- Research Article
- 10.1287/opre.1110.0925
Contributors
- Feb 01, 2011
- Operations Research
- Sandro Bosio
Contributors
A multiplicity of techniques must be used in systems analysis in order to answer the variety of questions that arise in research on management systems. A research organization devoted to solving management science problems will inevitably use mixtures of these techniques. The purpose of this paper is to examine the nature of systems analysis, and past experiences with it, to help develop a strategy for selecting appropriate techniques. To facilitate the development of this strategy, several categorizations are developed: (1) of the characteristics of the kinds of systems studied by systems analysts; (2) of the many purposes of systems analysis; and (3) of the attributes of many systems analysis techniques. Then the simulation category is examined further with a more detailed breakdown presented on the spectrum of simulation techniques. Finally, an illustration is given of the way in which the various systems analysis techniques have been used to evolve a greater understanding of supply and inventory policies and systems. There seems to be a natural way in which the use of the several techniques evolved and were fitted together. It is believed that this pattern has occurred in other large systems studies, and that it would be applicable to those large and complex systems in which there would not be a significant pool of prior research available. Management Technology, ISSN 0542-4917, was published as a separate journal from 1960 to 1964. In 1965 it was merged into Management Science.
Contributors
Contributors
AI-Supported Reality: Revisiting Models and Techniques of Systems Analysis in Water Resources and Agriculture Management
This paper reviews contemporary developments in systems analysis applied to water resources and agricultural management, highlighting the growing influence of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML). The literature in this field encompasses a wide range of approaches, methods, and applications, including hydrological simulation models, decision-support systems, and participatory governance frameworks. In recent years, increasing attention has been devoted to systematically reviewing and categorizing these approaches, particularly in light of rapid advances in AI- and ML-based technologies. The present study focuses on the contributions and impacts of AI and ML on systems analysis methodologies compared with the state of the field approximately a decade ago. By revisiting and classifying key groups of approaches, methods, and software tools, the paper provides an updated overview of the current status of systems analysis in water resources and irrigation management. This overview also serves as a reference framework for assessing future methodological and technological developments. Adopting a systems-thinking perspective, the review spans multiple spatial and management scales, from plot-level irrigation practices to river-basin water allocation. The paper aims to support a more holistic understanding and improved design and evaluation of water–agriculture systems, while also strengthening policy support for sustainable resource management. Finally, it highlights the need for continued interdisciplinary integration, enhanced stakeholder participation, and the development of operational tools capable of translating complex systems insights into actionable water management strategies in the emerging context shaped by AI and ML.
Read moreUsing Systems Analysis and Dynamics to Evaluate Public Private Partnerships with Data and Best Practices from SAFER Santa Rosa
Public private partnerships have been gaining the interest of emergency management and security-related federal organizations. In 2010, the National Academies Press published a framework for resilience-focused private-public sector collaboration which may be the catalyst for how resilience-oriented public private partnerships are developed in the future (National Academies Press. 2010). Public private partnerships can be utilized to increase citizen awareness and preparedness, to address a specific need in a community, or to accomplish any other function that brings a community and government together. “Utilized correctly, a public private partnership is a win-win situation for all participants” (Hahn, 2010, p. 274). Although perceived as very successful, no prior systems analysis has been conducted on these partnerships. In this chapter, a successful public private partnership is evaluated using systems analysis techniques. Results of that analysis, along with details of the original case study and the public private partnership itself are presented.
Read moreCybersecurity Requires a Clear Systems Engineering Approach as a Basis for Its Cyberstrategy
Systems engineering is the branch of engineering concerned with the development of large and complex systems, where a system is understood to be an assembly or combination of interrelated elements or parts working together toward a common objective. Past experience has shown that formal systems engineering methodologies have not always been successfully applied to large and complex cybersecurity systems. These complex systems have become commonplace when applying cyberstrategies in cybersecurity operations. The ability to build, operate and maintain such systems is crucial to the effectiveness of cybersecurity operations. Most importantly, a cyberstrategy program must surround these systems on a global scale across multiple inter-related platforms. In this chapter, the authors demonstrate why a systems engineering approach is best suited for large and complex information systems used in cybersecurity, as well as the overall cyberstrategies that must also reside over these systems.
