of quantum computers is based on the synthesis of low-cost quantum circuits. The quantum circuit of any Boolean function expressed in a Positive Polarity Reed-Muller (PPRM) expansion can be synthesized using Multiple-Control Toffoli (MCT) gates. This paper proposes two algorithms to construct a quantum circuit for any Boolean function expressed in a PPRM expansion. The Boolean function can be expressed with various algebraic forms, so there are different quantum circuits can be synthesized for the Boolean function based on its algebraic form. The proposed algorithms aim to map the MCT gates into the NCV gates for any quantum circuit by generating a simple algebraic form for the Boolean function. The first algorithm generates a special algebraic form for any Boolean function by rearrangement of terms of the Boolean function according to a predefined degree of term d term , then synthesizes the corresponding quantum circuit. The second algorithm applies the decomposition methods to decompose MCT circuit into its elementary gates followed by applying a set of simplification rules to simplify and optimize the synthesized quantum circuit. The proposed algorithms achieve a reduction in the quantum cost of synthesized quantum circuits when compared with relevant work in the literature. The proposed algorithms synthesize quantum circuits that can applied on IBM quantum computer.

In the field of quantum computing, variational quantum algorithms (VQAs) represent a pivotal category of quantum solutions across a broad spectrum of applications. These algorithms demonstrate significant potential for realising quantum computational advantage. A fundamental aspect of VQAs involves formulating expressive and efficient quantum circuits (namely ansatz), and automating the search of such ansatz is known as quantum architecture search (QAS). Recently reinforcement learning (RL) techniques is utilized to automate the search for ansatzes, know as RL-QAS. This study investigates RL-QAS for crafting ansatz tailored to the variational quantum state diagonalisation problem. Our investigation includes a comprehensive analysis of various dimensions, such as the entanglement thresholds of the resultant states, the impact of initial conditions on the performance of RL-agent, the phase transition behaviour of correlation in concurrence bounds, and the discrete contributions of qubits in deducing eigenvalues through conditional entropy metrics. We leverage these insights to devise an entanglement-guided admissible ansatz in QAS to diagonalise random quantum states using optimal resources. Furthermore, the methodologies presented herein offer a generalised framework for constructing reward functions within RL-QAS applicable to variational quantum algorithms.