• Cite Icon14
  • https://doi.org/10.36644/mlr.115.7.essentialCopy DOI Icon

The Essential Structure of Property Law

Show More
  • Abstract
  • Literature Map
  • References
  • Citations
  • Similar Papers
Abstract

This Article examines a characteristic of property entitlements fundamental to the structure of property systems that has received scant academic attention, a characteristic referred to as the mutual exclusivity principle. According to this principle, a property system does not allow for the existence of incompatible rights. Two people cannot separately be the owners of the same resource, for instance. By contrast, two people can each hold valid but contradictory contract rights to the resource. Although the existing property literature has stressed the “exclusive” nature of property, the various ways in which property is imagined to be exclusive, such as by conferring “rights to exclude,” fail to capture the essence of property as a distinct legal institution. Unlike these alternative conceptions of exclusiveness, the mutual exclusivity principle holds true across the range of different types of property entitlements, including not just fee simple ownership but also security interests and servitudes, and across the range of assets subject to property law, including not just land and physical objects but also intangibles like intellectual property and corporate shares. Recognizing the role of the mutual exclusivity principle yields a number of practical insights. It helps explain various institutional features of property law, such as the system of future interests, the use of possession-based rules, the role of recording systems, and the negative, thing-based structure of property entitlements. It illuminates connections between property and other fields like corporations law and it calls into question aspects of existing doctrine, such as the preferred status of exclusion rights under the U.S. Constitution’s Takings Clause. It also modifies the influential theory that property law is heavily shaped by problems of high information costs: while existing accounts seem to suppose that property law entails relatively high information costs because it imposes a relatively broad set of duties on others, many of the information cost problems identified in the literature actually result from the mutual exclusivity problem, rather than from the breadth of property duties. At a more general level, understanding the centrality of the mutual exclusivity principle suggests some change in direction is called for within the wider property literature. American property scholarship has been preoccupied with questions about the scope and strength of property rights, overlooking the separate problem of ascertaining who happens to hold a given right, a problem distinctive to property law. Property, this Article argues, is at least as much about title chains, patent searches, and creditor priorities as it is about trespass, remedies, and eminent domain.

Similar Papers
  • Research Article
  • Citations2

Economics, Capitalism, and Corporations: Contradictions of Corporate Law, Economics, and the Theory of the Firm

  • Jan 01, 2020
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • Wm Dennis Huber
  • Single Book

Evicted!

  • Jan 01, 2009
  • David Schultz
  • Research Article
  • Citations3

A Purpose-Based Theory of Corporate Law

  • Jun 27, 2019
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • Asaf Raz
  • Book Chapter

Beyond Exclusion

  • Sep 01, 2009
  • Lee Anne Fennell
  • Single Book
  • Citations58

The Principles of Personal Property Law

  • Jan 01, 2017
  • Duncan Sheehan
  • Research Article

Medieval Canon Law by James A. Brundage

  • Jan 01, 1997
  • The Catholic Historical Review
  • John E Lynch
  • Book Chapter

Impossible Neutrality: Cultural Differences and the Anthropological Incompleteness of Western Secularization

  • Jan 01, 2023
  • Mario Ricca
  • Single Book
  • Citations1

Economic Foundations of Law second edition

  • Jun 24, 2010
  • Stephen J Spurr
  • Supplementary Content

17. Local Corporationss: A Corporate Form to Reduce Information Costs and Maintain Supportive Resource

  • Dec 31, 2015
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • James S Krueger
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Expropriatory Intent: Defining the Proper Boundaries of Substantive Due Process and the Takings Clause

  • Oct 13, 2001
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • Ronald J Krotoszynski Jr
  • Single Book
  • Citations102

The International Law of Property

  • May 01, 2014
  • John G Sprankling
  • PDF
  • Research Article

An Analysis of the Applicability of the Bona Fide Acquisition System to Stolen Goods: A Case Study and Economic Analysis of Law Approach

  • Jul 31, 2024
  • Lecture Notes in Education Psychology and Public Media
  • Zhitao Qian
  • Research Article
  • Citations16

The Evolution of Relational Property Rights: A Case of Chinese Rural Land Reform

  • May 16, 2015
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • Shitong Qiao +1
  • Research Article
  • Citations14

The Importance of Data Access Regimes for Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning

  • Apr 19, 2019
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • Bertin Martens
  • Research Article
  • Citations1

Rebalancing Intellectual Property in the Information Society: The Human Rights Approach

  • Apr 05, 2011
  • SSRN Electronic Journal
  • Ana Santos
Cactus Communications logo

Copyright 2026 Cactus Communications. All rights reserved.