Read moreThe proposed ICCP certification in systems analysis (CSA)
Systems analysts occupy a unique position within the structure of information processing: They deal not only with the technology and with the creative dimensions of systems development, but also with the resolution of conflict between the objectives of product-oriented users and process-oriented programmers. While this conflict is frequently not open, a form of adversary relationship typically develops between users and software specialists, and the systems analyst becomes the focal point in reducing this alienation. Contemporary methodologies which aid in the systems development process have helped to reduce the friction, but the systems analyst still must frequently assume the role of arbitrator and diplomat.Coupled with the above role is the emerging position of the systems analyst as a quality assurance specialist. As organizations become increasingly dependent upon computer-based information systems, some of which are life-critical, systems analysts must assume greater responsibility for the results — good or bad — of the applications they develop and install. Accountability of this type has always been one distinguishing characteristic of the true professional.Although information processing is itself an evolving discipline, some computing professionals have responsibilities and requisite knowledge more clearly defined than those of the systems analyst. The bodies of knowledge relevant to the information systems manager and the senior programmer are well represented in the content of the two examinations currently offered by the Institute for Certification of Computer Professionals (ICCP): the Certificate in Data Processing (CDP) and the Certificate in Computer Programming (CCP), respectively. The systems analyst remains the primary computer professional not covered by a certification program.
Read moreA Laboratory Microcomputing System for Physiological Signal and System Analysis
The use of engineering signal and systems analysis techniques in physiological research and teaching is growing (for example, Rompelman et al., 1977; Kitney, 1979; Lal, 1979; Christakos and Lal, 1980) for they provide a powerful and precise body of methods for carrying out certain types of experimental and theoretical investigations. One factor which has hindered their introduction and use in physiology has been the lack of a small, fairly cheap, easy to use laboratory computing system equipped with a biomedically relevant range of facilities for stimulus generation, data capture, data analysis and process modelling.
Read moreThe response of arterial pressure to halothane: A systems analysis
The relationship between the delivered halothane concentration, and the mean arterial pressure was studied by systems analysis techniques in dogs. Halothane administration was controlled by a servo motor.
Read moreA tutorial on sum of squares techniques for systems analysis
This tutorial is about new system analysis techniques that were developed in the past few years based on the sum of squares decomposition. We present stability and robust stability analysis tools for different classes of systems: systems described by nonlinear ordinary differential equations or differential algebraic equations, hybrid systems with nonlinear subsystems and/or nonlinear switching surfaces, and time-delay systems described by nonlinear functional differential equations. We also discuss how different analysis questions such as model validation and safety verification can be answered for uncertain nonlinear and hybrid systems.
Read moreApplying systems analysis to program failure in organizations
Certain systems analysis techniques can be applied to examinations of program failure in continuing education to locate weaknesses in planning and implementing stages. Since failures can be the result of human errors and environmental conditions (and frequently a combination of both), a systems design to determine causes must include techniques that can detect both individual and nonhuman factors. Questions to guide an analysis and various procedures are recommended. Unexamined failures may lead to “tossing the baby out with the bathwater,” when analysis, in fact, could be the initial step toward successful future implementation.
Read moreLignocellulosic Biomass Feedstock Supply Logistic Analysis
Biomass transportation is a key component of the biomass feedstock sustainable supply system, supporting the emerging bioenergy sector based on lignocellulosic feedstock. It provides the link between biomass feedstock producers and end-users such as biorefineries. However, transportation and associated logistics are also responsible for a major portion of the total feedstock supply cost and energy consumption. It is a highly complex system exhibiting “many-to-few” as well as “one-to-one” delivery logistics. The biomass form, intended end use, supply and demand locations and available equipment all affect the performance of the transportation logistics system. Sustainability of the supply system requires optimized logistic chains, cost-effective transportation alternatives, standardized facility design and equipment configurations, efficient regulations and a careful environmental impact analysis. These issues have been studied rigorously in the last decade. The objective of this paper is comprehensively analyze the existing literature which can then be used to conduct a systematic analysis and innovative design of transportation logistics systems. It analyzes major feedstock transportation alternatives and the implementation of those for various types of energy crops such as energy grasses and agricultural residue. The importance of equipment configuration, performance-based standards development and regulations is emphasized and the status quo reviewed. Finally, approaches described in the literature to model, simulate and optimize transportation systems are reviewed.
Read moreChapter 1 - Bayesian networks for failure analysis of complex systems using different data sources
Chapter 1 - Bayesian networks for failure analysis of complex systems using different data sources
Complexity and Disaster Forensics: Paradigms, Models and Approaches for Natural Hazards Management in the Pacific Island Region
“Complexity and Disaster Forensics: New Paradigms, Models and Approaches for Natural Hazards Management in the Pacific Islands Region” assesses and applies complex systems theory, modeling and analysis to disaster forensics policy and research. To better understand the root cause and complex causality of disasters, complex systems theory, with roots in the fields of statistical physics, information theory, and non-linear dynamics, and systems analysis, is applied to help communities and nations achieve important social development goals, reduce institutional brittleness and increase disaster resilience by promoting positive transformations in the co-evolving and mutually dependent human-environmental condition, and by capitalizing on opportunities provided by human creativity, diplomatic openings, technologic capacities and environmental change. The case studies, investigations and models outlined in this chapter collectively demonstrate the quality, breadth and depth of complex systems and disaster forensics methodologies. Game-theoretic (“Small World”) decision analyses, “Large world” (complex systems) models of mutually interactive game design are put forth to capture the complexity of climate related disasters and to reduce the threat of climate refugees in the Pacific Island region. The resulting risk management lessons learned were applied to communities in the Pacific Island of Vanuatu, the most natural disaster prone country in the world.
Read moreThe Clinical Information System
The case study described in this chapter concerns the introduction of a new computer based integrated Clinical Information System (CIS) into a British National Health Services Trust-the Sunrise Trust. At the time of the study most of the system modules had been developed and were being tested largely for technical aspects. The system was being introduced during a period when the organization was experiencing significant changes. It was an environment where new structures were being created and the existing ones changed. Indeed, the case study was selected primarily because of these factors. The analysis of these structures, formal and informal, provides insight into the management of information systems. Various stakeholders in the Hospital Trust felt that a computer based information system would facilitate the change process. However the analysis and design of the system posed its own problems. The system turned out to be inflexible with respect to the core health care delivery process. It was also nonresponsive to the needs of the key stakeholders. Analysis of the case shows that clearly the formal methods adopted by the system analysts fell short of determining the rapid changes required for care. In particular this was an important issue, since the context of the British National Health Services posed pressures on individual trusts to be cost effective. This resulted in long term patients being moved out into the community. However, this richness in the context was overlooked by the analysts. They developed “logical” models of the system, which ended up in being “tidy pictures of reality” and were prescriptive and utterly inflexible. Structured Systems Analysis and Design Method (SSADM) was used as a modelling tool, which amplified the rational view of decision making and information technology (IT) applications (for more details on SSADM see Downs et al., 1988). The interpretations identified in the case show a clear mis-match between the formal models and perceptions of the system users who inevitably reflect a more informal and pragmatic approach to their own organizational realities. The analysis of the case poses a number of interesting issues. It questions the relationship between the complexity of the social relations and systems design. Furthermore it brings to the fore the paradoxical viewpoints of different stakeholders and the emergent concerns for a system analyst. The chapter also identifies the impact of an “overformalized” information system on the integrity of an organization. In doing so it evaluates the nature and significance of social power structures in systems analysis, design and implementation.
Read morePerformance Enhancement and Accident Reduction in Complex Systems: Perspectives and a Research Program
Accidents in complex systems seldom arise from a single source, and are most often the result of multiple factors occurring at different levels of the system. Understanding the “systems” aspects of human performance (and performance error) in complex systems is a necessary part of any effort to avoid serious mishaps due to human error. This panel is intended to coincide with the development of a major research effort at the University of Wisconsin to address these issues. The Center for Human Performance in Complex Systems will apply the disciplines of systems engineering and ergonomics design to improve complex systems processes from the perspective of human performance. The purpose of this panel is to foster and demonstrate the Center's interest in bringing together a variety of perspectives and expertise bases to improve the overall quality and breadth of its activities. Each of the participants has a longstanding interest in improving the quality of human performance in complex and critical systems environments. Although they cannot represent the entire spectrum of relevant disciplines and perspectives of ergonomics and systems analysis, they provide a balance of insights, experience, and enthusiasm. This balance is essential to improving our understanding of factors affecting complex socio-technical systems, and implementing strategies to prevent and ameliorate the effects of system degradation and breakdown.
Read moreInfoSymbiotics/DDDAS: from big data to new capabilities
In recent years there have been transformative changes in the application systems landscape in that we deal with more complex systems - often systems-of-systems, be they natural, engineered, or societal systems. In tandem is the emergence of advanced infrastructure environments for analysis, understanding and management of such systems, spanning wide and heterogeneous range of powerful computational and instrumentation infrastructures, including ubiquitous end-user devices and pervasive networks of sensoring and control systems. All these drive multilevel models and multimodal data representations of such systems, computed or measured, spurring unprecedented volumes of data, termed Big Data. The opportunity to exploit these tin intelligent ways and convert them into new capabilities will be discussed in the context of the InfoSymbiotics/DDDAS (Dynamic Data Driven Applications Systems) paradigm, whereby computational and instrumentation aspects of an application system as viewed as unified, allowing discovery and use of data, essential to improve the analysis of a system.
Read more